•   
  •   
  •   

CanadaCOMMENTARY: Use of the word ‘genocide’ undermines the MMIWG report

19:15  08 june  2019
19:15  08 june  2019 Source:   globalnews.ca

National inquiry calls murders and disappearances of Indigenous women a 'Canadian genocide'

National inquiry calls murders and disappearances of Indigenous women a 'Canadian genocide' The thousands of Indigenous women and girls who were murdered or disappeared across the country in recent decades are victims of a “Canadian genocide,” says the final report of the national inquiry created to probe the ongoing tragedy. The inquiry's final report, obtained by CBC News and verified by sources, concludes that a genocide driven by the disproportionate level of violence faced by Indigenous women and girls occurred in Canada through "state actions and inactions rooted in colonialism and colonial ideologies.

'The case for using the term ' genocide ' is tenuous at best and counterproductive at worst,' Rob Breakenridge says. 2:11 Trudeau says MMIWG report amounts to genocide , promises national action plan. WATCH: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau discussed the report on Missing and Murdered

Trudeau says MMIWG report amounts to genocide , promises national action plan – Jun 3, 2019. comments Leave a comment . Trudeau said the federal government would do a “thorough review” of the MMIWG report and “develop and implement a national action plan to address violence against

COMMENTARY: Use of the word ‘genocide’ undermines the MMIWG report© REUTERS/Chris Wattie A woman holds a sign during the closing ceremony of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls in Gatineau, Que., on June 3, 2019.

(Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.)

As the world marked the 25th anniversary of the horrors of the Rwandan genocide, I had the occasion to conduct one of the more emotional and moving interviews of my career.

Melchior Cyusa now lives in Calgary after somehow managing to escape from the massacre in Rwanda. He was just nine years old at the time. Most of his family, however, suffered a far more horrific fate: Cyusa's parents and five siblings were among the more than one million who were slaughtered in those three horrific months.

Former Harper-era minister doubles down on calling MMIWG inquiry report 'propagandist'

Former Harper-era minister doubles down on calling MMIWG inquiry report 'propagandist' A former federal Aboriginal affairs minister under the Stephen Harper government is doubling down on his social media claim that the finding of “genocide” by the National Inquiry into Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and girls was “propagandist.”

The report defined the level of violence against the women as a 'Canadian genocide .' "Part of me is concerned that they're using words in a loose way that have massive implications," Turpel-Lafond In his view, Akhavan said discussions over the use of the term genocide are a distraction from the

He had refrained from using the word " genocide " when pressed by an audience member earlier in the day. Trudeau also remarked that women's rights to make choices with "It's Genocide ": Final MMIWG report says Canada must do more - Продолжительность: 1:01:36 Global News 1 576 просмотров.

That is what most people think of when they hear the word "genocide." As such, the idea that genocide has happened in this country is not something that most Canadians are likely to accept. That may also mean that otherwise-sensible observations and recommendations made by those simultaneously touting the genocide claim will be disregarded.

READ MORE: ‘This is genocide’ — Final MMIWG report says all Canadians have role in ending violence

And if that turns out to be the case with regard to the final report from the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, then it will have ultimately done a disservice to the entire process.

As an Indigenous Woman, I Was Triggered By the MMIWG Report

As an Indigenous Woman, I Was Triggered By the MMIWG Report “The true power of the inquiry does not lie in the hands of the government. It lies with us—the survivors, families and people who the inquiry is about”

It’s now looking ahead at the report ’s release. WATCH: MMIWG inquiry begins two-day community hearing in Moncton. The former chairman of the commission that reported on the legacy of Canada’s residential schools, Sen. Murray Sinclair, said his commission heard from numerous women

MMIWG report genocide . National billboard campaign hopes to continue MMIWG conversation. COMMENTARY : Use of the word ‘ genocide ’ undermines the MMIWG report . 'The case for using the term ' genocide ' is tenuous at best and counterproductive at worst,' Rob Breakenridge says.

In the aftermath of the report’s release, there was some drama around the question of whether Prime Minister Justin Trudeau would say the word "genocide." Initially, he resisted, but the following day he did, indeed, say it: “We accept the finding that this was genocide. And we will move forward to end this ongoing national tragedy.”

Interestingly, Trudeau’s statement implies past tense — so this was genocide but it no longer is? At what point did the genocide end?

READ MORE: Why ‘genocide’ was used in the MMIWG report

Honestly, though, this is about as glib a way as possible for the head of our government to be making the staggering admission that this country is guilty of genocide. Yes, there was genocide, but now let’s move on? In what other conversation about any other genocide would that be a remotely reasonable response?

Even if one could mount a reasonable case that the plight of these murdered and missing Indigenous women and girls constitutes genocide, or if one accepts the rationale put forth by the inquiry on this question, there is still the question of what, exactly, we think it accomplishes.

Indigenous Rights Bill In Jeopardy, Days After MMIWG Report Urged Its Passage

Indigenous Rights Bill In Jeopardy, Days After MMIWG Report Urged Its Passage OTTAWA — Odds are shrinking that an NDP MP’s bill proposing the government review its laws to ensure they meet minimal international rights standards for Indigenous peoples will pass before Parliament adjourns for summer. 

MMIWG report and genocide : Why the word is so controversial - Продолжительность: 4:56 CBC News 3 303 просмотра. Scheer disagrees with MMIWG genocide finding | Power & Politics - Продолжительность: 3:04 CBC News 7 830 просмотров.

COMMENTARY : Use of the word ‘ genocide ’ undermines the MMIWG report . Changes to Canada’s solitary-confinement bill could help with MMIWG report findings. Stay in the loop. Get a roundup of the most important and intriguing national stories delivered to your inbox every weekday.

If it is now a distraction to get hung up on the g-word, and if we’re not inclined to commence war crimes tribunals for those deemed to be responsible for carrying out this genocide, then why was there a need to make this case in the first place? To what end?

READ MORE: World can learn from Canada regarding findings of MMIWG probe: Trudeau

Moreover, the case for "genocide" is undercut by the mandate and the focus of the inquiry itself. This was not an examination of the plight of all Indigenous Peoples — Indigenous men were specifically excluded. Are we to accept that there was genocide against Indigenous women but not men, despite the fact that the latter group has traditionally suffered from a higher rate of homicide? Are we to simply presume that this genocide was carried out against Indigenous men, even though this inquiry did not seek to examine their plight?

There’s also the unintended consequences of what has happened here, and we seem to have opened quite a can of worms. For example, both the Organization of American States and Amnesty International have suggested that Canada should be investigated for committing genocide.

Feds would ‘absolutely’ support OAS probe into MMIWG report’s allegation of genocide: Bennett

Feds would ‘absolutely’ support OAS probe into MMIWG report’s allegation of genocide: Bennett Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Carolyn Bennett says the government would support an international probe.

But the case for using the term genocide is tenuous at best and counterproductive at worst.

For one, it’s not a term we should seek to water down and it would be a shame if Canada’s ability to speak out about genocide or the types of human rights abuses that can pave the way for genocide was weakened as a result of this.

Moreover, though, if we want Canadians to accept the conclusions and recommendations of the report then that job is made all the more difficult by a rather controversial — and arguably absurd — assertion that only serves to give people an excuse to disregard all this work.

This is an otherwise very serious and scathing report. It should shock Canadians into action. We should be having a conversation about how our shameful indifference contributed to this immense tragedy. But, unfortunately, that’s not the conversation that’s taking place.

Rob Breakenridge is the host of 'Afternoons with Rob Breakenridge' on Global News Radio 770 Calgary and a commentator for Global News.

Read more

The RCMP was created to control Indigenous people. Can that relationship be reset?.
The RCMP was modelled after a British police force created to control Irish people. That force has since been disbanded — should the Mounties follow suit?

usr: 1
This is interesting!