•   
  •   
  •   

Canada Top Canadian WHO adviser under fire after downplaying airborne threat of COVID-19

12:25  21 april  2021
12:25  21 april  2021 Source:   cbc.ca

What you need to know about COVID-19 in Ottawa on Tuesday, April 13

  What you need to know about COVID-19 in Ottawa on Tuesday, April 13 Here's CBC Ottawa's latest roundup of key updates during the coronavirus pandemic.Ontario is closing schools and moving all students to online learning amid a surge in new COVID-19 cases.

a man wearing a suit and tie: Dr. John Conly, an infectious diseases physician and professor of medicine at the University of Calgary who also advises the World Health Organization, denies that aerosol transmission is a primary route of COVID-19 transmission, despite mounting evidence to the contrary. © Jennifer Lee/CBC Dr. John Conly, an infectious diseases physician and professor of medicine at the University of Calgary who also advises the World Health Organization, denies that aerosol transmission is a primary route of COVID-19 transmission, despite mounting evidence to the contrary.

An influential Canadian doctor and top adviser to the World Health Organization has come under fire from international experts for his controversial comments downplaying the risk of airborne spread of the coronavirus.

Dr. John Conly, an infectious diseases physician and professor of medicine at the University of Calgary, not only denied that aerosol transmission is a primary route of transmission, despite mounting evidence to the contrary, but also said that N95 masks can cause "harms" — including acne.

COVID-19 live updates: Hospitalizations rise as Quebec reports 1,559 cases, 7 deaths

  COVID-19 live updates: Hospitalizations rise as Quebec reports 1,559 cases, 7 deaths Updated throughout the day on Wednesday, April 14. Questions/comments: ariga@postmedia.com Top updates Two-thirds of Quebecers think province is lifting restrictions too quickly – poll Elderly show similar antibody response to 1st dose of AstraZeneca and Pfizer shots in UK study Opinion: We should want what’s best for our children’s teachers Opposition criticizes CAQ for welcoming back MNA Denis Tardif, caught partying without respecting health directives COVID-19 cases are rising again among eldercare residents Ontario-Quebec border controls needed, Montreal public health director says Avoid Montreal’s crowded emergency wards for minor health issues, authoritie

"Any time you look at benefits, you need to look at harms, of which there are many harms with N95s — and I think to ignore them you are at your peril," Conly told a panel discussion at the University of Calgary on April 9 on the role of airborne transmission in the COVID-19 pandemic.

"There is acne, also issues with eczema, conjunctivitis, CO2 retention; there has been decreased O2 concentrations in pregnant women — many side-effects to this."

His comments on oxygen and carbon dioxide have been largely discredited, with a 2014 study in the American Journal of Infection Control showing no significant differences in levels between pregnant and non-pregnant women wearing N95 masks.

The WHO's position is there's a possibility that aerosol transmission can lead to outbreaks of COVID-19 in certain situations. A change in stance from the WHO on aerosol transmission as the main driver would have huge implications on the need for increased air ventilation and better personal protective equipment for health-care workers and essential workers around the world.

Feds to send personnel, rapid tests to Ontario as province struggles to contain COVID-19

  Feds to send personnel, rapid tests to Ontario as province struggles to contain COVID-19 The federal government is stepping in to provide more help to Ontario as COVID-19 cases soar, putting strain on the province's healthcare system.In a video posted to Twitter on Sunday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau detailed how his government would be providing additional support to Ontario.

Conly is one of Canada's most experienced infectious diseases experts who was once head of the department of medicine at the University of Calgary and the medical director for infection prevention at Alberta Health Services.

He also holds considerable global influence in the pandemic as the chair of the WHO's Infection Prevention and Control Research and Development Expert Group for COVID-19, which makes key decisions on the research that informs the WHO's recommendations.

"We absolutely know there are situational airborne settings," he added during the panel discussion. "But to be able to say that it is the only and predominant means, I think we need better scientific evidence."

Conley carries 'a lot of weight' with WHO

The WHO has been criticized in the past for its reluctance to acknowledge aerosol transmission — or microscopic airborne particles — as a primary driver of the pandemic, and experts say Conly is at the heart of the issue within the organization.

COVID-19: Science advisory group outlines suggestions for pandemic response; Ontario and Ottawa see drop in new cases

  COVID-19: Science advisory group outlines suggestions for pandemic response; Ontario and Ottawa see drop in new cases Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland seeking pharmacy appointments for AstraZeneca vaccine Province kicks off 24/7 pharmacy vaccinations in Toronto hot spots and enables walk-in vaccinations for drug stores with capacity A group of science and health experts who provide information the province uses to craft its pandemic response have released a statement outlining what will, and will not, help Ontario as it struggles with the third wave of the COVID-19 crisis.

"Frankly, I think he just can't admit he's wrong," said Linsey Marr, one of the top aerosol scientists in the world and an expert on the airborne transmission of viruses at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Va.

"He does carry a lot of weight with WHO, and unfortunately I think his thinking is still stuck in what we knew 20 or 30 years ago and hasn't updated with what we've learned since then — and especially what we've learned over the past year."

Global acknowledgement of airborne spread

The United Nations agency also came under fire in July after 239 scientists from 32 countries wrote an open letter calling on it to update its messaging on the risk of airborne transmission of the coronavirus.

The WHO amended its guidelines days after the letter and acknowledged the possibility that aerosols can lead to outbreaks of COVID-19 in places such as choir practices, restaurants and fitness classes.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) updated its guidelines in early October to include that COVID-19 can sometimes be spread by airborne transmission, after mistakenly posting and later removing a draft version of guidelines in late September.

COVID-19 live updates: Quebec reports 1,217 cases, 6 deaths as hospitalizations jump

  COVID-19 live updates: Quebec reports 1,217 cases, 6 deaths as hospitalizations jump Updated throughout the day on Wednesday, April 21. Questions/comments: ariga@postmedia.com Top updates CFL season postponed until August, league announces Quebec confirms first case of B.1617 variant, in the Haute-Mauricie region Province reports 1,217 cases, 6 deaths as hospitalizations surge Security guard abused by public, ignored by government in pandemic As minimum age drops to 45, Montrealers line up for AstraZeneca vaccine Québec solidaire wants scientific study of curfew’s benefits and drawbacks Despite lockdowns, COVID cases are rising in Quebec schools Air quality in Quebec classrooms is ‘acceptable and safe,’ Roberge says Opinion: Montrealers all over th

The CDC also updated its guidelines to say the risk of COVID-19 infection from surfaces is now officially considered low — meaning disinfecting groceries, wiping down packages and cordoning off playgrounds are likely unnecessary.

The Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) then quietly updated its guidance without notice in November, weeks after other countries and international health organizations, making mention of the risk of aerosol transmission for the first time.

PHAC went another step further and released further recommendations for Canadians on April 12 aimed at reducing the spread of aerosol transmission of COVID-19 and the need for adequate ventilation and air filtration to reduce the number of virus particles in the air.

a person holding a sign: An update to Public Health Agency of Canada guidelines on the risk of aerosol transmission came after Dr. Theresa Tam, the country's chief public health officer, recommended the use of three-layer non-medical masks in November to prevent the spread of COVID-19. © Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press An update to Public Health Agency of Canada guidelines on the risk of aerosol transmission came after Dr. Theresa Tam, the country's chief public health officer, recommended the use of three-layer non-medical masks in November to prevent the spread of COVID-19.

Science 'very strong' in favour of aerosol transmission

"The science is very strong to support aerosol transmission," said infectious diseases specialist and medical microbiologist Dr. Raymond Tellier, who is also an associate medical professor at McGill University in Montreal.

COVID-19: 'We got it wrong,' tearful Ford announces; Ontario reports 3,682 new cases

  COVID-19: 'We got it wrong,' tearful Ford announces; Ontario reports 3,682 new cases Federal government banning flights from India and Pakistan Ottawa Public Health reports 281 new cases, two new deaths Thursday. Canada hits vaccination milestone: 10.8 million doses administered; nearly 30 per cent of adults have receive at least one dose. The federal government is suspending passenger flights from Indian and Pakistan for the next 30 days amid rising COVID-19 cases in the two countries. Thursday’s announcement comes after at least 32 flights from India’s Delhi and two from Pakistan landed in Canada over the past two weeks with passengers who later tested positive for COVID-19.

"We keep having example after example, and the objections are becoming increasingly unconvincing."

After the University of Calgary panel discussion, CBC News spoke to Conly, who said he was just one voice among many at the WHO. He stressed that the way the virus transmits is "very complex" and that the "majority" of transmission occurs through "close contact."

"Social distancing, or physical distancing as some call it, and hygiene, cleaning and disinfection of surfaces. That's where our focus should be," he said. "The science about how it's transmitted and where it goes, it will get itself sorted out."

Conly was an author of a recent preprint study funded by the WHO that refuted the notion of aerosols as a primary mode of spread for the virus because "the lack of recoverable viral culture samples" from the air "prevents firm conclusions on airborne transmission."

But in response to that study, which has not yet been peer-reviewed, a group of researchers — including Canadian epidemiologist Dr. David Fisman — published a comment in The Lancet that called into question its conclusion.

The researchers present 10 reasons why they conclude the virus that causes COVID-19 is primarily transmitted through the air, including superspreading events, long-range infections, the higher risk of indoor transmission and the fact that virus particles have been detected in the air.

The paper concludes that casting doubt on airborne transmission of the virus amounts to "scientific error" and that there is "consistent, strong evidence" that it spreads via aerosols, which are "likely to be dominant" over droplet and surface transmission.

Mandryk: Moe's focus will continue to be on a big win with vaccines

  Mandryk: Moe's focus will continue to be on a big win with vaccines It’s never been right to talk about “political wins” during this COVID-19 pandemic, and it seems especially misplaced to talk about Premier Scott Moe’s political wins after the week he’s just had. Saskatchewan now has the highest per capita COVID-19 hospitalization rate in the country and record ICU numbers. So bad are things in Regina that ICU doctors pleaded with Moe and Health Minister Paul Merriman to come and see the mess for themselves — an invitation quickly rejected by reason of politicians not wanting to get in the way in crowded ICUs.

"If you don't include airborne, how are we in the middle of the global pandemic?" said Kimberly Prather, an atmospheric chemist and aerosol scientist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in San Diego, Calif.

"How do you explain outdoor versus indoor? How do you explain superspreader events? How do you explain everyone that shares the room and never touches each other or gets close to each other gets infected? I mean, you can't."

Prather, who went head-to-head with Conly at the University of Calgary panel earlier this month in favour of airborne transmission, was one of the co-authors of The Lancet comment that argued against his preprint article and a signatory of the letter to the WHO in July.

"The evidence just keeps coming in every day ... there has not been a single paper that has pointed out why it isn't aerosols," she said.

"The fact that the [WHO] is not just shouting that from the mountaintops to save lives is, quite frankly, disappointing."

a group of people walking down the street: Kimberly Prather, an atmospheric chemist and aerosol scientist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, says the evidence on aerosol transmission continues to grow and that Conly's reluctance to acknowledge it, combined with his influence at the WHO, has implications for global public health guidelines. © Ben Nelms/CBC Kimberly Prather, an atmospheric chemist and aerosol scientist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, says the evidence on aerosol transmission continues to grow and that Conly's reluctance to acknowledge it, combined with his influence at the WHO, has implications for global public health guidelines.

A recent study published by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed that a singer at a church in Australia in July was able to infect several others from a distance of more than 15 metres indoors, while a second CDC study found an infection occurred in a New Zealand quarantine hotel in September after an exposure time of less than a minute in an open doorway.

And a recent outbreak at a gym in Quebec City where physical distancing and mask use were not enforced has been linked to more than 500 COVID-19 cases and become one of the largest recorded superspreading events in Canada.

Prather said Conly's reluctance to acknowledge aerosol transmission as a main driver of the pandemic, combined with his influence at the WHO, has implications for global public health guidelines — such as for hospitals or schools.

"He has tremendous power," she said. "What else is it going to take? Because just the amount of evidence in this short of a time period is incredible."

COVID protocol-related absences: 04/25 .
Each day, the NHL will publicly release the list of players that are unavailable to their respective teams due to being in COVID-19 Protocol. Here is today’s list: Calgary – Josh Leivo Colorado – Joonas Donskoi, Mikko Rantanen New Jersey – P.K.Calgary – Josh Leivo

usr: 5
This is interesting!