Tech & Science : Sorry, It Looks Like A Researcher Didn't Just Crack The Voynich Manuscript After All - - PressFrom - Australia
  •   
  •   

Tech & Science Sorry, It Looks Like A Researcher Didn't Just Crack The Voynich Manuscript After All

01:45  19 may  2019
01:45  19 may  2019 Source:   gizmodo.com.au

The Person Who Solves the Mysterious Inscription on This French Rock Will Be Awarded $2200

The Person Who Solves the Mysterious Inscription on This French Rock Will Be Awarded $2200 The village of Plougastel-Daoulas in Brittany, France is home to a stone with a mysterious message that could date back centuries.

Sorry, It Looks Like A Researcher Didn't Just Crack The Voynich Manuscript After All © Image: The Voynich Manuscript Pages of the manuscript (Image: The Voynich Manuscript) A university in the United Kingdom is backpedalling after publishing an article claiming that one of their scientists helped crack the famously indecipherable Voynich manuscript, according to a statement.

The manuscript dates back to the 15th century, and Polish book dealer Wilfrid Voynich purchased the book in 1912. Since then, cryptographers have worked to decode the book’s mysterious language. No attempt has been verified.

Earlier this week, the University of Bristol claimed that one of its researchers had cracked the script and, as has happened several times before, experts are refuting the claims.

Airbnb backs government proposal to crack down on tax cheats

Airbnb backs government proposal to crack down on tax cheats Online rental giant Airbnb has backed a proposed new reporting regime that cracks down on Australian taxpayers who are under-declaring their incomes. Airbnb yesterday told hosts it supported the Federal Government’s proposal for gig economy platforms to share their online sellers’ financial information with the Australian Tax Office. The goal is ensure Australians correctly report their income from jobs such as renting out their home on Airbnb, driving an Uber or completing a task through Airtasker. “The Treasury is currently considering a new mandatory data sharing framework for the sharing economy.

The (now deleted) May 15 University of Bristol press release declared that “A University of Bristol academic has succeeded where countless cryptographers, linguistics scholars and computer programs have failed”. The paper cited by the press release, published in the peer-reviewed journal Romance Studies by University of Bristol researcher Gerard Cheshire, breaks down the manuscript letter by letter.

It claims that the manuscript is written in a “Proto-Romance language”, and is a “compendium of information on herbal remedies, therapeutic bathing and astrological readings concerning the matters of the female mind, of the body, or reproduction, of parenting, and of the heart in accordance with Catholic and Roman Pagan beliefs...” and compiled by a Dominican nun.

Kyrgios' astonishing crack at Nadal, Djokovic

Kyrgios' astonishing crack at Nadal, Djokovic Nick Kyrgios has roasted Rafael Nadal, Novak Djokovic and more in an incredible no-holds-barred interview.

Like other past claims, this most recent claim was accompanied by a barrage of press from tabloids and other sites repeating the text of the press release.

But immediately, the challenges began rolling in. “Sorry, folks, ‘proto-Romance language’ is not a thing. This is just more aspirational, circular, self-fulfilling nonsense,” Lisa Fagin Davis, executive director of the Medieval Academy of America, tweeted.

“I tried several years ago to reproduce Cheshire’s Voynich results, because initially I was intrigued. But when you apply his Roman-letter substitutions and then try to translate the result, you have no choice but to be subjective. It’s gibberish. The methodology falls apart,” she tweeted later.

“Regarding the decipherment of the individual symbols, a number of people have come up with a mapping to Latin letters, but those mappings rarely agree with each other, or with this proposal,” Greg Kondrak from the University of Alberta told Jennifer Ouellette at Ars Technica.

Facebook Has So Many Apps, It's Killing One You Didn't Know Existed

Facebook Has So Many Apps, It's Killing One You Didn't Know Existed Instagram is reportedly killing off its direct message app. And the most surprising thing about this is that Instagram has a direct message app? As CNET reports, Wednesday night social media consultant Matt Navarra observed that users of Instagram’s standalone app Direct are given a notice that reads: “In the coming month, we’ll no longer be supporting the Direct app. Your conversations will automatically move over to Instagram, so you don’t need to do anything.” This was news to many people at Gizmodo. Instagram debuted Direct in December 2017 and we did, in fact, cover it at the time.

All of the pushback prompted the University of Bristol to retract their press release and issue a statement, which ended: “Following media coverage, concerns have been raised about the validity of this research from academics in the fields of linguistics and medieval studies. We take such concerns very seriously and have therefore removed the story regarding this research from our website to seek further validation and allow further discussions both internally and with the journal concerned.”

Claims that the Voynich manuscript have been solved are about as common as claims of proofs of the Riemann hypothesis, most recently from Turkish electrical engineer Ahmet Ardiç who claimed that the text is written in old Turkish, and television screenplay writer Nicholas Gibbs who claimed it was mainly Latin abbreviations, Ars Technica reported.

It’s always exciting — but new announcements rarely hold any water.

How did all of this happen? First off, “peer review” is an important first step in the scientific process, but it is not a stamp of approval. It’s like a restaurant telling you that the food is cooked — it might still be awful or give you food poisoning. Peer reviewed papers are frequently retracted or corrected.

Archaeological Mystery Deepens As More 'Jars Of The Dead' Uncovered In Laos

Archaeological Mystery Deepens As More 'Jars Of The Dead' Uncovered In Laos An ancient burial practice involving the use of massive stone jars seems to have been more widespread in Southeast Asia than once assumed, owing to a surprising trove of new discoveries in Laos. A team of archaeologists co-led by Dougald O’Reilly from the Australian National University, with help from Lao government officials, have discovered 15 new megalithic sites in Laos containing 137 previously unidentified stone jars that are thought to have been related, in some way, to disposal of the dead.

Then there’s the science media hype-pipeline. Universities will find an interesting paper and summarise it in layperson terms uncritically for a press release. Many online news sites will pretty much parrot the press release with a sexier headline without vetting the claims.

The more in-depth analysis is usually left to a select few news outlets — but inevitably, factually accurate stories are less interesting than the press release or come out after the hype train has left the station.

Anyway, the Voynich manuscript is probably not decoded. Maybe it will never be completely decoded! But if you want the full truth behind a wild claim, it’s usually worth waiting a day or two to see how the experts have weighed in.

Pictures: 16 of history's greatest unsolved mysteries

Read more

Power companies vulnerable to Uber-style disruption, researcher warns.
The move could be a double-edged sword for households, with the benefits of potentially lower power bills offset by the risk of more intermittent supply. QUT researcher Associate Professor Robert Perrons recently addressed a United Nations event in Geneva, Switzerland, to warn of a coming change in the energy sector. Professor Perrons said an agile digital disrupter could easily insert itself into the existing power supply chain before big power companies could react. “The archetypes are obvious- we see the Ubers, the AirBNBs, the Amazon.coms,” he said.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 6
This is interesting!