•   
  •   
  •   

Technology Why Big Oil faces court cases that echo the litigation against Big Tobacco in the '90s

12:15  24 october  2019
12:15  24 october  2019 Source:   cbc.ca

12 Hilarious Questions Young People Have About the ’90s

12 Hilarious Questions Young People Have About the ’90s Young Twitter users are asking questions about the '90s, proving they definitely don't understand how anyone survived before the smartphone.

It's been called Big Oil 's " Big Tobacco " moment, echoing the famous litigation that exposed how tobacco companies deliberately generated scientific After years of pretrial wrangling, the first Big Oil case began in civil court in New York on Tuesday. Lawyers for Exxon Mobil face accusations from

It's been called Big Oil 's " Big Tobacco " moment, echoing the famous litigation that exposed how tobacco companies deliberately generated scientific uncertainty even though they knew that cigarettes cause cancer. "They are brought under very similar legal theory," said Ann Carlson

a tower with smoke coming out of it: The oil industry is facing a series of legal cases that are expected to examine what companies knew about the potential impact of climate change, when they knew it, and what they did with that information. © Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation The oil industry is facing a series of legal cases that are expected to examine what companies knew about the potential impact of climate change, when they knew it, and what they did with that information. How much did the oil industry know about the impact of fossil fuel emissions on the climate? When did they know it? And what did they do with that knowledge?

Those are the central questions in a series of court cases attempting to hold companies accountable for their role in climate change.

It's been called Big Oil's "Big Tobacco" moment, echoing the famous litigation that exposed how tobacco companies deliberately generated scientific uncertainty even though they knew that cigarettes cause cancer.

US Open: Why can't Serena Williams win historic 24th Grand Slam?

US Open: Why can't Serena Williams win historic 24th Grand Slam? Serena Williams missed another chance for her 24th Grand Slam title, losing her fourth final in a row. At 38, is she longer capable of a major win?

For all the skeletons we have already found in big oil ’s closet, however, we are still only looking through the keyhole. Tracking down a few hundred documents has allowed us to uncover some key cogs in the climate denial machine. Yet it is a sprawling, well-funded, well- oiled network that stretches far beyond

In Australia, this is now literally the case .Wildfires there have been raging for more than a month and Key breakthroughs in tobacco control came as congressional investigations – as well as legal Federal charges were brought against Kraft, 24 other men, and employees at Orchids of Asia Day

"They are brought under very similar legal theory," said Ann Carlson, an environmental law professor at the UCLA School of Law. "That is that the companies are creating a public harm or public nuisance by misleading the public about whether their product actually causes harm."

After years of pretrial wrangling, the first Big Oil case began in civil court in New York on Tuesday. Lawyers for Exxon Mobil face accusations from the state's attorney general that the company misled shareholders about how it was calculating the cost of future government policies to limit carbon emissions.

Exxon Mobil has publicly denied the allegations.

"The New York attorney general's allegations are false," Exxon Mobil spokesperson Steven Soper told CBC News in an email. "We tell investors through regular disclosures how the company accounts for risks associated with climate change. We are confident in the facts and look forward to seeing our company exonerated in court."

Why the Saudi oil attack is a ‘big deal’ that could be a ‘game changer’ in stock markets and crude prices

Why the Saudi oil attack is a ‘big deal’ that could be a ‘game changer’ in stock markets and crude prices An intensifying Middle East conflict is threatening to throw the world’s energy market into disarray after a weekend drone attack destroyed parts of Saudi Aramco’s Abqaiq plant — one of the world’s largest processors of oil.

Just as the case against Big Tobacco went, the case against vaping companies will ultimately boil down to how much was known internally about the As Juul echoed in the House hearing, the FDA’s own position on nicotine is that nicotine “does not directly cause the estimated 480,000 deaths each

Fossil-fuel firms are among the biggest donors to the defeated US president and the Republican party leaders who have endorsed his legal challenge to overturn The tighter they bind, the more powerful they become. This is the alliance that pushed Biden to victory. In the future it is likely to strengthen as

Meanwhile, a similar investor case is being investigated by the attorney general of Massachusetts.

There are more than a dozen other lawsuits in the U.S. against the industry at various stages in the legal process. Those cases have been launched by municipal and state governments, including New York City, Baltimore, San Francisco and Rhode Island, all attempting to hold oil companies accountable for climate-related damages.

The details of the cases differ, but they share a common thread.

"They are based on allegations that the oil companies engaged in systematic misrepresentation of information, [that they] kept sort of one set of information internally and then told the public something else," said Carlson.

In Rhode Island's complaint against nearly two dozen energy companies, the state describes "a co-ordinated, multi-front effort" by the industry "to conceal and deny their own knowledge of those threats." It alleges the companies "have known for decades that those impacts could be catastrophic and that only a narrow window existed to take action before the consequences would be irreversible."

Inside the vaping crisis that has hooked—and killed—young people

  Inside the vaping crisis that has hooked—and killed—young people Vapes were said to be a powerful tool in the global effort to get people off smoking, and maybe off nicotine, too. What went wrong? First, the catastrophic health effects of vaping are now becoming frighteningly apparent. Second, it’s become clear that vaping has a devoted, often addicted, youth market.“For a lot of people, it’s astonishing,” says Elizabeth Saewyc, a professor of nursing at the University of British Columbia and research director of B.C.’s most recent adolescent health survey.

As it turns out, it was Big Tobacco who lifted their playbook from Big Oil ! to hide behind constitutional First Amendment protections for fraudulent practices (a tactic which failed when Big Tobacco used a similar defense during litigation in the 80s and 90 s .)

Dr. Franklin T. Wilson. 25 October 2019 ·. ‪ Why Big Oil faces court cases that echo the litigation against Big Tobacco in the ' 90 s https environmental activist Great Thunberg’s surprise appearance at a Friday climate strike in Iowa City on its social media channels, according to a report in the Gazette.

Canadian cities considering climate litigation

In Canada, there are similar legal rumblings against the industry.

Toronto city council has referred a notice of motion to staff to research "the long-term cost implications of climate change to City of Toronto's infrastructure and programs." Staff are also instructed to examine "any legal avenues to pursue compensation for these costs from major greenhouse gas emitters."

Victoria is currently getting a legal opinion, which will be offered free to other cities.

And more than a dozen B.C. municipalities have sent a letter asking various oil companies to pay their share of climate-mitigation costs.

Andrew Gage is with West Coast Environmental Law group in Victoria, which is urging municipalities to launch court cases against the industry to try to recover damages from sea-level rise and other climate-related impacts.

"Municipalities can't afford to not try to clarify the legal obligations of these companies," he said. "What we've suggested is the local governments in B.C. need to be looking at a class action lawsuit that would allow a number of communities to pool their resources and work together to hold these really large global companies accountable."

Can the courts legislate action on climate change?

  Can the courts legislate action on climate change? Canadian youth have filed a lawsuit against the government for violating their rights to security and equality. It is one of nearly 1,400 climate lawsuits worldwide.The lawsuit alleges that the government has violated the youths’ rights to life, liberty and security of the person under Section 7 of the Charter by failing to protect essential public trust resources like air and water. It also alleges that the government has violated the youths’ right to equality under Section 15 of the Charter, since youth are disproportionately affected by the effects of climate change, and it asks the government to prepare a plan to get off fossil fuels.

What Big Oil knew and when

The essential argument for most of the lawsuits is that the oil industry knew that its products were affecting the climate, but instead of alerting the public and changing their business model, companies deliberately promoted scientific uncertainty about climate change to delay laws that might limit carbon emissions.

For evidence, many of the cases rely on a series of internal company documents uncovered by investigative journalists that suggest oil industry scientists and executives were aware, decades ago, that fossil fuel emissions were changing the world's climate.

a woman smiling for the camera: Environmental law professor Ann Carlson is following the litigation against the oil industry closely and says the cases have a 'decent chance' of success.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Environmental law professor Ann Carlson is following the litigation against the oil industry closely and says the cases have a 'decent chance' of success.

Dutch journalist Jelmer Mommers, based in Amsterdam and working for De Correspondent and The Guardian, uncovered documents produced by Shell in the 1980s.

He published a confidential Shell report from 1988 called "The Greenhouse Effect" that contains a dire warning: "By the time the global warming becomes detectable it could be too late to take effective countermeasures to reduce the effects or even to stabilize the situation."

Mommers said the document illustrates that the company accepted the climate predictions being made by independent scientists.

Plain cigarette packs to hit shelves as 'best in the world' regulations kick in

  Plain cigarette packs to hit shelves as 'best in the world' regulations kick in Plain cigarette packs to hit shelves as 'best in the world' regulations kick inPlain-packaged cigarettes have started to pop up on shelves as the tobacco industry prepares for Health Canada's regulations to take effect on Nov. 9, after which retailers will have a 90-day window to offload their remaining inventory.

"This is a very detailed analysis of what the science at that point is saying about CO2 emissions and about their impact on climate," he said. "And it's a very explicit report and issues very strong warnings."

Mommers also uncovered a film Shell produced in 1991 called Climate of Concern, warning about the risks of climate change and suggesting possible solutions.

"[Shell] made it as a documentary to be seen by the public," he said. "They showed it in libraries, in schools, in universities, and the explicit purpose was to sort of issue a warning and tell people that this is going on, this is threatening our future, and we should act on it."

a man sitting at a table: Investigative journalist Jelmer Mommers published confidential Shell documents showing the company's understanding of climate science dating back to the 1980s. © Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Investigative journalist Jelmer Mommers published confidential Shell documents showing the company's understanding of climate science dating back to the 1980s.

Mommers said he was amazed by how much the company knew about climate change at the time.

"Already Shell in 1991 could sum up all the facts about climate change, all the threats that we all know by heart nowadays," he said. "It was very shocking actually to see how much knowledge was already there."

Shell Canada says the film was part of an education series made by the company's documentary film unit.

"Shell's position on climate change has been publicly documented for more than two decades," spokesperson Jana Masters wrote in an email to CBC News.

Other investigative reporters have published industry documents from Exxon that suggest company officials were aware of the scientific consensus on climate change in the 1970s.

Seeing Double! 12 Sets of Twins Were Born in a Missouri Hospital in Just 1 Week

  Seeing Double! 12 Sets of Twins Were Born in a Missouri Hospital in Just 1 Week Seeing Double! 12 Sets of Twins Born at Missouri Hospital in One WeekIn just this week, Saint Luke’s Hospital has welcomed 12 sets of twins, an amount the hospital says is the largest number of twins they’ve ever had at one time, and photographer Helen Ransom of Faces You Love captured precious images of all of them.

"There is general scientific agreement that the most likely manner in which mankind is influencing the global climate is through carbon-dioxide release from the burning of fossil fuels," a senior scientist with Exxon told company executives in 1977.

Instead of telling the public what they knew about the impending risks from their products, the court documents accuse the industry of trying to delay potential policy changes by fuelling political uncertainty and climate skepticism. Baltimore's official court filing states:

"Defendants concealed the dangers, sought to undermine public support for greenhouse gas regulation, and engaged in massive campaigns to promote the ever-increasing use of their products at ever greater volumes."

Mommers said the oil companies realized that if governments were to take real action to reduce carbon emissions, it would hurt their business.

'Emphasize the uncertainty'

An Exxon memo from 1988 acknowledges the climate threat, stating: "The greenhouse effect may be one of the most significant environmental issues for the 1990s," and that "the principal greenhouse gases are byproducts of fossil fuel combustion."

But the same memo also reveals "Exxon's position" was to "emphasize the uncertainty in scientific conclusions" and to "resist the overstatement and sensationalization of potential greenhouse effect which could lead to noneconomic development of nonfossil fuel resources."

Exxon Mobil told CBC News in an email that the news reports based on those internal company documents do not accurately reflect the company's position on climate change.

"News reports that claim we reached definitive conclusions about climate change decades before the world's experts are simply not accurate," Soper wrote. "Climate change is a serious issue that will require the collective efforts of governments, individuals and companies to address in a meaningful way."

Make your own tea bags: DIY quick and easy

 Make your own tea bags: DIY quick and easy © pixabay Make your own tea bags: DIY quick and easy Pleasant and healthy, tea is the second most consumed drink in the world (after water). Here's how to make your own homemade tea bags with this quick and easy DIY. Cultivated for over 5000 years , tea is one of the oldest drinks. Antioxidant , it also prevents stomach cancer and esophagus . Sips of nutritional qualities and health benefits , there are all kinds.

If one of them succeeds, we're going to see the floodgates open and all sorts of new cases. - Ann Carlson, environmental lawyer

Shell Canada spokesperson Jana Masters said the company doesn't believe "the courtroom is the right venue to address climate change."

"We agree that action is needed now on climate change, so we fully support the Paris Agreement and the need for society to transition to a lower-carbon future," she wrote in an email to CBC.

"We believe that smart policy from government, supported by inclusive action from businesses like ours and from civil society, is the best way to reach solutions and drive progress."

Ann Carlson, the environmental law professor at UCLA, said she has provided pro bono consultation for some of the municipal cases but is not otherwise involved in the litigation. She said if those cases make it to trial, government lawyers will be able to interrogate oil company executives, which could reveal more information about what the industry knew about climate change and when.

'Decent chance of success'

So far, the New York attorney general's case against Exxon is the only one that is actively unfolding in an open courtroom. The other cases are at various stages in the legal process.

"I think the cases do have a decent chance of success," said Carlson.

She said the cost to industry could be enormous if companies are forced to help municipalities pay to adapt to rising sea levels, or for the costs of wildfire and storm damage.

And all it would take is one successful case, she said.

"If one of them succeeds, we're going to see the floodgates open and all sorts of new cases filed by other municipalities, other states, alleging damages caused by the oil companies' failure to warn, failure to do anything about their own behaviour that was causing climate change."

Make your own tea bags: DIY quick and easy .
© pixabay Make your own tea bags: DIY quick and easy Pleasant and healthy, tea is the second most consumed drink in the world (after water). Here's how to make your own homemade tea bags with this quick and easy DIY. Cultivated for over 5000 years , tea is one of the oldest drinks. Antioxidant , it also prevents stomach cancer and esophagus . Sips of nutritional qualities and health benefits , there are all kinds.

Topical videos:

usr: 0
This is interesting!