•   
  •   

Tech & Science Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that

18:29  13 july  2019
18:29  13 july  2019 Source:   cnet.com

Amazon confirms it holds on to Alexa data even if you delete audio files

Amazon confirms it holds on to Alexa data even if you delete audio files ‘The American people deserve to understand how their personal data is being used’

Here ' s what we know about that . First Amazon admitted it -- now Google says it's listening , too. Here are the specifics, and the questions we still Personally, I don't have a problem with an Amazon or Google employee or contractor listening to an anonymized recording of me saying "turn off the

Is an Amazon employee listening to you? In a response to the story, Amazon confirmed to CNN Business that it hires people to listen to what customers say to Alexa. People can opt out of Amazon using their voice recordings to improve the software in the privacy settings section of the

Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that© Provided by CBS Interactive Inc. The Google Home Mini and Amazon Echo Dot smart speakers. Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Ever since Alexa and Google Assistant first burst onto the scene and started populating people's homes with smart speakers and other gadgets outfitted with always-listening microphones, people have wondered whether anyone other than their AI assistant of choice was listening in.

Well, the answer is yes -- both Amazon and Google have admitted that they hire contractors to listen to anonymized user audio clips for the purposes of improving their respective assistant's capabilities.

That might have seemed like an obvious assumption to some, but to many, it was a wake-up call. That's true not just for Amazon and Google, but for all of the gadgets and services that need our data to function. What are these companies doing with our data? How are they protecting it? Are they sharing any of it with third parties?

Google suspends New Zealand 'trending' emails after suspect's name released

Google suspends New Zealand 'trending' emails after suspect's name released Google says it suspended an email alerting system in New Zealand after it breached a murder case suppression order, which prompted condemnation from Wellington. © ABC NEWS Google suspends New Zealand 'trending' emails after suspect's name released The suspension of the service comes as the tech giant and its peers, such as Facebook and Twitter, as well as governments around the world, wrestle with the question of responsibility for the content published on a select number of sites.

Voice recordings are used to improve the accuracy of your interactions with Alexa. Deleting voice recordings associated with your account may degrade your experience. While we 're unable to respond directly to your feedback, we 'll use this information to improve our online Help.

Amazon makes all recent recordings available for listening in the companion Alexa app for iOS Amazon has said consistently that the Echo speakers only listen in and record after you use the More: Amazon ( and Alexa) know a whole lot about you. Here ' s how download and delete that info.

Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that© CNET

The Google Home Mini and Amazon Echo Dot smart speakers.

What Amazon and Google say

"We only annotate an extremely small sample of Alexa voice recordings in order improve the customer experience," an Amazon spokesperson told CNET in April. "For example, this information helps us train our speech recognition and natural language understanding systems, so Alexa can better understand your requests, and ensure the service works well for everyone."

The spokesperson added that employees can't directly access identifying information about the people or accounts associated with the recordings.

"All information is treated with high confidentiality and we use multi-factor authentication to restrict access, service encryption, and audits of our control environment to protect it," the spokesperson said.

Google is testing a play button for Chrome’s toolbar

Google is testing a play button for Chrome’s toolbar It appears that Google will soon add a play button to its Chrome browser, as spotted by Znet and Techdows. The button will live on Chrome’s toolbar, and will allow users to play or pause a video or music that’s playing in a tab. The feature is called Global Media Controls, and it’s currently being tested on Chrome’s Development browser, Canary. Once it’s enabled, the feature appears next to the URL field, and will highlight what is playing, even if it’s on a different tab.

Amazon was capturing every voice command in the cloud and relying on data associates like her to train the system. Slatis first figured she’d been The recordings she and her co-workers were listening to were often intense, awkward, or intensely awkward. Lonely sounding people confessing

Here ' s what to do. USA TODAY 1 day ago Jefferson Graham, USA TODAY. Amazon and Google record every interaction, even if you don't ask a specific question, and the Imagine you say something like " Amazon and Alexa have decimated our company, now we 're flat broke and don't know what to Concentrate on your work, and if you need to listen to music, wear some headsets and turn the

Meanwhile, Google chalks it all up to the complexities of building a fully capable, multilingual voice assistant.

"As part of our work to develop speech technology for more languages, we partner with language experts around the world who understand the nuances and accents of a specific language," David Monsees, product manager for Google Search, said in a blog post Thursday. "These language experts review and transcribe a small set of queries to help us better understand those languages. This is a critical part of the process of building speech technology, and is necessary to creating products like the Google Assistant."

Google adds that the audio samples these contractors listen to amount to about 0.2% of all recordings, and that user account details aren't associated with any of them.

"Reviewers are directed not to transcribe background conversations or other noises, and only to transcribe snippets that are directed to Google," Monsees said.

An artist shamed Google with his doodle. Then Google called about a job.

An artist shamed Google with his doodle. Then Google called about a job. Davian Chester posted on Facebook, “So I noticed that Google didn’t make a doodle for Juneteenth. I decided to help out! lol.” Chester, 26, had no idea it was about to go viral — or that he would soon end up on a celebratory billboard and get a call from Google about a job. The billboard designed by Keith Phillips for Davain Chester, which stands in Columbus, Ga., for the rest of the month. (Keith Phillips) “It blew up and took off,” said Chester, who lives in Columbus, Ga., near the Alabama border. “It was crazy.

New research shows Amazon ’s Alexa and other voice assistants regularly record audio How often do Alexa and her ilk listen to your conversations? Maybe more than you think. Here ’ s the bad news: About half of the accidental recordings lasted six seconds or longer, with some recording as much

Here ' s a closer look at how they handle your voice requests. Amazon is far from the only major tech firm that sells voice -activated devices designed to listen for requests. Amazon may be the current industry leader, but Google 's line of Google Assistant-powered smart speakers is slowly gaining

Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that© Provided by CBS Interactive Inc. Always-listening gadgets equipped with Alexa or Google Assistant like this Lenovo Smart Clock are seeking a place in just about every room of our homes. Chris Monroe/CNET

0.2% -- is that it?

Google's blog post specifically addresses audio that reviewers are listening to for the purpose of helping Google Assistant master a variety of languages, dialects and accents. But are there any other purposes for which Google or its contractors listen to user audio?

I asked Google that exact question, but a company spokesperson didn't answer. Instead, they reiterated that language experts review around 0.2 percent of all audio snippets. The spokesperson did not address whether or not Google has any other purposes for listening to user audio outside of what's described in Monsees' blog post -- details Google only shared after one of those language experts provided Belgium-based VRT NWS with more than a thousand recordings of people using Google Home smart speakers and the Google Assistant app.

I asked again -- are the language experts Monsees describes the only contractors or employees at Google who listen to user audio? The spokesperson referred me to Google's privacy policy, which reads:

Google uses humans to review Google Assistant queries

Google uses humans to review Google Assistant queries Workers say their job is to improve the accuracy of the AI assistant.

Amazon employees around the world regularly listen to recordings from the company’ s smart speakers as We only annotate an extremely small sample of Alexa voice recordings in order [to] However, as any user of a smart speaker knows , ambient noise can be mistaken for the wake word

Amazon and Google are the leading sellers of such devices. The researchers said that they were able to hide commands in recordings of music or spoken text that went unnoticed by humans but were understood by personal assistants such as Apple’ s Siri, Google ’ s Assistant and Amazon ’ s Alexa.

"We restrict access to personal information to Google employees, contractors, and agents who need that information in order to process it. Anyone with this access is subject to strict contractual confidentiality obligations and may be disciplined or terminated if they fail to meet these obligations."

As for Amazon, the Alexa FAQ page reads:

"...we use your requests to Alexa to train our speech recognition and natural language understanding systems. The more data we use to train these systems, the better Alexa works, and training Alexa with voice recordings from a diverse range of customers helps ensure Alexa works well for everyone."

That said, an Amazon spokesperson says that the actual percentage of audio recordings the company listens to and transcribes is very small, and similar to what Google pegs it at.

"We annotate a fraction of one percent of interactions from a random set of customers to improve the Alexa experience for customers," the spokesperson tells me.

As with Google, I also asked if there were any other instances outside of these where Amazon employees would listen to a user's audio recordings. Amazon's answer: "No."

What about third parties? Is my voice data being shared?

Good question. Let's start with Google.

The company has a multitude of different posts that talk about its approach to privacy for various Google services, and there's a lot to mine through in order to find clear answers. In some cases, the text is confusing.

A New Android Malware Affects 25 Million Smartphones. Here's What You Need to Know About the Dangers of Open Systems

A New Android Malware Affects 25 Million Smartphones. Here's What You Need to Know About the Dangers of Open Systems Security research firm Check Point Research discovered that third-party app stores are serving up malware that masquerades as a legitimate app. An Israeli security company says that a new malware it calls "Agent Smith," replaces good apps on your Android device with versions that serve up ads in a profit-making scam. The security company, Check Point, says that the malware "currently uses its broad access to the device's resources to show fraudulent ads for financial gain.

One instance occurs on a page for Google Nest services outlining the company's commitment to privacy -- a separate page from the Google or Google Assistant privacy policies. Google explains that the guide is there "to explain as clearly and simply as we can both how our connected home devices and services work, and also how we'll uphold our commitment to respect your privacy."

A few paragraphs later, the page reads:

"...we commit to you that for all our connected home devices and services, we will keep your video footage, audio recordings, and home environment sensor readings separate from advertising, and we won't use this data for ad personalization. When you interact with your Assistant, we may use those interactions to inform your interests for ad personalization."

Read back to back, those sentences seem to contradict each other. Google won't use audio recordings for ad personalization, but when you use the Assistant, Google may use those interactions "to inform your interests for ad personalization." So which is it? Does using the Google Assistant impact the ads you see or doesn't it?

Shortly thereafter, the post refers you to Google's overall privacy policy for more specifics. Click through and scroll down a ways, and you'll find a section on ads that reads:

"We don't share information that personally identifies you with advertisers, such as your name or email, unless you ask us to. For example, if you see an ad for a nearby flower shop and select the 'tap to call' button, we'll connect your call and may share your phone number with the flower shop."

It looks like people are cancelling their Amazon Prime membership after browsing Prime Day deals, revealing a flaw in the sales bonanza

It looks like people are cancelling their Amazon Prime membership after browsing Prime Day deals, revealing a flaw in the sales bonanza Amazon's annualPrime Day is designed to boost revenues and keep existing Prime members loyal as shoppers splurge on deals. It's also a way to recruit new members.

What does that mean for Google Assistant audio recordings, though? If I ask where the nearest flower shop is, am I going to be added to an anonymized list of people who might be interested in buying flowers? Will that list ever be shared with a marketing company for online bouquet deliveries that would then market to me?

"While we may use your interactions to inform your interests for ads personalization, this scenario would not happen," a Google spokesperson tells me. "A third party could not send you a coupon based on your interaction with the Assistant."

"We do not sell your personal information to anyone," the spokesperson adds. "This includes your Assistant queries or interests derived from those queries with advertisers."

A user with a question like mine might refer to the privacy section of the Google Nest support page, which reads, "There are some circumstances where we share information with third parties, which are listed in Google's Privacy Policy."

The problem is that Google's privacy policy doesn't really help with device-specific questions like that. In fact, Google's privacy policy only includes the word "voice" once, as an item in the list of "activity information" Google collects (that's also the only place in the policy that mentions the word "audio"). Meanwhile, the policy doesn't include the words "microphone," "recordings" or "assistant" at all.

"User control is very important to us," said the Google spokesperson, adding that, "you can always review your Google settings to control the ads you see, including opting out of ad personalization completely.

Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that© Provided by CBS Interactive Inc. An Amazon post titled, "Alexa, Echo Devices, and Your Privacy" makes no mention of Amazon contractors listening to your recordings, and it doesn't address whether your data is shared with third parties. Chris Monroe/CNET

What about Amazon?

"No audio recordings are shared with third parties," an Amazon spokesperson tells me. "If you use a third party service through Alexa, we will exchange related information with that third party so they may provide the service. For example, if you interact with a third party Alexa skill, we provide the content of your requests (but not the voice recordings) to the skill so the skill can respond accordingly."

Joe Jonas Congratulates Wife Sophie Turner on Emmy Nomination -- Read His Sweet Message

Joe Jonas Congratulates Wife Sophie Turner on Emmy Nomination -- Read His Sweet Message Here's how the crooner marked the special occasion!

Like Google, Amazon has a page on common Alexa privacy questions that's separate from the overall Alexa terms of use. It's concise, just 400 words or so, and it makes no mention of any instances where an Amazon employee or contractor would listen to your recordings. There's also nothing in it about whether or not Amazon shares any of your data or recordings with third parties.

Those are two of the most common privacy-related questions facing Alexa today. A post titled "Alexa, Echo Devices, and Your Privacy" ought to address them.

Same goes for Amazon's Alexa FAQ page. Along with not providing any of the same specifics Amazon shared with us in April about when and why contractors might listen to your Alexa audio, the FAQ offers no clear answers about the kind of Alexa data Amazon might be sharing with advertisers.

The only reference to advertisements in the FAQ is the blanket statement, "We also do not sell children's personal information for advertising or other purposes," along with a link to Amazon's Children's Privacy Disclosure.

The overall Amazon privacy page doesn't make much mention of Alexa except for one reference to "Alexa internet" in a long paragraph listing the types of data Amazon collects. However, the page does describe Amazon's approach to sharing the information it collects with third parties. This includes sharing information for the purpose of promotional offers.

"Sometimes we send offers to selected groups of Amazon.com customers on behalf of other businesses. When we do this, we do not give that business your name and address," the page reads.

An Amazon spokesperson offered more of an explanation of how your Alexa usage can impact what ads you see, and what controls you have over that.

"The experience on Alexa is similar to what you'd see on the Amazon website or Amazon app," the spokesperson said. "For example, if you make a purchase via Alexa shopping, that purchase may be used to provide personalized ads, similar to what you'd see if you purchased something on the website. You can opt-out of receiving personalized ads from Amazon at any time."

Amazon and Google are listening to your voice recordings. Here's what we know about that© Provided by CBS Interactive Inc. Voice assistants offer utility and convenience, but not without trade-offs. Josh Miller/CNET

Should I chuck these things out the window?

That seems excessive. I don't blame anyone who doesn't want to fill their house with cameras and microphones, but I also don't blame anyone who's willing to trade some of their data with a company they feel comfortable with in order to bring some new convenience and utility into their lives. It's nearly impossible to navigate today's age without making trades like that on a daily basis.

In the meantime, I think the correct way to think about this is to assume that anything you say to your digital assistant might very well be heard by someone else in the future. After all, these companies are collecting and retaining voice recordings and transcripts, in some cases indefinitely. That's not for your benefit, it's for theirs.

The real question with all of this is whether or not your privacy is being harmed. Personally, I don't have a problem with an Amazon or Google contractor listening to an anonymized recording of me saying "turn off the dining room" to try and figure out why the assistant thought I said "turn off the dynamo." It's similar to the way an employee at Sony might review my PlayStation usage after a game crashes to figure out what went wrong and help prevent it from happening again.

The difference is that when my video game crashes, my PS4 asks for my permission to take a look at the crash report. Amazon and Google would argue that they do that, too -- but it's a blanket permission that users blindly agree to when they accept the sprawling user agreements during initial device setup. In today's age, I'd argue that's not good enough. At a minimum, clearer language in the app during setup about when, why and how other humans might eventually need to listen to your audio would likely help a lot of users feel better about tapping "accept."

As for data sharing, companies like Amazon and Google also ought to do a better job of describing their practices -- not just in dense legalese buried deep within one of several different privacy statements, but in straightforward, easy-to-find terms that people can actually understand. Perhaps they're worried that doing so might scare potential users away from their platforms. If that's the case, then maybe that wake-up call was long overdue.

Read more

Joe Jonas Congratulates Wife Sophie Turner on Emmy Nomination -- Read His Sweet Message.
Here's how the crooner marked the special occasion!

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 6
This is interesting!