World Why it is wrong to draw parallels between Trump and Mugabe

12:00  24 november  2020
12:00  24 november  2020 Source:   aljazeera.com

3 years after Mugabe overthrow, many Zimbabweans say life’s worse

  3 years after Mugabe overthrow, many Zimbabweans say life’s worse Prospects of job creation and economic growth in the post-Mugabe era continue to remain bleak.The reason? Mnangagwa’s promises of jobs and democracy.

Why it pays to keep a close eye on Donald Trump and draw parallels from history, including viewing a PBS show (Rachel Carson: American Experience) which I

"Donald Trump is retracting the promise of American freedom to an extent we have not seen from a President since Franklin Roosevelt forced Japanese Americans into internment camps during World War II. "Today the Statue of Liberty weeps over President Trump 's discrimination."

On November 6, after a speech by Donald Trump in which he baselessly claimed the 2020 US presidential election was fraudulent, ABC journalist Leigh Sales criticised what she saw as an outgoing president’s attempt to undermine the democratic process by tweeting “Robert Mugabe keeps coming to mind”.

a man wearing a suit and tie: US President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally at Cecil Airport in Jacksonville, Florida, US, September 24, 2020. [Tom Brenner/File Photo/Reuters] © US President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally at Cecil Airport in Jacksonville, Florida, ... US President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally at Cecil Airport in Jacksonville, Florida, US, September 24, 2020. [Tom Brenner/File Photo/Reuters]

And Sales was not the only one who compared Trump’s actions in the aftermath of the election to those of Zimbabwe’s former president. Samantha Power, Pulitzer-Prize winning author and former US ambassador to the UN, for example, also claimed on the same day that Trump was “going full-on Robert Mugabe”.

There Is No Trumpism Without Trump

  There Is No Trumpism Without Trump The Republican Party now has two paths forward.These legislators foresaw that their state, and its 20 electoral votes, would probably be won by the Biden-Harris ticket. But Republicans still possessed a 107–91 majority in the state assembly, and a 29–21 majority in the state Senate.

Trump Campaign general counsel Jenna Ellis tweeted a joint statement with Rudy Giuliani which reads: "Sidney Powell is practicing law on her own. Oddly, Trump seemed to consider Powell a member of his legal team last week. Earlier Saturday, Trump attorney Jordan Sekulow hinted on Newsmax that

Gideon Rachman, the FT's chief foreign affairs commentator, highlights three parallels between Brexit and the Trump phenomenon that should worry the Clinton campaign.

Many others made similar comparisons between Trump and African leaders on social media in the following days, expressing their surprise that election results can be contested in such a way in the United States, and implying that the president’s insistent refusal to concede to his rival is a move more fitting to democracies in Africa.

This is problematic for multiple reasons. First of all, it is an argument built on the false assumption that American democracy is not vulnerable to authoritarian interventions and power grabs like “lesser” democracies elsewhere in the world, and especially in Africa. It is an argument born out of America’s belief in its own moral superiority and its political class’s inherent racial biases.

In 24 hours, Trump went from almost conceding to falsely claiming “I WON THE ELECTION!”

  In 24 hours, Trump went from almost conceding to falsely claiming “I WON THE ELECTION!” Rejecting reality, Trump tweeted he won the election more than a week after it was declared for Biden.These efforts came to a head late Sunday night with a tweet that read, “I WON THE ELECTION!”

Последние твиты от Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump). 45th President of the United States of America🇺🇸. It is brought on behalf of one of the most respected members of the United States Congress who is disgusted, like so many others, by an Election that is a fraudulent mess.

Zimbabwe's 91-year-old President Robert Mugabe reads out the wrong speech at the opening of parliament.

On the surface, these may seem like harmless comparisons between political leaders with similar dictatorial tendencies. But why do so many choose to draw parallels between Donald Trump and African leaders when the recent history of the West itself is full of political leaders who have been as autocratic, as power hungry, and as willing to undermine democratic procedures as their African counterparts? Was it not Western colonialism that paved the way for many of Africa’s democratic failures in the first place, anyway?

The current comparisons between Trump and authoritarian African leaders have a lot to do with the perceived moral superiority of whiteness in the US. White Americans, consciously or not, view themselves and their country as morally superior to others. As a result, when their president acts in a way that is objectively immoral and undemocratic, they find comfort in labelling that behaviour as something outside of whiteness by making comparisons between him and African leaders they accept as naturally morally inferior.

Three years after Mugabe's ouster, hope dissipates in Zimbabwe

  Three years after Mugabe's ouster, hope dissipates in Zimbabwe Zimbabwe's former leader Robert Mugabe stepped down on November 21, 2017, bringing an end to nearly four decades of iron-fisted rule. His resignation came days after military tanks rolled through the capital Harare. The coup was greeted with euphoria, tens of thousands pouring into the streets to celebrate. But today, three years after his successor Emmerson Mnangagwa took over, the high hopes for change have dissipated into disaffection. - WhatHis resignation came days after military tanks rolled through the capital Harare. The coup was greeted with euphoria, tens of thousands pouring into the streets to celebrate.

WASHINGTON—President Donald Trump appeared to draw an equivalence between Russian President Vladimir Putin and the behavior of the U.S The statement, made in an interview with Fox News host Bill O’Reilly that will air before Sunday’s Super Bowl, came after Mr. Trump again said he

So you are probably justified in disliking some Trump voters, mainly because they have proven to be very nasty people. But it would be wrong to condemn all the They follow Trump and it is a blanket endorsement of everything he does, even if he cozies up with a dictator who dismembered a journalist

This problematic, and widespread, belief in the perpetual morality of whiteness can easily be seen in the coverage of atrocities committed by white assailants by the US media.

In 2013, for example, when a white student opened fire on other students at a middle school in Nevada, the media overwhelmingly portrayed him as a struggling child who had been bullied, and cited the abuse he allegedly endured as a possible motivation for his actions.

And two years later, in 2015, when self-proclaimed racist Dylan Roof walked into a church in Charleston and shot nine African Americans dead, many media pundits repeatedly referred to him as someone who is “mentally ill”.

In 2018, a study by researchers from Ohio State University revealed that white shooters were 95 percent more likely to be described as “mentally ill” than Black shooters in news stories. The study also showed that, “when shooters were framed in the media as mentally ill, 78 percent of white attackers were described as being victims of society – as being under a lot of stress, for example – versus only 17 percent of black shooters”.

The Damage Trump Could Do Before the Inauguration

  The Damage Trump Could Do Before the Inauguration Some of his methods would be immediately evident; others, hidden. © Ralph Freso / Getty “We’re going to have to be very vigilant in the next two months for abuse of the pardon power, awarding of contracts to friends and family, and destruction of records, as well as policy decisions to box in the incoming administration,” Representative Adam Schiff, the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, who helped prosecute the case against Trump in the Senate impeachment trial earlier this year, told me. Trump, too, may feel boxed in, and for that reason he may be more prone to acting out.

The message here is clear – in the eyes of white America, white people are incapable of being inherently evil, and for them to commit atrocities, there must be some other phenomenon at play.

This belief that immoral, violent and unethical behaviours stand strictly outside the norms of whiteness is the reason why so many people are eager to compare Trump to African leaders and not explore the problems with the core dynamics of American democracy, including white supremacy, that resulted in such a person being elected president in the first place. It is, after all, easier to cast Trump’s actions as an “anomaly”, something that should have only been seen in Africa, than accept that he is, actually, a natural and typical product of American whiteness.

After an election official in Nevada voiced his concerns for the safety of his staff following the presidential election, for example, journalist Louise Milligan expressed her shock by tweeting “No, this did not happen in a far-flung tinpot regime, it did not happen in a banana republic.”

In this short tweet, Milligan clearly demonstrated that she, like many others in Western media and political circles, view election violence as something that is expected to happen in “banana republics” and “tinpot regimes”, terms often used to describe countries populated with people of colour, and not in America. While expressing her shock about the behaviour of Trump’s supporters, she implied that while such violence is out of the norm in the US, it is natural elsewhere in the world, perhaps in Latin America and Africa.

Trump Could Push Don Jr. and Ivanka in 2024, but Trumpism Is a Hard Sell Without Him

  Trump Could Push Don Jr. and Ivanka in 2024, but Trumpism Is a Hard Sell Without Him The president's children have been touted as potential successors should he not choose to run himself again in the future.While the presidential election has been called in Joe Biden's favor—Trump continues to reject this, dismissing the judgement of the "lamestream media"—the Republican incumbent received more votes than any sitting commander-in-chief in history.

This is untrue. Just like it is the case in the US, election violence and tensions come on the back of specific political realities and democratic struggles in each country. There is no country in the world where the population is inherently wild and violence is a natural and expected part of the electoral process.

It is, however, not uncommon for white people in the West to hold such baseless beliefs about people living in “banana republics” and “far-flung tinpot regimes”. These views, often accepted by many as fact without much consideration, are a byproduct of the white supremacy that is at the core of Western civilisation, and American democracy.

White people are only able to view themselves, and their countries, as superior by casting others as inferior – intellectually, culturally and morally. When colonialists came to Africa, for example, they declared the Indigenous inhabitants of the continent as morally and intellectually inferior to legitimise the invasion, exploitation and theft of their lands and resources. They also tried to legitimise slavery by claiming Black people were inferior to them, and as a result not deserving of basic human rights and dignity.

Comparisons that are currently being made between African nations and Trump’s America may seem trivial and unimportant, but they have real-world consequences. They attempt to cast Africa as the metric for violence and tyranny, while masking intrinsic problems of American democracy that resulted in a white supremacist authoritarian occupying the White House. This is an attitude detrimental both for Africa and the US.

There is no perfect democracy either in Africa or the West. But if American media, politicians and pundits continue to act as if authoritarianism, tyranny and disrespect for democracy are concepts that are exclusive to Africa, or “banana republics” elsewhere in the world, they can never truly resolve the democratic crisis their country is currently experiencing.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

Federal appeals court rejects a Trump election lawsuit: “Calling an election unfair does not make it so” .
The Trump campaign can’t stop losing election lawsuits.The president’s latest legal defeat came Friday when an three member appeals court rejected a Trump campaign suit against Pennsylvania election officials that alleged the state engaged in “unconstitutional discrimination” against Trump voters in a scathing, unanimous decision that found the president’s lawsuit had “no merit.

usr: 3
This is interesting!