Sport The coaching scrutiny ladder
Hot City wary of Mariners in A-League game
Melbourne City have shot up the A-League table but will face their biggest yet when they host ladder-leading Central Coast at AAMI Park.After a slow start to Patrick Kisnorbo's tenure as coach, City have found the form that saw them reach a grand final for the first time last season.
Already only two rounds into the 2021 AFL season, the murmurs and media talk – including social media chatter – turns to coaches and the extent to which they are scrutinised.
Based on this chatter and other factors, I have constructed a coaching scrutiny ladder ranging from the most under scrutiny or pressure, perceived or otherwise, to the least.
I then compare with the current position of the team on the ladder. This is an exercise that can be conducted at various stages of the year.
Coaching scrutiny ladder
1. Nathan Buckley (Collingwood, ninth)
2. Simon Goodwin (Melbourne, fourth)
3. David Teague (Carlton, 15th)
A-League ladder to get tighter: Stajcic
The congested A-League ladder could get even tighter, according to Alen Stajcic, coach of the table-topping Central Coast Mariners.Saturday's 1-1 home draw with last-placed Melbourne Victory extended the Mariners' winless run to three but they remain at the top of the table.
4. Ken Hinkley (Port Adelaide, first)
5. Chris Scott (Geelong, 11th)
6. Leon Cameron (GWS, 16th)
7. John Longmire (Sydney Swans, third)
8. Brett Ratten (St Kilda, tenth)
9. Ben Rutten (Essendon, 17th)
10. David Noble (North Melbourne, 18th)
11. Chris Fagan (Brisbane, 14th)
12. Matthew Nicks (Adelaide, 12th)
13. Stuart Dew (Gold Coast Suns, sixth)
14. Justin Longmuir (Fremantle, eighth)
15. Luke Beveridge (Western Bulldogs, fifth)
16. Adam Simpson (West Coast Eagles, seventh)
17. Alastair Clarkson (Hawthorn, 13th)
18. Damian Hardwick (Richmond, second)
Video: Big guns return for Blues' blockbuster (Wide World of Sports)
I group the coaching scrutiny ladder into six groups. The first group is made up of positions one to four in scrutiny and pressure.
NRL ScoreCentre: Knights vs Wests Tigers, Cowboys vs Titans, live scores, stats and results
The Titans will be hoping to continue their north-of-the-border dominance against Cowboys, while the Wests Tigers claim their first win of the season. Follow our ScoreCentre for all the live scores and stats.While the Wests Tigers have spoiled Mitchell Pearce 300th NRL match posting their first premiership points of the season.
Collingwood being Collingwood means that the coach is always under the pump. Add to this close to ten years in the job, with limited success, and it means that Nathan Buckley takes number one position.
Interestingly, the first four are from big clubs that are historically successful, but they have very limited recent success in premierships. These clubs attract considerable external noise.
The choice of Ken Hinkley at number four might surprise but expectations are high at the spiritual home Alberton Oval, and although things are going well at the moment, that can change at any moment.
The next group ranges from positions five to seven. This group should be under more pressure but are perhaps surprisingly not as much so. Despite Chris Scott’s protestations, the performance of Geelong in the finals since their last premiership has been mediocre.
Katrina Powell named new Hockeyroos coach
New Hockeyroos coach Katrina Powell will have less than four months to unite a fractured squad for the Tokyo Olympics, but she's up for the challenge.The Hockeyroos have been mired in off-field dramas for years, the issue coming to a head in 2020 when allegations of bullying, body shaming and homophobic behaviour were aired by current and former players.
A shock loss to Adelaide in Round 1 and a very lucky win against Brisbane at home should have the pressure metre running hot.
For GWS, it is surprising that the coach does not come under more scrutiny given the rapid fall from grace following a grand final appearance in 2019 and player exodus. Perhaps being outside the Melbourne media bubble assists.
John Longmire is revitalising his side, going for youth, although Sydney’s finals performances since their flag in 2012 have been patchy, including two grand final losses in 2014 and 2016.
Brett Ratten is in a group on his own at number eight. He is an experienced coach, although not at St Kilda. His overall coaching record is mixed, but St Kilda looks in promising shape, notwithstanding their loss at the weekend.
The next group relates to positions nine and ten. These are the first-year coaches, who despite ladder positions, will be given reasonable breathing space. However, should the losses mount, then the heat will come quickly.
Following this group are those in positions 11 to 14. These are recent coaches in the AFL, with less than five years at the helm, and in a number of cases are either tracking well or building nicely, such as Gold Coast under Stuart Dew and Fremantle under Justin Longmuir.
Take 5: Weighing the potential replacements for Roy Williams
While statistically David Teague fits into this camp, the pressure of being head coach at Carlton elevates him into the most scrutinised category.
Sports opinion delivered daily
Finally is the group 15-18 that is in the ‘recent credits in the bank’ classification – coaches who have achieved the ultimate premiership in recent times. The incumbent premiership coach, Damien Hardwick, has the most credits and obtains the wooden spoon for being the least under scrutiny.
The ladder above shows a comparison between the coaching scrutiny ladder and actual ladder position of the club in question at this moment.
There is no overwhelmingly strong relationship between the two. However, tentatively, there appears to be some relationship at the lower reaches of the coach ladder. More secure leaders have their clubs in better positions.
Of course, the sample size is only small based on two rounds, but as has been said a great deal in recent days, very few clubs recover to make finals after being 0-2 down. I have no doubt as well that the scrutiny ladder will vary considerably before we see the end of 2021.
Emma Watkins' rare new footage with fiance Olive Brian .
Emma Watkins shares rare new footage with her husband to be, Oliver Brian that will melt your heart. Emma Watkins aka the beloved yellow-skivvy wearing Wiggle, stunned fans this week when she announced she was engaged! The news, which was, of course, joyous, came as somewhat of a surprise to followers as the performer has kept her relationship with fiancé Oliver Brian relatively private until now. In fact, Emma's engagement announcement was her first post with Oliver on Instagram, ever.