World 'No consultation' before India Covid lockdown

15:35  29 march  2021
15:35  29 march  2021 Source:   bbc.com

India tells overseas vaccine buyers it must prioritise local need

  India tells overseas vaccine buyers it must prioritise local need India’s health minister says the country is expanding its vaccination campaign to battle surging COVID cases.“In the coming weeks and months … obviously there will be a demand spike and obviously people are preparing for it,” India’s Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar said on Friday at the Times Network’s India Economic Enclave.

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government did not consult key ministries and states while imposing the world's strictest coronavirus lockdown, according to an investigation by the BBC's Jugal Purohit and Arjun Parmar.

a group of people standing in front of a crowd: India's coronavirus lockdown saw a huge exodus of migrant workers from cities © Getty Images India's coronavirus lockdown saw a huge exodus of migrant workers from cities

The BBC filed more than 240 right to information applications with various Indian government departments - health, finance, disaster management - to find out if and how much they were consulted ahead of the lockdown.

The responses revealed that there is no evidence of key experts or government departments being consulted prior to the lockdown being implemented.

Why you won't find many Queenslanders 'outraged' by Brisbane lockdown

  Why you won't find many Queenslanders 'outraged' by Brisbane lockdown The expected backlash from Queenslanders to their premier's decision to lock down Greater Brisbane from Monday afternoon never came -for one simple reason. Nobody cares. Nobody who isn't going to feel it directly in their hip pocket anyway. Or who isn't planning a wedding or engagement party or has a sick relative lying in hospital over the border.Other than in those heartbreaking situations, it's pretty much business as usual.

The home ministry, which played a key role in executing the lockdown, repeatedly rejected our request for information. It said the answers we sought were related to "strategic and economic interest and it also contains information which is held under fiduciary relationship and thus exempt from disclosure of information under section 8(1)(a) and (e) of Right to Information Act, 2005."

The government has also denied our request for a statement explaining why concerned departments were not consulted ahead of time.

The world's 'strictest' lockdown

On 24 March last year, Mr Modi announced a complete lockdown across India to stem the spread of coronavirus cases.

India went into a lockdown early - it had confirmed just 519 cases and nine deaths at the time. Experts hoped that forcing people to stay home would halt the virus' spread and give officials time to ramp up test and trace efforts as well as medical facilities.

Brisbane's lockdown is almost certain to be EXTENDED through Easter

  Brisbane's lockdown is almost certain to be EXTENDED through Easter Greater Brisbane residents were ordered into a snap three-day lockdown on Monday afternoon, while hundreds more around the state who visited the city since March 20 remain in self-isolation.Greater Brisbane residents were ordered into a snap three-day lockdown on Monday afternoon, while hundreds more around the state who have visited the city since March 20 remain under orders to stay at home and self-isolate.

But the 68-day shutdown - which the University of Oxford termed the world's strictest - proved devastating for the poor, costing them jobs and, in some cases, their lives.

All services, expect hospitals, pharmacies and groceries, closed. Offices, schools, colleges and all public transport was suspended. Flights in and out of India were stopped.

The poor, especially undernourished children and pregnant women who rely on government programmes, found it difficult to access benefits. Immunisation programs were halted. People suffering from serious illnesses struggled to access crucial health services even in urban areas such as Mumbai and Delhi.

But the hardest hit were informal workers, who make up the bulk of India's workforce - from domestic helps to street vendors to construction workers. They were suddenly left out of work and with no guarantee of when they would start earning again.

Staff at Brisbane hospital's coronavirus-infected ward in isolation

  Staff at Brisbane hospital's coronavirus-infected ward in isolation All staff who entered Ward 5D at Brisbane's Princess Alexandra Hospital between 8pm on March 23 and 12pm on March 26 must self-isolate - even if they did not treat Covid-positive patients.Hospital staff who worked in an infectious disease ward at the centre of two Queensland Covid-19 clusters have been forced into isolation.

Experts believe the lack of consultation ahead of the lockdown led to local governments being ill-prepared for the exodus of migrant workers from cities to villages. Without any public transport, millions of them began walking them home and many died on the way in accidents or due to hunger and exhaustion.

On the other hand, some epidemiologists believe that India's lockdown saved tens of thousands of lives, and bought time to beef up medical infra and capabilities.

But when the country began to reopen in June last year, cases began to spike. India now has the world's third-highest number of infections after the United States and Brazil.

It has so far reported more than 12 million cases and 160,000 deaths.

'No consultations, no meetings'

Even before the national lockdown was imposed, 30 states and federally administered territories had already declared local lockdowns, according to government data. Many of them were in effect till 31 March, 2020.

But the federal government said a nationwide lockdown was necessary "for consistency in the application and implementation of various measures across the country".

Why India is at risk from a 'severe' second wave

  Why India is at risk from a 'severe' second wave Experts believe India is facing the threat of a devastating and deadlier second wave of coronavirus.There were only 28 patients in the Covid-19 ward of the 1,000-bed non-profit Kasturba Hospital in Wardha, Maharashtra - down from 180 patients at the peak of the pandemic last summer. The intensive care unit (ICU) was empty for the first time in months.

"The prime minister acted only after consultations with everyone," said Rajiv Kumar, Vice Chairman of the Niti Ayog, a government think tank. "To say that it was done out of nowhere would be wrong."

a group of people walking down the street: The sudden lockdown announcement triggered panic buying in cities © Getty Images The sudden lockdown announcement triggered panic buying in cities

But queries to the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) revealed that no consultations or meetings were held with Mr Modi in attendance about Covid-19 or the need for a lockdown.

The offices of the chief ministers in Delhi, Assam and Telangana, as well as those of the governors of Punjab, Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh replied to the BBC's request saying they did not have any evidence indicating prior consultations on the lockdown.

"The kind of responses you have received are unacceptable," says Anjali Bhardwaj who works to promote transparency and accountability in government.

"The pandemic began from January and we locked down after 20 March. It was not like there was an overnight development akin to a flood or an earthquake. So the expectation was that when the prime minister declared there would be a lockdown, it was a decision arrived at after consultations from all quarters."

The lockdown also hobbled India's economy and its GDP recorded the sharpest contraction in its history.

How the colonisation of India influenced global food

  How the colonisation of India influenced global food From Britain to France to Portugal, India left its mark on the tastes and menus of its European colonisers.We were having khichdi – mashed lentils, diced vegetables and rice topped with caramelised onions. “Did you know that the British kedgeree (a mix of rice, flaked fish and boiled eggs) is inspired by our khichdi?” Anoushka asked, drizzling spoonfuls of ghee (clarified butter) onto the khichdi on her plate.

Both economic and health experts believe localised lockdowns would have had better results and allowed state governments more flexibility.

"There was scope to plan better. It needed to be a decentralised decision, depending on states and districts. A complete lockdown was not required. What has happened now is a huge shock because the Indian economy was performing poorly anyway," says Priya Ranjan Dash, a public policy analyst.

Recollecting the events of last year, Sima Kumari says, makes heart pound.

She was working as a nurse at a care home in Goa state when the lockdown was annnounced.

"Our employer denied us our salary and wanted us to work without Personal Protective Equipment (PPE). We had no option but to quit," she says.

She says she was finally forced to go home to Jharkhand on the special trains the government organised for migrant workers. They were crowded and she says was terrified.

"One man would keep shouting at us, asking us to maintain distance even as they packed us in like sheep. I would prefer death over reliving a situation like that again."

Read more of our coverage on India's coronavirus lockdown

  • Why do you lock down 1.3bn people?
  • Will coronavirus cause food shortages in India?
  • The Covid-19 migrants who never got home
  • Could hunger kill more people than coronavirus?
  • Delhi 'wasted' lockdown to become Covid hotspot

Warning over variants and COVID measures as cases in India surge past 100,000 a day .
New cases of COVID-19 in India have surged passed 100,000 a day - the highest total of daily cases recorded in the country since the pandemic began. © Associated Press Politicians have been campaigning without COVID-19 protections More than 103,790 new cases were recorded on Sunday, taking the total number of coronavirus cases in India to over 12.5 million, second only to the United States and Brazil.Live COVID updates from the UK and around the worldWith 477 deaths recorded in the same period, the COVID-19 related death toll stands at 165,132, the fourth highest in the world.

usr: 0
This is interesting!