Canada 'He said, she said': Sex and sensitivity raised in complaints about doctors

18:40  10 february  2018
18:40  10 february  2018 Source:   cbc.ca

Police say they will enforce protest-free buffer zones around abortion clinic

  Police say they will enforce protest-free buffer zones around abortion clinic A block from Parliament Hill, Ottawa’s Morgentaler abortion clinic is bracing for harassment of its staff and patients in spite of an Ontario law creating a 50-metre protest-free buffer zone around clinics that takes effect Thursday. The province’s Safe Access to Abortion Services Act comes into force Feb. 1, almost 30 years to the day after the Supreme Court of Canada acquitted Dr. Henry Morgentaler and struck down the criminal restrictions on abortion services as unconstitutional.

'He said, she said': Sex and sensitivity raised in complaints about doctors© (Yannis Behrakis/Reuters) 'He said, she said': Sex and sensitivity raised in complaints about doctors

In one complaint, a female physician accuses one of the three male doctors she shares a clinic with of playing loud music and whistling while she's trying to consult with patients.

In another, an admittedly modest female patient accuses a male cardiologist of insensitivity after he comments on a necklace hanging between her bare breasts as she sits topless for an exam.

In the first complaint, the female doctor accuses her colleague of misogyny. And in the second, the female patient —a "well-educated business executive" — claims the experience left her feeling "stupid and unintelligent."

'He violated me,' retired officer says of RCMP doctor in Halifax

  'He violated me,' retired officer says of RCMP doctor in Halifax 'He violated me,' retired officer says of RCMP doctor in HalifaxBut the woman, now retired and in her 50s, said that dream turned sour from the start when she went to a medical office in Halifax in the late 1980s for a required physical exam as part of her application process.

'It is the reality'

Both are files recently heard by B.C.'s Health Professions Review Board, which acts as a kind of appeal body for people unhappy with the decisions of medical profession regulatory boards.

They are separate cases, but combined represent a snapshot of a profession that, like many others, is being forced to grapple with larger attitudes about sex and sensitivity.

"Much as I would like to think that we as physicians are held to and hold ourselves to a higher standard, alas, we are part of society and the things that happen in other areas of society happen in medicine as well," says Susan Phillips, Queen's University professor in family medicine and public health services with an expertise in gender studies.

"So if there are pockets of sexism or bullying found elsewhere they're going to be found in medicine too. I don't think this is rampant ... but it is the reality."

Liberal candidate reprimanded by law society

  Liberal candidate reprimanded by law society A Toronto-area provincial Liberal candidate — and daughter of the riding’s federal MP — was disciplined by the law society for professional misconduct after more than 150 complaints of “harassing and threatening” behaviour by her staff in their work for collection agencies.Deanna Sgro, the candidate for Humber River-Black Creek, was reprimanded in 2013 for professional misconduct for not properly overseeing her staff to the “standards of a professional law office.”A tribunal of the Law Society of Upper Canada said the sheer number of complaints was significantly higher than other lawyers, and that the aggressive phone calls and other tactics by Sgro’s staff were “ab

'Superiority due to his maleness'

Both the complaint from the female doctor and the complaint from the female patient were initially dismissed by B.C.'s College of Physicians and Surgeons. The Health Professions Review Board is tasked with deciding if the decisions were reasonable given the range of possible outcomes.

Their decisions, while made public, are anonymous.

In the case of the whistling, music-playing colleague, the female doctor said she asked him to either tone it down or close his door; he did neither.

She accused him of having "a problem with women or a sense of superiority due to his maleness."

The board said the matter basically amounted to a "he said, she said" situation, right down to their colleagues: "one offered a statement that was critical of the registrant and the other was largely supportive."

The college chose not to criticize the male doctor, instead sending "strongly worded correspondence insisting" they resolve their differences in a professional manner.

Montreal doctor fined for 'gifts' to gynecologists who referred patients

  Montreal doctor fined for 'gifts' to gynecologists who referred patients Hing-Sang Hum has been fined $27,500 for giving almost $36,000 to three gynecologists who referred patients to his clinic.A Montreal doctor has been fined $27,500 in a case involving gynecologists who referred patients to his ultrasound clinic.

The review board found that decision fell within the acceptable range of outcomes.

"The fact that the complainant does not agree with the outcome does not make the disposition unreasonable," the board noted.

'Private when it comes to my body'

In the case of the cardiology patient, the board found the college had failed to address the central elements of the case: complaints the doctor hadn't adequately explained the scope of an exam that would see the patient sit topless in his office for a considerable amount of time and her discomfort over the comment about her necklace.

"I have never liked going to the doctor and it is because I am very private when it comes to my body. The only man who has ever seen me exposed was my husband," the woman wrote.

"I prided myself on that, as did my husband, but that was taken away from us when [the doctor] chose to perform a redundant test while leaving me exposed the entire time for no reason I can think of other than to 'have a look' for his own self-gratification."

For his part, the cardiologist, who has 30 years experience, responded by saying he was "deeply dismayed" by the complaint and is sensitive to any verbal or non-verbal cues of discomfort and would have asked the husband to accompany his wife had he asked.

Wynne sticks by candidate disciplined by law society over harassment complaints

  Wynne sticks by candidate disciplined by law society over harassment complaints Premier Kathleen Wynne is defending a controversial Liberal candidate who was reprimanded by the law society after 155 complaints of harassment and intimidation against staff at her firm.“We were very aware of the situation,” Wynne told reporters after making an announcement to expand the emergency department at Scarborough’s Centenary hospital. “We have a very strict vetting process in place and my understanding is that she has gone through a process with the law society. “There have been apologies and she has complied with all of the requirements with the law society.

"I usually chat with the patient about anything (their work, their necklace, their grandchildren, or anything else that comes to mind) in order to try to put them at ease," the doctor wrote.

"I take great pride in my 'bedside manner' and in being as affable and caring as possible."

The woman's husband countered by saying "there is a difference between chatting about the weather ... and inquiring about a piece of [jewelry] lying between the exposed breasts of your brand new topless patient."

The board said the college had "side-stepped" the woman's allegation that the statements were inappropriate according to guidelines that state that physicians "should be careful to ensure that any remarks or questions that are asked cannot be construed as demeaning, seductive or sexual in nature."

The college's inquiry committee must now reconsider the matter and issue a new finding that incorporates that criticism.

The review board's decision says that might cost money but "the key issues that were not addressed in the inquiry committee's decision are of sufficient concern to the complainant, the patient and to the public interest that these expenditures are warranted."

'This obviously struck a chord'

Phillips wouldn't comment on the specifics of either of the B.C. cases, but said they dovetail with research she's been conducting that suggests that decades after concerns were first widely raised about sexual harassment of female doctors, the issue is still very much a concern.

In 1993, she made international headlines with a study that revealed that nearly three quarters of female doctors responded to as survey that said they had been sexually harassed by patients.

She is now part of a group looking at sexual harassment among medical students. She says their preliminary findings suggest the problem continues particularly among female students from peers, patients and teachers.

"They wrote a lot and they thanked us for asking about this," she says. "But this obviously struck a chord with them."

Phillips says they hope to publish the research soon.

Throat sensor helps you recover from a stroke .
It can track speech and swallowing cues that reflect your progress.The sensor is not only more accurate than a mic, but considerably more comfortable and durable. A set of "novel materials" help it bend and stretch so that it's not irritating your throat or breaking under stress. Doctors can see how you speak and swallow in real life, not just in the controlled conditions of a hospital room.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!