•   
  •   
  •   

Canada Trudeau, Singh want to criminalize protests that block hospitals. But can they?

07:30  14 september  2021
07:30  14 september  2021 Source:   globalnews.ca

Singh not critical of Trudeau’s handling of 2 Michaels detained in China

  Singh not critical of Trudeau’s handling of 2 Michaels detained in China Sunday marked 1,000 days of detention of the two Canadian Michaels in China.Singh made the comments during an interview with The West Block’s Mercedes Stephenson on Sunday in Quebec City, Que.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau ’s pledge on Monday to criminalize protests that block hospitals and other health-care facilities would be entirely within. Read more: ‘It’s not right’: Trudeau vows to criminalize blocking access to hospitals amid protests . NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh has similarly promised to criminalize any blockade to accessing health care, as well as any assault of health-care workers. Under the Liberal plan released Monday, new legislation would make it a criminal offence to intentionally block access to any healthcare services building, including vaccine and abortion clinics.

OTTAWA — NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says anyone planning to take part in demonstrations planned in front of hospitals today shouldn't do it and is warning of criminal sanctions in the future if his party is elected to govern. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., Singh says he would make changes to the Criminal Code to dissuade anyone from protesting close to a hospital or health-care workers. He says a federal government can't ban protests , but harsher penalties like making harassing health-care workers or services a factor in sentencing is a way to denounce such demonstrations.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau's pledge on Monday to criminalize protests that block hospitals and other health-care facilities would be entirely within the government's legal rights, expert say, with any challenges to such a law likely to fail.

a group of people riding on the back of a truck: Protesters gather at the Foothills Hospital to oppose COVID-19 related public health measures in Calgary, Alta., Monday, Sept. 13, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh © Provided by Global News Protesters gather at the Foothills Hospital to oppose COVID-19 related public health measures in Calgary, Alta., Monday, Sept. 13, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh

Trudeau made the promise as demonstrators gathered outside hospitals across the country to protest COVID-19 health policies, with patients and health-care workers sometimes having to be escorted through the crowd by police to protect their safety.

The richest TV stars in the world

  The richest TV stars in the world Check out the biggest earners and the world’s highest paid television personalities.

The federal New Democrats and Liberals made mirror pledges on Monday to criminalize protesters that block hospitals or harass health-care workers as party leaders denounced planned demonstrations at hospitals nationwide. Provincial and local politicians warned anyone showing up to not block hospital entrances, adding that police were ready to maintain access for patients, doctors and nurses if necessary. Election Dispatch: Sign up for a daily update on the campaign. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said a federal government can't ban protests , nor

The federal New Democrats and Liberals made mirror pledges on Monday to criminalize protesters that block hospitals or harass health-care workers as party leaders denounced planned demonstrations at hospitals nationwide. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said a federal government can't ban protests , nor can it limit where people can demonstrate like provinces such as Ontario have done with bubbles around abortion clinics and farms. But Singh pointed to the Criminal Code as a means to dissuade such demonstrations from happening.

Constitutional law experts agree that such a law would still abide by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms — provided it doesn't go further than protecting access to health care, which remains an essential service.

"A blanket ban on protests would be difficult to defend in court," said Joel Bakan, a professor in the Peter Allard School of Law at the University of British Columbia.

"But I think a narrower ban that ensured that protests were not interfering with patients trying to access hospitals and doctors and ambulances and whatnot would almost surely be upheld."

Read more: ‘It’s not right’: Trudeau vows to criminalize blocking access to hospitals amid protests

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh has similarly promised to criminalize any blockade to accessing health care, as well as any assault of health-care workers.

COVID-19 hospital protests ‘a morale blow’ to Canada’s exhausted health-care workers

  COVID-19 hospital protests ‘a morale blow’ to Canada’s exhausted health-care workers The protests are being organized by a group called Canadian Frontline Nurses in an effort to stand up to the most recent public health measures. Read more: Warnings issued ahead of expected protests at hospitals across Canada The most controversial aspect of the new measures is a vaccine passport, which some provinces, like British Columbia and Ontario, are set to introduce, while others have a version already in operation.The protests are having an increasingly adverse effect on nurses, according to Venugopal.

OTTAWA — The federal New Democrats and Liberals made mirror pledges on Monday to criminalize protesters that block hospitals or harass health-care workers as party leaders denounced planned demonstrations at hospitals nationwide. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said a federal government can't ban protests , nor can it limit where people can demonstrate like provinces such as Ontario have done with bubbles around abortion clinics and farms. But Singh pointed to the Criminal Code as a means to dissuade such demonstrations from happening.

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh condemned on Monday the planned demonstrations outside of hospitals across Canada stating it is “wrong” and “not a place to protest .” He added that no one should have a barrier from accessing health care.

Under the Liberal plan released Monday, new legislation would make it a criminal offence to intentionally block access to any healthcare services building, including vaccine and abortion clinics. Intentionally intimidating or threatening a health-care worker would also become a criminal offence.

Bakken and other experts explained that while Section 2B of the Charter allows freedom of speech and expression, Section 1 allow for "reasonable limits" on those freedoms — and blocking hospitals would not qualify for an exemption.

Clare McGovern, a political science lecturer at Simon Fraser University, says a law based on the Liberal and NDP promises would "absolutely" be challenged, but cited Section 1 as the main reason why any challenges would likely be dismissed.

"These protesters would already be on shaky ground if they tried to argue their freedom of peaceful expression is being threatened, because much of what we've been seeing has not been that," she said.

Trudeau, Singh want to criminalize protests that block hospitals. But can they?

  Trudeau, Singh want to criminalize protests that block hospitals. But can they? ET spoke with Gabrielle about the inspiration behind her gown as she arrived at the 2021 Met Gala in New York City.

OTTAWA — The federal New Democrats and Liberals made mirror pledges on Monday to criminalize protesters that block hospitals or harass health-care workers as party leaders denounced planned demonstrations at hospitals nationwide. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said a federal government can't ban protests , nor can it limit where people can demonstrate like provinces such as Ontario have done with bubbles around abortion clinics and farms. But Singh pointed to the Criminal Code as a means to dissuade such demonstrations from happening.

OTTAWA — A series of planned protests at hospitals nationwide against pandemic-related restrictions is being roundly denounced by federal party leaders, with NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh vowing criminal sanctions to dissuade similar gatherings in the future if his party is elected to govern. Provincial and local politicians have warned anyone showing up to not block anyone from entering hospitals , adding that police are ready to maintain access for patients, doctors and nurses if necessary. Speaking in Sioux Lookout, Ont., Singh said he would make changes to the Criminal Code to dissuade anyone

"But even if the court said 'okay, your freedom of expression is being infringed,' they would ask the government if they are justified in this law. And I think the government would be on solid ground, because they would say they're protecting access to health care. And courts are already very sympathetic to that cause."

Video: Liberals pledge to outlaw blocking access to health-care facilities

Many experts cited the "buffer zone" laws around abortion clinics passed in the 1990s by some provinces and cities, including in British Columbia and Ontario, that could provide legal precedent or a roadmap for writing the new federal law.

Such laws, which were passed in response to protests and so-called "sidewalk counselling" of abortion patients, have been upheld in court despite repeated legal challenges. Even when B.C.'s provision on sidewalk counselling was repealed, it was reinstated on appeal months later.

SFU criminology professor Colton Fehr points out that in the case of hospitals, as it was with abortion clinics, the point is to reinforce that the right to public safety supersedes one's right to protest.

Rihanna Casually Wears Over 267 Carats of Diamonds to Complement Her Parka Couture

  Rihanna Casually Wears Over 267 Carats of Diamonds to Complement Her Parka Couture Bold and beautiful: stars stun as they arrive at the Met Gala

"Whether or not you agree with someone's objectives when they protest, the whole idea of protesting is just as fundamental to a democratic society," he said.

"But at the same time, certain protests can have extremely damaging effects. And I think you've seen that with some of these protests that we're seeing at hospitals today."

Video: Protests against pandemic protocols, vaccine passports held at Canadian hospitals

As for criminalizing the threatening of health-care workers, Section 423 of the Criminal Code already contains provisions against harassment and threats that were originally put in place to criminalize stalking.

While that could also apply to health-care workers, experts say having specific language in place helps further protect certain people and actions — and looks good politically for whoever introduces such new laws.

"We're in the middle of an election ... and you don't get votes by saying, 'Well, the Criminal Code already covers that issue,'" said Margot Young, a professor at the University of British Columbia's Peter Allard School of Law.

"You get votes by saying, 'We appreciate this harm and we're going to give it specific, focused attention.' And it seems to me that's what he's doing now."

Young also pointed to the enhanced security laws passed in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks in the United States: although airport and border security had already been legislated, the new laws spoke to "the politics of the time."

NDP leader Jagmeet Singh promises cap on cellphone bills during Windsor stop

  NDP leader Jagmeet Singh promises cap on cellphone bills during Windsor stop Federal NDP leader Jagmeet Singh returned to Windsor Tuesday night repeating a promise to cap cellphone bills, bring in universal pharmacare, make housing more affordable and tax the super rich with “unlimited zeal.” “There are some people out there we think should start paying their fair share,” Singh told a crowd of supporters at Gateway Aviation Windsor. “People keep on telling me it’s getting harder and harder with the cost of living.” Singh’s campaign bus rolled up to Windsor’s Gateway Aviation Windsor shortly after 8 p.m. This was his third campaign visit to Windsor.

In this case, she said a new law could help direct rallies to "more appropriate" sites like outside federal government buildings or constituency offices, where protesters could take their message directly to policymakers.

Read more: COVID-19 hospital protests ‘a morale blow’ to Canada’s exhausted health-care workers

Some health-care workers on Monday, exhausted after 18 months of working on the front lines of the pandemic, called the protests “a morale blow” and “frankly disgusting.”

Constitutional law experts agreed, with Bakan from UBC saying it was "abhorrent" that patients and health-care workers feared for their safety.

Even if the motivation for Trudeau and Singh is political, Young said their pledges to crack down through legislation makes sense.

"(Trudeau) is very directly responding to a lot of voters who are fed up with the images of ambulances not being able to get through to hospitals, and are generally fed up with what they understand to be just selfish, entitled behaviour on the part of those who are opposed to vaccination," Young said.

"That being said, we don't know yet if the legislation we're proposing will address this properly or go too far. We don't have any details. And the constitutionality is in those details."

Canadians head to the polls as political wildcards leave election outcome up in the air .
Canadians head to the polls today for the final day of voting in this 44th general election and surveys suggest the result is far from certain with as many as six parties in contention for seats in Parliament. More than 5.8 million Canadians have already voted in the advance polls, and Elections Canada has received nearly one million special ballots — a record-setting early turnout that suggests there's an energized electorate. Poll workers will start the vote count tonight, but the outcome may not be known until tomorrow after the many mail-in ballots are verified at hundreds of returning offices nationwide.

usr: 3
This is interesting!