CanadaCould new Airbnb rules discourage legal secondary suites?

15:51  29 august  2019
15:51  29 august  2019 Source:   thestar.com

Airbnb quietly shut down a top host amid scathing reviews, but hundreds of guests were left to stay with him

Airbnb quietly shut down a top host amid scathing reviews, but hundreds of guests were left to stay with him After 'AJ' was suspended, dozens of his listings returned under new accounts with fake profile pics

Could new Airbnb rules discourage legal secondary suites?© Rene Johnston Alexis Leino, photographed at his home, is an Airbnb host whose case is being advocated at this week's LPAT hearings over the city's proposed Airbnb regulations.

Desiree Narciso bought her late-1800s house in 1992. She and her family live on the second and third storeys. The first floor is rented to a long-term tenant for $2,700 a month and the basement operates as an Airbnb that can be used as one apartment or separated into two units that rent for between $90 and $160 a night each.

The rental income has helped Narciso recover from devastating flooding and structural problems that have forced her to practically rebuild the place in recent years, she told a provincial tribunal that is hearing an appeal of the city’s approved short-term rental accommodations.

Renter who listed spare room on Airbnb ordered to repay roommate's damage deposit

Renter who listed spare room on Airbnb ordered to repay roommate's damage deposit Kaley Antaya has been a renter in B.C. for 14 years, but she says she has never faced as many problems as when she started dealing with the tight rental market in Vancouver. Last year, Antaya's living situation went sideways after her roommate, Amy Wutzke, listed a third bedroom for short-term rentals on Airbnb. "It was a nightmare," Antaya said over the phone. "I felt completely unsafe." Antaya, 33, left without giving 30 days' notice, as per her agreement with Wutzke. But when Antaya moved out, her roommate refused to refund her $400 damage deposit. The B.C.

Narcisco said she planned to also use the main floor of her house as an Airbnb-style rental when the long-term tenant decides to move. She has obtained all the variances and building permits required by the city to build her rentals.

“I am a poster child for building compliance,” the Little Portugal resident told the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal (LPAT) on Wednesday.

Short-term rentals are something Narciso said she has long understood to be legal and none of the designers and architects who have helped her repair and renovate her house have suggested otherwise, although she told the tribunal she has never explicitly asked if short-term rentals are legal.

But if Toronto’s new short-term accommodation rules go ahead, Narciso would no longer be able to rent the basement and main floor of her house on a short-term basis. The regulations would permit her to rent up to three separate rooms in her house. But legal secondary suites would have to be rented on a long-term basis only and it would be up to the tenant, the principal resident of that unit, to decide if they want to let out their home.

Hearings to begin in landlords’ appeal over Toronto rules for Airbnb, other short-term rentals

Hearings to begin in landlords’ appeal over Toronto rules for Airbnb, other short-term rentals The teal front door of Serena Purdy’s white house leads the eye straight down one of Kensington Market’s quirky little laneways where pots of lavender and herbs adorn her stoop. It’s more of a graffiti-covered alley than residential street. But PhD student Purdy, who has lived there for 16 years, remembers it was alive with neighbours only a year ago, a close community that rallied in crisis and celebration. Last Tuesday afternoon, the only passerby is pulling a wheeled suitcase. Familiar friends and local artists who once occupied the buildings surrounding her house have been displaced by tourists and strangers occupying what are now short-term rentals.

The city’s regulations about short-term rentals — considered a term of less than 28 days — were supposed to take effect in June. But they haven’t been enforced because of the appeal from landlords like Narciso who say the new rules would restrict how they use their property to generate income.

Earlier on Wednesday, lawyer Sarah Corman — who is representing Alexis Leino, a landlord who uses his basement suite for short-term rentals and doesn’t want a long-term tenant — asked senior city planner Caroline Samuel if the new rules might discourage some homeowners from installing legal secondary units or even ripping them out.

Samuel, who wrote the city’s policy that was approved in late 2017, has testified that Toronto is encouraging homeowners to install secondary suites to boost the supply of long-term rentals.

In cross-examination, Corman asked Samuel if homeowners might be more likely to build those second units if they could use them as they wish — even if they didn’t rent them on a long-term basis, the next owner of the home might, the lawyer suggested.

Airbnb hosts, short-term rental critics facing off over regulations at appeal hearing

Airbnb hosts, short-term rental critics facing off over regulations at appeal hearing A years-long battle over how to regulate short-term rentals in Toronto is continuing this week at the province's Local Planning Appeal Tribunal, with some arguing the city's proposed rules are a "deflection" from policymakers' attempts to fix an ongoing affordable housing shortage. The regulations, which focus on the short-term rentals available through companies such as Airbnb and Vrbo, were approved by council in 2018. Multiple hosts appealed the rules before they could be put into place.

“We don’t know that,” Samuel said. “I don’t know (that) more people are going to build them because they can use them however they want. We have no evidence to support that.”

Corman went on to ask, “If somebody has a basement unit that’s not a lawful secondary suite, (can that) be rented out as part of the principal residence as a short-term rental?”

Samuel replied, “If someone has rooms in their basement and it’s not a lawful secondary suite and did not obtain the appropriate approvals to create a secondary suite, did not obtain a building permit, does not meet fire code, for example, it’s not considered a secondary suite. It would be another room in the house.”

“As soon as they invest in it and bring up to fire code and building code standards, they no longer can rent out that same room as a short-term rental,” said Corman.

“That’s correct, because now it’s a separate, self-contained living accommodation,” replied Samuel.

Responding to a question about what happens if the homeowner removes the features that comprise a secondary suite such a fire door, Samuel said it “is a tricky question.

“I can’t answer what you can do to undo legal secondary suites,” she said. “That’s something for a zoning examiner, someone in the buildings department to determine. I can’t determine that.”

On Thursday, the fourth day of the seven-day LPAT hearings, city housing expert Narmadha Rajakumar and McGill University researcher David Wachsmuth are expected to testify.

Read more

Student discounts 2019: The ultimate guide to discounts across Canada.
Save some money and cut expenditures by taking advantage of student discounts. We all know that a great way to reduce debt while in post-secondary school is to keep a budget. But another way to save some money and cut expenditures is to take advantage of discounts available to students. “Many businesses, stores and restaurants offer a discounted student rate with proof of enrollment (student card, student discount cards/apps, etc.), which can turn into a big savings for you,” notes the Canadian Scholarship Trust Plan. That’s especially true for some of the biggest retailers across the country.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!