•   
  •   
  •   

Canada Refugee adjudicator says woman’s choice to keep baby means rape never happened

15:06  11 february  2020
15:06  11 february  2020 Source:   globalnews.ca

Nikki Bella on her body changing and how she 'loves' her baby bump

  Nikki Bella on her body changing and how she 'loves' her baby bump Nikki Bella dishes on her body while pregnant with first child.The "Total Bellas" star posted several early morning videos to her Instagram Story on Friday, showing off her baby bump.

The adjudicator also said she would have expected the woman to report the rape to medical professionals and her family “if, indeed, it took place.” She also says the board must stop refugee judges relying upon myths and stereotypes, such as expecting sexual assault survivors to report their

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Gender-based violence experts are deeply disturbed by a recent decision that said a woman ' s explanation for keeping her child 'does not make sense.'

a close up of a piece of paper: Canada's Immigration and Refugee Board letterhead. Canada's Immigration and Refugee Board letterhead.

Sexual assault and gender-based violence experts say they are deeply disturbed by the recent decision of a Canadian refugee adjudicator who said it “does not make sense” that a woman would keep a child conceived by rape.

The adjudicator also said she would have expected the woman to report the rape to medical professionals and her family “if, indeed, it took place.”

READ MORE: Calls for change at refugee board after woman asked why husband didn’t ‘just kill’ her

“(I am) sensitive to the subject of rape, but the claimant’s explanation does not make sense as to why she would keep a child who would remind her of being raped, unless that is not the case,” wrote Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) adjudicator Sarwanjit Randhawa in her April 2019 decision.

Julianne Hough and Brooks Laich Spotted Together Amid Split Rumors

  Julianne Hough and Brooks Laich Spotted Together Amid Split Rumors Julianne Hough and Brooks Laich Spotted Together Amid Split RumorsThe Dancing With the Stars judge, 31, and Laich, 36, were photographed getting breakfast at Joan’s on Third cafe in Los Angeles. The pair looked casual with Hough wearing a cropped nude sweatshirt, gray sweatpants and sneakers and the hockey player sporting shorts and a Nike shirt.

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . The woman ' s lawyer says the question was an "egregious violation" of guidelines set out for cases involving allegations of sexual assault and domestic abuse.

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Global News has learned from multiple sources that a baby suffered a medical episode during the event and that due to the large number of people, it was difficult for emergency services to get to them.

During a hearing held roughly two weeks earlier, Randhawa asked the claimant if she considered having an abortion when she found out she was pregnant.

READ MORE: Refugee judge asks woman why her husband wouldn’t ‘just kill’ her

The woman said, no, it was her first child and she is against abortion. She also said she knows what it’s like to grow up without parents and that it isn’t the baby’s fault how she was conceived.

Still, Randhawa asked the woman why she chose to keep her baby.

“If you’re raped, why would you keep a child of rape?” she asked.

The Federal Court overturned Randhawa’s decision when government lawyers conceded she deprived the woman of her right to procedural fairness and natural justice.

Nneka MacGregor, executive director of Womenatthecentre, an organization that works to end gender-based violence, says she is appalled by Randhawa’s apparent lack of understanding about sexual assault, abortion access, and a woman’s right to choose.

Jameela Jamil comes out as 'queer' on Twitter

  Jameela Jamil comes out as 'queer' on Twitter Jameela Jamil said she never broadcasted her sexuality, but never hid it.The "Good Place" star took to Twitter on Wednesday to officially reveal her sexuality. The personal reveal comes after HBO Max announced that she would be involved in a "9-episode unscripted voguing competition series." The casting prompted many in the LBGTQ community to voice their displeasure, claiming that the show should be filled with members of its community.

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Gender-based violence experts are deeply disturbed by a recent decision that said a woman ' s explanation for keeping her child 'does not make sense.'

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Gender-based violence experts are deeply disturbed by a recent decision that said a woman ' s explanation for keeping her child 'does not make sense.'

READ MORE: Refugee judge who asked woman why husband didn’t ‘just kill’ her to face internal review

MacGregor is calling on the IRB to take immediate steps to stop adjudicators from re-victimizing vulnerable claimants.

“It’s offensive,” MacGregor said. “It's not anomalous, it's not one rogue judge. It's on the regular, it's enough that people should be concerned.”

‘Horrified but not surprised’

Global News has previously reported on the IRB’s mishandling of sexual assault and gender-based cases, as well as claims that the board does not do enough to discipline refugee judges when they get things wrong.

In December, IRB appeals judge Jennifer Pollock ruled that a different refugee judge breached procedural fairness and violated the board's gender guidelines by repeatedly asking a woman fleeing domestic abuse why her husband didn’t “just kill” her. The board has also launched an internal review of the case.

Moon Angell has moved out of Dog the Bounty Hunter's home

  Moon Angell has moved out of Dog the Bounty Hunter's home Moon Angell has moved out of Dog the Bounty Hunter's homeSources close to the reality star told TMZ that Moon, who moved into his home after Beth died, packed up her things and left after the two "sat down this week for a deep convo, and he thanked her for everything she's done for him" since Beth died. "Dog told Moon he's ready to move on, and she saw the writing on the wall -- time for her to move out," reports the entertainment news outlet.

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Gender-based violence experts are deeply disturbed by a recent decision that said a woman ' s explanation for keeping her child 'does not make sense.'

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . * Abortion destroys human life, it disrespects women and it destroys families. There is no way to diminish its impact or cobble it among other “pro-life” issues of our time like immigration, the death penalty, gun

READ MORE: Lawyers allege ‘sexist,’ ‘aggressive’ behaviour by powerful immigration, refugee judges

A 2018 investigation revealed allegations of “sexist” and “aggressive” behaviour by two former refugee judges, including one who demanded to see colour nude photos of a sex trafficking victim.

In response to these reports, the board said it takes allegations of wrongdoing seriously and that it investigates concerns in accordance with “fairness and due process.”

The IRB has, however, said there should be “no doubt” about the competence and professionalism of its members.

But Kaitlin Bardswich, development manager at Women's Shelters Canada, an organization that provides services to women fleeing abuse, says she has significant doubts about the competence of some refugee judges.

“Horrified but not surprised,” she said, referring to Randhawa's conduct.

Bardswich says Randhawa’s decision suggests she is ignorant of the lived experiences of sexual assault survivors, many of whom choose to keep children conceived by rape.

READ MORE: Man nicknamed ‘Dr. No’ because he denied so many refugees, rehired to decide asylum claims

A Toronto startup folded after a sexual harassment claim. This is the woman who spoke out

  A Toronto startup folded after a sexual harassment claim. This is the woman who spoke out When Planswell shut down in late 2019, CEO Eric Arnold said the "social media storm" caused by the former employee's allegations affected investor interest.Tucked in a booth, Arnold explained his position.

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . Gender-based violence experts are deeply disturbed by a recent decision that said a woman ' s explanation for keeping her child 'does not make sense.'

Refugee adjudicator says woman ’ s choice to keep baby means rape never happened . The Metropolitan Police Service in London, England, announced it will be using facial recognition cameras to help combat crime.Could something like this happen in Ontario?The London cameras, accord…

According to a 1996 study published in the American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, roughly 34,000 American women become pregnant each year after being sexually assaulted. The study showed that, on average, 32 per cent of survivors choose to keep their children, while half choose to have an abortion.

And even in the most extreme circumstances, such as the 1994 Rwandan genocide where roughly 20,000 children were conceived by rape, many victims chose to keep their children.

For a refugee judge to say a woman’s explanation for keeping a baby does not make sense is “horrifying,” Bardswich said.

“If that can happen in a genocidal situation, it can happen anywhere,” she said.

Bardswich is calling on the IRB to stop decision-makers from casting doubt on women because of how they act after being sexually assaulted. And if the board is unable or unwilling to do it, she says the government should step in.

READ MORE: Woman who says she was raped by MS-13 gang member challenges constitutionality of Canada-U.S. border deal

“It’s the government’s responsibility,” she said. “They purport to be a feminist government … I think they need to put that into action.”

“Questioning women about how or why they did something after being raped, that’s not something we should be doing.”

Report: Jake Muzzin, Maple Leafs close to four-year extension

  Report: Jake Muzzin, Maple Leafs close to four-year extension The Toronto Maple Leafs only have five defensemen on their current roster under contract for next season with Jake Muzzin and Tyson Barrie scheduled to hit unrestricted free agency on July 1. That may be changing.The Toronto Sun’s Lance Hornby writes that the Maple Leafs and Muzzin are close to agreeing to a four-year contract, with many suggesting it will be in the $5.5M range.However, that deal may have to wait before it is official.

Judges rely on ‘myths,’ stereotypes

Gillian Hnatiw, a lawyer who specializes in sexual assault law and chairs the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund, says Randhawa’s questions and ruling are “saturated with disbelief and skepticism.”

She also says the board must stop refugee judges relying upon myths and stereotypes, such as expecting sexual assault survivors to report their attacks to police, medical professionals or family members.

Other myths include thinking women commonly lie about being sexually assaulted, expecting women should leave their abusers sooner, or believing that what a woman wears can lead to her being raped, Hnatiw said.

Refugee judges also routinely focus on inconsistencies in claimants’ stories as a way of challenging their credibility. But in cases involving sexual assault or domestic abuse, the board’s guidelines say adjudicators must consider how trauma affects a woman’s ability to recount past events, specifically saying women may have trouble remembering certain details.

In this case, Randhawa questioned the claimant about alleged “differences” in her account of being attacked. At first, according to the documents, the woman said she was gang-raped. Later, when speaking to a psychiatrist, she said she was assaulted by two men.

READ MORE: Silenced by fear of deportation, why a woman who survived attempted murder is speaking out

But the alleged differences aren’t actually differences, Hnatiw said, because there’s no legal definition of the term “gang rape” in Canada.

Senators and Dylan DeMelo far apart in extension talks

  Senators and Dylan DeMelo far apart in extension talks DeMelo si looking for a sizeable salary increase while the Senators are hoping to not go too high for their tastes.The 26-year-old has been an important part of Ottawa’s back end this season, logging a career-high 19:55 per night, which is fourth among their defensemen. He also has chipped in with ten assists in 49 games while averaging nearly two hits per night. That’s a pretty good return for someone that carries a salary just $200K above the league minimum. It also has him well-positioned to land a notable raise on his next contract, especially as a right-shot defender, a spot that is often in short supply.

“It’s sadly not an uncommon thing for decision-makers in our society to allow rape myths to creep into their decisions,” she said.

“But these decisions from the IRB are, I would say, almost on a different level of disconnect from the law.”

Concerns require ‘immediate attention’

After declining to answer nearly two dozen questions about this story, IRB Chairperson Richard Wex sent a letter to refugee advocates across Canada saying the board is introducing new measures to make sure decision-making is done “efficiently, fairly, and in accordance with the law.”

This includes enhanced monitoring of refugee judges to “promote quality assurance” with how they conduct themselves during hearings, and annual, third-party reviews of the board’s refugee protection division.

Wex also said he believes the cases reported by Global News are “by no means systemic or representative in nature.” Still, he said they are concerning and that they “point to an area requiring immediate attention.”

In response to these reports, the board is imposing mandatory “refresher training” for all refugee judges, Wex said. The IRB also plans to set up a team of judges with specialized training to decide gender-based claims and to update its gender guidelines for the first time since 1996.

Wex’s letter also referenced concerns about the board’s ability to hold refugee judges accountable for their bad behaviour. He stopped short of admitting any specific problems with how the IRB disciplines judges, but said he is “personally committed” to making any changes necessary to strengthen the existing process.

But lawyers, such as Raoul Boulakia, say there’s no fixing the existing system, and that the board must implement an independent panel with the power to investigate refugee judges.

Boulakia also says training is only as good as what judges are willing to absorb.

MacGregor, meanwhile, says the board needs to rethink the way it approaches concerns over the mishandling of gender-based cases.

READ MORE: Immigration board ‘revamping’ complaint process after Global News investigation

While she doesn’t dispute Wex’s claim that the vast majority of decision-makers do their jobs well — none of the experts Global News spoke with dispute this claim — she says the board must accept that in some cases, there are adjudicators whose behaviour and decisions show they act with little to no regard for the rules.

Global News asked the IRB if anyone from the board talked with or disciplined Randhawa after her decision was reversed. The board did not answer this question, adding that it is now reviewing the matter and that it would be inappropriate to comment further.

'Today' host undergoing vocal cord surgery, out 6 weeks .
Sheinelle Jones will be on vocal rest for two weeks.Sheinelle announced the news while hosting the "3rd Hour of Today" on Thursday.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!