Australia: Former Adelaide midwife Lisa Barrett found not guilty of manslaughter over home birth deaths - - PressFrom - Australia
  •   
  •   

AustraliaFormer Adelaide midwife Lisa Barrett found not guilty of manslaughter over home birth deaths

09:21  04 june  2019
09:21  04 june  2019 Source:   abc.net.au

Manslaughter charge after Ferrari crash

Manslaughter charge after Ferrari crash A man who allegedly crashed a stolen Ferrari in Perth's north, killing a female occupant, has been charged with manslaughter. The 38-year-old man is accused of speeding off when police officers approached the vehicle on Saturday morning, before crashing just 100m away near the intersection of Vincent and Charles streets in North Perth. © Supplied The vehicle can be seen on fire in this footage captured by a witness. The Ferrari caught fire, killing a 40-year-old woman inside. The car was allegedly stolen from West Perth about 10.20am yesterday. © Supplied A man is led away by officers.

Former midwife Lisa Barrett is found not guilty of two counts of manslaughter over the deaths of two babies during home births in 2011 and 2012.

Former Adelaide midwife Lisa Jane Barrett , 52, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of manslaughter over the deaths of Tully Kavanagh in The Adelaide midwife faced the charges over the death of two babies. The home birth video was played in court while the mother gave evidence.

Former Adelaide midwife Lisa Barrett found not guilty of manslaughter over home birth deaths© ABC News Former midwife Lisa Barrett outside court. Former midwife Lisa Barrett has been found not guilty of two counts of manslaughter over the deaths of two babies during home births in 2011 and 2012.

Ms Barrett, 52, stood trial in Adelaide's Supreme Court before Justice Ann Vanstone without a jury.

Former Adelaide midwife Lisa Barrett found not guilty of manslaughter over home birth deaths
How To Get A Home Loan With 5% Deposit
Find out more on Finder
Ad Finder.com.au

The prosecution argued Ms Barrett was grossly negligent in the advice she gave the mothers and failed to inform them of the developing emergencies which required urgent hospital transfers.

However, Justice Vanstone found while Ms Barrett's conduct fell short of a competent midwife, it did not amount to criminal negligence.

Road rage stabbing accused Benjamin Joshua George pleads guilty to murdering driver

Road rage stabbing accused Benjamin Joshua George pleads guilty to murdering driver A man, who stabbed another driver in an alleged road rage incident in Adelaide's northern suburbs in 2017, pleads guilty to murder.

Former SA midwife Lisa Barrett has pleaded not guilty to two counts of manslaughter in relation to two After an inquest in 2012, South Australian Deputy Coroner Anthony Schapel found that Tully Lisa Barrett , 50, was last year charged with the deaths of two babies during high-risk homebirths .

A former South Australian midwife charged over the deaths of two babies during home births has been found not guilty of two counts of manslaughter . In the first case of its kind in Australia, Lisa Barrett , 52, pleaded not guilty over the deaths of Tully Kavanagh, the second of twins born in 2011

Last year, Ms Barrett pleaded not guilty to two counts of manslaughter over the deaths of the two babies.

The prosecution argued they would have survived if not for Ms Barrett's involvement.

The claim was rejected by Ms Barrett's defence lawyer Scott Henchliffe SC, who told the court "the direct causes of their deaths were not acts of the accused or her omissions".

Sarah Kerr's son Tully died two days after his birth in October 2011.

Tully's twin sister, who was delivered first, survived.

Ms Kerr previously told the court that Ms Barrett appeared calm and did not convey to her the "extreme danger" her son was in during labour before a decision was eventually made to transfer her and the child to hospital by car.

Justice Vanstone said she was satisfied that the prosecution had failed to prove Ms Barrett's acts or omissions had caused Tully's death.

Fyans Creek woman who ran over partner in ute found guilty of murder

Fyans Creek woman who ran over partner in ute found guilty of murder A jury convicted a 68-year-old woman of deliberately running over her partner after hearing of the pair's volatile relationship.

Former South Australian midwife Lisa Barrett has pleaded not guilty to two counts of manslaughter relating to the deaths of two unrelated babies during home births in Lisa Barrett has been charged with manslaughter for two separate baby deaths . Baby Tully Kavanagh died during a home birth

A former midwife charged over the deaths of two babies during home births has been found not guilty of two counts of manslaughter . Adelaide woman Lisa Barrett , 52, was cleared on Tuesday over the deaths of Tully Kavanagh in 2011 and another baby boy in 2012.

"I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that, although unregistered, the accused held herself out as having the skills of a midwife and took on the role of midwife in respect of the pregnancies," she said.

"She therefore, owed a duty of care to each baby.

"On count one, the prosecution has failed to prove that the accused's acts or omissions in the antenatal period, or during the labour, caused Tully's death.

"In addition, I have found that the prosecution fails on proof of criminal negligence."

Judge says prosecution failed to prove both counts of manslaughter She said while she found the accused's conduct less than competent, the prosecution had also failed to prove Ms Barrett's fault in the death of the second baby.

"On count two, the prosecution has failed to prove that the accused's acts or omissions in the antenatal period caused [the second baby's] death," she said.

"While I have found that the accused's conduct in relation to the labours of both women fell short of that of a reasonably competent midwife, in neither case has it been proved beyond reasonable doubt to be grossly or culpably negligent as the law of manslaughter by criminal negligence requires.

"Although I find the accused's conduct was less than competent, I am not satisfied that her conduct merits criminal sanction."

Read more

'Dishonest' Kiwi midwife tricked patient by giving saline instead of painkillers.
She told a colleague her patients believe anything she tells them.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!