•   
  •   

WorldComment: The Abortion Debate Is No Longer About Policy

09:51  29 may  2019
09:51  29 may  2019 Source:   theatlantic.com

Scott Morrison's front bench a new challenge following success at federal election 2019 and recent retirements

Scott Morrison's front bench a new challenge following success at federal election 2019 and recent retirements With the recent exodus of Cabinet ministers and expectations of rewards for well-performing states in the election win, Scott Morrison has a lot to consider as he assembles his new front bench.

Cataclysmic discord lies ahead. Abortion politics is no longer about policy wins, but about This is where our politics has carried the abortion debate , where our so-called leaders and voters have Just as Virginia Governor Ralph Northam’s comments on children born after a failed abortion seemed to

Every fetus that was going to be aborted but instead makes it into an artificial womb could be considered a life saved. It is unlikely that the abortion debate will be resolved soon — certainly not as a legal matter. But as a practical and philosophical one, artificial wombs offer a way for both sides

Comment: The Abortion Debate Is No Longer About Policy© James Lawler Duggan / Reuters Competing demonstrators displaying anti-abortion and pro-abortion-rights signs at the annual March for Life

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Comment: The Abortion Debate Is No Longer About Policy
Credit Cards Are Now Offering 0% Interest Until 2020
Find out more on Finder
Ad Finder.com.au

Abortion politics in 2019 is a morality play about what happens when one side has all the political power, yet feels culturally embattled. In this atmosphere, victories are not satisfying if they leave the other side with a foothold, a vestige of respectability. Cataclysmic discord lies ahead.

Two Hollywood Projects Pull Production From Georgia Due to Abortion Ban

Two Hollywood Projects Pull Production From Georgia Due to Abortion Ban Kristen Wiig's Lionsgate comedy 'Barb and Star Go to Vista Del Mar' and Reed Morano's Amazon series 'The Power' have opted to relocate production from the state in the wake of the controversial legislation.

But it eventually changed its policies so that no clinics could be reimbursed for their donations. Meanwhile in Texas, lawmakers have said they will cut all Medicaid payments to Planned Parenthood, alleging the clinics were " no longer capable of performing medical services in a professionally

That stability makes me think the abortion debate isn’t going anywhere in the foreseeable future. It also makes me wonder if the country might ever find its way to some If you look closely at the charts, you’ll notice that public opinion typically moves in the opposite direction to the sitting president’s policy .

Abortion politics is no longer about policy wins, but about establishing dominance. This is why Governor Andrew Cuomo could not be satisfied with the passage of the Reproductive Health Act, which eliminated several restrictions on the procedure, but instead had to light up the Empire State Building pink, to declare that abortion rights were now creedal in New York. It was not just the passage of the Reproductive Health Act, but specifically the display of cultural force, that made abortion opponents feel so embattled and isolated.

This dynamic was also evident in Alabama, where the people in power hold the opposite position on abortion as their counterparts in New York and recently passed H.B. 314, a bill that virtually outlaws the procedure.

Calls for tougher regulation on Australia's funeral insurance industry

Calls for tougher regulation on Australia's funeral insurance industry There are calls for tougher regulation of the funeral insurance industry to better protect elderly Australians. Brett Aberton discovered his mother’s policy was cancelled after she failed to make her annual payment. "Most definitely makes me angry and not just for my mother but for all Australian elderly that are probably going down the same road," Mr Aberton told A Current Affair. © A Current Affair One woman A Current Affair spoke with has paid out $19,000 for funeral insurance to Tower Life, but will only get $10,000 coverage.

Comments . Duda has been in office since 2015 and experts say bringing the abortion legislation before MPs now was “opportunisitic” and part of moves to keep his core supporters happy ahead of presidential elections that are controversially set to go ahead on 10 May.

Demonstrators gathered outside the Georgia State Capitol for an abortion rights rally in Atlanta on Tuesday.Credit Audra Melton for The New York Times.

One scene from the Alabama Senate debate furnishes a quintessential example of the decline of our democracy, of the diminishment of any capacity our political process might have had to help us work through difficult issues together. During the committee markup of the bill, lawmakers passed an amendment to provide an exception for rape or incest.

On May 9, as H.B. 314 was headed toward a final vote, Alabama’s Republican Lieutenant Governor Will Ainsworth broke protocol by stripping out the amendment without making a motion or acknowledging his Democratic colleagues’ requests for a roll-call vote. Democratic State Senator Bobby Singleton shouted, “There was no motion. You didn’t even make a motion!” Ainsworth simply ignored his colleague’s interjections.

Then, Democratic State Senator Vivian Figures stepped up to address Ainsworth, perhaps calculating that calm diplomacy might prove effective where righteous indignation had not. “I know you want this bill to pass, and you’re going to get your way, but at least treat us fairly and do it the right way. That’s all I ask.

Comment: Voice will end cycle of instability

Comment: Voice will end cycle of instability Being constitutionally enshrined, the Voice to Parliament will be durable well beyond political timetables. It means that Indigenous empowerment and active participation in the democratic life of the state is not dependent on which political party is in power. The second reason for constitutional entrenchment is that it is intended to compel government to listen. At the moment, the government and policy makers are not compelled to listen or hear what First Nations have to say about the laws and policies that impact upon them.

For those of us in the Muddle, the arguments about a woman’s right not to parent are much less compelling than the right to control her own The justification for legal abortion is that pregnancy is slightly dangerous and very physically taxing, and women shouldn’t be forced to endure it against their

Applause in parliament on Thursday after contentious bill cleared its final hurdle, following weeks of protest.

That’s all that women in this state ask, both Democrats and Republicans. If there has been a motion made, we should have a vote on that motion,” Figures said. Surely this display of courtesy would solicit a reciprocal response? Not in our politics today. Not when you have the gavel, and the power, and have no need for the other side. In fact, Ainsworth responded by quite literally refusing to acknowledge the existence of his Democratic colleagues, insisting that no one objected to his maneuver.

Ainsworth’s actions reflect an audacious disrespect that is now ubiquitous in our politics. The lieutenant governor, I imagine, was thinking something like: They have Hollywood. They manipulated the courts to establish abortion rights by fiat. They mock the pro-life cause, and do so with impunity. They have all the power. Except here. Except right now. They can know how it feels to be powerless for a change, like their opposition is unstoppable and they are irrelevant. Just so, Cuomo perhaps thought, They have the White House. They manipulated Senate procedures to establish a majority on the Supreme Court. They mock reproductive rights, and do so with impunity. They have all the power. Except here. Except right now. They can know how it feels to be powerless for a change, like their opposition is unstoppable and they are irrelevant.

Compulsory superannuation 'bad policy' for house-hunting millennials

Compulsory superannuation 'bad policy' for house-hunting millennials The wages that Australian millennials are forced to put aside for retirement are better off being spent now buying a home, according to the Centre for Independent Studies (CIS). 

Abortion is something that policy makers, like most people, accept but don't want to talk about. Both houses will in all likelihood vote on abortion later this year when amendments to the bill that will replace the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act are debated .

This is a glossary of policy debate terms. In policy debate , the affirmative (AFF) is the team which affirms the resolution. The (NEG) negative side refutes the affirmation . The affirmative team will have a plan that they are advocating for that should be within the resolution.

This is where our politics has carried the abortion debate, where our so-called leaders and voters have allowed it to be carried. The abortion debate now lacks even the pretense of comity. No one seeks to reconcile rational, competing claims. Because the issue is so personal—it strikes at the very heart of what it means to be a person with life and agency—our discussions ought to remind us of our humanity and frailty. Instead, our toxic politics has taught us that to acknowledge nuance is to make ourselves vulnerable and exposed.

How comfortable have we become using politics as an immoral weapon in the name of our self-assured moral cause? This is, in the most favorable light, what Ainsworth decided to do. But how moral could his cause be if he is willing to advance it in such an immoral manner?

We are not dealing with public servants here—not if the title is anything more than a euphemism. Instead, we have politicians supported by advocacy groups and moneyed interests whose goal is to attain whatever level of power is necessary to act unilaterally. This is what a representative democracy looks like when stripped of trust, respect, virtue, and sense of community.

President Donald Trump appreciates the utility of a nihilistic politics that seeks to maximize feelings of fear and embattlement rather than hope and possibility. I have argued elsewhere that it was Trump’s ability to build up a sense of embattlement among his voters, offering only himself as a pressure valve, that allowed him to win in 2016. Abortion has been central to that strategy, and as I predicted in The Atlantic in the wake of the New York bill and the Virginia controversy, abortion will play a central role in Trump’s appeal in 2020.

The ‘#MeToo hurricane’: Rape case divides a Russian city and stirs rare debate on feminism and justice

The ‘#MeToo hurricane’: Rape case divides a Russian city and stirs rare debate on feminism and justice A policewoman accused colleagues of rape. What was more shocking to many was that the case went to trial.

However, Alabama might just have solved the other side’s enthusiasm-gap problem. The 2020 candidates seem to think so; they are already moving even further left on abortion—almost all of them are promising to pursue federal legislation that would codify Roe and override state-level restrictions.

Democrats are suggesting they’ll make abortion a central issue in 2020, similar to the role of the Affordable Care Act in 2018. Just as Virginia Governor Ralph Northam’s comments on children born after a failed abortion seemed to confirm anti-abortion activists’ worst fears, the Alabama bill is being used to advance progressives’ Handmaid’s Tale narrative.

Meanwhile, the majority of Americans remain somewhere between supporting abortion-on-demand and supporting a federal law that would force the victim of a rapist to carry that child to term. Though it can’t be uttered in our politics, most Americans understand both that a fetus or unborn child is more than just a “clump of cells,” and that the unborn child is uniquely situated, implicating the life of its mother in a way that is singular among human relationships.

Trump recognizes the threat the recent turn in our abortion politics poses for him. In his response to the Alabama law, Trump responded with an unusually coherent series of tweets.

He wrote:

As most people know, and for those who would like to know, I am strongly Pro-Life, with the three exceptions—Rape, Incest and protecting the Life of the mother—the same position taken by Ronald Reagan. We have come very far in the last two years with 105 wonderful new.........Federal Judges (many more to come), two great new Supreme Court Justices, the Mexico City Policy, and a whole new & positive attitude about the Right to Life. The Radical Left, with late term abortion (and worse), is imploding on this issue. We must stick together and Win.... ....for Life in 2020. If we are foolish and do not stay UNITED as one, all of our hard fought gains for Life can, and will, rapidly disappear!

Unfortunately for Trump, he might find he’s unable to contain the sense of embattlement he stoked for political gain. The thing about embattlement is that even when your side attains power, it always feels like it’s slipping away, so you fight even harder.

Pictures: US abortion rights rally across the nation

Comment: The Abortion Debate Is No Longer About Policy
Read more

Alabama passes bill requiring chemical castration for certain child molesters.
An Alabama measure that would require certain child sex offenders to undergo chemical castration before being released from prison is awaiting the governor's signature. The bill, known as HB 379, was introduced by Republican state Rep. Steve Hurst and targets child sex offenders whose offenses involve anyone under 13, according to the legislation. How To Get A Home Loan With 5% Deposit Find out more on Finder Ad Finder.com.au “They have marked this child for life and the punishment should fit the crime,” Hurst told WIAT-TV in Birmingham. The offenders would be required to foot the bill for the procedure.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!