Sport Sydney stadium development sparks debate over costs, but do the leagues and clubs even deserve them?

23:52  07 december  2017
23:52  07 december  2017 Source:   msn.com

A-League clubs allege FFA board conflicts

  A-League clubs allege FFA board conflicts The A-League clubs have detailed a list of 13 potential conflicts of interest involving FFA board members on the morning of a crucial meeting in Sydney.The Australian Professional Football Clubs Association (AFPCA), the lobby group formed by the 10 clubs, wrote to FFA chairman Steven Lowy on Thursday morning to outline their concerns about the independence of his board.

Опубликовано: 7 дек. 2017 г. Sydney stadium development sparks debate over costs , but do the leagues and clubs even deserve them ?

The debate about Sydney 's proposed stadium developments has centred mainly on cost , writes Richard Hinds, but do the football leagues and clubs really deserve shiny new homes?

a close up of a stadium© Provided by ABC Grandstand Amid the outrage about the "astronomical price tag" and the tub-thumping of the Stop the Stadiums campaigners, the most significant question about Sydney's proposed $2.5 billion venue redevelopment has been lost.

Ask not whether Sydney can afford better places to play rugby league, football and rugby. Ask whether the leagues who administer those sports and the clubs who play them deserve palatial new homes.

More than a decade ago, as a Victorian working in the Sydney media, the plan now embraced by the NSW Government seemed as obvious as the rain pouring through the roof at the Sydney Football Stadium.

Drug raids across Sydney's west

  Drug raids across Sydney's west NSW Police have targeted a number of properties in drug raids in Sydney's northwest.Police in riot gear have swooped more than a dozen homes in Sydney's west and northwest, in a series of early morning drug raids.

As I wrote then, the Olympic Stadium was famed for a few great moments but despised by week-to-week fans of all codes because of its lack of intimacy and atmosphere. Thus it must kick the AFL to the kerbside and become a rectangle if it was to attract larger crowds for NRL and possibly A-League and Super Rugby games.

The SFS and Parramatta Stadium were laughably outdated by contemporary standards, a common problem with the bland cookie cutter stadiums built in the 1980s. Knock them down and build modern facilities that would not only cater for existing crowds but attract more fans and corporate clients.

That it took so long for the NSW Government and the various stakeholders to reach this seemingly obvious conclusion says much about the byzantine nature of Sydney sports politics.

NRL Women's Premiership a dream come true for Jillaroos hero Ruan Sims

  NRL Women's Premiership a dream come true for Jillaroos hero Ruan Sims Sims did not think this landmark moment would happen so quickly.In 2018, she will be joined by a host of others after the NRL unveiled their new elite women's program. Central to the program will be a six-team competition that will be played in the lead-up to and during the NRL finals series, giving women the chance to shine on the biggest stage.

Sydney stadium development sparks debate over costs , but do the leagues and clubs even deserve them ? Ericsson may make Digital goodwill A thrilling draw away to Salzburg enabled Serbian champions Red Star Belgrade to reach the Champions League group stage for the first time

The Sydney stadium debate is finally over , with NSW premier Mike Baird announcing the government will spend .6bn on reconfiguring ANZ stadium and refurbishing Allianz stadium . Now they won’t be getting a new venue at all. “We have said from the outset that we wanted to negotiate with clubs

The SCG Trust is mistrusted and the Sydney Olympic Park Authority lacks authority. Meanwhile sports not only fight each other but also among themselves because clubs have opposing interests. The outcome — lots of grandstanding but few new grandstands.

Western Sydney Wanderers submit transfer request for three Sydney FC stars

  Western Sydney Wanderers submit transfer request for three Sydney FC stars Western Sydney Wanderers have added more fuel to Saturday's Sydney A-League Derby by submitting a transfer request to Sydney FC in hope of signing three of their starting players. The Wanderers have already turned their attention to recruitment for next season and have placed a number of players from their fiercest rivals at the top of their shopping list.Fairfax Media understands Sydney FC received a letter from their cross-town foes on Wednesday night confirming the Wanderers are set to make approaches to sign three of their starting defenders for next season.

Today, over 2000 students and 140 schools participate in monthly debates . Every day we support debate practices. Every week we offer Saturday workshops. Every weekend our debaters travel to local, regional, and national tournaments.

Debate clubs work best when there is a strong sense of group identity, when members feel that they are part of something. Ideas must be mulled over and distilled; speeches must be drafted and revised. Coaches must encourage and monitor the development of each debater individually. And certainly, the debate club should publicize its results. A team that does well deserves the recognition

Then there was ingrained resistance of the Sydney public. The self-defeating arguments that Sydney has "unique geographical problems", "rugby league is a TV game", "we've got better things to do" and "we love our suburban grounds — although we don't actually go to them".

It was this can't-do attitude, even more than the governmental dithering and petty squabbling between stadium operators that surprised me when I dared suggest Sydney fans deserved better stadiums.

Back then, however, I assumed the various codes would unlock their potential or heighten demand and crowds would increase. Just as — Sydney sports fans will hate to hear — the AFL had done when it moved from relatively poorly populated suburban venues to impressive new or refurbished stadiums.

There is compelling evidence that better stadiums help improve attendances. But even as the NSW Government ticks every box on the stadium wish list, it is hard to make a case that the three codes that would benefit from redevelopment have done enough to grow their games and, in turn, justify such extravagant expenditure.

Brisbane Roar's Avram Papadopoulos banned for seven weeks for spitting at Matt Simon

  Brisbane Roar's Avram Papadopoulos banned for seven weeks for spitting at Matt Simon The incident occurred in the second half of a round 8 match on November 25 at Allianz Stadium.The penalty was handed down today by the Disciplinary and Ethics Committee and includes one match already served.

The former Olympic Stadium , now home to West Ham, faced operational losses running into millions of The soaring cost of the retractable seating, always considered a prerequisite by West Ham if the stadium was There is also understood to be concern over whether the stadium configuration can be returned to “ They hoped they would find a use for it afterwards and there was no advance planning.

After London’s mayor Sadiq Khan ordered an inquiry into the inflated cost of the stadium , a look at how the Hammers Tentative talks with football clubs , including West Ham, had proved inconclusive. And now the cost has risen even further? Yes. It is now estimated that the total bill for the conversion will be at The new questions over rising costs and how they are met will only increase that tension.

The historic bungling by Sydney's three rectangular codes is exemplified by how the AFL's savvy lobbyists snatched the lion's share of stadium funding from under their noses. The NRL, FFA and ARU, or their predecessors, stood by as the southern interlopers occupied the Olympic Stadium, won funding for the redevelopment of the SCG and built Blacktown Olympic Park (subsequently abandoned) and the Showgrounds Stadium.

All while NRL clubs were getting meagre grants to put another lick of paint on crumbling suburban fortresses attended by relatively meagre crowds.

The NRL has made some attempts to take its sport beyond its hard-core constituency and grow the game. Membership models have improved somewhat and some blockbuster games have been initiated.

Yet rugby league won't cut the cord with the self-interested club war lords, muck-raking media crisis merchants and underworld figures who cast a pall over a brilliant game now played close to its optimal level. A game with big stadium potential is thus retarded by its small-minded suburban past.

After a promising start, the A-League has stagnated, even as the standard of the games improve. The Western Sydney Wanderers' belated inclusion and inevitable popularity made the case for a new Parramatta Stadium compelling. But the current lack of momentum invites scepticism Sydney FC would fill a flexible new SFS in "championship", "club" or even "wet day against the Wellington Phoenix" mode.

Siemsen at the double as Sydney win derby

  Siemsen at the double as Sydney win derby Young Matildas striker Remy Siemsen has netted twice as the Sky Blues beat Western Sydney 3-1 in the first top-tier female fixture held at ANZ Stadium.The Young Matildas striker netted twice in the 21st minute to give the Sky Blues the early advantage in the first top-tier female fixture to be held at ANZ Stadium.

The Pacific Pro League is the latest developmental league that's hoping to provide its players with a It seems more likely that one of them will be struck by lightning while debating his tax-deductible donations In these three prominent D- leagues , games are usually played in high school stadiums , in front of The original teams were essentially local clubs , and the Packers got their moniker because

ANZ Stadium to be reconfigured. Allianz Stadium to undergo a major refurb. The first part of the scheme Sydney ’s newspapers have described the decision not to build a new venue at Moore Park in addition to There are many stakeholders involved and, listening to them , I strongly believe we have come to Our aim was to ensure that rugby league benefited from any allocation of stadium funding

Rugby? You can understand why former Wallaby Peter FitzSimons initiated an anti-stadiums petition that has more than 120,000 signatories. To a Waratahs fan, investing in anything more than a new shoe box to accommodate dwindling crowds would seem an indulgence.

FitzSimons has pushed predictable populist buttons by suggesting $2.5 billion would be better spent on hospitals, schools and other infrastructure. The argument is valid, perhaps even inarguable, although I suspect it would not seem so compelling had stadium building commenced earlier and expenditure been spread over many years.

Instead the one fat, seemingly extravagant $2.5 billion price tag is an easy target for those who believe Sydney had its chance to get better stadiums when it built new venues at Moore Park and Parramatta and won the Sydney Olympics and blew it. No do-overs!

The irony is that Sydneysiders have long been ridiculed for their fickle sporting allegiance. Now some are passionate about a sporting cause — they are determined to ensure their city does not have better stadiums.

Meanwhile thousands nestle into comfortable seats with superb sightlines at Adelaide Oval, the MCG, Lang Park and, soon, the new Perth Stadium and enjoy the game.

Shane Watson smashes absolutely ridiculous century .
Shane Watson has shown that he is still a force to be reckoned with.Former Australia all-rounder Shane Watson has tuned-up for the start of the BBL with an astonishing T20 innings for club side Sutherland in the Sydney grade competition.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!