Australia Why do politicians sound so fake? We asked a linguist to explain

21:10  07 february  2020
21:10  07 february  2020 Source:   crikey.com.au

River health monitored through grunting fish, rasping snails and even farting riverbeds

  River health monitored through grunting fish, rasping snails and even farting riverbeds Scientists capture the chorus of underwater sounds that fish, snails and insects make to monitor the health of rivers.But the bizarre babbling of aquatic life has allowed scientists and environmentalists to gain a greater understanding of river health across Australia, particularly when environmental water is delivered.

A Linguist Attempts to Explain Why Donald Trump Often Sounds Incoherent. But politicians tend to use them as a handy misdirection tool, as ThinkProgress has reported. For example, in the first debate, he was asked to explain why he once supported a liberal, single-payer health care system.

So why don’t we give more weight to the views of the people who are best qualified to evaluate what to do ? Before answering that question, it is important to distinguish between epistocracy and something with which it is often confused: technocracy. They are different.

Scott Morrison wearing a suit and tie© Provided by Crikey

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

There is little joy to be had listening to politicians these days. This was confirmed by interviewer David Speers recently as he prepared to take over the ABC’s Insiders.

People are just switching off, Speers noted. His explanation? “Our leaders just don’t talk to us in the way that real people do.”

Billie Eilish hid secret Sydney sound in hit song Bad Guy

  Billie Eilish hid secret Sydney sound in hit song Bad Guy Sydney has two words for Billie Eilish: You're welcome. After discovering the award-winning singer used the noise from the local pedestrian traffic lights in her hit song 'Bad Guy', NSW Roads has responded with their own version of the track. "Our pedestrian crossings are proud to have inspired Grammy Award winner Billie Eilish, and she's inspired us right back," NSW Roads wrote on Facebook before offering their own lyrics to the iconic beat. require(["inlineoutstreamAd", "c.

5. Why should people be socially conscious? Do you believe that everyone can help to make our society better? 7. Do you think in the new millennium peoples will become closer andfinally unite or keep their national integrity? Which way would you prefer? Why ?

All too often, ___(journal) ask them the most ____ ( ridicule ) questions, and when they do get an interesting question, I sit there watching in ___ (believe) as some of the most ___ ( power) people in the country give totally ___( convince ) responses. Journalists , ridiculous, disbelief, powerful, unconvincing.

Linguistics can shed light on what he means by this.

Fifty years ago, British philosopher of language Paul Grice proposed a model to explain how meaningful communication between speakers is made possible.

Key to this is our dependence on certain co-operative norms. Grice dubbed these the “maxims of conversation”.

He identified four:

  1. Being truthful (quality)
  2. Being relevant (relation)
  3. Saying no more and no less than is required (quantity)
  4. Being clear (manner).

Many of the less-than-impressive aspects of politicians’ talk can be understood in terms of how these basic principles are violated.

Let me illustrate with examples from our prime minister’s recent communications.

Maxim of quality

Be truthful. Do not say what you know or believe to be false.

How New Indigenous Languages Are Changing Australia

  How New Indigenous Languages Are Changing Australia The surprising emergence of these languages comes as the traditional ones spoken by Australia's Indigenous people are rapidly dying out.Yet the dynamic nature of language is giving some indigenous groups and linguists something to cheer about: Younger indigenous generations are driving the rise of a new crop of languages — ones that fuse aspects of traditional languages with modern English.

I`ve asked my mother for some money so that I go to the pictures. As I lay in my cabin I heard the sound of waves . against the hull.

schwa sound Stress and intonation: Word stress Words for talking Past forms Editing Individual sounds : Sales talk about selling A letter Matching sounds Listening practice Collocations Forms of to be Stress and intonation: page 24 / page 64 Stress patterns within words The sounds of English

While we expect basic truthfulness in conversations with our fellows, this has never been a requirement for a successful political career (see “the Iraqi regime has weapons of mass destruction”).

Our PM is beginning to chalk up something of record in this area. A recent standout case was his claim to have had a conversation with the young pregnant woman during his ill-fated visit to Cobargo. The video evidence shows the PM turning his back on the woman and walking away.

The out-and-out lie is sadly becoming more and more a feature of modern political discourse. Its prevalence in this country would reward greater investigation. The New York Times now keeps a tally of Trumpian untruths.

Arguably more common, however — and probably more insidious — is the carefully concocted half-truth. Our PM has a particularly assured and forceful way of delivering these. Thus, the following from his recent National Press Club address:

Tourists to spend another night stranded in Milford Sound

  Tourists to spend another night stranded in Milford Sound More than 200 tourists trapped at Milford Sound in New Zealand because of flooding will not be rescued until Wednesday due to weather conditions. However, rescue operations were under way on Tuesday morning to rescue about 100 campers on tracks in Fiordland, as helicopter pilots got a break in the weather. require(["inlineoutstreamAd", "c.

Why does the note taker say about a woman who " utters such depressing and disgusting sounds "? She has no right to live. How does Mrs. Higgins' view of Eliza's future compare to Mrs. Pearce's view? Who is Nepommuck? He is an interpreter, linguist , Higgins first pupil; he could unmask Eliza.

Before long, #NotATranscript was trending on Twitter, as people recognized something fundamentally misleading in calling a document a “transcript” if it was not a verbatim record of what was said. But what’s behind this, and why does it matter?

Question: So why did you [administer the sports funds] that way?

PM: To support local communities … and to ensure that girls didn’t have to change out the back of the shed.

Linguistic studies have shown that acts of verbal deception are often associated with certain give-away voice cues: hesitations, speech errors, pause frequency.

It seems a particular talent of the PM that these are rarely detectable in his delivery.

Maxim of relation

Be relevant. Talk about what is pertinent to the conversation.

Scott Morrison wearing a suit and tie© Provided by Crikey David Speers notes the entrenched techniques of politicians used to subvert this maxim of relevance: scripted messages and talking points, sometimes repeated at absurd length.

The PM has honed his own particular techniques here. One of the more notable ones is to pivot quickly away from giving any account of his actions (a past tense timeframe) and to move straight into the realm of the present and future.

Thus, at the National Press Club, the first question he faced was an invitation to reflect on his handling (or mishandling) of events over the summer:

'Has she left any fake tan for the rest of the planet?' Married At First Sight fans roast bride Natasha Spencer for her enhanced glow

  'Has she left any fake tan for the rest of the planet?' Married At First Sight fans roast bride Natasha Spencer for her enhanced glow Married At First Sight bride Natasha Spencer has been roasted by fans of the show for her intense fake tan. Despite the 26-year-old stating she was proud of her looks, fans were quick to criticise the dark tone.'Holy god, has Natasha left any fake tan for the rest of the planet,' Triple J political reporter Shalailah Medhora commented on Twitter. While another questioned: 'Did Natasha forget to rinse off the fake tan?' require(["inlineoutstreamAd", "c.

Question: … if you had your time again, what would you have done differently?

And the response:

PM: … Well, what I tend to do is focus on the tasks that I need to do each and every day.

The impression intended in such a switch is of a man unencumbered by the past, whose gaze is always fixed on the nation and its future.  In short, an action man.

Maxim of quantity

Say no more and no less than what is required.

The commentaries of politicians invariably give us the inverse of these two requirements — too much of what we don’t want (verbiage), and not enough of what we do (genuinely important information).

Scott Morrison has shown himself an adept violator of both these principles.

Regarding the former (a surfeit of information), the PM has a particular gift for simply running on, the function of which is to run down the clock in interviews, so limiting the number of questions that can be asked.

However, it is in avoiding giving information that the PM really shines. These are the now notorious ScoMo shutdowns.

Thus, along with the standard clichés — e.g. “I reject the premise of your question” and “I don’t respond to hypotheticals” — Morrison draws on a range of unique slogans coined over his career: “on water matters”; “that’s a bubble question”; “that’s gossip”; and “that’s not even a debate”.

How to rort-proof grant programs: delete politicians

  How to rort-proof grant programs: delete politicians The persistence of grant rorting suggests politicians can't be trusted with administering grants programs. Bureaucrats aren't perfect, but won't pork-barrel and misuse taxpayer money.Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

British linguist, Peter Bull has identified 35 different ways that politicians avoid interview questions. Many of these feature in the PM’s playbook.

Maxim of manner

Be clear, avoid ambiguities, organise your thoughts in meaningful ways.

We all struggle to be clear in the messages we convey. For politicians, the struggle often seems to be in achieving the reverse effect.

How else are we to explain the following construction from the PM when asked at his Press Club appearance about his office’s involvement in the Bridget McKenzie sports rorts affair?

PM: All we did was provide information on the representations made to us.

What many assume to have been the active involvement of the PM’s office in the rorts affair here becomes the “providing of information on representations”. It will be the task of journalists in the days ahead to uncover what that tortured phrase might actually mean.

The public’s faith and trust in politicians seems in terminal decline nowadays. One way to arrest this decline would be to simply require them to speak more like real people.

Timothy Moore is a lecturer in linguistics and literacy at Swinburne University of Technology.

The 2020 US Presidential race: A cheat sheet .
Well dang, the fat lady sang for the Yang Gang—and Michael Bennet and Deval Patrick’s campaigns too.The math just didn’t work out.

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!