•   
  •   
  •   

CanadaDoctor guilty of sexual abuse but revoking licence too harsh, court says

00:41  13 august  2019
00:41  13 august  2019 Source:   thestar.com

R. Kelly Pleads Not Guilty In NYC Court To Sex Abuse Charges

R. Kelly Pleads Not Guilty In NYC Court To Sex Abuse Charges Singer R. Kelly will be arraigned in a Brooklyn courtroom on federal sex abuse charges. Kelly sate handcuffed in between his lawyers as one of them entered a not guilty plea on his behalf to a five count indictment of racketeering and sex trafficking. His two girlfriends, sister, brother and supporters were also in the courtroom, CBS2’s Alice Gainer reported. The singer was already in custody after his arrest in Chicago last month on child pornography charges. Here in New York, he’s charged with exploiting five victims identified as Jane Does.

Doctor guilty of sexual abuse but revoking licence too harsh, court says© Andrew Francis Wallace Dr. Martin Lee hide his identity outside the College of Physicians and Surgeons on May 2, 2017. Lee will get a second chance at keeping his medical licence following an appeal court decision that found the penalty of revocation too harsh.

WARNING: This story contains images/details that some may find disturbing.

A Mississauga doctor who showed a gay porn magazine to a female patient will get a second chance at keeping his licence, following a recent court decision.

Dr. Martin Lee’s licence was initially revoked in 2017 by the discipline committee of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. Among other things, the committee found the rheumatologist had sexually abused one patient by showing her gay pornography and asking: “What is S&M? What do they get from it? How could two men do that?”

Ryder Cup winner Olesen charged with sexual assault on flight

Ryder Cup winner Olesen charged with sexual assault on flight Ryder Cup winner Olesen charged with sexual assault on flight

The committee also found he sexually abused another patient by rubbing his groin against her hip area while providing injections, and by “using sexually explicit and crude language when asking her personal questions about her sex life.” That patient had testified at the discipline hearing that Lee asked her questions like: “Is your husband’s c--- big?” and “Can he still put it in my p----?”

Lee appealed to the Divisional Court, where in a ruling released last month the court upheld the findings of sexual abuse, but overturned the penalty of revocation.

The court has sent the case back to the discipline committee to come up with a new punishment.

“In this case, the penalty was not carefully tailored to the circumstances of the case; was not consistent with prior decisions; and was not proportionate,” said the decision delivered by a panel of three judges, Frances Kiteley, Robert Del Frate and Helen Rady.

Richard Callaghan: Longtime US figure skating coach accused of sexual abuse in a new lawsuit

Richard Callaghan: Longtime US figure skating coach accused of sexual abuse in a new lawsuit A figure skater has filed a lawsuit accusing longtime US Figure Skating coach Richard Callaghan of sexually abusing him for approximately two years, beginning when he was about 14. The lawsuit, filed in San Diego court, alleges Callaghan sexually molested figure skater Adam Schmidt repeatedly between 1999 and 2001, both while coaching the then-teen and later at a competition in San Diego. Schmidt, now 34, is a former member of the US National Figure Skating Team, his lawyers said.

“The evidence did not support revocation. The committee made an error in principle by imposing revocation and in so doing, ordered an unfit penalty which must be quashed.”

One of Lee’s lawyers, Mark Veneziano, declined to comment to the Star as the case will now be going back to the committee.

At the hearing before the discipline committee, the college’s lawyer had argued for revocation of Lee’s licence, while the doctor’s lawyers argued for a six-month suspension and a requirement that Lee not be able to practise on female patients for two years unless in the presence of a chaperone.

That hearing took place on May 2, 2017. Less than a month later, while the committee was still deliberating its decision on punishment, the provincial government’s Bill 87 came into law. The bill made changes to the law around sexual abuse by health professionals, sparked by a years-long Toronto Star investigation into doctors who were still practising despite having been found guilty by the college of sexual abuse.

CannTrust shares plunge again as Health Canada deems 2nd cannabis facility 'non-compliant'

CannTrust shares plunge again as Health Canada deems 2nd cannabis facility 'non-compliant' Shares in Canadian cannabis company CannTrust lost about a quarter of their value on the stock market Monday after the company said Health Canada has deemed a second one of its facilities "non-compliant with certain regulations." The Vaughan, Ont.-based company's problems began about a month ago after government health authorities discovered it had been producing cannabis plants in unlicensed greenhouses. Health Canada halted the sale of products from the company's facility in Pelham, Ont.

Among other things, the bill removed the power of discipline committees to impose gender-based restrictions on a doctor’s licence, such as the restriction being requested by Lee’s lawyers. The college argued that the amendments were retrospective and should be applied in Lee’s case. The discipline committee sided with the college and went on to revoke Lee’s licence.

The Divisional Court disagreed with the committee that the amendments are retrospective. It also found the committee was wrong not to consider the penalties in prior cases when crafting a punishment for Lee. The doctor’s lawyers had filed several prior cases where the conduct by the physician was comparable or worse than Lee’s, but where the penalty was suspension and not revocation.

The judges pointed to a Court of Appeal ruling involving the college, which found “it is important in establishing a penalty that there be consistenty with prior decisions.” In sending the case back to the discipline committee, the Divisional Court stated that revocation is not a fit penalty and cannot be on the table.

“The committee held that revocation would send a clear message to other victims of sexual abuse by physicians that reporting such behaviour is encouraged and will be taken seriously,” the Divisional Court wrote.

“But the committee did not consider whether other penalties would accomplish the same objective.”

Read more

Moncton murderer pleads guilty to killing fiancée's dog, committing robberies.
A Moncton man pleaded guilty to killing a dog and committing several robberies around the time he killed his fiancée last year.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!