Canada: Experts say Scheer’s plan to close border loophole ‘doomed to failure’ - PressFrom - Canada

Canada Experts say Scheer’s plan to close border loophole ‘doomed to failure’

21:45  09 october  2019
21:45  09 october  2019 Source:

Trudeau’s main political rival has American citizenship

  Trudeau’s main political rival has American citizenship TORONTO (AP) — Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's main political rival in elections this month holds dual Canadian-U.S. citizenship, but a spokesman for Conservative party leader Andrew Scheer says he recently embarked on the process of renouncing his American citizenship. The Conservative party has criticized previous party leaders for holding dual citizenship.

a man wearing a suit and tie: Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer says he'll © Global News Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer says he'll "close loophole" in Canada-U.S. border agreement.

Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer says that, if elected, he would close the loophole in the Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) that allows people to make refugee claims in Canada even if they enter the country at an unofficial border crossing.

The Conservatives also aren’t ruling out creating detention camps at the border to house irregular migrants while their claims are being processed.

READ MORE: Scheer vows to close asylum ‘loophole’, unveils immigration plan at Roxham Road crossing

Scheer pledges to close asylum 'loophole' at Roxham Road crossing

  Scheer pledges to close asylum 'loophole' at Roxham Road crossing ST-BERNARD-DE-LACOLLE, Que. — Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer says he will close the loophole that allows tens of thousands of asylum seekers to claim refugee status. Scheer is announcing his immigration plan at the Roxham Road crossing in Hemmingford, Que., which is separated from the United States by a few metres of scrub. The federal government says nearly 50,000 people have entered Canada there in the last two years, most of them intending to claim asylum once they're on Canadian soil.

Asked directly if detention camps were something a Conservative government would create at the border, the Conservatives said the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act provides criteria for detaining asylum seekers. This leaves the option of creating detention camps open.

Scheer’s pledge, made Wednesday at Roxham Road in Quebec, came with few details on exactly how he would close the loophole.

Scheer said his “preferred option” would be to renegotiate the STCA with the U.S., but when pressed on what he would do if U.S. President Donald Trump refused to make a deal, Scheer was light on details.

“There are other options. There are other tools available to the government that we will also be exploring,” Scheer said.

One of these options is to declare the entire Canada-U.S. border an official port of entry. This way, people entering the country would be covered by the STCA and — if they do not qualify for an exemption under the agreement — would be sent back to the U.S.

Scheer’s Vow To Close Border Crossing Loophole Is 'Specious': Refugee Law Expert

  Scheer’s Vow To Close Border Crossing Loophole Is 'Specious': Refugee Law Expert OTTAWA — Andrew Scheer’s promise to close a “loophole” in the Safe Third Country Agreement is “specious,” according to a refugee law expert. The Conservative leader made the announcement Wednesday at the Canada-U.S. border crossing at Roxham Road in Saint-Bernard-de-Lacolle, Que. It was one policy item he proposed to “restore public confidence in Canada’s immigration system.” The agreement applies at official ports of entry and requires prospective refugee claimants who want to come to Canada to return to the first safe country in which they arrived to start the process there.

Scheer suggested this is one of the options he’s looking at when he said the “principles” of the STCA could be applied at other points along the border.

But migration experts, border security officials and the government have questioned whether this is possible.

READ MORE: Experts surprised immigration didn’t play more prominent role in federal leaders’ debate

Sharry Aiken, a Queen’s University law professor, says any plan to scrap the loophole in the STCA without agreement from the U.S. is “doomed to failure.”

Meanwhile, she says expanding the agreement to cover the entire border is nonsensical because Canada does not have the resources to enforce this type of mass “securitization” of the border, nor is this type of strategy effective.

“It’s a huge border."

Aiken points to the U.S.-Mexico border as an example of why increased security does not mean fewer irregular migrants.

Fear and the border: why Andrew Scheer is talking about gangs and migrants now

  Fear and the border: why Andrew Scheer is talking about gangs and migrants now With less than two weeks left to go in the federal election campaign, Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer is talking about border security and foreign criminal gangs. He chose an interesting moment to do so.The Conservative leader stood near Roxham Road in southern Quebec, where asylum seekers crossing from the United States have forced the federal government to establish an unofficial border crossing. As Scheer spoke, opinion polls and seat projections showed his party trailing the Liberal Party nationally and losing ground to the Bloc Quebecois in Quebec.

“As we can see in relation to what’s going on with respect to America’s efforts in relation to Mexico, they’re an abysmal failure,” she said. “People are still crossing, just at higher costs and at peril to their lives. People are dying all the time.”

Promise would require new legislation

Since spring 2017, there has been a significant influx of asylum seekers in Canada, many of whom entered the country irregularly at unofficial border crossings.

The total number of asylum claims made in Canada in 2018 was 55,000, of which about one-third crossed the border irregularly. This was up from 23,500 total claims two years earlier.

In addition to pledging to close the loophole in the STCA, Scheer said he would move existing judges from the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) closer to the border and widely used unofficial crossings to speed up the processing time for claims and make crossing “illegally” less attractive.

But Aiken and others say Scheer could not do this without first introducing new legislation to change the IRB’s mandate. That’s because the IRB operates independently of the government, and administrative decisions are strictly the authority of the IRB’s chairperson, she said.

Elizabeth May accuses Justin Trudeau of stripping refugees of their human rights

  Elizabeth May accuses Justin Trudeau of stripping refugees of their human rights Trudeau said in the debate that May’s claim that new federal rules were denying refugees’ human rights was “absolutely false.” His government has also defended the new rule by saying no one will be removed from Canada without first receiving a pre-removal risk assessment to determine if they are in danger.“Canadians believe that we need to have a fair, and strong immigration system that applies to everyone and we are working to make sure that we protect human rights,” Trudeau said.“There’s no free pass to get through the border,” he said.

READ MORE: Conservative MP uses campaign flyer to spread falsehoods about ‘fake refugees’

Raoul Boulakia, a Toronto-based immigration lawyer, says moving refugee judges to the border would also make it a lot harder for asylum seekers to access a lawyer — a right they are guaranteed under Canada’s Constitution.

Meanwhile, Craig Damian Smith, director of the Global Migration Lab at the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, said Scheer’s pledge lacks vital details.

For example, he wonders if Scheer would create detention camps at the border for asylum seekers who enter the country irregularly to be held while their claims are processed.

Smith also questions the logistics of the move. The IRB isn’t just made up of judges, he said. There are translators, administrative staff, offices and other things needed in order for claims to be heard and judges to be able to do their jobs.

Smith says holding asylum seekers at the border while their claims are processed — no matter how quickly this is done — presents other problems, such as limiting their ability to work, pay taxes and receive health care.

READ MORE: Just 0.3% of irregular migrants in Canada found to have serious criminal past

The Conservative Party, meanwhile, says that if elected, it will amend existing immigration legislation and regulations to make sure IRB judges can be deployed to irregular crossing “hot spots.”

The money needed to relocate IRB judges will come from existing budgets, Conservatives say, adding that there are no plans to change current work-permit rules for people whose asylum claims are allowed to go forward.

Scheer has repeatedly said closing the STCA loophole would make Canada's immigration system fairer, more orderly and more compassionate.

Canada’s border agency ‘cancels’ arrest warrants for people it wants to deport but cannot find .
“In limited circumstances, an immigration warrant may be cancelled even if it cannot be confirmed that an individual has left Canada,” according to a CBSA spokesperson.When their visas expire or their refugee claims are rejected, they are supposed to leave. But not everyone does.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!