Money What it would mean for pensioners if Kenney creates an Alberta pension plan
The anger is real, but is western separatism?
Since last week's federal election returned Justin Trudeau's Liberals to power, with no seats in Alberta and Saskatchewan, the anger in Alberta seems to have intensified. Western separatism is again being bandied about. It may not be even be at the tepid levels of support that it had in the early '80s, but it's not just relegated to the fringes of the fringes of the internet these days.
Naturally, some questions arise whenever anyone floats the possibility of transferring billions of public dollars from one fund manager to another.
Speaking Saturday during a keynote address to close the Manning Conference in Red Deer, Alberta, Premier Jason Kenney laid out measures that will be explored as part of what's being called the Fair Deal Panel.
He announced initiatives that include creating a provincial police force, establishing a formal provincial constitution and opting out of federal cost-sharing programs.
The panel will also study the possibility of withdrawing from the Canadian Pension Plan (CPP) in favour of an Alberta-based alternative.
Pension and severance payments released for Canada's defeated or retired MPs
Pension and severance payments released for Canada's defeated or retired MPs Eleven of the 94 MPs leaving are from B.C.
That squares with previous comments Kenney has made on pensions, including during a Facebook livestream a little more than a week ago. In that stream, he said he believed a "compelling case" could be made to withdraw from the CPP.
So were an Alberta pension plan to be implemented, how would a fund transfer take place? Who would manage and invest those funds? And why now?
How would it work?
The short answer is: it's unclear.
Alberta pensioners have been paying into CPP since it was established in 1965 by Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson. The CPP fund has $400.6 billion in assets as of June 30 — money that has been partly contributed by Albertans.
Economist Trevor Tombe said there's no precedent for what has been proposed by Kenney.
"For Alberta to withdraw from the CPP would be a phenomenally complex undertaking, because you'd have to figure out what share of the fund is transferred to the Alberta fund," Tombe said. "How would people's CPP contributions and benefits they've already earned, how would that translate into an Alberta system?"
Opinion | Jabs between Kenney and Notley reach new level of ridiculousness
Opinion | Jabs between Kenney and Notley reach new level of ridiculousnessJust when you thought Alberta politics couldn't get any more divisive or combative or just plain ridiculous, you get Thursday morning's legislative committee meeting where NDP leader Rachel Notley butted heads with Premier Jason Kenney.
It's possible that the Alberta government could set up a parallel pension system to the CPP and gradually phase out of one and into another, Tombe said.
"But it would be phenomenally complex [to set up]. And I'm not sure what it would achieve," he said.
In a scenario where the Alberta government was able to transfer the billions in dollars in Alberta pensions to a local authority, those funds would, in all likelihood, be managed by the Alberta Investment Management Corp., or AIMCo.
Who would manage the funds?
AIMCo is a Crown corporation, meaning it is owned by the provincial government.
The corporation already manages $100 billion in government pensions and other funds, and approximately $17 billion in assets as part of the Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund.
According to the corporation's mandate and roles document, it operates at arms-length from the government but there is "broad cooperation and collaboration between AIMCo and the Government of Alberta."
Kelly McParland: It took decades to push Alberta to this point — but it was inevitable
The combative address Jason Kenney delivered in Red Deer on Saturday didn’t come out of the blue. This is a storm cloud that’s been hovering around Alberta for a very long time. Eventually it was going to erupt. There have been plenty of precursors. From Pierre Trudeau’s first lunge at Alberta’s oil wealth almost 40 years ago via the National Energy Program, Albertans have kept a wary eye on Ottawa and its grabby revenue fingers. The distrust was there in Preston Manning’s creation of the Reform Party; again in the 2001 “firewall” letter signed by Stephen Harper and others; in “the West wants in” movement and in Rachel Notley’s discovery that electing a New Democrat premier
Bryce Tingle, a regulatory lawyer and professor at the University of Calgary, said keeping the relationship arms-length was important for a number of reasons.
You don't want public money used to reward friends of the politicians or powerful constituencies. - Bryce Tingle, University of Calgary professor
"It's good because you want your money to be managed by professionals. You don't want politicians, who typically don't have very much training in investment selection, stock picking and trading strategies, to be in charge of banking investments," Tingle said. "You also don't want public money used to reward friends of the politicians or powerful constituencies."
Though the government wrote in its budget it planned to build up a "made in Alberta" portfolio through AIMCo, a spokesperson said that didn't mean the corporation would be pressured to use the funds to support provincial initiatives.
"The 'made in Alberta' strategy referenced in the budget document ensures that AIMCo retains its position as a leader of investment management services in Western Canada by further solidifying its role and increasing its assets under management," said Jerrica Goodwin with Alberta's Treasury Board and Finance in a written statement. "The 'made in Alberta' phrasing is not a reference to a change in the way that AIMCo invests their client's money."
Braid: Despite attacks, Kenney's ideas aren't separatist or dangerous
Premier Jason Kenney and hockey crank Don Cherry went off at nearly the same moment Saturday. Premier Jason Kenney and hockey crank Don Cherry went off at nearly the same moment Saturday.
Were AIMCo to use pension funds to invest in Alberta-based companies and economies that move would likely backfire, Tingle said.
"If AIMCo was to invest preferentially in, let's say oil and gas, and it was underperforming the rest of the market, so AIMCo reported steady subpar returns, that would eventually become a political football," Tingle said. "Because that pension money is what Albertans depend on to live on when they stop working."
We have full investment discretion over what kinds of investments we make and they need to maximize net investment returns for our clients. - Denes Nemeth, director of communications with AIMCo
Denes Nemeth, director of communications with AIMCo, said the organization would not respond to influence from the provincial government.
"[If] any provincial government directed AIMCo to manage a specific company, a specific asset, a specific type of infrastructure, absolutely not," he said. "We have full investment discretion over what kinds of investments we make and they need to maximize net investment returns for our clients."
AIMCo funds achieved a net return of 2.3 per cent in 2018, down from 9.3 per cent a year prior.
A CBC News investigation published in July revealed AIMCo had shares worth a total of about $4.8 million as of March 31, in both GEO Group and CoreCivic, two companies linked to for-profit prison companies, including one linked to controversial migrant detention centres in the United States.
AIMCo confirmed the corporation no longer owned shares in those companies.
Discussion around an Alberta pension plan can be traced back to the "firewall letter," penned by a number of prominent conservative figures, but it has largely fallen off the radar over the past two decades.
But in a time of continued western alienation, Tingle said it could be part of a larger bargaining chip with Ottawa.
"As far as I can see, the threat to withdraw from CPP is actually the most credible tool the provincial government has in its quiver to bring people to the table and negotiate on the things Alberta cares about," he said.
For Tombe, the panel has its work cut out for it, with no obvious first step forward.
"It would be very complex, and there currently does not exist details or credible analysis on how to do it," he said. "So at the moment, it's just a talking point."
John Ivison: Jason Kenney needs to play it cool to deal with Wexit heat .
What we’ve got here is a failure to communicate. Eastern Liberals like Kathleen Wynne on CTV’s Question Period spent the weekend accusing Alberta Premier Jason Kenney of “fanning the flames” of Western separatism. Those closer to the action could only shake their heads and point out that Kenney is Canada’s best hope for taking the sting out of a Wexit movement that is becoming ever more venomous. Sources close to Kenney note his frustration that he is being denounced as perfidious by people who should know better.
Kenney slams Trudeau immigration plan
Conservative Jason Kenney defends his party's record and slams Liberal leader Justin Trudeau for his proposed changes to the immigration system.
Canada Election 2019 Leaders' Debate
Hear directly from the party leaders seeking your vote in the 2019 Canada election. Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau, Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer, NDP ...