Canada: Scheer’s TVA French debate performance was death blow for Tories in Quebec: former candidate - - PressFrom - Canada

Canada Scheer’s TVA French debate performance was death blow for Tories in Quebec: former candidate

19:07  03 november  2019
19:07  03 november  2019 Source:

Scheer's Conservatives missed scoring 'on an open net,' Peter MacKay says as leadership talk heats up

  Scheer's Conservatives missed scoring 'on an open net,' Peter MacKay says as leadership talk heats up As Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer prepares to meet with his caucus for the first time since last week's election defeat, questions are being raised about whether he should stay on to lead the party into the next election.During an event at The Canada Institute in Washington, the former long-time MP was asked for his thoughts on how the Conservatives failed to defeat Justin Trudeau's Liberals after the prime minister's public missteps, and despite deep divisions in parts of the country over the Liberal carbon tax and pipeline politics.

Andrew Scheer had a bad night in the French -language debate on Wednesday, and Tasha Kheiriddin says it showed how the COMMENTARY: Andrew Scheer ’ s Quebec conundrum and what it means for the Conservatives. The TVA French leaders’ debate has come and gone, and for once, pundits

The debate , hosted by TVA , the most watched network in Quebec , was billed as a "face-à-face" Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau presses Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer for his personal views on abortion and a woman' s right to choose during the TVA French -language leaders debate Wednesday.

a man standing in front of a microphone: Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer addresses supporters after announcement of federal election results in Regina, Sask., Oct. 21, 2019. Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer addresses supporters after announcement of federal election results in Regina, Sask., Oct. 21, 2019.

Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer's performance in the TVA French campaign debate was the death blow for his party's electoral hopes, one failed Quebec candidate and former provincial political organizer suggests.

In an interview with the West Block's Mercedes Stephenson about why Scheer failed to win over voters in Quebec — and whether he now needs to be replaced as leader — Tom Pentefountas said while the party's increase in its share of the popular vote was "phenomenal," two of the main barriers keeping the party from victory was Scheer's evasion in responding to concerns about his opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage.

Andrew Coyne: No point in Tories changing their leader if they don't change their message

  Andrew Coyne: No point in Tories changing their leader if they don't change their message Should Andrew Scheer step down as Conservative leader? Probably, but it’s beside the point. Scheer is more a symptom of the Conservatives’ malaise than a cause. The party was unable to attract the support of more than 35 per cent of voters in this election, but that has been more or less the case for most of the last 30 years, ever since the breakup of the Mulroney coalition. In three elections (1993-2000) when the right-of-centre vote was split between the Reform and Progressive Conservative parties it averaged about 37 per cent of the vote. In five elections as the Conservative party under Stephen Harper’s leadership it averaged 35 per cent.

Andrew Scheer , not Justin Trudeau, faced some of the toughest criticisms of the debate . by Steven Zhou. Leader of the Bloc Quebecois Yves-Francois Blanchet, left to right, Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer , TVA host Pierre Bruneau, Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau and NDP Leader Jagmeet

His performance on the TVA debate is unlikely to have expanded his growth potential in Quebec . It is not that the debate But Trudeau, the NDP’s Jagmeet Singh and Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet were all considered to have had a decent night, essentially at Scheer ’ s expense.

READ MORE: Scheer’s leadership at centre of tensions brewing within Conservative party

“The night of the TVA debate, that was the coup de grace for us. We continued to fight valiantly but that was a demarcation point unfortunately and after that, there was no coming back. People have no appetite for these issues," said Pentefountas, who ran for the Conservatives in Laval-Les Îles this year and was a member of the executive of Action démocratique du Québec, the former right-wing provincial political party.

He said what Scheer needed to do was assure Quebec voters he recognized a "clear delineation" between personal faith and public policy, and that his failure to do that ultimately cost him the trust of Quebeckers — something Pentefountas predicted the party will not be able to win back without a different leader.

Courts order election recounts in Quebec, B.C. ridings

  Courts order election recounts in Quebec, B.C. ridings Superior courts in B.C. and Quebec have ordered judicial recounts in two federal ridings following close races where the winning and losing candidates were separated by only a few hundred votes. Elections Canada said recounts were granted after requests from the second-place candidates in the riding of Port Moody-Coquitlam, about 25 kilometres east of Vancouver, and in the Montreal riding of Hochelaga. In Port Moody-Coquitlam, Conservative candidate Nelly Shin had 153 more votes than NDP candidate Bonita Zarrillo, according to official Elections Canada results.

Despite the mudslinging, Thursday night’ s French debate among the six leaders was a far more moderate He also brought up former Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper repeatedly Trudeau’ s plan has been a failure, Scheer said. When Trudeau accused Scheer of pledging to give

But Trudeau, Scheer and Singh all turned their sights on Blanchet as well, as all three parties are losing ground to the Bloc in Quebec . Earlier Thursday, Blanchet had to apologize for four of his candidates who have previously made comments or shared articles on social media attacking Islam.

“We need in the short term to proceed to a leadership race and have a leader in place who can speak to Canadians and evacuate these social issues first and foremost, and can speak to Canadians in both official languages."

Since losing the election two weeks ago, Scheer has been the target of attacks from party members, both anonymous and on the record, who argue his socially conservative opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage cost the party critical support in the seat-rich regions of the Greater Toronto Area and Quebec.

Because the Greater Toronto Area has so many of the seats in the House of Commons, whether a party resonates with voters there is a key determinant for whether they will be able to form government — and their share of seats in Quebec frequently determines whether a government is a minority or majority.

Scheer increased the Conservatives' share of the popular vote and brought the party from 99 to 122 seats, but failed to fulfill repeated vows to the party faithful that he would secure them a majority government.

Chris Selley: Conservatives, don't ditch Scheer just yet

  Chris Selley: Conservatives, don't ditch Scheer just yet Chris Selley: Conservatives, don't ditch Scheer just yetThere are many things for the Conservative Party of Canada to ponder in the wake of their election-night performance last week, and one of them is certainly Andrew Scheer’s leadership. It should by no means be beyond reproach. Quite apart from anything else he signed off on a dispiriting grab-bag of a platform that seemed uninterested in attracting any new Conservative voters, with the unfortunate exception of Quebec nationalists who can’t abide teachers wearing hijabs.

September 15, 2019: Andrew Scheer said he will stand by candidates despite "controversial" comments in the Doug Ford Dennis King François Legault Hazel McCallion Scott Moe John Tory . Pundits argued that Goodale was being hypocritical, due to his role with Scheer and the same-sex

Trudeau shows up but Scheer in the hot seat during French -language debate . The debate , hosted by the private TVA television network and newspaper Le Journal de Montreal, pushed This debate , which centred around issues important in Quebec , was the first involving the Bloc Quebecois leader.

READ MORE: Peter MacKay says Tories missed shot on open net in federal election campaign

Given the Liberals were carrying the weight of the SNC-Lavalin scandal and the revelation that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had repeatedly worn blackface and brownface, former Conservative cabinet minister Peter MacKay last week compared Scheer's loss to "having a breakaway on an open net and missing the net."

He also called Scheer's opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage a "stinking albatross" hung around his neck by Scheer's failure to address his views in a way that reassured voters.

Peter Van Loan, also a former Conservative cabinet minister under Stephen Harper's government, said in an interview on the West Block that Scheer's views came to dominate the campaign conversation because the party failed to put forward the kind of bold policy that would have given voters something to chew on.

“Looking back, I think where the weakness of the Conservative campaign was was the lack of a defining platform plank that could've been the ballot question," Van Loan said. "Some kind of exciting, clear, challenging issue — probably on the economic front or job creation front, taxation front — something like that that people could debate and have the election about."

He said while he felt Scheer's responses to questions on his socially conservative positions were adequate, not having a defining platform plank left space for those concerns to become prominent in the minds of voters.

"They were able to fill out that space because nothing else was doing that.”

Van Loan said, to him, the test of whether a leader can stay on after failing to win an election is whether they moved the needle forward — he says since Scheer did that, he deserves a second chance.

But he stressed the party needs to "go back to the drawing table" to come up with "bold policy steps" that can win over those critical voters in the GTA.

Pentefountas, who was appointed by Harper as vice-chairman of the CRTC in 2011, disagreed and said Scheer needs to go.

“Losing an election on things you can’t control is one thing," he said.

"Losing an election to things you can entirely control is completely unacceptable.”

Would a Quebec leader help the Greens gain a foothold in the province? .
The Greens won three seats elsewhere in Canada in October's federal election, but not a single riding in Quebec. Could having a Quebecer at the helm change that?Alex Tyrrell, the leader of Quebec's provincial Green Party, said he plans to run for the job and is expected to officially throw his hat in the ring in the coming days.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!