Canada: Calgary-area UCP MLAs say they won't support conscience rights bill - - PressFrom - Canada
  •   
  •   
  •   

Canada Calgary-area UCP MLAs say they won't support conscience rights bill

14:55  17 november  2019
14:55  17 november  2019 Source:   calgaryherald.com

Alberta Bill Many Fear Will Reopen Abortion Debate Passes 1st Vote

  Alberta Bill Many Fear Will Reopen Abortion Debate Passes 1st Vote EDMONTON — A bill that many worry will restrict Albertans’ access to abortion, LGBTQ healthcare and contraception passed the first reading in the province’s legislature Thursday. United Conservative MLA Dan Williams, who represents Peace River, introduced the Conscious Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act, which aims to assert freedom of conscience and religion for health providers. “Health care providers should never have to choose between their most deeply held beliefs and their job,” said Williams in a written statement released after the vote.

A controversial private member’s bill meant to extend protection for physicians’ conscience rights will not be supported by a pair of Calgary - area MLAs who’ve spoken out against the bill they say could do more harm than good.

A controversial private member’s bill meant to extend protection for physicians’ conscience rights will not be supported by a pair of Calgary - area MLAs , who’ve spoken out against the bill in its current form.

a man wearing a suit and tie: Airdrie-Cochrane UCP MLA Peter Guthrie. Patrick Gibson/Cochrane Times Airdrie-Cochrane UCP MLA Peter Guthrie. Patrick Gibson/Cochrane Times

A controversial private member’s bill meant to extend protection for physicians’ conscience rights will not be supported by a pair of Calgary-area MLAs, who’ve spoken out against the bill in its current form.

Introduced in the legislature by Peace River UCP backbencher Dan Williams last week, Bill 207 would prevent patients from submitting a professional complaint or suing a health care worker for failing to provide a service if medical staff objects to it. The bill would also add “conscientious beliefs” as grounds protected from discrimination in the Alberta Human Rights Act.

Braid: Bill 207 challenges abortion access based on 'conscience'

  Braid: Bill 207 challenges abortion access based on 'conscience' There seems to be an airborne virus that threatens premiers. For Jason Kenney, chartering a plane for $16,764 to fly some friendly premiers to Saskatoon is inexplicably foolish. Now, this is nothing like ex-premier Alison Redford’s “ghost riders in the sky,” the technique of booking non-existent passengers on a government plane, leaving the legroom to herself and her entourage. Air Kenney’s passengers do appear to be real rather than ghostly. The excuse — Stampede hospitality plus government business — is at least defensible.

Alberta politicians are to debate the role of conscience rights and the responsibilities of physicians United Conservative backbencher Dan Williams is to introduce Thursday a private member’s bill to Williams says his bill is meant to simply affirm Charter rights . But the Opposition NDP said the bill is

WATCH ABOVE: A UCP MLA 's bill meant to "commit health care providers'… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law," passed first reading at the Alberta legislature on Thursday. Chris Chacon reports.

Speaking to Postmedia Saturday, Airdrie-East UCP MLA Peter Guthrie and Minister of Justice and Solicitor General Doug Schweitzer, MLA for Calgary-Elbow, said they both object to the bill, which its opponents have said could further restrict patients’ access to abortions, contraception, and medical aid in dying.

“I do worry about access to health care and there’s some challenges that are going to come from this — interpretations that are going to be made,” said Guthrie. “I think we have freedom of conscience, freedom of religion already and I think that as far as our mandate to reduce red tape, this will increase red tape.

“Because of the ambiguity around it, and the nature of the bill, it has more questions that arise from it than solutions. I don’t think that this is something that’s going to help Albertans.”

Jason Kenney Still Silent On Alberta’s Controversial ‘Conscience Rights’ Bill

  Jason Kenney Still Silent On Alberta’s Controversial ‘Conscience Rights’ Bill As doctors and medical associations speak out against Alberta’s controversial conscience rights bill, which would allow doctors to refuse referrals for services they’re morally or religiously opposed to, such as abortion or assisted dying, the province’s premier remains silent. The private member’s bill introduced by United Conservative Party (UCP) MLA Dan Williams passed first reading last week, with unanimous support from they party’s MLAs in attendance for the vote. It will now move to a second reading, which involves debate in the Alberta legislature.

A UCP MLA ’s bill meant to “commit health care providers’… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law,” passed first reading at the Alberta legislature on Thursday. Chris Chacon reports.

Peace River UCP backbencher Dan Williams said his bill seeks to support existing policies in Alberta, which give physicians the ability to refuse to provide service on the Peace River UCP backbencher Dan Williams tabled Bill 207, the Conscience Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act, in the

Guthrie, who voted in favour of the bill in its first reading, defended his vote saying it was vital to actually see what the bill entailed.

“I believe that if an MLA brings forward — and this includes the opposition as an MLA — brings forward legislation they feel is important, it should get heard,” he said. “When a bill is introduced, that’s what the first reading is.

“At that point, we haven’t actually read the bill, we haven’t seen it yet. Once it’s voted upon, then we actually get the bill in hand and can read it.”

In talks with his Calgary-Elbow constituents, Schweitzer said he heard from a vocal community that opposes the bill.

“The last few weeks I’ve heard from my constituents, talking to them about different pieces of legislation that are before us in Edmonton and when it comes to Bill 207, my constituents have been clear to me that we simply cannot support this type of legislation right now in Alberta,” said Schweitzer. “In its current form, it just simply does not work.

Notley takes aim at UCP budget, Bill 207 at membership council in Edmonton

  Notley takes aim at UCP budget, Bill 207 at membership council in Edmonton Notley takes aim at UCP budget, Bill 207 at membership council in Edmonton “We’ve stood together shoulder to shoulder, fighting for what matters — good jobs, good schools, and strong public services, strong public health care, and a more fair and just society,” Notley said to the crowded room at NAIT. “And these aren’t just our values, these really are Alberta values.

A UCP MLA 's bill meant to "commit health care providers'… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law," passed This page is not available right now. This can sometimes happen if you have internet connectivity problems or are running software/plugins that

A UCP MLA 's bill meant to "commit health care providers'… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law," passed first reading at the Alberta legislature on Thursday.

“It’s controversial, it has the perceived and real potential impact on health care services against Alberta. That’s not what I campaigned on locally.”

a group of people posing for the camera:  Alberta Justice Minister Doug Schweitzer, at the lecturn, announces the government’s initial plan to combat rural crime in Alberta on Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2019, at a private ranch in Wetaskiwin County. Postmedia file© Larry Wong Alberta Justice Minister Doug Schweitzer, at the lecturn, announces the government’s initial plan to combat rural crime in Alberta on Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2019, at a private ranch in Wetaskiwin County. Postmedia file

Schweitzer said he believes the bill needs greater study.

“I really appreciate private members trying to bring forward ambitious bills and legislation, but something this comprehensive, something that impacts health care … requires study, it requires thoughtful processes,” he said.

On Friday, Premier Jason Kenney said he hadn’t read the four-page bill nor had he contemplated its implications, adding he wouldn’t say if he supported it.

Kenney also said his government will “always have free votes” on bills introduced to the legislature by individual MLAs, as compared to government bills.

On Monday, a legislative committee will consider whether all MLAs should have an opportunity to debate Bill 207 , or kill the Conscience Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act.

‘This encourages patient abandonment’: Edmontonians rally against Bill 207 at Alberta legislature

  ‘This encourages patient abandonment’: Edmontonians rally against Bill 207 at Alberta legislature The bill, which has now passed first reading, was introduced in the legislature by Peace River United Conservative Party MLA Dan Williams."It's a risky and slippery slope when you talk about providing people a right to discriminate," said Sandra Azocar, executive director of Friends of Medicare.

A UCP MLA 's bill meant to "commit health care providers'… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law," passed first reading at the Alberta legislature on Thursday.

A UCP MLA 's bill meant to "commit health care providers'… [ conscience ] rights from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in provincial law," passed This page is not available right now. This can sometimes happen if you have internet connectivity problems or are running software/plugins that

Calgary Nose Hill MP Michelle Rempel said Saturday her north Calgary office has received many phone calls about the bill.

“I have had concerns expressed into my MP office — no one wants people to not have access to health care,” said Rempel, who noted her comments were being made as a concerned citizen, with the bill being a provincial matter. “And I think there are concerns with this bill, should it be passed, that could come to pass.

“Especially people who belong to marginalized communities. I think, for me, because there’s a lot of unanswered questions with the bill, it does concern me. It’s encouraging to see provincial colleagues within the UCP such as Doug and Peter express similar concerns and expect a high degree from the bill that could have wide-ranging consequences for Albertans.”

zlaing@postmedia.com

On Twitter: @zjlaing

British Columbia becomes 1st Canadian province to pass UN Indigenous rights declaration .
The legislation passed the committee stage and third reading at the unanimously on Tuesday, to cheers and applause from MLAs on both sides of the house. Bill 41, the UNDRIP bill, has passed Third Reading, and is now "an Act." Huge applause and shouts by MLAs on ALL sides. Passed "without objection", or, in Latin "nemine contradicente". Historic moment. #bcpoli— Keith Baldrey (@keithbaldrey) November 27, 2019 READ MORE: B.C.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 0
This is interesting!