Health Dr Karl: Is cockroach 'milk' really a superfood?

04:00  12 june  2018
04:00  12 june  2018 Source:   abc.net.au

Dr Karl explains the difference between A1 and A2 milk

  Dr Karl explains the difference between A1 and A2 milk A2 milk is one of the more interesting additions to the ever-expanding varieties of milk — but the science behind its benefits is a little murky. A1 and A2 are specific proteins found in cow's milk, though in different proportions depending on the breed of cattle.

Hung Nguyen: People see the video and give their opinions to. Anyone can comment on how to improve the video better. You can subscribe to the channel to

Since 2016, there's been a stream of articles in the media about cockroach " milk ". Dr Karl washes away this notion with a cold, hard glass of myth-busting facts.

Juicy: would you like a cup of cockroach milk?© Provided by ABC News Juicy: would you like a cup of cockroach milk?

For the past two years, the idea of cockroach milk has whipped up a media storm.

One of the latest examples comes from the Daily Mail in May 2018.

It ran a story with the headline: "Beetlejuice for breakfast? Experts say COCKROACH milk could be the next non-dairy fad and claim it tastes just like cow's milk".

A subheading in the piece shouted: "Cockroach milk may be a new superfood as study found high nutritional values".

What's going on here? Is cockroach milk a superfood? Do cockroaches even make milk!?

As clear as milk

Milk is defined as a liquid, coming from the mammary glands of a mammal.

Here's How Soy Milk Stacks Up Against Other Plant-Based Milks

  Here's How Soy Milk Stacks Up Against Other Plant-Based Milks Non-dairy milks aren't perfect fill-ins for cow squeezings. All of the milks and "milks" in the supermarket are, nutritionally, just fine for your drinks or porridge or whatever you like. The difference only matters if a plant-based milk is going to make up a lot of your nutrition for the day — for example, if you are a toddler chugging it all day long.

Cockroach Milk Is the Disgusting Superfood Trend That Just Won't Die. In 2016, researchers dissected baby roaches and discovered that roach milk forms tiny crystals after being digested by the babies — and these crystallized milk particles are loaded with nutrients.

Cockroach milk is the latest superfood trend, reportedly packed with protein, amino acids, and healthy sugars. Find out more about cockroach milk . Is Cockroach Milk Really a New Superfood ? Here's What We Know. The Internet is going crazy over a dairy-free, insect-based milk product.

We are a bit loose with milk labelling, given we have soy, rice and almond milk.

How to make the perfect healthy smoothie

  How to make the perfect healthy smoothie These blends will satisfy and satiateBut it's easy to get stuck in smoothie habits, so we spoke to accredited practising dietitian Themis Chryssidis, who runs Sprout Cooking School, for the baseline rules for a good smoothie and what you should always have in your fridge to whip up something you'd pay $15 for in a trendy café.

Some scientists and cockroach milk producers admit that it may be hard to get people on the bandwagon, but that's not the only road block for Besides for its unappealing name, cockroach milk is hard to come by. Roaches aren't the easiest creatures to milk , NPR reports. It's also still unclear if

There is a new purported superfood out there, and it may surprise — or even disgust — you at first glance. I’m talking about cockroach milk , a new fad that many are calling a protein powerhouse. Cockroach milk may be the most nutritious milk yet discovered, but can you milk a cockroach ?

But, do cockroaches have tiny little udders?

To answer that, we have to go back a step to 'Cockroach Parenting 101'.

There are three main options for a cockroach to raise its babies.

First, dumping them somewhere safe to slowly mature. Second, attaching the eggs somewhere on the outside of its little cockroach body. The third option is to keep its eggs inside a small pouch-like brood sac until they mature.

This is very similar to what happens with baby joeys reared in a kangaroo's pouch.

Only one species of cockroach uses this third approach, and that's the Pacific beetle cockroach, which is found in Australia.

Inside a female's brood sac, there are often about 9–12 cockroach embryos.

To feed these embryos, the mother simply exudes a liquid through the wall of the brood sac for the embryos to drink up.

This liquid is very rich in fats, proteins and carbohydrates — like milk.

So, that's cockroach milk? Not quite

Not all this liquid is immediately absorbed by the baby roaches. They convert some of it into tiny crystals.

Broccoli coffee: Scientists hope powdered veg can improve diets, cut down crop waste

  Broccoli coffee: Scientists hope powdered veg can improve diets, cut down crop waste The humble flat white is getting a green makeover in an effort to help Australians boost their vegetable intake.

Cockroach milk is exactly what it sounds like: milk from cockroaches . It’s another non-dairy milk option, similar to almond milk or oat milk — it’s just As it turns out, yes, it really is that good for you. While it’s unclear if cockroach milk will actually become a *thing,* it definitely should because it’s full

This is because cockroach milk , or post-natal fluid, is being hailed as the latest foody fad for non-dairy drinkers. According to researchers from the Institute for However, cockroach milk isn’t the easiest to come by. As well as the fact that the cockroaches die in the process of extracting the fluid, it would

It was these crystals, that eventually led to the Daily Mail headline, and the torrent of superfood claims.

Back in 2016, an international team of crystallographers from India, the USA, Japan and France published a paper in a journal accurately named the International Union of Crystallographers Journal.

The researchers looked at the crystals inside the cockroach embryos' stomachs.

In the summary of this paper was the phrase: "crystalline cockroach-milk proteins" — now we're listening: "cockroach-milk".

While the Daily Mail took the story one way, others, such as Inverse, wrote a tongue-in-cheek piece about cockroach "milk".

It had the headline: "Everyone Calm Down, Cockroach Milk Isn't Taking Over Just Yet", and the subheading: "We're here to report that it's not even really milk".

It also went on to point out that to get 100 ml (or a cup) of cockroach milk, more than 1,000 mother cockroaches would have to be harvested.

Why do some say it's a superfood?

The original journal article did say crystalline cockroach milk is loaded with fats (about 20 per cent of the dry weight), so it's very high in calories or kilojoules.

And perhaps that's all you need for a new superfood.

One of the main superfood claims of cockroach milk is based on the fact it has about four times the energy content of cows' milk.

But if you just want energy content, why stop at milk? The highest energy content you can get is pure oil, such as olive oil, which is 100 per cent fat.

I should also point out that cockroach milk has never been tested in humans, and so, has never been found to give them wondrous health benefits — so it's impossible to back up the superfood claim at this point.

The Daily Mail's phrase "... tastes just like cow's milk" comes from one biochemist who apparently told US National Public Radio a colleague of his sampled a tiny amount of cockroach milk and found it "tasted like pretty much nothing".

Still, these pesky facts haven't stopped the tabloids from milking the story for all it's worth.

Just because you lose weight on a diet doesn't mean it's a good diet .
A smarter way to think about healthy eatingIt's hard not to immediately copy what she's been doing.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!