Canada: Appeal Court majority says federal carbon tax constitutional - - PressFrom - Canada
  •   
  •   
  •   

CanadaAppeal Court majority says federal carbon tax constitutional

21:40  03 may  2019
21:40  03 may  2019 Source:   msn.com

Trudeau says Ontario 'shortsighted and irresponsible' for challenging carbon tax

Trudeau says Ontario 'shortsighted and irresponsible' for challenging carbon tax MONTREAL — The Ontario government's attempt to block the federal carbon tax is shortsighted and irresponsible, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told an environment conference in Montreal Thursday. But Trudeau's criticism of those who disagree with his government's plan to address climate change didn't stop at Ontario Premier Doug Ford's administration. Trudeau accused some federal opposition parties of denying climate change even exists and said

REGINA — Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has ruled in a split decision that a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional . Two of the five Appeal Court justices differed in their opinion and ruled the federal government's actions are not a valid use of that section of the Constitution .

REGINA — Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has ruled in a split decision that a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional . Two of the five Appeal Court justices differed in their opinion and ruled the federal government's actions are not a valid use of that section of the Constitution .

Appeal Court majority says federal carbon tax constitutional © Provided by Canadian Press Enterprises Inc

REGINA — Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has ruled in a split decision that a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional.

The Saskatchewan Party government had asked the court for its opinion on the levy that came into effect April 1 in provinces without a carbon price of their own.

In a 155-page decision on the reference case, Chief Justice Robert Richards writes that establishing minimum national standards for a price on greenhouse gas emissions falls under federal jurisdiction.

He writes Ottawa has the power to impose its carbon tax under a section of the Constitution that states Parliament can pass laws in the name of peace, order and good government.

Ahead of Trudeau meeting, Kenney calls assessment bill a threat to unity

Ahead of Trudeau meeting, Kenney calls assessment bill a threat to unity OTTAWA — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says if the federal bill overhauling environmental assessments passes in its current form it will threaten Canadian unity and there will be "an immediate constitutional challenge." Kenney is at the Senate energy committee this morning to talk about Bill C-69, which he calls the "no more pipelines" bill. He is telling the committee the bill flagrantly violates Alberta's constitutional right to regulate its natural resources. The legislation establishes a new process for reviewing major projects with a national scope or in federal jurisdiction.

REGINA — Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has ruled in a split decision that a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional . Two of the five Appeal Court justices differed in their opinion and ruled the federal government's actions are not a valid use of that section of the Constitution .

REGINA — The federal government used a favourable court decision on its carbon tax Friday to put pressure on premiers who don't like it to stop fighting it. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal ruled in a split decision that the tax imposed on provinces without a carbon price of their own is constitutional .

Two of the five Appeal Court justices differed in their opinion and ruled the federal government's actions are not a valid use of that section of the Constitution.

Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe, who has said a carbon tax hurts his province economically, said there will be an appeal.

"Though I am disappointed by today's ruling, our fight will continue on behalf of Saskatchewan people – who oppose the ineffective, job-killing Trudeau carbon tax," he said on Twitter. "It was a 3-2 split decision and we look to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada."

Over a two-day hearing in February, Saskatchewan argued that the question wasn't one of climate change, but rather the division of power.

It argued a carbon tax is unconstitutional because it's not applied evenly across the country and oversteps into provincial jurisdiction.

Appeal Court to rule on Saskatchewan's court challenge of federal carbon tax

Appeal Court to rule on Saskatchewan's court challenge of federal carbon tax Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal is to make the first ruling in Canada on whether a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional. The Saskatchewan Party government filed a legal challenge of Ottawa's levy that came into effect April 1 in provinces without a carbon price of their own. Over a two-day hearing in February, Saskatchewan argued that the question isn't one of climate change, but rather the division of power. It argued a carbon tax is unconstitutional because it's not applied evenly across the country and erodes the sovereignty of provincial jurisdiction.

+ A split Saskatchewan Court of Appeal ruled the federal government does have the constitutional power to implement a carbon tax in provinces that don’t meet Ottawa’s minimum price. Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe said the province will appeal a decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.

A split Saskatchewan Court of Appeal ruled the federal government does have the constitutional power to implement a carbon tax in provinces that don’t meet

"There is no recognized constitutional requirement that laws enacted by Parliament must apply uniformly from coast to coast to coast," Richards wrote in the decision released Friday.

"The environment is not a legislative subject matter that has been assigned to either Parliament or the provincial legislatures under the Constitution Act."

Federal government lawyers suggested Ottawa has the power to put a price on pollution, because greenhouse gas emissions are a national concern.

"It’s the first word, it's not necessarily the last word," Dwight Newman, a University of Saskatchewan law professor, said before the ruling came down.

He said the decision will serve as "persuasive authority" that will be closely examined by other provinces waging their own legal battles against the federal tax.

Manitoba, New Brunswick and Ontario all became subject to a carbon price last month.

Appeal Court majority says federal carbon tax constitutional

Appeal Court majority says federal carbon tax constitutional REGINA — Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has ruled in a split decision that a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional. 

Saskatchewan’s highest court has concluded that the federal carbon tax is constitutional , handing Prime Minister Premier Scott Moe says Friday's ruling from the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal is disappointing, but is The majority also found that the carbon tax , in a constitutional sense, is not

A slim majority on the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal has ruled that the federal government’s national carbon -pricing system is constitutional . The province also said it breached the constitutional principle that only legislatures can impose taxes as the executive branch would determine what

Manitoba recently filed papers in Federal Court for its challenge, while Ontario was in court last month to argue its case and is waiting for the outcome.

"If they (Saskatchewan Appeal Court justices) write a persuasive judgment it could impact on how other courts decide the matter," suggested Newman.

"Of course, both sides could learn from the arguments made in this one — and how they fared — and even make adjustments in the other cases."

New Alberta Premier Jason Kenney has promised he will scrap the carbon tax the former NDP government brought in and also fight in court if Ottawa tries to impose a national tax on his province.

Newman notes that given the complexity of the case, Saskatchewan's Appeal Court arrived at a decision "surprisingly quick."

Sixteen groups — including the attorney generals of British Columbia, Ontario and New Brunswick — intervened in the court case on both sides of the debate.

The federal government's carbon price starts at a minimum of $20 a tonne and is to rise $10 each year until 2022.

Stephanie Taylor, The Canadian Press

Read more

South African government to appeal Caster Semenya case.
The South African government says there will be an appeal against the Caster Semenya ruling. The sports ministry says Athletics South Africa, the country's track and field body, will appeal the decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Athletics South Africa was one of two parties alongside Semenya to challenge the IAAF's testosterone regulations at the Swiss-based sports court. ASA declined to comment on a possible appeal and Semenya's lawyers have not announced an appeal.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!