CanadaGrowing calls for Canada to stop deportation of international student who worked too much
Visa rejections frustrate efforts to bring in more international students
OTTAWA — At a time when Canada is attracting more students from around the world, there are concerns qualified applicants from certain countries are getting turned away because of its visa process. Most students have been coming to Canada in recent years from India and China. Fazley Siddiq, a University of New Brunswick professor who served as dean of the business department, said visas have been a headache for applicants from countries like Pakistan and Nigeria. "It's frustrating for the students, it's frustrating for universities," Siddiq said. "The security checks were so stringent that no one could make it. Or at least, in my experience, very few were given visas.
There are growing calls for Canada to stop the deportation of an international student who worked too much.
On Monday, Global News told the story of Jobandeep Sandhu, an international student from Punjab, India who wasfor working more hours than was allowed under his study permit.
The story has also prompted demands for changes to the policy that led to Sandhu’s pending deportation — a policy that advocates have called both “arbitrary” and “unethical.”
International student arrested, facing deportation for working too many hours
An international student from Punjab, India was arrested and could be deported for overworking. Advocates say it's time for Canada to consider changing the rules.
“It’s ridiculous that we're treating international students as criminals for working too hard,” said Sofia Descalzi, incoming chairperson of the Canadian Federation of Students.
“The federation is opposed to any sort of deportation of international students based on financial needs or based on the fact that a student was working too hard just to make ends meet,” she said.
At the time of his arrest, Sandhu was working full time as a truck driver while finishing a diploma at Canadore College in Mississauga, Ont., to become a mechanical engineering technician.
Foreign students in Canada are allowed to work a maximum of 20 hours a week “off campus” without breaching the terms of their study permit.
But with his parents facing financial pressure back home and the high cost of tuition mounting — roughly $27,000 in international student fees — working full time was the only way he could afford to stay in school, Sandhu said.
Alleged ‘heavyweight’ gangster could be poster child for B.C.’s public inquiry into money laundering
Allegations against Kwok Chung Tam could illustrate how the Vancouver-area real estate market may have been exploited by Chinese organized crime. In 2018, a Global News investigation revealed that a secret police study linked more than $1 billion worth of high-end Vancouver-area property transactions in 2016 to suspected money laundering and organized crime, while an independent review released last week by B.C.'s government estimated $5 billion was laundered through the province's real estate last year alone.
'Differential' tuition fees are a problem
According to Descalzi, high costs — along with universities’ and colleges’ growing reliance on these fees to fund education — are the main source of the problem for students like Sandhu.
She also says the government can’t expect international students to pay three or even four times as much in tuition fees as Canadian students while at the same time limiting the number of hours they’re allowed to work.
“We're seeing differential (tuition) fees going up every single year across the country,” she said.
“(And) we're using people that want a better life and who come here and that are already sacrificing so much to make up for the shortfalls of our provincial and federal governments that should be funding post-secondary education.”
'Distasteful alliances': The secret story of Canada's fight against migrants
Doing business with alleged criminals, hunting for human smugglers, providing surveillance equipment to corrupt regimes: Those are just some of the methods used to prevent migrants from making their way to Canada.
But according to the government, the primary focus of study permit holders in Canada must be to study.
The government also says the 20-hour limit on work ensures foreign students complete their studies while allowing them an opportunity to earn some money and gain valuable experience.
Petition to stop deportation
It’s not only student groups that have rallied behind Sandhu since word of his arrest and pending deportation spread.
Syed Hussan, co-ordinator at the Migrant Workers Alliance for Change — a group that supports non-permanent residents living and working in Canada — contacted Sandhu and has helped set up ancalling on the government to let him stay.
As of Friday morning, the petition had nearly 40,000 signatures.
“One of the largest pools of migrant workers in the country is people who are international students and are essentially low-wage, precarious, part-time workers who study and then generally leave the country,” Hussan said.
“We’re calling for justice for Jobandeep and to ensure that he's able to stay.”
Few details offered on CBE school bullying review as another Calgary mother calls for action
The Calgary Board of Education continues to offer few details of a promised independent review into bullying at its schools, as more complaints and stories from concerned parents continue to surface. Several parents have shared disturbing stories of bullying at Calgary elementary schools and what they see as apathy and inaction by both the schools concerned and the school board. The worst case involved nine-year-old Amal Alshteiwi, who took her own life at home after sustained bullying at her northeast elementary school.
According to Hussan, Sandhu isn’t just an international student — he’s a worker who should have rights.
He calls the 20-hour work limit placed on international students a “random number” and says it opens the door to potential abuse from employers, such as forcing international students to work for cash and to accept less than minimum wage.
Since launching the petition to keep Sandhu in Canada, Hussan says he’s heard from hundreds of international students concerned about their own working conditions.
Deportation rescheduled for June
After his arrest, Sandhu was given a report by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) that said he was “inadmissible” to Canada because he had worked too many hours for his study permit.
He was then ordered to buy a flight home to India and leave the country no later than May 31.
But on Tuesday, during a scheduled meeting with the CBSA, Sandhu says he was told the ticket he bought was no good because it had a layover in Dubai.
According to Sandhu, the CBSA told him he needed to buy a new flight without a connection and gave him until June 15 to leave.
The government provided no update on Sandhu’s application to remain in Canada as a temporary resident, which was filed by his lawyers in January.
“My understanding is that it is still in progress,” said Mathieu Genest, a spokesperson for Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen.
What would happen if we forgave student debt?.
One expert says the question of forgiving student loans isn't really about education — it's about economics.
Why Is Australia Deporting So Many Kiwis? | Foreign Correspondent
Australia is detaining, cuffing and deporting more New Zealanders than any other group. Guest reporter Peter FitzSimons finds it's riling Kiwis and straining ...
41-year-old Adoptee Deported After 37 Years in the U.S. (HBO)
When Shin Song Hyuk was three years old, an American couple in Detroit adopted him and moved him from South Korea to the United States. His new family ...