World Justice Kagan Criticizes SCOTUS Decision to Lift California's Indoor Worship Ban Amid Pandemic

20:31  06 february  2021
20:31  06 february  2021 Source:   newsweek.com

Queensland FINALLY opens the border to Sydney

  Queensland FINALLY opens the border to Sydney Queensland has finally opened the border to Sydney and surrounding areas after locking it out for six weeks.The border will open from February 1, Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk announced on Thursday morning.

On Friday, a Supreme Court ruling lifted some restrictions that banned indoor worship services in California as the coronavirus pandemic continues. However, Associate Justice Elena Kagan penned a dissent that criticized the 6-3 decision.

a person holding a sign: Demonstrators holding signs demanding their church to reopen, protest during a rally to re-open California and against Stay-At-Home directives on May 1, 2020 in San Diego, California. © Sandy Huffaker / AFP/Getty Demonstrators holding signs demanding their church to reopen, protest during a rally to re-open California and against Stay-At-Home directives on May 1, 2020 in San Diego, California.

The ban was lifted on indoor services for California's Tier 1 counties—those with widespread COVID-19 risks. Despite religious establishments being able to hold worship services during the pandemic, some restrictions are still in place, such as 25 percent capacity limits or bans on singing and chanting.

Gavin Newsom, Facing Recall, Clashes With Teachers' Unions Over California Schools Opening

  Gavin Newsom, Facing Recall, Clashes With Teachers' Unions Over California Schools Opening Unions are calling for teachers to be vaccinated, but Newsom is refusing to budge and pushing on with his plan to reopen schools.Teachers unions have reportedly said they will not send their members into an unsafe environment, calling for all teachers to be vaccinated before returning to the classroom.

In a July 2020 Statewide Public Health Officer Order, the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) had said that places of worship, as well as gyms, protests, salons and more, would need to halt indoor operations if counties appeared on the CDPH's County Monitoring List for three days in a row.

In her opinion, Kagan—one of the three liberal justices on the bench, including Sonia Sotomayor and Stephen Breyer, who dissented—raised pandemic concerns, while criticizing some of the justices' arguments.

"Justices of this Court are not scientists. Nor do we know much about public health policy. Yet today the Court displaces the judgments of experts about how to respond to a raging pandemic," she wrote.

Gladys Berejiklian eases coronavirus rules starting next FRIDAY

  Gladys Berejiklian eases coronavirus rules starting next FRIDAY New South Wales residents can expect significantly eased coronavirus restrictions from next Friday after the state went 17 days with zero new Covid-19 cases.NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian said on Wednesday the state recorded no new cases of the deadly virus from more than 12,000 tests overnight.

Kagan continues to say that California's policies "treat worship just as favorably

as secular activities," which have the same risk of transmitting coronavirus.

"Under the Court's injunction, the State must instead treat worship services like secular activities that pose a much lesser danger," she wrote, saying that the mandate "risks worsening the pandemic."

Throughout her dissent, Kagan argued that restrictions placed on worship services had also been placed on secular activities that posed a similar risk, and that outdoor worship services have continued in the Golden State through winter, because the temperature is usually milder. She also stated that employers such as film studios had strict COVID guidelines in place that wouldn't be as feasible as for a religious congregation. She also questioned the court's understanding of the science that influenced the policies.

Oregon Restaurant Issued Nearly $9,000 in Fines for 'Willfully' Ignoring COVID Seating Limits

  Oregon Restaurant Issued Nearly $9,000 in Fines for 'Willfully' Ignoring COVID Seating Limits Restaurants are vying for a return to indoor dining as they struggle to meet the bottom line.Trudy Logan, owner of Springfield restaurant Along Came Trudy, was fined $9,215 by state authorities for two violations of the state's temporary rules to prevent the spread of COVID-19. The first involved willfully ignoring capacity limitations, and the second was a failure to enforce mask wearing across staff and customers.

Kagan noted that creating COVID-19 policies is often difficult, and worried about the precedent that the court's decision has set.

"That task becomes harder still when officials must guess which restrictions this Court will choose to strike down. The Court injects uncertainty into an area where uncertainty has human costs," she explained.

Concluding her dissenting opinion, the justice said she hoped the decision won't "worsen the Nation's COVID crisis," showing disappointment that the Supreme Court didn't follow the science.

"Our marble halls are now closed to the public, and our life tenure forever insulates us from responsibility for our errors. That would seem good reason to avoid disrupting a State's pandemic response. But the Court forges ahead regardless, insisting that science-based policy yield to judicial edict," Kagan wrote.

In his statement, Justice Neil Gorsuch pointed towards entertainment industry productions that have continued amid the pandemic showing an issue in California's decisions, raising questions about singing during religious services. "But if Hollywood may host a studio audience or film a singing competition while not a single soul may enter California's churches, synagogues, and mosques, something has gone seriously awry," he wrote.

The Pandemic Is in Tenuous Retreat

  The Pandemic Is in Tenuous Retreat New COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations, and deaths all dropped this week.The good news in COVID-19 data continued this week, as new cases, hospitalizations, and deaths all dropped. For the seven-day period running January 28 to February 3, weekly new cases were down more than 16 percent over the previous week, and dropped below 1 million for the first time since the week of November 5. This is still an astonishing number of new cases a week, but far better than the nearly 1.8 million cases reported the week of January 14. Tests also declined nationally, but by less than 3 percent, nowhere near enough to explain the steep drop in cases.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett disagreed with the decision to keep the singing and chanting restrictions in place, also pointing towards entertainment productions. "[I]f a chorister can sing in a Hollywood studio but not in her church, California's regulations cannot be viewed as neutral," she wrote.

In an emailed statement to Newsweek, Daniel Lopez, a press secretary for California Governor Gavin Newsom's office, wrote that the state will continue to enforce restrictions kept in place by the high court's decision.

"The state of California has taken necessary steps throughout the pandemic to protect Californians from COVID-19 and prevent our health care system from being overwhelmed by the disease, particularly during the recent surge. While the Supreme Court enjoined the state's restriction on indoor worship services in counties where COVID-19 is widespread, the Court left in place public health measures imposed to protect worshippers, their families, and the communities in which they live. We will continue to enforce the restrictions the Supreme Court left in place and, after reviewing the decision, we will issue revised guidelines for worship services to continue to protect the lives of Californians," Lopez wrote in a statement.

Newsweek reached out to the Supreme Court's Public Information Office for comment.

Related Articles

  • Indoor Singing and Chanting Can Be Prohibited at Church Gatherings in Calif., Supreme Court Rules
  • Christians, Including Pastor Receiving Death Threats, in Crosshairs After Capitol Riot
  • 'Liberal' Churches Warned of Possible Attacks Around Biden Inauguration Day

Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

How the Black Church Embraces Tragic History and the Fervor of Faith .
“It was out in the country, far from home, far from my foster home, on a dark Sunday night. The road wandered from our rambling log‑house up the stony bed of a creek, past wheat and corn, until we could hear dimly across the fields a rhythmic cadence of song,—soft, thrilling, powerful, that swelled and died sorrowfully in our ears. I was a country schoolteacher then, fresh from the East, and had never seen a Southern Negro revival. To be sure, we in Berkshire were not perhaps as stiff and formal as they in Suffolk of olden time; yet we were very quiet and subdued, and I know not what would have happened those clear Sabbath mornings had some one punctuated the sermon with a wild scream,

usr: 0
This is interesting!