•   
  •   

Australia Scott Morrison posted pictures of his COVID-19 vaccination on Facebook. And then the anti-vaccine commenters appeared

01:01  26 february  2021
01:01  26 february  2021 Source:   abc.net.au

Delivery of Over A Million COVID Vaccines Shots Delayed by U.S. Winter Storm

  Delivery of Over A Million COVID Vaccines Shots Delayed by U.S. Winter Storm Vaccine shipment delays were reported in several southern and Midwestern states, including Texas, Florida, Georgia and Michigan.The delivery of over a million COVID-19 vaccine doses have been impacted so far, including 407,000 first doses and 333,650 second doses in Texas, 200,000 total doses in Florida and 133,000 in Colorado.

Our vaccination program is underway! These are the first 20 Australians to get vaccinated against # COVID 19 today ahead of the rollout getting fully underway tomorrow. Our first priority is to protect our most vulnerable Australians and the frontline workers who are protecting all of us, and getting vaccinated does just that. I was also vaccinated today along with Australia’s Chief Medical Officer Professor Paul Kelly to give further confidence to Australians these vaccines are safe and effective.

Vaccine nationalism is worsening Covid - 19 in Malawi. Vaccine inequality threatens global Covid - 19 recovery. "Is anyone surprised? I sure hope not. This is, after all, a PLAN-Demic," he added, referencing a widely discredited video that went viral on Facebook and other platforms, which included erroneous claims about vaccines . Ben Garrison, a popular right-wing cartoonist who was invited to the White House by US President Donald Trump, only to be disinvited due to his work's alleged anti -semitism, wrote on Twitter that Morrison 's comments should make Americans "beware" the

shape, arrow: RMIT ABC Fact Check presents the latest debunked misinformation on COVID-19. (RMIT ABC Fact Check) © Provided by ABC Health RMIT ABC Fact Check presents the latest debunked misinformation on COVID-19. (RMIT ABC Fact Check)

CoronaCheck is RMIT ABC Fact Check's weekly email newsletter dedicated to fighting the misinformation infodemic surrounding the coronavirus outbreak.

You can read the latest edition below, and to have the next newsletter delivered straight to your inbox.

CoronaCheck #54

With Australia's COVID-19 vaccine rollout finally under way, misinformation and conspiracy theories abound on social media, and Prime Minister Scott Morrison's Facebook page has not been immune. This week, we've fact checked some claims published within the comment sections of Mr Morrison's posts.

Australia's COVID-19 vaccine rollout now has some certainty but there are still many unknowns

  Australia's COVID-19 vaccine rollout now has some certainty but there are still many unknowns The announcements about Australia's COVID-19 vaccine rollout have been travelling at warp speed this week and although there are now some guarantees, there are still many unknowns."The eagle has landed," Health Minister Greg Hunt announced on Monday, declaring 142,000 doses of the Pfizer vaccine had touched down in Australia — after much nervousness.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has moved to assure Australians any coronavirus vaccine will not be compulsory, despite earlier saying he expected that would be the case. Key points Talking up hopes of a successful vaccine on Wednesday morning, Mr Morrison told Melbourne radio station 3AW he would "expect it to be as mandatory as you can possibly make it", noting the devastation COVID - 19 has wreaked on the world. "There are always exemptions for any vaccine on medical grounds, but that should be the only basis," he said.

The type of vaccine being developed against the virus has never – outside of Ebola – been used before. The trials have been extremely rushed & involved testing only small numbers. What could possibly go wrong? The first thing I want to say here is that the type of vaccine being developed against Covid - 19 has never been used before, outside of Ebola. Some people feel that they should not really be called vaccines , because they are completely different from anything that has gone before.

We've also looked at a claim made by US President Joe Biden, who compared COVID-19 deaths to those sustained in war, and check a statement from Treasurer Josh Frydenberg on so-called "welfare dependency".

Fact checking the comments on Scott Morrison's vaccine Facebook posts

Prime Minister Scott Morrison this week became one of the first people in Australia to be vaccinated against COVID-19, receiving the jab on Sunday alongside a small group that included healthcare workers, hotel quarantine workers and an 84-year-old World War II survivor.

Taking to Facebook to , Mr Morrison said he and Chief Medical Officer Paul Kelly had received the shot in order to "give further confidence to Australians these vaccines are safe and effective".

Victoria administers first COVID-19 jab

  Victoria administers first COVID-19 jab Victoria has given its first COVID-19 vaccine this morning, becoming the first state to officially begin the vaccination rollout. © Nine Monash Health's Professor Rhonda Stuart has become the first person in Victoria to receive the COVID-19 jab. Head of infection prevention at Monash Health, Professor Rhonda Stuart, was the first Victorian recipient of the Pfizer vaccine, getting the jab about 7.30am.About 100 healthcare workers are expected to be vaccinated in the first Monash Health clinic today.

As we know the new COVID - 19 disease appeared in China towards the end of 2019. Therefore it was named COVID - 19 which is an acronym for Corona Virus Disease 2019. Data from the World Integrated Trade Solution, however, shows something astonishing: “in 2017 and 2018 – two years before COVID - 19 – hundreds of millions of test kits for COVID - 19 were distributed Two years before the outbreak of COVID - 19 the USA, the EU, China and nations around the world started exporting millions of diagnostic test instruments for… COVID - 19 , a disease that supposedly didn’t even exist back then .

UK allows mixing COVID - 19 vaccines as experts warn of risks. HUNDREDS of Israelis get infected with Covid - 19 after receiving Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine . Best of the Web: COVID ' vaccines ' are a medical experiment on humanity. Best of the Web: Actual science: University of Florida researchers find no asymptomatic or presymptomatic spread of Coronavirus. Scientists scramble to identify culprit behind covid vaccine allergic reactions. Doctor reportedly has severe allergic reaction to Moderna COVID vaccine . A brilliant analysis of vaccination , by Richard Moskowitz, MD and homeopath.

But while Australian media outlets, including fact checkers, were blocked from posting to Facebook at the time of Mr Morrison's posts, hundreds of the platform's users were able to flood the comments section of many posts on Mr

Morrison's page with unfounded conspiracy theories and misinformation about the jab.

We've fact checked some of the most egregious claims — all of which are publicly visible on the Prime Minister's page.

The most common allegation shared on Mr Morrison's posts was that the orange tip of the hypodermic needle seen directed towards the Prime Minister's arm was a "cap" preventing Mr Morrison from being given the vaccine.

"If you look a bit closer you can see the orange cap is still on," one commenter said.

Others, meanwhile, claimed the wrong needle entirely was used for the vaccination.

"Any nurse or doctor immediately knows this is faked, as the wrong needle gauge was used," one woman wrote. "It should have been a blue IM [intramuscular] needle, not an orange subcutaneous needle."

Hollywood’s most awkward celebrities

  Hollywood’s most awkward celebrities When you think of celebrities, you usually imagine impossibly attractive people who never wait in line, who dine at five-star restaurants, are dressed to the nines, and look positively effortless. You think George Clooney, Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt. You think style, grace, and charisma. And then there are those celebrities who seem like they weren't prepared for fame at all. They’re the stars you love for saying the things Jennifer Aniston never would. They're sometimes unbearable to watch, but you can't look away. Click through to see the most awkward stars to ever scoot across red carpets.

After an anti - vaccine influencer posted it, it was picked up in several places, including an apocalypse-themed evangelical Christian site that promotes conspiracy theories about vaccines , the Covid - 19 pandemic and the US election. Anti - vaccine activists sent her angry messages saying she should never have taken part in the trial. At the same time, others sent her abusive messages accusing her of deliberately fuelling disinformation. Patricia insists she never meant to deliberately deceive. She disabled her social media profiles because of the messages, and says she's particularly upset by the

Suspicion of vaccines has been around almost as long as modern vaccines themselves. But in recent years, the anti - vaccination - or "anti-vax"- movement has gained traction online. Social media has been blamed for allowing unfounded claims about vaccines to spread more easily. Labour called for emergency legislation that would see financial and criminal penalties for a continued failure to act, and said they would vote for it. media captionResearch shows a number of young people may choose not to have a Covid - 19 vaccination . On Monday, news of a potential vaccine made headlines after

Catherine Bennett, the chair of epidemiology at Deakin University, told Fact Check the orange section of the needle was not a cap, but rather "the hub that holds the needle".

She added that contrary to the assertions on Facebook, the needle used on Mr Morrison would have been an intramuscular needle, and that the "low dead space" needles used for the Pfizer vaccine did not follow the same colour coding as suggested by the commenter.

Professor Bennett pointed Fact Check to a selling intramuscular needles with orange hubs in the size necessary for administering a COVID-19 vaccine.

A common argument waged by people when urging the lifting of restrictions during periods of lockdown — the supposedly high "survival rate" of people infected with COVID-19 — was referenced by commenters on Mr Morrison's posts as justification for refusing the vaccine.

"Totally unnecessary for a virus with a 98 per cent recovery rate," one Facebook user wrote, while another suggested the survival rate was as high as 99 per cent.

According to the at the Baltimore-based Johns Hopkins University, the "observed case-fatality ratio" — that is, the number of deaths per confirmed cases — is currently just over 2 per cent globally.

The Five Fallacies That Hamstrung Our Response to COVID-19

  The Five Fallacies That Hamstrung Our Response to COVID-19 The assumptions made by public officials, and the choices made by media, too often backfired.One might have expected the initial approval of the coronavirus vaccines to spark similar jubilation—especially after a brutal pandemic year. But that didn’t happen. Instead, the steady drumbeat of good news about the vaccines has been met with a chorus of relentless pessimism.

As the university , the case-fatality ratio can differ across countries, in part, due to differences in the number of people tested, the demographic of the population and variances in healthcare systems.

In Mexico, a country hit hard by the pandemic, the observed is as high as 8.8 per cent, while in the US and the UK that number is 1.8 per cent and 2.9 per cent respectively.

Australia's observed case-fatality ratio is 3 per cent.

While these figures are not far off from the claims made on Facebook, they fail to paint a full picture of the harm caused by COVID-19.

Professor Bennett told Fact Check that an Australian study had found that up to 20 per cent of COVID-19 patients still suffered symptoms months after contracting the virus, and that overseas studies had returned similar findings.

According to Professor Bennett, allowing the coronavirus to spread freely could also have devastating effects if the health system became overwhelmed.

"That would not only increase the [COVID-19] fatality rate as not everyone can then get optimum care, it also impacts health service access, including intensive care, for all indications," she explained.

"So, more people die or suffer serious consequences from illnesses when health staff, hospital beds or drug supplies are impacted."

How AstraZeneca's vaccine gets rid of its bad reputation

 How AstraZeneca's vaccine gets rid of its bad reputation © Copyright 2021, L'Obs Will the AstraZeneca vaccine soon be authorized for people over 65? While it is for the moment reserved for people below this age group, "the Sunday Journal" affirms on February 28 that the High Authority of Health "should review its copy" and "pronounce itself in a period of two weeks on an authorization for its administration to an older public ”.

A number of commenters on the Prime Minister's Facebook posts shared claims that the Moderna, Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccines all remained in a "trial phase" with end dates set for 2022 and 2023.

"The trials don't end until 2023," one woman wrote. "No one knows until after then if these [vaccines] are indeed 'safe'."

at Reuters, while it is correct that the vaccines have been given "estimated study completion" dates into the next few years, the Facebook claims lack some important context, in that it is standard practice for safety monitoring to continue after a vaccine has been approved for use.

Another popular claim repeated in Mr Morrison's comment section is the assertion that the COVID-19 vaccine can alter a person's DNA.

"Which means you are coercing ppl to have an RNA (DNA changing) experiment!," reads one comment.

BBC Reality Check, some COVID-19 jabs, including the Pfizer vaccine, use a fragment of the virus's genetic material, known as messenger RNA (mRNA).

As the fact checkers explained, the vaccine works by "giving the body instructions to produce a protein which is present on the surface of the coronavirus".

"The immune system then learns to recognise and produce antibodies against the protein."

Speaking to Reality Check, Jeffrey Almond, a visiting professor of microbiology at the University of Oxford, said that injecting RNA into a person did not "do anything to the DNA of a human cell".

The fact checkers said that was a view shared by two other independent scientists.

Fact checkers at , , , and all reached the same verdict.

The key ingredient that could hold back vaccine manufacturing

  The key ingredient that could hold back vaccine manufacturing You may not have heard of them, but lipid nanoparticles are key to the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines.Here’s part of the answer: We’re still racing to make a special type of lipid, a relatively unknown but critical component of the vaccines being manufactured by Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech. These vaccines use messenger RNA, the genetic component commonly known as mRNA that instructs cells to make proteins, which in turn teach the human body how to fight the virus that causes Covid-10.

Included in the comments left on Mr Morrison's posts were allusions to 23 Norwegian people who supposedly died after receiving a COVID-19 jab.

"Tell us about the 23 Norwegian people that died within 24 hours of being vaccinated," one man said.

These comments appear to be referring to news stories published in January which reported that there had been 23 deaths among elderly people who had received a COVID-19 vaccine in Norway.

But there's no indication that those deaths were caused by the vaccine.

According to the in a of weekly reports published by the Norwegian Medicines Agency, as of February 16 the number of deaths of elderly people reported in the two weeks following COVID-19 vaccinations had grown to 93, with most of the deceased residents of nursing homes.

"Many people in this patient group who have so far been vaccinated are very frail or terminally ill patients," the report states.

"At this time of year, an average of around 50 people die every day in the age group 85 years or older, and around 35 people every day in the age group 75-85.

"It is therefore to be expected that deaths will occur soon after vaccination, without there necessarily being any causal link to the vaccine."

In its report, the agency further explains that many of the reports of deaths state that "no link with vaccination is suspected" but that the report had been filed "for the sake of completeness".

"These reports do not currently constitute a signal of an adverse reaction and do not provide a basis for revising the product information for the vaccines," the agency concludes.

From Washington, D.C.

A month into Joe Biden's presidency, the US has passed a grim milestone — more than 500,000 American deaths from COVID-19.

The Washington Post Fact Checker Mr Biden had muddled his maths when he compared the COVID-19 death toll to that of the two world wars and the Vietnam War combined.

Black, Latino Californians Given 20% Of State's COVID Vaccines, But Make Up 42% of Population

  Black, Latino Californians Given 20% Of State's COVID Vaccines, But Make Up 42% of Population California Gov. Gavin Newsom has called equity his "North Star," but the vaccine rollout is leaving the state's largest, most vulnerable communities behind.African Americans have received 3 percent of vaccine doses while they make up 6 percent of the state, according to the Associated Press. Latinos, who make up 39 percent of the state, have received 17 percent of doses. The vaccination gap is much narrower for white Californians, who make up 36 percent of the state's population. State health data shows that 32 percent of white people in the state have already received shots.

Mr Biden, the Post said, had made a similar claim in his inaugural address when he stated the 400,000 US lives lost to COVID-19 to that point were equal to the number of lives "America lost in all of World War II".

That claim, which had included deaths in battle during World War II, as well as other deaths in service other than in theatre, checked out.

But using that same metric to assess Mr Biden's more recent claim shows that lives lost in all three wars (around 580,000) so far outnumber those lost to COVID-19 in the US.

However, another measure — looking only at lives lost in battle during those wars — gives a figure of about 392,000 deaths, aligning with Mr Biden's claim.

"Indeed, if Biden was using only battlefield deaths, he actually could have said more people died of COVID-19 than in combat during all of America's wars against foreign enemies," the fact checkers said.

"That's because fewer than 500,000 died in battle if you add up every war from the Revolutionary War to the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. (We're obviously not counting the Civil War.)"

In other news: Josh Frydenberg says welfare dependency was at a 30-year low heading into the pandemic. Is that correct?

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg recently pointed to the Government's pre-pandemic success in cutting the unemployment rate, claiming this had led to the lowest welfare dependency for three decades.

"And let's not forget that going into this crisis, we saw welfare dependency at a 30-year low because we'd got that unemployment rate down," Mr Frydenberg told ABC's Insiders program.

Fact Check that while, yes, the data does put welfare dependency at a 30-year low, there's more to the story than Mr Frydenberg's claim suggests.

In June 2019, one measure of "welfare dependency", the proportion of the working-age population being paid a major welfare benefit, was at its lowest rate — 14 per cent — since the early 1990s.

Another measure, the proportion of households getting at least half of their income in the form of government benefits, was also at a record low before the pandemic, at 22.5 per cent.

However, experts consulted by Fact Check noted that lower levels of unemployment had not been the only reason for this shift.

Government policy changes, including the introduction of tougher eligibility rules and obligations tied to some payments, the abolition of certain payments and declining payment rates relative to wages, had also played an important role.

Moreover, in the years leading up to 2020, there had been a significant increase in the number of working-age people not entitled to social security.

This growing cohort included international students, working holiday visa holders and skilled migrants, and an unknown number of New Zealanders whose social security rights were curtailed from the early 2000s.

It also included recently arrived permanent residents, who now face a four-year wait before they can receive government benefits.

Although difficult to quantify precisely, this increase has had the effect of lowering welfare dependency relative to the labour market.

Edited by Ellen McCutchan

Got a fact that needs checking? Tweet us or send us an email at

Black, Latino Californians Given 20% Of State's COVID Vaccines, But Make Up 42% of Population .
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has called equity his "North Star," but the vaccine rollout is leaving the state's largest, most vulnerable communities behind.African Americans have received 3 percent of vaccine doses while they make up 6 percent of the state, according to the Associated Press. Latinos, who make up 39 percent of the state, have received 17 percent of doses. The vaccination gap is much narrower for white Californians, who make up 36 percent of the state's population. State health data shows that 32 percent of white people in the state have already received shots.

usr: 0
This is interesting!