Canada: How Alberta will keep its $30-per-tonne carbon tax but make it easier for some big emitters to avoid paying - - PressFrom - Canada
  •   
  •   
  •   

Canada How Alberta will keep its $30-per-tonne carbon tax but make it easier for some big emitters to avoid paying

10:45  30 october  2019
10:45  30 october  2019 Source:   cbc.ca

Conservative carbon tax 'resistance' showing cracks after Liberals re-elected

  Conservative carbon tax 'resistance' showing cracks after Liberals re-elected The so-called "resistance" force of Conservative premiers waging war against the carbon tax implemented by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau began showing cracks on Tuesday, following the Liberals' re-election. While some of the five provincial leaders who had publicly criticized or legally challenged the carbon tax maintained their attacks in the hours after voters elected a minority Liberal government, at least one appeared to back down. TheWhile some of the five provincial leaders who had publicly criticized or legally challenged the carbon tax maintained their attacks in the hours after voters elected a minority Liberal government, at least one appeared to back down.

Alberta will keep its carbon price on large emitters at $ 30 per tonne , Premier Jason Kenney's United Conservative government has announced. That remains an open question. What's certain, for now, is that avoiding that price — or profiting from it — is about to get easier for some of Alberta 's biggest

Alberta is imposing a $ 30 - per - tonne carbon tax on large industrial facilities in January and using part of the proceeds to fund green technology projects. The tax could increase in future years to keep pace with the federal government’s climate plan. The industrial carbon tax , known as the Technology

Jason Kenney in a suit and tie with smoke: Alberta will keep its carbon price on large emitters at $30 per tonne, Premier Jason Kenney's United Conservative government has announced.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Alberta will keep its carbon price on large emitters at $30 per tonne, Premier Jason Kenney's United Conservative government has announced.

Alberta's new UCP government will continue to apply a $30-per-tonne carbon price that covers the majority of greenhouse gas emissions in the province, but will loosen the rules so that some of the largest emitters could be on the hook for $330 million less in charges next year.

New legislation introduced Tuesday will replace the previous NDP government's regulations on most large emitters in the province, including oilsands operations, natural gas producers, chemical manufacturers and fertilizer plants. The rules for electricity generators, however, will be left largely unchanged.

The big election winner? The carbon tax

  The big election winner? The carbon tax A key discovery from Monday's federal election results is that most Canadians support political parties that promote a carbon tax. Roughly two-thirds of voters marked an "X" by the name of a Liberal, NDP, Green or Bloc Québécois candidate. Some experts say it's time the Conservatives take note.To this day, the only way Alberta's Kenney describes carbon pricing is as the "job-killing" carbon tax.

At CAD$ 30 per tonne of CO2e, a carbon tax will raise the cost of gasoline by about 7 cents per litre It is a cap on emissions rather than production, which makes it even harder to determine when the line is to In Paris, the new Trudeau government was among the first of the big emitters to commit to an

What big business pays : Large industrial emitters will be covered by a different system and will be taxed For example, British Columbia’s carbon tax is $ 30 per tonne , which translates to about seven cents for a litre of gas. In theory, people will cut their carbon use over time to avoid paying the tax .

All told, the province estimates these types of heavy-emitting facilities account for 55 to 60 per cent of Alberta's greenhouse gas emissions.

Environment Minister Jason Nixon believes the new policy will satisfy the federal government's requirements for carbon pricing on large emitters, meaning Ottawa won't impose its own pricing system on Alberta's industry. This system runs in parallel to the federal fuel charge — commonly known as the carbon tax — that applies to individuals and lesser-emitting companies.

With another Liberal government elected earlier this month, Ottawa is set to impose a $30-per-tonne fuel charge in Alberta starting on Jan. 1, along with rebates for individuals. But Tuesday's legislation only deals with the large-emitter side of things, which operates under a different carbon-pricing system.

Ford 'going to pursue' carbon tax challenge to Supreme Court

  Ford 'going to pursue' carbon tax challenge to Supreme Court Doug Ford said Thursday his government is “going to pursue” its legal challenge of the federal carbon tax, days after Justin Trudeau’s Liberals secured another mandate in the form of a minority government. Speaking in his first media interview since Monday's election, Ford told CP24 "we will see it through" when asked about the fate of the challenge.In June, Ontario's top court struck down his government's case against the tax, saying the federal legislation — the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, enacted in April — is constitutionally sound.

But a $ 30 - per - tonne carbon tax rate in Alberta , whether imposed provincially or federally, is Still, the federal government approved Quebec’s cheaper plan as sufficient to avoid the more expensive Indeed, the Canadian oil and gas sector is dealing with several challenges; a higher carbon tax just

At CAD$ 30 per tonne of CO2e, a carbon tax will raise the cost of gasoline by about 7 cents per litre It is a cap on emissions rather than production, which makes it even harder to determine when the line is to In Paris, the new Trudeau government was among the first of the big emitters to commit to an

All this talk may sound a bit theoretical and wonkish, but the stakes are real — and they're high. This legislation is expected to create winners and losers. Millions of tonnes of CO2 and hundreds of millions of dollars are on the line.

Nixon says the new law will "reduce costs for industry and help businesses stay competitive while reducing emissions."

Others worry the change will actually boost Alberta's emissions when compared to the existing regime for industrial-scale greenhouse gas producers, brought in by the previous NDP government.

Here's what's about to change.

What's old is new again, sort of

It's almost impossible to talk about this without getting bogged down in acronyms, so right off the hop, here are the three you need to know. Each four-letter word refers to a different carbon-pricing policy, brought in via a different Alberta government, since 2007.

From income taxes to AirBnB rentals: How Alberta's new budget will affect your personal finances

  From income taxes to AirBnB rentals: How Alberta's new budget will affect your personal finances Albertans will pay more for everything from income taxes to user fees to tuition to smoking and AirBnB rentals under the budget unveiled by the United Conservative government on Thursday. The budget aims to balance the books by 2022-23 and relies heavily on tax reductions and streamlining for corporations with the assumption those benefits will trickle down to individuals.The only signs of relief for individuals will come in the form of child benefits for families, or in the form of reduced taxes on corporate dividend payouts if you happen to own profitable stock.

Alberta 's carbon tax started at a tonne in January and will go to $ 30 a tonne in 2018. By 2018, a single person will pay about 0 more for gas, heat and other goods affected by the price Ontario and Quebec have cap-and-trade systems, which cap emissions for big emitters and force those who

This is a list of countries by carbon dioxide emissions per capita. Countries are ranked by their metric tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions per capita in 2009. The data only consider carbon dioxide emissions from the burning of fossil fuels and cement manufacture

  • SGERSpecified Gas Emitters Regulation (via Ed Stelmach's PCs)
  • CCIRCarbon Competitiveness Incentive Regulation (via Rachel Notley's NDP)
  • TIERTechnology Innovation and Emissions Reduction (via Jason Kenney's UCP)

The latest policy is described as a hybrid of the two older systems.

The first system, SGER, took effect back in 2007. It charged a price of $15 per tonne for industrial emissions that exceeded an established target for each facility. This actually made Alberta one of the earliest adopters of a price on carbon.

The NDP raised that price to $20 per tonne in 2016 and again to $30 in 2017. And then, in 2018, it replaced the whole policy with its revamped version. The big difference with CCIR wasn't the price (which remained at $30 per tonne) but rather new targets that determined who pays that price (for exceeding the target) and who profits from it (by coming in under the target and amassing credits that can be sold for cash).

Now, the UCP government is set to replace CCIR with TIER in 2020. The price will remain at $30 per tonne (which happens to be the minimum required by the federal "backstop" on provincial carbon policies) but, again, it's those targets that are changing.

Alberta tables climate plan for industry; retains key parts of old legislation

  Alberta tables climate plan for industry; retains key parts of old legislation EDMONTON — Alberta has introduced a new climate plan for the province's big greenhouse gas emitters that it says will achieve similar emissions cuts as the former NDP government's plan and at less cost. "Our projections are that we're looking at getting similar results for less price for industry," said Jason Nixon, environment minister for the United Conservative government.

At $ 30 a tonne , there is Alberta and British Columbia at the top. Large emitters won't join the carbon tax program until 2018, so instead they will keep paying into an existing program, called Some significant details are unknown about Alberta 's carbon tax with billions of dollars in the balance.

At CAD$ 30 per tonne of CO2e, a carbon tax will raise the cost of gasoline by about 7 cents per litre The carbon tax is not designed to kill the oil-sands industry. On the contrary, it is designed to It is a cap on emissions rather than production, which makes it even harder to determine when the line is to

How much difference can a target make? A lot.

"It's anticipated that by transitioning to TIER, industry will save over $330 million in avoided compliance cost in 2020," reads a government briefing provided to reporters Tuesday.

And who stands to gain the most?

"The ones that stand to save the most are the worst performers, from a carbon perspective," said Sara Hastings-Simon, a research fellow at the University of Calgary who studies carbon-pricing policy.

New targets easier to hit

That's because those new targets will be easier to meet for the most carbon-intensive facilities.

Under the CCIR policy, which remains in effect until Dec. 31, there are industry-wide targets for emissions intensity. But TIER will change that. Instead of being compared to their peers, as a group, facilities will be compared to their own past performance.

So in the oilsands, for instance, there is currently a target (measured as carbon emissions per barrel of oil produced) that applies to all facilities. Come in below the target, and you can earn carbon credits. Come in above the target, and you owe.

But starting in January, each facility will play by a different set of rules. Instead of being measured against an industry-wide standard, a facility will be measured against its own average emissions intensity from 2013 to 2015. Its target will then be set at 10 per cent below that level for 2020.

Moe asks PM for 'hiatus' on carbon tax to negotiate climate plan with feds

  Moe asks PM for 'hiatus' on carbon tax to negotiate climate plan with feds Moe asks PM for 'hiatus' on carbon tax to negotiate climate plan with feds Moe made the pitch in a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau posted on his social media accounts Thursday. He noted that Trudeau had committed to an in-person meeting “soon” at the time of their post-election telephone call last week.

Firms will pay a carbon tax of $ 30 per tonne , just like everyone else. As many large emitters are in trade-exposed industries, unable to pass on the One may take issue with the lack of real revenue neutrality in Alberta ’s carbon tax , but the response should be in calling for tax reductions elsewhere.

How SGER worked. It was often said SGER priced carbon at per tonne — but that came with a Removing the carbon tax and only applying limited pricing on some large emitters "just doesn't Alberta Finance Minister Joe Ceci says his government's broader carbon -pricing policy is more

To avoid punishing facilities that have already made major gains in their environmental performance, there will also be a "high-performance" target that facilities can choose to compare themselves against instead. The government says facilities can opt for whichever target is "less stringent" in their own case.

Under all three policies, facilities that exceed their target have three choices: buy credits from another facility, buy carbon offsets, or pay into a government fund at the applicable carbon price (currently $30 per tonne).

That fund is then used to dole out grants that support technology and innovation aimed at reducing emissions.

But, under TIER, that's not all the money will be used for.

Deficit reduction and the 'war room'

According to the provincial budget released last week, the province expects to take in about $478 million in carbon charges from large emitters in the next fiscal year.

Of that, it plans to put $200 million toward "innovation and technology." Another $189 million is earmarked for deficit reduction and to fund the government's energy "war room," a public relations operation that aims to combat what the province describes as misinformation about the oil and gas industry.

Hastings-Simon noted the money raised under CCIR was also used for things other than emissions-reducing technology, but said "the use of funds has broadened" under TIER.

"There's nothing inherently wrong with using revenue raised from a carbon tax to do other things," she said. "Of course, the more you spend it on programs that reduce emissions, the more emissions reductions you get. And vice versa."

If Wexit were to happen, Alberta would be a world leader in greenhouse gas emissions per capita

  If Wexit were to happen, Alberta would be a world leader in greenhouse gas emissions per capita Globally, he said there is a "clear trend towards transitioning to a low carbon economy," which could spell trouble for the would-be country. "Alberta being extremely resource rich, like fossil fuels, resource rich and with a relatively small population, it makes the ratio totally out of whack," he said. "Their economy is so focused on the one resource. It's not a good position to be in when you want to be a country."Wexit is a burgeoning political movement stemming from Western Canada's dissatisfaction with the federal government.

In order to make the tax politically palatable and assist carbon heavy industries with the change, it can help Alberta implemented a tax on all types of fuel in 2017 with plans to increase the price per tonne by Here, these concerns stem from a federal plan in which big greenhouse gas emitters —such as

This is a list of sovereign states and territories by carbon dioxide emissions due to certain forms of human activity The following table lists the 1990, 2005 and 2017 annual CO 2 emissions estimates (in Megatonnes of CO 2 per year) along with a list of calculated emissions per km² (in tonnes of CO 2

And that leads to the next question: How will all this affect Alberta's greenhouse gas emissions?

Some see TIER as less effective — slightly

In a PowerPoint presentation provided to reporters Tuesday morning, the provincial government said there would be no real difference in emissions reduction once TIER replaces CCIR.

"Emissions outcomes are expected to be similar to the previous regulation," the presentation states.

Government staff reiterated that during a conference call with reporters, saying that because the per-tonne price remains the same between CCIR and TIER, the incentive for facilities to reduce their emissions also remains the same.

But an earlier version of the presentation obtained by CBC News, which includes speaking notes for the presenter, suggests otherwise.

a train on a track with smoke coming out of the water: Rather than an industry-wide standard, emissions from different oilsands facilities will be treated differently under TIER, the new carbon-pricing system for large emitters introduced by Alberta's UCP government.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Rather than an industry-wide standard, emissions from different oilsands facilities will be treated differently under TIER, the new carbon-pricing system for large emitters introduced by Alberta's UCP government.

"Emissions reductions are anticipated to be approximately five megatonnes less in 2024 under TIER than under the preceding CCIR," the speaking notes read.

A senior government official who agreed to speak to CBC News on condition that their name not be published, for the purpose of clarifying the ins and outs of this complex policy, said the difference is slight and due to a variety of factors.

"[TIER] is still getting almost the same reductions as CCIR, with considerably less cost to industry," the official said.

"Basically they're the same when it comes to the effect of the regulation. Where there's a difference is that, under the NDP, there were some other complementary measures ... and so when you added those in, that's where you get about a six megatonne difference."

Alberta's carbon tax on heavy emitters could be next bargaining chip in heated battle with Trudeau

  Alberta's carbon tax on heavy emitters could be next bargaining chip in heated battle with Trudeau OTTAWA — Proposed changes to Alberta’s carbon tax on industrial firms could become the province’s latest bargaining chip with Ottawa, amid souring relations between the two over differences in climate change policy. Environment Minister Catherine McKenna is currently reviewing a proposal by Alberta to adjust its so-called “Technology Innovation and Emissions Reduction,” or TIER, a carbon tax applied solely to heavy emitters. Alberta posted the proposed changes late October.

BC’s carbon tax is both the most comprehensive and transparent carbon tax in the Western Hemisphere, if not the world. The carbon tax does not appear to have impeded overall economic activity in British Columbia. Some politicians keep portraying it as a tax grab rather than a tax shift.

For context, six megatonnes is about 2.2 per cent of the roughly 273 megatonnes Alberta emitted in 2017.

The official also noted the broader UCP plan will have "other programs" to complement TIER, which are expected to further reduce emissions.

'Weaker signal'

The new policy has been praised by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers for recognizing the "unique circumstances" of each facility but, in the eyes of the Pembina Institute, TIER represents a step backward from CCIR.

The new regulation "sends a weaker signal for industry to reduce emissions," according to Jan Gorski, an analyst with the environmental think-tank.

"The new system is unfair and inefficient, sending skewed market signals by punishing companies with good performance and those that have already taken steps to reduce emissions while rewarding those that haven't taken steps to reduce emissions," Gorski said in a written statement.

Hastings-Simon, who used to work with Pembina, said there's a mix of pros and cons in the new regulation, if the goal is to curb Alberta's output of greenhouse gases.

"It's a change but not a complete retreat," she said. "It's not like a 180. It's a shift."

a screenshot of a cell phone: At left is a slide from PowerPoint presentation obtained by CBC News prior to the Alberta government's introduction of new carbon-pricing legislation. At right is a newer version of the presentation officially released to reporters Tuesday morning.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation At left is a slide from PowerPoint presentation obtained by CBC News prior to the Alberta government's introduction of new carbon-pricing legislation. At right is a newer version of the presentation officially released to reporters Tuesday morning.

By maintaining the industry-wide target on power plants, she said the UCP's new legislation is actually more stringent on electricity producers than even the federal backstop on large emitters would be. But, by loosening the targets for all other industries, she worries the province is sending the wrong signal — not in terms of carbon price, but overall psychology.

While she understands, in theory, that the incentive to reduce emissions remains the same if the price stays at $30 per tonne, she doesn't believe that's how things always play out in practice, especially among the heaviest emitters that face the biggest obstacles in reducing their carbon footprint.

"If you're in the business of making and selling widgets, you think about, 'OK, well, I better get down to my target so I don't have to pay a carbon price,'" she said. "But you don't necessarily then think, 'Oh, well, if I reduce my target even more, I'm going to get emissions performance credits that I can sell to somebody else.' Because that's not your your main business."

That said, the $30 price may continue to climb.

Federal rules — and uncertainty

Existing federal legislation will bump the minimum carbon price up to $40 in 2021, then $50 in 2022 — assuming nothing changes in Ottawa. But with the uncertainty of a minority Parliament, nothing is set in stone.

In their conference call with reporters Tuesday, provincial government officials admitted the door is open to future price increases under TIER, given the direction the federal government has provided so far.

Nixon, however, said he wouldn't entertain the "significantly hypothetical question" of how big a carbon price Alberta's large emitters will have to pay in 2021 and beyond.

a young man holding a microphone: Sara Hastings-Simon is a research fellow with the University of Calgary whose work focuses largely on carbon pricing.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Sara Hastings-Simon is a research fellow with the University of Calgary whose work focuses largely on carbon pricing.

"We will be having that conversation with the federal government and we will be having that conversation with industry," he said.

How high will the carbon price go in the future? That remains an open question.

What's certain, for now, is that avoiding that price — or profiting from it — is about to get easier for some of Alberta's biggest emitters.

Alberta's carbon tax on heavy emitters could be next bargaining chip in heated battle with Trudeau .
OTTAWA — Proposed changes to Alberta’s carbon tax on industrial firms could become the province’s latest bargaining chip with Ottawa, amid souring relations between the two over differences in climate change policy. Environment Minister Catherine McKenna is currently reviewing a proposal by Alberta to adjust its so-called “Technology Innovation and Emissions Reduction,” or TIER, a carbon tax applied solely to heavy emitters. Alberta posted the proposed changes late October.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!