World India keeps world guessing on net zero carbon goal
How bad will climate change get?
These five climate scenarios show us what the future of the planet could look like.Humans have already warmed the planet by at least 1 degree Celsius by burning fossil fuels that spew heat-trapping gases into the sky. The oceans are rising, and deadly disasters like wildfires, heat waves, and flooding are becoming more destructive. Almost every part of the world is experiencing the effects of climate change.
US climate envoy John Kerry secured a modest win in announcing renewable energy plans with India last week - but got no clarity on how India plans to achieve its net zero emissions target.
Mr Kerry has been trying to agree ambitious carbon reduction targets with major emitters in a bid to reassert US leadership on climate.
China however rebuffed his attempts to separate climate from other disputes. "The US hopes to make climate co-operation an 'oasis' of China-US relation but if the 'oasis' is surrounded by 'desert', the 'oasis' will sooner or later become desert," FM Wang Yi reportedly told Mr Kerry.
China’s disruption of ocean carbon sinks betrays its climate commitments
Vitally important 'blue carbon' sinks — marine ecosystems that capture and store carbon — are being threatened by China's massive ocean expansion.Blue carbon is a strategic global climate asset, but disruptions to it are currently not even systematically measured, much less reported, by leading disruptor China or any other nation. Kerry can publicly highlight the issue and begin making the case for factoring seabed and marine ecosystem disruption into the global climate policy equation.
India was happy for Mr Kerry to announce (for the second time - it was initially launched in April) the Climate Action and Finance Mobilization Dialogue (CAFMD), which is mainly aimed at helping India achieve its 450 gigawatts (GW) renewable energy target.
But there was nothing on how India plans to slash its carbon emissions to the required level.
Net zero means reducing greenhouse gas emissions as much as possible and then balancing out any further releases by absorbing an equivalent amount from the atmosphere - for instance, by planting trees.
China, the world's largest carbon emitter, has already announced it will be carbon neutral by 2060 and its emissions will peak before 2030 - although it has been criticised for building new coal plants.
India Hicks, 54, heads off on her luxurious Greek honeymoon in style
Prince Charles ' goddaughter India Hicks, 54, donned an all white personalised Nina Morris suit as she headed off on her luxurious honeymoon to Greece in style.The granddaughter of Earl Mountbatten, 54, who was a bridesmaid at the wedding of Charles and Lady Diana Spencer, tied the knot with her partner of 26 years David Flint Wood in a 'very conventional' ceremony which took place in Brightwell Baldwin Parish Church in Oxfordshire on Friday.
The US, the second largest emitter, has set 2050 as deadline to reach net zero and it says it will decarbonise its power sector by 2035.
But the world's third-largest emitter India has neither announced the net zero year nor has it submitted to the UN an updated climate plan with raised carbon-reduction ambition, as required by the Paris agreement every five years.
The UN, however, says of the 191 countries taking part in the agreement, only 113 have so far come up with improved pledges.
Analysis of the climate plans submitted so far shows that emissions are actually set to rise by 16% by 2030, which could lead to a temperature rise of 2.7C (4.9F) above pre-industrial levels.
The Paris climate agreement aims to limit global average temperature rise to well below two degrees, and strives for 1.5 degrees higher than the pre-industrial period to avoid dangerous climate change.
Scientists say the world has already warmed by 1.1 degrees since then and global carbon emissions need to be cut by 45% by 2030 to stop the Paris target from slipping out of reach.
Many carbon credits for deforestation could be 'nothing more than hot air', report finds
A new analysis finds the level of deforestation "avoided" by carbon offset schemes is too high to have occurred in the first place, likening them to "paying someone not to drive to work when they never drove to begin with".But do all of those offsets actually make a difference?
The recent report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has even warned that some of the earth's climate systems may have already been dangerously disturbed because of the rise in temperature.
Video: Uranium goes on a run (CNBC)
With countries expected to submit their updated plans, known as Nationally Determined Contribution (NDCs), before the upcoming major climate summit, COP26 in Glasgow, many eyes are now on India.
During his Delhi-visit last week, Mr Kerry did not put the spotlight on India on this issue, at least not in public, but he did stress on the net zero agenda.
"Beyond just deploying renewable energy, my friends, we need to develop, demonstrate and scale up emerging technologies that will be crucial for the net zero transition, let me just emphasise this," he said during the launch of the CAFMD.
During the same programme, India's Climate Change Minister Bhupender Yadav, neither mentioned net zero nor talked about any new carbon-reduction ambition.
IMF urges Australia to tighten controls on industrial polluters
IMF Australia mission chief Harald Finger says given Australia is not using a carbon price to drive down greenhouse gases, it should toughen the rules around industrial emissions. He said many countries had adopted a net zero target and "if Australia were to join [them] we would welcome that".Carbon pricing was the most effective way to transition to a lower emissions economy, Mr Finger said, warning Australia's so-called safeguard mechanism had "not been very binding".
Instead, he defended India's present climate plan. "India's climate actions are rated high in many independent assessments….India's NDC has been rated as two degrees Celsius compatible."
In its first NDC, India had committed to cut carbon emissions by 33-35% from 2005 levels within 2030 and Indian authorities say the country is set to exceed the target.
But scientists have calculated that there is a huge gap between countries' carbon-reduction pledges in their first NDCs and what is needed to attain the Paris climate goal.
Hence there is a need for increased carbon-reduction ambition in the near-term and net zero emission target for the long-run.
But India has been arguing that it should not be expected to make deep carbon-cuts like developed countries because it is still developing and fighting poverty while having to rely on an energy-mix that largely relies on fossil fuels.
While going big on renewable energy, particularly solar power, the Indian government has announced plans to significantly increase coal production as part of post-Covid economic recovery.
"Good to see @ClimateEnvoy John Kerry. Continued our discussions on climate action and climate justice," tweeted Indian foreign minister S Jaishankar after meeting Mr Kerry last week.
What would it look like if the media reported on net zero by 2050 properly?
While the media is distracted by the meaningless argument over net zero by 2050, events are being driven by bigger structures and systems than personality politics.On Friday, in a meeting that attracted virtually no coverage from the mainstream media, state and territory ministers, led by Victoria, NSW and the ACT, smashed up Angus Taylor’s plans to impose a tax on every household to support the Coalition’s coal-fired power donors. All Taylor got was a face-saving commitment to “progress further design work on a mechanism that specifically values capacity in the NEM”, based on principles that include states being able to “meet their energy and emissions reduction objectives”.
So, by the end of his trip, Mr Kerry did praise India's track record on renewable energy but had nothing on whether India had committed itself for net zero and increased emission-reduction ambition.
"I'm confident that India is going to announce one thing or another going into COP , as will many other nations we haven't heard from yet. So, I anticipate increased ambition from a lot of different places," he was quoted as saying by Indian newspapers.
If India really does what Mr Kerry hopes it would do, it might unintentionally help the US in its bid to regain leadership in global climate regime - particularly when Washington faces an "unfriendly" China on the climate front as well.
But what if India chooses not to do so and if China continues with its "no co-operation if it is just climate" position?
Will the two team up to resist developed countries as they have done during past climate negotiations even when there were issues between them?
There are no easy answers.
But what India and China do will have an immense influence on global climate action - or inaction, for that matter.
You may also be interested in:
Morrison’s net zero plan: how the media will react .
How will a mainstream media characterised by obsession with personalities, a lack of policy substance and a focus on surface issues respond to Morrison's coming climate policy? We think we have a good idea.“Scott Morrison has fundamentally changed Australia’s economic trajectory and singlehandedly ended Australia’s climate wars, which have contributed to the defeat of five prime ministers before him, including the mighty John Howard.