CanadaCanadian health care stuck in the ’60s, expert says
Tory slams Ford over health, child-care cuts amid pricey plan to expand booze sales
Province spending "hundreds of millions of dollars to make beer more widely available," Mayor John Tory says, while also cutting funding for public health and child care.
In the first instalment of a Global News series exploring the Canadian health-care system, experts are calling attention to a framework they believe is decades out of date.
When Patty De Guia lost her leg to cancer months after giving birth to her third child, she expected Canada’s universal health-care system to give her the tools to recover. It never did — instead leaving her bankrupt, legless and suffering from severe depression.
Today, with help from family, friends and strangers, De Guia has a new lease on life to go along with her new prosthetic. But she questions how a system designed to help everyone equally left her to fend for herself.
Provincial child-care cuts will hurt families, Tory says in letters to Toronto PC MPPs
Mayor John Tory sent letters to Toronto's 11 Progressive Conservative MPPs outlining how the province's cuts to child-care funding could hurt families in their ridings. The letters, which were sent Friday, specify the number of subsidized child-care spaces at risk of being curtailed or cancelled and the number of children on the wait list for a city-funded subsidy in each PC-held riding in the city. Tory calls the cuts unilateral and retroactive and notes that they were made without any consultation with Toronto officials.
“The system was designed in the '60s, and it looks like a system that was designed in the '60s because the predominant forms of health care were doctors and hospitals,” said UBC professor Michael Law, who is also Canada Research Chair in access to medicines.
Today, he says, the statistics show a system in disarray that is leaving the country's most vulnerable citizens to make life-and-death choices. According to Law, more than two million Canadians don’t take prescription drugs as prescribed because they can’t afford it.
“It’s a horrible decision to have to make to have to choose between your health and your heat or your health or your food,” he said. “It’s not something that one expects from a country where everyone thinks we have universal health care.”
Toronto Tory MPPs say they stand by Ford’s budget cuts
Local Progressive Conservative MPPs under pressure to stand up for Toronto against deep funding cuts say they’re standing behind Premier Doug Ford, even if a couple don’t want to talk about it.
De Guia learned that first-hand as costs quickly spiralled out of control. While in hospital, her chemotherapy drugs were covered, but after being discharged, she was told to use lower-dose chemo pens at home that cost $4,000 apiece and were only partially covered by private insurance. And that was before getting fitted for an above-the-knee prosthetic leg.
“I had no clue that (prosthetic) legs were so expensive,” she said. “I just thought it automatically is taken care of for you, especially if you have insurance, and then you would get the best leg for your lifestyle. I mean, I was a mother at the time, and it didn’t make sense to have something that’s a pipe and a hinge because I’m never going to keep up with my kids.”
Indeed, the leg provided to her was, in essence, a loaner. It cost $10,000, of which she had to pay $2,500 out of pocket, but she had to give it back once she was able to purchase a more permanent option. Because Ontario’s public health insurance plan doesn’t cover prosthetics, she was on her own, and the leg her doctor recommended at the time cost $50,000.
Money moves you need to make in your 60s and beyond
In retirement, you need to safeguard your nest egg while growing it enough to beat inflation. Here's how to do it.
Unable to afford such a high cost, De Guia used a wheelchair, crutches and her one good leg to move around for nine years while dreaming of walking her kids to school. It wasn’t until neighbours set up a GoFundMe page that she was able to raise enough money to buy a suitable prosthetic for almost $90,000.
“I don't understand why the government will pay for reconstructive surgery on breast cancer patients," said De Guia. "You don't need a breast to pick up your children from school. You don't need a breast to get to work."
In Ontario, the public health insurance plan pays for breast reconstruction surgery.
When medicare was first conceived in the 1960s, there was an intense debate over what would and wouldn’t be covered. Ultimately, the Liberal government decided to exclude services outside of hospitals and doctors' offices. But perhaps the most critical decision was to not fund pharmacare. Today, pharmaceutical prices in Canada are the second highest in the world after the U.S.
“Well, there's a theme there, which is that (father of medicare) Tommy Douglas always said that there are two dangers for medicare,” said health policy analyst Michael Rachlis. “The first is public payment. And we don't have public payment for drugs, and that means at least 20 per cent of Canadians who should have had a drug didn't take it last year.”
Funding pharmacare would be expensive. Rachlis says there are estimates that upwards of $10 billion would have to be added to the tax base, but he also counters that it could yield almost the same amount in savings.
“There's money to be saved, both in negotiating better prices with the drug company in particular and the opportunity to have more effective, efficient prescribing," he said. "But we're not going to be able to get them if we don't have a public scheme.”
'Held hostage': Halifax woman's immigration application stuck in Sydney.
A Halifax woman who is applying to become a permanent resident of Canada says the federal immigration system is keeping her and many others in limbo waiting for a decision. © CBC Li looks out her window towards a nearby park. Skyler Li has repeatedly asked for more information about her case from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, offering to supply anything agents need to give her an answer. But she said she is always told to wait. © CBC Lee Cohen is an immigration lawyer in Halifax. "I only need a decision," she said from her Halifax home.
Alberta Votes: Leaders debate special coverage
NDP Leader Rachel Notley, UCP Leader Jason Kenney, Liberal Leader David Khan and Alberta Party Leader Stephen Mandel will debate the election issues ...
Beyond Ketofast: Your Need-to-Know Guide – Part 2 with Dr. Joseph Mercola #588
This is part 2 of a two-part bonus episode of Bulletproof Radio. Be sure to listen to part 1, Ketofast: Your Need-to-Know Guide #588. In this episode of Bulletproof ...