•   
  •   
  •   

Canada Sen. Mike Duffy appeals ruling blocking him from suing Senate over suspension

17:41  17 january  2020
17:41  17 january  2020 Source:   msn.com

Police officer wants compensation after being shot at with live rounds during training exercise

  Police officer wants compensation after being shot at with live rounds during training exercise A Montreal police officer was shot at by a colleague after live rounds were used in an active shooter simulation in 2014.A Quebec labour tribunal ruling on the incident suggests the SPVM may have tried to keep it under wraps.

TORONTO — Sen . Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate . He says his suspension by the Upper As a result, Duffy argues normal immunity the Senate has from legal action doesn't apply in his case. The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator

Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate . He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically As a result, Duffy argues normal immunity the Senate has from legal action doesn't apply in his case. The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator

Mike Duffy wearing a suit and tie walking on a sidewalk© Provided by The Canadian Press

TORONTO — The Senate forfeited any claim to immunity from lawsuits over its suspension of Mike Duffy, because its actions were politically motivated and unlawful, the senator's lawyer argued on Thursday.

In submissions to the Ontario Court of Appeal, Lawrence Greenspon said the decision in November 2013 to suspend Duffy without pay came at the direction of then-Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper's office.

"It's constitutionally outrageous what happened here," Greenspon said. "Our claim is that parliamentary privilege…does not extend to unlawful conduct."

Singer Meat Loaf Is Suing Hyatt Regency, Claiming Fall from Stage Left Him Hospitalized for 42 Days

  Singer Meat Loaf Is Suing Hyatt Regency, Claiming Fall from Stage Left Him Hospitalized for 42 Days Singer Meat Loaf Is Suing Hyatt Regency After Fall from StageThe incident unfolded in May 2019 when Meat Loaf, né Michael Lee Aday, was preparing to speak at a question-and-answer panel during Texas Frightmare Weekend —  an annual horror convention in Dallas, according to a complaint filed in the District Court of Tarrant County, Texas obtained by Courthouse News Service.

OTTAWA -- Sen . Mike Duffy is asking Ontario's Court of Appeal to overturn a decision blocking him from suing the Senate for millions of dollars over his dramatic and protracted suspension without pay more than five years ago. Last month, Ontario Court Justice Sally Gomery ruled the Senate 's

OTTAWA — Sen . Mike Duffy is asking Ontario’s Court of Appeal to overturn a decision blocking him from suing the Senate for millions of dollars over his dramatic and protracted suspension without pay more than five years ago.

The P.E.I. senator was ultimately acquitted in 2016 of 31 criminal charges in a ruling that slammed the conduct of Harper's office in what was one of the biggest political scandals of his government. Despite Duffy's exoneration, the Senate refused to repay the hundreds of thousands of dollars he lost in pay and pension, court heard.

Duffy now wants $7.8 million in reimbursement and damages from the Senate, RCMP and federal government. However, a lower court in December 2018 sided with the Senate that parliamentary privilege made it immune to lawsuits, prompting Duffy's appeal.

Greenspon told the three-judge panel that immunity — designed to separate parliamentary and executive powers — should not apply in this case. The Senate's actions against Duffy, he said, were carried out on behalf of what he called misconduct in the Prime Minister's Office.

Sen. Mike Duffy begins appeal of ruling blocking him from suing Senate

  Sen. Mike Duffy begins appeal of ruling blocking him from suing Senate TORONTO — Sen. Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate. He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically motivated and possibly unlawful. As a result, Duffy argues normal immunity the Senate has from legal action doesn't apply in his case. The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator without pay in November 2013 amid questions about his expenses. He was also criminally charged, but ultimately acquitted.The Senate counters that parliamentary privilege gives it the right to control its own proceedings.

OTTAWA— Sen . Mike Duffy is asking Ontario’s Court of Appeal to overturn a decision blocking him from suing the Senate for millions of dollars over his dramatic and protracted suspension Duffy is asking the appeal court to set aside Gomery’s ruling and order the Senate to cover his legal costs.

TORONTO — Sen . Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate . He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically motivated and possibly unlawful.

"The Senate bowed to the directions of the executive from which it was supposed to be independent," Greenspon said. "Unlawful conduct caused the loss. Parliamentary privilege…does not extend to unlawful conduct."

Sen. Mike Duffy appeals ruling blocking him from suing Senate over suspension

  Sen. Mike Duffy appeals ruling blocking him from suing Senate over suspension TORONTO — The Senate forfeited any claim to immunity from lawsuits over its suspension of Mike Duffy, because its actions were politically motivated and unlawful, the senator's lawyer argued on Thursday.In submissions to the Ontario Court of Appeal, Lawrence Greenspon said the decision in November 2013 to suspend Duffy without pay came at the direction of then-Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper's office.

Senator Mike Duffy is asking Ontario’s Court of Appeal to overturn a decision blocking him from suing the Senate for millions of dollars over his dramatic and protracted suspension without pay more than five years ago. Last month, Ontario Court Justice Sally Gomery ruled the Senate ’s decision to

Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate . He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically Duffy is suing the Senate and the RCMP for the way they handled accusations about his expenses. The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator

Among other things, Greenspon said Harper's office threatened Duffy that he'd be kicked out of Senate unless he admitted to inadvertently abusing his expense account and repaid the money, about $90,000. The threats, the lawyer said, amounted to extortion.

If the Senate believes its actions were proper, Greenspon said, it should defend itself in court.

"Let them call the evidence," Greenspon said. "Let them defend the propriety of their actions."

Senate lawyer Maxime Faille urged the court to dismiss the appeal. Separation of powers, he argued, is a constitutional cornerstone.

"Parliamentary privilege is one of the ways the fundamental constitutional separation of powers is respected," Faille said.

Top court's TMX decision a 'slap-down' for B.C., Alberta government says

  Top court's TMX decision a 'slap-down' for B.C., Alberta government says The Supreme Court of Canada has delivered its verdict on B.C.'s attempt to challenge the Trans Mountain expansion project — and its decision was music to the Government of Alberta's ears.The British Columbia government's appeal represented one of many legal hurdles for the delayed and embattled expansion project, and its dismissal quickly drew a positive statement from Alberta Premier Jason Kenney.

Mike Duffy has begun his appeal of a ruling that bars him from suing the Senate . He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically As a result, Duffy argues normal immunity the Senate has from legal action doesn’t apply in his case. The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator

The Senate suspended the P.E.I. senator without pay in November 2013 amid questions about his expenses. He says his suspension by the Upper Chamber was politically motivated and possibly unlawful. As a result, Duffy argues normal immunity the Senate has from legal action doesn’t apply in

Both Chief Justice George Strathy and Justice James MacPherson queried whether such privilege is absolute, even if the Senate were acting for a "corrupt purpose" as Duffy alleges.

"The action here is that the conduct of the executive branch poisons both the Senate process and the resulting decision relating to Sen. Duffy," MacPherson said. "If that's true, is there no remedy?"

Faille countered that the Senate is the "sole judge" of whether it follows its own rules. Duffy's suspension and request for reimbursement falls entirely within Senate purview, and allowing the courts to review internal Senate decisions would be an unprecedented undermining of its independence, he said.

"We are dealing with a Senate decision regarding the use of Senate resources by a senator," Faille told the panel, which also includes Justice Mahmud Jamal.

Duffy's side believes his case was given a boost by a top court ruling in the United Kingdom last fall that Prime Minister Boris Johnson had acted illegally when he prorogued the British parliament.

The U.K. decision, Faille argued, was a review of executive action — not parliamentary proceedings — something courts have done for centuries.

But Greenspon said in closing that asserting privilege if the underlying conduct is unlawful defies logic, fairness and the rule of law.

"This is an important case and we'll reserve," Strathy said.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Jan. 16, 2020.

Colin Perkel, The Canadian Press

Note to readers: This is a corrected story. A previous version said lawyer Maxime Faille acted for the government.

Vicki Gunvalson is officially leaving The Real Housewives of Orange County after 14 years .
Vicki Gunvalson is officially leaving The Real Housewives of Orange County after 14 years . Late on Friday, she took shared the news on Instagram with her followers.“I will always be the OG of the OC, but it’s time to say goodbye to The Real Housewives of Orange County,” Gunvalson wrote in the caption of photo from her early years on the series. “It’s been an incredible ride for 14 years and I want thank all of you for your support, for your love and for ‘whooping it up’ with me along the way.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!