Canada Leaders, health officials condemn hospital protests, call for safety zones
If you’re hoping for some TV drama, this week’s debates might deliver
Federal leaders' debates don't always deliver that history-making unforgettable zinger, but Randy Boswell thinks it could happen this time around.In 2011, it was Jack Layton turning squarely to Michael Ignatieff and tearing into the Liberal leader for having “the worst attendance record” in the House of Commons: “You know,” said the NDP leader, “most Canadians, if they don't show up for work, they don't get a promotion.
About 50 people, some with signs, protested against vaccine mandates near The Ottawa Hospital’s Civic campus Monday while hospital security officers and some concerned health workers looked on.
The protest was one of more than a dozen “silent vigils” outside hospitals across the country Monday organized by a group calling itself Canadian Frontline Nurses. The protests were widely condemned by political and health leaders.
Live updates: Leaders face off in second federal election debate in French
This is the Montreal Gazette’s live coverage of tonight’s federal leaders’ debate. Questions/comments? email@example.com Top updates: Trudeau and O’Toole neck and neck with less than two weeks left in campaign: Leger poll Welcome to our live coverage Tonight’s French debate, Thursday’s English debate pivotal for federal leaders In 2019, the Liberals narrowly outpaced the Bloc in Quebec The Greens were poised for a breakthrough in 2019. Now their woes may impact the wider election Opinion: With two weeks to go, the real campaign is beginning Opinion: No room for error in Round 2 of federal leaders’ debates Opinion: With two weeks to go, can Justin Trudeau reverse th
Along Carling Avenue across from the Civic, a counter-protester, dressed in a dinosaur costume, expressed the view of many critics with a sign that read: “This is an asinine place to protest.”
The protest was significantly smaller than one held on Sept. 1 at the Civic. Protesters stayed on the sidewalk across from the hospital and did not attempt to block traffic or harass people going in and out. Numerous cars and trucks honked their support as they drove by.
Still, one health-care worker waiting for a bus nearby said the protest was discouraging: “We still have (COVID) cases in the hospital and a lot of people who are sick.”
One protester, carrying a sign that read: “My body, my choice,” said she is a teacher and does not believe people should be forced to accept the COVID-19 vaccines in order to retain their jobs. Jennifer Cartwright said she is not alone and others like her are also opposed to mandatory vaccination but afraid to speak up.
Live updates: Leaders face off in only federal election debate in English
This is the Montreal Gazette’s live coverage of tonight’s federal leaders’ debate. Questions/comments? firstname.lastname@example.org Top updates: Ahead of debate, leaders agree on something, urge Canadians to get vaccinated Leaders arrive at debate site On Twitter, leaders focus on vaccinations, economy and getting the voting out Welcome to our live coverage Here’s the agenda for tonight’s debate Leaders gearing up for English-language debate tonight after French joust Tonight’s debate could be crucial, pollster says Too close to call – Liberals and Conservatives running neck and neck, polls suggest François Legault favours minority Conservative government Lacklustre secon
When asked why she was protesting outside a hospital, she said: “I think people have to stand for their beliefs no matter where it is.”
Kelli O’Brien, a patient at the University of Ottawa Heart Institute, showed up to support patients and health workers.
“I had a heart attack last November and I can’t imagine anybody facing a crisis like that having to be met with opposition. During the most critical time of going to the hospital they shouldn’t feel unsafe so I want them to know there is a friendly face willing to help them and also to show support for the amazing frontline workers that we have inside that building that should not have to be dealing with this during a pandemic.”
Ottawa Centre NDP MPP Joel Harden and Somerset Ward Councillor Catherine McKenney were also prepared to escort people into the hospital if they felt intimidated.
COVID-19 hospital protests ‘a morale blow’ to Canada’s exhausted health-care workers
The protests are being organized by a group called Canadian Frontline Nurses in an effort to stand up to the most recent public health measures. Read more: Warnings issued ahead of expected protests at hospitals across Canada The most controversial aspect of the new measures is a vaccine passport, which some provinces, like British Columbia and Ontario, are set to introduce, while others have a version already in operation.The protests are having an increasingly adverse effect on nurses, according to Venugopal.
In a statement, The Ottawa Hospital said protesters were putting staff, physicians and patients at risk.
“Staff and physicians at The Ottawa Hospital have worked tirelessly throughout the pandemic to protect those most at risk in our community. They all deserve to come into work safely, free from risk or harm. Those demonstrating outside of the hospital are putting not only staff and physicians at risk, but also the hundreds of patients who come to the hospital for care every day. “
Premier Doug Ford called the protests “selfish, cowardly and reckless.
“Our healthcare workers have sacrificed so much to keep us safe during this pandemic,” he said. “Leave our health care workers alone.”
Health Minister Christine Elliott also condemned the plans to protest, saying: “Peaceful protest is a right but our healthcare heroes do not deserve to be intimidated or obstructed from delivering or accessing care.”
On Sept. 1, protesters from the group slowed traffic outside hospitals across the country, including on Carling Avenue outside the Civic campus of The Ottawa Hospital.
COVID-19 live updates: Dubé wants at least 88% of eligible Quebecers double-vaccinated
Updated throughout the day on Monday, Sept. 13. Questions/comments: email@example.com Top updates Anti-vaccine protesters should steer clear of hospitals, Dubé says Hospital says protests against pandemic measures ‘demoralizing’ for health care staff Trudeau vows to make it an offence to intimidate or threaten health workers or people seeking treatment Plante denounces anti-vax protests targeting students, health workers Staff, equipment shortages at CHSLD Herron predated pandemic: former director of care Unvaccinated people are occupying ICU beds that could be used by people on surgical wait lists, Collège des médecins says Alberta man and woman charged fo
A nurse from the Civic, watching the last protest, said she found it dispiriting, calling it: “ignorant, disgraceful and disrespectful to do so in front of healthcare workers who have been taking care of the Ottawa population during the pandemic.”
On Sunday night, Premier Doug Ford called the protests “selfish, cowardly and reckless.
The RNAO, which represents Ontario’s registered nurses and the OMA which represents doctors also released a statement condemning plans to protest.\”Most people who go to hospitals go there because they have to. They are sick. They need urgent, emergency or lifesaving care. They are having cancer treatment, surgeries or diagnostic tests. Some are getting ready to give birth while many others are being treated for COVID-19.
“We respect democracy and the rights of people to protest, but these must not be held anywhere where they block entry and exit to health-care facilities, especially access to emergency vehicles or patients seeking emergency care.”
Last week, the Eastern Ontario Health Union warned that a vaccine mandate protester who attended a rally outside of the Cornwall Community Hospital on Sept. 4 had active COVID-19 and might have spread it to others.
The RNAO and OMA are calling for safe zones around hospitals and other health settings. They are also calling for charges to be laid against protesters engaging in harassment, aggression or hate speech.
Trudeau, Singh want to criminalize protests that block hospitals. But can they?
Experts agree that such a law would still abide by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms so long as only dangerous or impeding protests are outlawed.Trudeau made the promise as demonstrators gathered outside hospitals across the country to protest COVID-19 health policies, with patients and health-care workers sometimes having to be escorted through the crowd by police to protect their safety.
Ontario NDP Leader Andrea Horwath proposed such a law for hospitals and small businesses to protect they from anti-public health harassment. She is calling for a return of the Legislature to pass that legislation.
“The growing number of scary anti-public health protests targeting hospitals should be enough to get Doug Ford to come back to work and jump into action. Patients and health care heroes are being harassed. And it’s up to us to stop it, right now.”
She said a woman with cancer was verbally attacked and shouted down in front of Kingston General Hospital during a recent protest.
There have been threats of violence and threats to impede patients and ambulances, according to health advocates. Protests have also targeted small businesses, and in the case of at least two anti-vaccine protests, people with COVID-19 attended.
Her bill would make targeted harassment of people and businesses upholding public health rules in safety zones a provincial offence punishable for fines of up to $25,000.
Ottawa South Liberal MPP John Fraser also called on the Ford government to create safe zone legislation.
Fraser said the Ford government’s failure to implement province-wide vaccine mandates for health workers forced hospitals to implement their own mandates, making them the targets of protesters.
“Their beef is with us,” he said. “Protest the politicians.”
Fraser also said the Ford government’s decision to prorogue the Legislature has left it in “legislative limbo” and unable to return quickly to debate urgent pandemic issues.
The protests were a topic of conversation on the federal election campaign Monday.
During a stop in Vancouver, Liberal leader Justin Trudeau promised to criminalize those who block access to hospitals or harass health-care workers.
Health and education workers support idea of 'bubble zones' after anti-vaccine protests at schools, hospitals .
After anti-vaccine protests outside hospitals and schools in B.C. this month, representatives of hospital workers and school principals are asking for protest exclusion zones to be put in place around key institutions. Thousands protested B.C.'s vaccine card rules outside hospitals earlier this month, and some healthcare workers were allegedly assaulted. On Friday, schools in and around Salmon Arm, B.C., were put into temporary lockdown after protestors entered them, and are set to remain locked beginning Monday.