Canada: Political disinformation is rampant online. How can voters cope? - PressFrom - Canada

CanadaPolitical disinformation is rampant online. How can voters cope?

13:26  12 september  2019
13:26  12 september  2019 Source:

Bob Hepburn: Why are voters tuning out federal election?

Bob Hepburn: Why are voters tuning out federal election? I admit I’m a political junkie, hooked on party platforms, campaign strategies, polls, election ads and backroom manoeuvres. For me, these are the best of times as I watch the ups and downs of the current federal election, filled with controversies, promises, fake news and photo ops. But I’ve become increasingly aware in recent days that many voters have tuned out this election, more so than possibly for any other federal election in decades. I’ve overheard a woman talking to her 20-something daughter about the election and the daughter responding: “There’s an election?”; I’ve listened as my dentist told me he just wants “it over;” I’ve heard a colleague speak about how no one

How disinformation is used and consumed. Proactive and reactive disinformation strategies in different country contexts. Disinformation —the use of half-truth and non-rational argument to manipulate public opinion in pursuit of political objectives—is a growing threat to the public sphere in

Outside the realm of politics , few would deny that the benefits of online information flows vastly outweigh their costs. By contrast, we do a much worse job of minimizing the risk posed by political deception and disinformation . If you get an e-mail from a wealthy heiress who offers to pay you a

Political disinformation is rampant online. How can voters cope?© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Between disinformation, emotionally-provocative posts and political spin, it can be hard to figure out what’s fact online.

The federal election is officially underway, and that means more Canadians will be moving online to discuss, debate and prepare for the vote.

But they'll be stepping into an environment that's been embroiled in the campaign for months, with messaging that range from disinformation to good old-fashioned politicking.

Here's a look at some of the major players online, the kind of messages they're sharing and what voters can expect online over the next five weeks.

Unlike U.S., Canada plans coordinated attack on foreign election interference

Unlike U.S., Canada plans coordinated attack on foreign election interference Ahead of the October election, Canada finds itself on the front lines of the war on disinformation and hacking.

The term “fake news” has become a cudgel for political leaders trying to discredit reporting, but disinformation – false content created explicitly to deceive or misinform – runs rampant online . Just last week, a study out of George Washington University found that a vast majority of Twitter accounts

Foreign politics & policy . How Ireland lost patience with Brexiting Brits. Boris Johnson heads to Dublin with relations at a low point. Why black voters are backing two old white guys.

Third party advertisers: Social media savvy through a hyper-partisan lens

While third party advertisers have played a role in Canadian democracy for a long time, there's a new breed that's solely focused on the election and is particularly savvy online. Using memes, videos and jokes, newer third party groups are hoping to influence voters with shareable online content.

North99, founded by former Liberal party staffers, and Canada Proud, founded by a former Conservative party staffer, are two of the most prolific of these newer groups.

Third party advertisers are required to register with Elections Canada if they spend $500 or more on advertising related to the election, and report where their money comes from and where it goes. They're also subject to spending limits and platforms where they advertise — like Facebook and Twitter — are required to keep a public registry of the ads under new election laws.

Russian election-meddling in Canada linked to Arctic ambitions: report

Russian election-meddling in Canada linked to Arctic ambitions: report OTTAWA — A new University of Calgary study is predicting Russian interference in the federal election campaign to serve what it describes as the Kremlin's long-term interest of competing against Canada in the Arctic. The study's author, Sergey Sukhankin, said in an interview that Moscow's ability to inflict serious damage is relatively low because Canadian society is not as divided as countries targeted in past elections, including the United States presidential ballot and Britain's Brexit referendum in 2016, as well as various attacks on Ukraine and the Baltic states.

That task force will be led by five non- political officials and is an addition to a “rapid response mechanism” housed within the Department of Foreign Affairs. Lawmakers in one house of parliament voted to repeal the legislation in mid-August after voters booted out the governing party.

“The fact is that voter fraud is rampant . In Texas, unlike some other states and unlike some other leaders, we are committed to cracking down on voter fraud.” But the same officials regularly gag on proposals to tighten the laws that regulate their own political money and behavior.

Third party groups aren't typically sharing disinformation — demonstrably false information deliberately shared with an intent to mislead — but instead frame information to promote a particular point of view. Lately, their messaging has largely been attacking opposition parties and politicians.

"We want to talk about issues that are going to resonate in key electoral battlegrounds in a pertinent, accessible, digestible way," said Jeff Ballingall, who runs the conservative-leaning Canada Proud.

Ballingall said some of the issues that resonate the most with Canada Proud readers are government corruption, inequality and the cost of living.

A recent post from Canada Proud, for example, shared a new report from The Globe and Mailthat said the RCMP have been blocked from accessing certain documents related to the SNC-Lavalin affair. Canada Proud tied the lack of access to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, calling him "corrupt" and dubbing him "Canada's crime minister."

Federal probe finds "co-ordinated" social media bots in Alberta election

Federal probe finds EDMONTON — A federal agency investigating the recent Alberta election has found evidence the campaign featured tactics including co-ordinated, false social media postings. In a report released late Friday, the Rapid Response Mechanism — created by the G-7 to monitor foreign influence on democratic elections — identified social media accounts that demonstrated "co-ordinated inauthentic behaviour." The agency was created by the G7 at the 2018 conference in Charleboix, Que. It is intended to strengthen co-ordination between members in identifying, preventing and responding to threats to G7 democracies from foreign actors using social media to meddle in elections.

To ban the manufacturing of Disinformation … I think, once the definitions of the political elements of the American culture are clearly defined as… The Impact Of Voter Suppression Laws On African American Participation In Florida And North Carolina From 1988 To 2012, by Anthony Lewis Daniels

The Online counts report will include vote history from statewide elections only, while counts that you request us to process will include high propensity Political Data offers two different methods for grouping voters by households. “ How can I identify the best high propensity voters in my area?”

This kind of provocative language can be powerful on social media, said Gordon Pennycook, a University of Regina cognitive psychologist and assistant professor who studies disinformation.

"The stuff that really works, that really gets spread, is the stuff that gives people a really strong immediate reaction, which is often fear or disgust," said Pennycook. "It's compounded when it has societal importance on something people care about, which is where it intertwines with politics."

Darker corners: where disinformation thrives

There are also plenty of online groups and pages that share political messaging but aren't official third parties. These groups, on Reddit and Facebook, aren't subject to any regulations and often peddle disinformation.

Disinformation can take a number of forms, including memes. Memes can include a false quote or made-up fact pasted on an image. The image format makes it easy to share but difficult to track. Since the image isn't linked to a single source that can be fact-checked, it's difficult to debunk memes, leading many people to believe they're true.

Voters deserve better on leaders’ debates

Voters deserve better on leaders’ debates When it comes to campaign debates, more is generally better than less. Let the leaders have it out. Let the chips fly and let the voters sort it out. With that in mind, as both citizens and journalists we’d ideally like to see the federal party leaders take part in more than the three debates that are now scheduled for the election campaign that will officially kick off on Wednesday. But does Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau deserve all the criticism he’s getting for agreeing to those three and no more? Not really.

Online Political Conversations. Consequences of Exposure to Disinformation Online . “The same way Russian electoral interference depends on the very real grievances of voters , brazen Russian The pro-Kremlin disinformation machine has been steaming at full speed in the past two weeks, as it

And that distrust has manifested itself in an onslaught of voter fraud-related hoaxes on social media. “I think it is coordinated by a political group that is interested in jeopardizing and delegitimizing the The TSE was also surprised by how much misinformation was aimed at electoral systems on Election

For example, a meme that circulated online earlier this year claimed Trudeau spent Victoria Day at a mosque. In fact, the image used shows Trudeau at an Eid al-Adha celebration from September of 2016.

Political disinformation is rampant online. How can voters cope?© Screengrab/Facebook Canada Proud frequently attacks Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in its posts.

Another strategy is to share information out of context, causing people to misunderstand its meaning. Such information can be old news stories shared as if they're new, or videos edited to leave out an extra sentence or important context. These posts often tap into fears and misunderstandings around immigration, voter fraud and corruption in government.

When it comes to spreading disinformation, Facebook is a hotspot because it's much more popular among Canadians than other platforms, according to Gabrielle Lim, a researcher at the Data & Society Research Institute focusing on the implications of disinformation, propaganda and "fake news" in society.

"Canadians are much more on Facebook than, say, Twitter or Reddit," Lim said. "If I were a disinformation operator wondering where I'm going to get the most impact, I'd look at what platforms people are using."

Party messages online: toeing the line

Long before the election was formally called, each of the major political parties was already engaging in campaign messaging online. While a lot of what they've said is par for the course (criticisms of policies and candidates), other messages have struck some social media users as misleading.

Federal NDP want voters to hear they're 'In it for You' on the campaign trail

Federal NDP want voters to hear they're 'In it for You' on the campaign trail Federal NDP want voters to hear they're 'In it for You' on the campaign trail

Disinformation can spread conspiracy theories and reinforce "filter bubbles" that isolate readers and viewers from alternative viewpoints and can create a cloud of confusion and paranoia. In our report, we highlight how disinformation is effective because it is quick, cheap and yields high rewards.

The upstart political parties’ messaging fits neatly into a pro-Russian narrative that , in recent months, has led experts and politicians to see a “Trojan horse” link between Europe’s rising anti-establishment movements and Moscow’s disinformation campaign. It’s one they say is aimed at undermining trust

Frequently, Canadians on social media will flag to CBC tweets from politicians that they consider unfair or misleading. For example, readers have complained about Liberal MP Bill Morneau tweeting about Conservative Party leader Andrew Scheer's comments on cutting government spending, and about Scheer himself sharing a debunked story about a U.K. child murderer coming to Canada.

"Politics is a rough sport and people occasionally take liberties in critiquing their opponent," said Michael Pal, an associate law professor at the University of Ottawa specializing in election law. "That's all normal. It's just happening more online."

Getting through the online bog

If you're overwhelmed by the mess of things online, you're not alone. Between disinformation, emotionally-provocative posts and political spin, it can be hard to figure out what's fact.

Simply keeping your eyes peeled for completely false information isn't enough, said Ben Nimmo, director of investigations at Graphika, a commercial analytics company in New York. Nimmo leads the company's efforts to track and detect disinformation online.

"It's always important to look out for obvious fakes — things that are demonstrably false — but that's really only a part of the overall spectrum of manipulation online," Nimmo said. "A lot of what we see is not a story which is 100 per cent fake. A lot of the time the facts will be reported accurately, but they'll be a lot of emotional targeting or emotional bias on top of it."

Nimmo said the best thing voters can do to protect themselves is to think critically about everything they encounter online, from tweets to blog posts to news articles. And if something you're reading causes you to feel an immediate emotional reaction, take it as a clue to step back and reconsider.

"Some of the news out there will be entirely genuine, some of it will be somewhat twisted, some of it will be entirely false, but we're all very incautious in the way we actually consume news on our phones," Nimmo said. "Take a step back, don't get sucked into the swirl."

Have you spotted something fishy online? Send your disinformation news tips to [email protected]

Party vs. candidate: When it comes to Toronto, does it matter who knocks at your door?.
The federal election campaign may be in full swing, but voters in several Toronto-area ridings still don't know who all of their candidates will be — and while that may not matter much right now, it could make the sliver of the difference needed for a win on Oct. 21. As of this week, the Liberals had yet t o finalize candidates in 31 ridings across the country, finally nominating former Liberal MPP Han Dong in the coveted Don Valley North seat on Thursday. The New Democrats were in rougher shape with more than 90 candidates left to nominate nationally.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!