Australia Hotel COVID-19 quarantine is not foolproof, so is it time to reconsider home quarantine for returned travellers?
Tough medicine: COVID vaccine agency is not having a good pandemic
The doctor who gave two elderly people incorrect doses of the COVID-19 vaccine was recruited by Healthcare Australia. Its reputation isn't too healthy.The doctor was recruited by specialist workforce recruitment agency Healthcare Australia, which the federal government has given the job of recruiting and supplying the extra vaccination workforce.
Since March 2020, more than 211,000 people have returned to Australia through hotel quarantine.
While some cases have leaked out into the community in Queensland, Victoria, New South Wales and Western Australia, so far the outbreaks have been able to be controlled.
The National Cabinet continues to focus on hotel quarantine as the model for ensuring that people returning to Australia don't spread the virus and its infectious variants inside the country.
The gigantic North Korea hotel that has been abandoned for almost 30 years
It was once supposed to be the pride of the communist regime in North Korea, but the Ryugyong Hotel in Pyongyang has been abandoned since 1992. Whether it will ever be completed is questionable - but the price would be astronomical. In Pyongyang, the capital of North Korea, there is a building that far towers over the rest of the cityscape. It is almost reminiscent of a jet fighter about to take off vertically into the air.
Today the federal government announced the.
But with more and more people wanting to return to Australia, some in the community are asking if it's worth taking another look at allowing those travellers to quarantine at home instead.
Has home quarantine been formally suggested before?
Yep, it has.in Victoria led by Jennifer Coate last year suggested a mix of hotel quarantine and quarantine in the home.
It wouldn't be for everyone — only those who were at minimal risk — presumably those coming from low-risk countries.
"Where a person can safely quarantine at home this avoids the risk of putting that person in physical proximity with others who are suspected of having COVID-19," the report said.
Qatar Airways passengers have hotel quarantine extended in Brisbane
Queensland Health said their monitoring of Covid cases identified a 'potential link' between infections detected with the B1.1.317 variant in a Qatar Airways flight.Queensland Health said their monitoring of Covid cases identified a 'potential link' between infections detected with the B1.1.317 variant in a Qatar Airways service.
"It also reduces the number of workers required in the quarantine facility, thereby reducing the number of people potentially being exposed to the risk of contracting the virus."
Others think it's a good idea too.
Sara Condron is a healthcare worker at a Perth hospital.
She travelled to Melbourne to see her father when he was seriously ill. Now she's back in Perth and quarantining at home.
Clearly there's a big difference between a person who travels within Australia and someone returning from overseas.
But Ms Condron said the benefits of home quarantine are clear for everyone to see.
"Quarantining is quite feasible at home — and you're not costing the government and you're not costing yourself — provided you've got some support," she said.
"At home you've got everything. And you're not a drain on any resource. No need for security guards."
Ms Condron said the mental health benefits of quarantining at home were enormous.
South African COVID-19 strain confirmed in Canberra's two active hotel quarantine cases
Canberra has recorded its first cases of the more contagious South African strain of COVID-19. Two returned travellers in hotel quarantine have tested positive for the variant..The two travellers arrived on a repatriation flight from Singapore on Monday.
"If you're in a hotel room and you've got nothing … then it's very difficult. I think anybody coming back from overseas if they had a preference would do home quarantine," she said.
Epidemiologist Catherine Bennett, from Deakin University, said Victoria had had thousands of people isolating at home as secondary or close contacts and by and large, most of them had complied with their obligations.
"It's something that has worked for the management of local outbreaks," Professor Bennett said.
"We know it can work. We've got smart tech solutions to keep it secure and randomised checking indicated that people … were doing the right thing."
What about when more people are vaccinated?
Tony Blakely, an epidemiologist from The University of Melbourne, said home quarantine may be appropriate when we get about 60 per cent of the population vaccinated in Australia.
"Then there should be little risk from infected folk arriving, because the virus is unlikely to take off and spread much," he said.
He said the returned travellers should probably be from low-risk countries, like China, South Korea and New Zealand, who are already vaccinated.
The Quest to Unlock the Mysteries of Long COVID
Low-tech treatments are helping some patients—and revealing more about how the virus does its damage.Image above: Nearly a year after she was infected with the coronavirus, Caitlin Barber still uses a wheelchair outside.
But there is still a risk, even if people are vaccinated, in high-risk countries like the UK.
"The vaccine is not perfect at stopping you getting infected and being able to pass it on," he said.
"So maybe for someone coming from a low-risk country such as China or South Korea and they are vaccinated, then the risk is low enough to use home quarantine.
But Professor Blakely doubts Australia could develop such a "nuanced" border policy.
Professor Bennett agrees that home quarantine may become a more viable option when vaccination rates increase.
She believes the focus at the border will be on keeping the more infectious variants out of the country where the vaccine might not be as effective.
"In those situations you might say those people with that strain … they might go into managed quarantine facilities," Professor Bennett said.
"Other people who have common garden varieties of COVID that we now know won't get very far in the community because more people are vaccinated — that's when we might rely more on home quarantine."
If the variants did get into the country that's when the international border quarantine program would play an important role, Professor Bennett said.
What about using technology?
If we wanted to use home quarantine to allow more people to safely return home to Australia, electronic tracking is one way to ensure they comply with COVID-19 quarantine obligations.
‘More severe than war’: Health workers reflect on a year of COVID
A year into the pandemic, front-line health workers around the world share their experiences battling the coronavirus.Front-line health workers around the world have faced enormous challenges to deliver essential care to patients, struggling with a lack of equipment, the constant fear of spreading the virus, and other issues such as social misconceptions relating to their work.
, Hong Kong and Abu Dhabi. Israel has also started a pilot project with electronic tracking devices.
Researcher Marietta Martinovic from RMIT University has studied the use of GPS technology to monitor convicted criminals for 20 years.
She said there had been big advances in GPS technology which could determine if people were confined to their homes by wearing devices that looked much like a hospital bracelet.
"You just cut [them] off at the end of use," she said.
"They cost less than $100 and they're already being used in places like Singapore."
In Singapore, people are given the bracelets at the airport and the devices are activated by an app or via a wall socket when they get home.
"And voila, they are monitored for 14 days in the confines of their home," Dr Martinovic said.
"I think something like that absolutely makes sense moving forward."
There would have to be a broader framework in place to determine who could qualify for home quarantine and who needed to go into hotel quarantine.
"There have to be clear rules and regulations about those options," she said.
Meanwhile, Sara Condron's keeping busy sewing, cooking and doing craft as she finishes her two weeks of quarantine at home in Perth.
"I think anybody coming back from overseas — if they had a preference — would do home quarantine," she said.
Sydney hotel quarantine worker tests positive to COVID-19 .
The quarantine worker had been working at two separate hotels and had received their first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine.NSW Health Minister Brad Hazzard said authorities were notified of the locally acquired case late last night and urgent contact tracing and genome sequencing is underway.