•   
  •   

Sport AFL and NRL grand finals TV coverage marred by vaudevillian commentary and one-sided analysis

02:20  27 october  2020
02:20  27 october  2020 Source:   msn.com

Gal: The Storm sledge I will never forget

  Gal: The Storm sledge I will never forget PAUL GALLEN: This is such a great grand final match-up that right now, I honestly can't say who I think will win.This is such a great grand final match-up that right now, I honestly can't say who I think will win.

AFL and NRL grand finals TV coverage marred by vaudevillian commentary and one - sided analysis . Is being 'decent' enough for Biden to win the US election? ATO's debt book grows to more than b.

AFL and NRL grand finals TV coverage marred by vaudevillian commentary and one - sided analysis . Posted 23mminutes agoMonMonday 26 OctOctober 2020 at 6:57pm. A mercy flight is finally bringing home Australians stranded in India.

As much as sport has become a product to be neatly packaged and presented in the highest-rating TV timeslot rather than the one most convenient for attendees, some of us still prefer to go to the game.

This was the first winter in 30 years that I could not attend an AFL or NRL match. The result was an unusual and inevitably unsatisfying reliance on TV coverage that made me yearn for my hard, moulded-plastic seat.

This is partly a matter of perception. As has been explained adroitly on this site by Russell Jackson, the TV cameras do not — and perhaps cannot — capture the vast Australian rules oval (and even the smaller rugby league grid) as completely as the human eye.

2020 AFL grand final: The ultimate preview

  2020 AFL grand final: The ultimate preview Some 217 days after the season started without a single soul watching Richmond play Carlton live at the MCG, the strangest AFL season in history will conclude when up to 30,000 fans pack the Gabba for a historic grand final between the Tigers and the Cats. It will be the first to be played away from the MCG since 1991, the first ever to be played outside of the state of Victoria and the first to be played at night. As a symbol, a small patch of MCG grass was trucked from Melbourne up to Brisbane last week and will be transplanted into the Gabba turf.

The NRL ’s grand final between Melbourne and Penrith on Sunday attracted a national average TV audience of 2.967 million and a peak audience of 3.442 million. The national average audience represented a 12% increase on last year’s figure of 2.641 million from the Sydney Roosters-Canberra

AFL live scores: Grand Final match centre. Martin’s freakish effort of four goals – all miraculous solo efforts – handed him the Norm Catch Fox Footy’s Grand Final Week coverage on Kayo. Stream all the latest news and insight right up until first bounce plus half-time and full-time analysis from the Fox

Then there is the experience of attendance: the companionship, the passion, the rise and fall of the crowd and that joyful or solemn walk from the ground to a nearby pub to digest the result with friends.

For all these reasons, the regular attendee can feel confined by and even captive to a TV broadcast that provides only a two-dimensional representation of our usually three-dimensional perception and none of the social niceties.

But on the most significant weekend for both the AFL and NRL, the greatest bugbear of this captive season was laid bare — the foibles of contemporary TV commentary and analysis.

There has been a gradual shift in the way AFL games are called. Once the action and the audience were the primary focus, now the game is as often a muse for chummy colleagues exchanging in-house banter.

The AFL all-time great alphabet teams: The wrap-up

  The AFL all-time great alphabet teams: The wrap-up Now that we have 21 teams based on surnames, it’s time to look at a few selection changes based on feedback and additional research as well as compare each team to come out with an overall best letter. You can read the full team lists here. Let’s start with some selection changes.

TV ratings for the NRL and AFL grand finals show its still a challenge to engage a national broadcast audience that covers non-traditional areas. During the NRL grand final between the Melbourne Storm and the However, analysis of ratings suggests that the value of grand final appearances, in

TV ratings for the NRL and AFL grand finals show its still a challenge to engage a national broadcast audience that covers non-traditional areas. Some fans take their sport very seriously such as this Hawthorn supporter during the 2013 AFL Grand Final . But what if you don’t have a team in the finals ?

BT and co flip the switch to vaudeville

This style seems to have its origins in FM radio, from where Seven's most prominent commentator, Brian Taylor — BT to his colleagues and legion of fans — and several other callers have emerged.

Taylor was excellent at engaging the audience of 21 to 45-year-old males Triple M expertly cultivated.

The blustery, blokey tone, the deliberate mispronunciations, the confected nicknames, the elongated vowels and the macho confrontations with fellow callers were hallmarks of the most successful radio shtick since another vaudevillian, Rex Hunt, hit the airwaves.

Like Taylor, Hunt was recruited by Seven. Although when it became obvious his bombastic style distracted from and even contradicted the vision rather than complementing it, he returned to the radio box. No shame there.

This also explains why one antidote prescribed to poor TV commentary — "Just turn it down and put on the radio!" — doesn't work well. Radio commentary is a separate art form that often jars with the visual medium that at its best embraces contemplative silence.

Dusty v Danger - two AFL giants who couldn't be more different

  Dusty v Danger - two AFL giants who couldn't be more different Richmond bad boy Dustin Martin and Geelong's Patrick Dangerfield might be likened to chalk and cheese off the footy ground. As far as the general public knows about it anyway. 'Dusty' Martin doesn't care much about revealing to the wider world what it is that actually makes him tick. In the wild, he's often described as aloof, arrogant and perhaps a little bit caught up in his own opinion of himself. He has good reason to think that way of course. 'Danger' is the polar opposite. The Cat superstar has participated in endless interviews for television, radio and newspapers this season.

Entry to all rugby league matches under the control of the NRL is subject to a number of conditions. NRL TV /. Grand Final Archive. Watch all of the matches from 1966 to 2018.

Phil Gould has taken to radio to hit back at claims his commentary during the NRL grand final wasn’t up to scratch. Speaking on Sydney talkback station 2GB on Monday morning, the former Panthers boss said he wasn’t biased in favour of his old team during his call for Channel Nine on Sunday night.

Although, it is apparent the reality show generation is accustomed to constant noise and the commentators talking to each other, not them. Indeed, many prefer it this way.

Perhaps this is why the style of BT and others who provide a kind of Gogglebox Footy experience, shouting over the game and each other rather than adding to the vision, is rewarded with big-game status.

Personally, throughout the AFL season I could not help wondering why the legacy of the game's greatest TV caller, Dennis Cometti, had been so quickly forgotten.

Cometti was mellifluous but also precise, prescient and — if anything — underestimated for his football knowledge.

The dry one-liners for which he was renowned — "he entered the pack optimistically and emerged misty optically" — were only occasional asides rather than the cornerstone of an otherwise astute commentary that left you feeling you knew more about what you had just seen.

Gould gets Storm fans' goat

Nine's veteran rugby league caller Ray Warren, with whom Cometti might be compared, remains the reliable, even soothing voice of his game.

Melburnians celebrate Richmond Tigers' historic AFL Grand Final win

  Melburnians celebrate Richmond Tigers' historic AFL Grand Final win Crowds dressed in yellow and black marched along Swan Street in Richmond to ring in the victory on Saturday night. Fans chanted as they walked around while cars drove down the street honking their horns. Carrying signs and waving flags, the Richmond supporters were ecstatic their team had clinched the Premiership Cup for 2020.

Moment reporter is forced to abandon her NRL Grand Final report after being swamped by A Channel 9 reporter was forced to abandon her coverage of the NRL Grand Final on Sunday night Given the youth of the current 2020 side , most of the men would've been pre-schoolers and toddlers

The AFL Grand Final between Geelong and Richmond looked set to be a slippery affair with the heavens opening in Brisbane on Saturday. Catch Fox Footy’s Grand Final Week coverage on Kayo. Stream all the latest news and insight right up until first bounce plus half-time and full-time analysis

It was the performance of Warren's offsider, Nine analyst Phil Gould, that rankled Melburnians, particularly, on grand final night.

As a former Penrith player, premiership coach and, until last season, the club's general manager, it was inevitable Gould would have a leaning toward the Panthers.

But as "Gus" trained his monocular on the Panthers it was fortunate Nine provided vision. If you had only listened to his comments you would have assumed Penrith had romped to a record-breaking victory.

Gould's antipathy towards the Storm — or, more kindly, his unstinting appreciation of their opposition — has become a reliable, even dryly amusing part of the Storm grand-final-viewing experience and plays into Melbourne's us-against-them mentality.

But, on this occasion, Gould lurched to the absurd when he declared the lopsided scoreboard was "so unfair to the Panthers", Melbourne's scoring feats and unstinting defence having somehow escaped his attention.

By the time Gould and his fellow commentators had abandoned the narrative-disrupting Storm dominance to engage in a State of Origin preview, it was well beyond an "ear of the beholder" belief that the coverage was an in-house Penrith production.

The Storm were left to provide the element of admiration and respect themselves, Cameron Smith's gracious victory speech an antidote to the almost grudging regard for their outstanding performance.

Now to the cricket season, where the couch bound have recently been presented a clear distinction: Seven's coverage, led by accomplished broadcasters Tim Lane and Alison Mitchell, has catered for the devotee, while Fox Sports' more raucous commentary has covered the T20 generation.

Although, after a winter held captive to the TV coverage, I doubt I'm the only one eager to get to the ground and let the action speak for itself.

Why AFL's night Grand Final is here to stay .
SHANE MCINNES: The curveball of COVID-19 forced the AFL's hand this season and some changes must remain.The curveball of the coronavirus pandemic forced the AFL's hand in many ways this season, with the league required to make changes to the game nobody could have foreseen back in February.

usr: 1
This is interesting!