Sport: Women's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway? - PressFrom - United Kingdom
  •   
  •   

SportWomen's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway?

11:45  13 june  2019
11:45  13 june  2019 Source:   inews.co.uk

Vettel doubles down on Ferrari's Canadian GP penalty stance

Vettel doubles down on Ferrari's Canadian GP penalty stance Sebastian Vettel coyly avoided questions about his Canadian Grand Prix penalty and his Ferrari Formula 1 team's Friday hearing in France, as he reiterated his belief he did nothing wrong . Ferrari has been summoned to the stewards tomorrow at Paul Ricard to discuss its request for a review of the incident where Vettel ran across the grass in Montreal and rejoined just as Lewis Hamilton tried to pass him for the lead.

France 2-1 Norway : Women ' s World Cup – as it happened. Read more. Norway ’s best chance fell to Engen. Amel Majri was disposed by Karina Sævik on the right and she swept it into the path of Caroline Graham Hansen, who forced a corner.

France took a big step towards the last 16 of the women ' s World Cup after Eugenie Le Sommer's penalty earned the tournament hosts a 2-1 victory against Norway . FULL MATCH DETAILS. Le Sommer struck from the spot after Wendie Renard's own goal had cancelled out Valerie Gauvin's

Women's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway? © Provided by Johnston Publishing Ltd

A special message from MSN:

Sport has the power to change lives. Yet in the UK only 8% of young women and girls are meeting the recommended exercise guidelines and millions are missing out on the transformational rewards of an active lifestyle. We’re committed to tackling the under-representation of women’s sport and have partnered with giving platform Benevity to raise funds for the charity Women In Sport. You can make a real difference - please donate now.

Having made it two wins from two with a 2-1 victory against Norway, France are building up a head of steam at a home World Cup which many have backed them to win.

Women's World Cup: Team of the Group Stages

Women's World Cup: Team of the Group Stages The Women’s World Cup in France has captivated audiences around the world so far, and it’s only going to get better. The favourites have all emerged relatively unscathed from the group stages, with France having some small scares on home soil. England and the United States eased through their groups, with other favourites also making it to the knockout stages. It was heartbreak for Scotland however, who suffered the pain of a last minute VAR penalty that would send them home. But, after it’s all said and done, who were the standout stars from the group stages of this year’s tournament? Here, we look at the stars so far from the Women’s World Cup in France so far.

A VAR penalty was the difference as France beat Norway despite conceding a calamitous own goal in their Group A fixture of the Women ' s World Cup . Highlights: France 2-1 Norway .

Women ' s World Cup 2019 power rankings. 1/24 1. United States. They had to wait for their turn but once it came, it was an all-time World Cup win. Thailand were blown away. As things stand, it seems the only obstacle between the holders and a fourth World Cup is a likely quarter-final against France .

Goals from Valerie Gauvin and Eugenie Le Sommer were enough to overturn a disastrous own goal from Wendie Renard and give Les Bleues all three points in Nice. Le Sommer's winner was not without controversy, however, given that it came from a penalty which many felt was wrongly awarded.

Women's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway? © Reuters REUTERS/Eric Gaillard

The penalty was given with the help of VAR after referee Bibiana Steinhaus decided to review a coming together between Ingrid Syrstad Engen and Marion Torrent in the box. In an attempt to clear a loose ball, Engen appeared to follow through on the onrushing Torrent and catch her just above the knee with her studs.

This was the penalty that was given using VAR with the game at 1-1.Penalty or no penalty?#FIFAWWC on @BBCFOUR.#ChangeTheGame pic.twitter.com/OlQZaTRKzP

Women's World Cup storylines to keep an eye on

Women's World Cup storylines to keep an eye on Summer is the time for international soccer competitions. Last year, the men had their World Cup, which France won by taking down Croatia in the finals. Speaking of France, that’s where the 2019 Women’s World Cup is being held. If you are wondering what to pay attention to in the competition, here are some storylines to follow. Will the United States repeat? The American men weren’t able to qualify for the World Cup, but their female counterparts have been a dominant force in women’s soccer for decades at this point. The United States women are the defending champs, having won the 2015 World Cup by besting Japan in the final. Only the Germans have ever been able to repeat.

Eugenie Le Sommer converts a penalty awarded by VAR to give France the lead against Norway in the Women ' s World Cup . Le Sommer wins it for France with VAR penalty . 12 Jun 201912 Jun 2019.

France scored a controversial VAR - awarded second-half penalty to defeat Norway 2-1 and all but confirm their spot in the last-16 of the Women ' s World Cup . France now top Group A with six points from two games, three clear of Norway and third-placed Nigeria, who they play in their final group

— Match of the Day (@BBCMOTD) June 12, 2019

After several viewings, Steinhaus pointed to the spot and booked Engen. Le Sommer smashed the ball into the back of the net from 12 yards in what proved to be the decisive moment of the game.

"VAR now giving softer than soft penalties," tweeted former England star Eniola Aluko. She was certainly not the only one who disagreed with Steinhaus' decision.

Controversial call

There were several arguments made against the penalty: that Torrent's momentum took her into Engen's boot, that Torrent had actually got the ball first and that, given that Steinhaus hadn't awarded a penalty initially, she should have stuck with her original decision.

Speaking at full time, BBC pundit and West Ham star Claire Rafferty said: "For me, instantly, I went for 'no penalty'. I think, potentially, yes she did follow through, but the initial jump into the challenge from Torrent was a definite sign that she couldn't really have stopped the momentum of the kick. For me, no, and the referee took a long time to make the decision as well. I think if you have that amount of doubt you should probably give the defender the benefit."

Marta sets record with 17th World Cup goal in Brazil victory

Marta sets record with 17th World Cup goal in Brazil victory Marta sets record with 17th World Cup goal in Brazil victory

Watch France 's Wendie Renard score an "incredible" own goal against Norway to leave the score 1-1 in the Women ' s World Cup . Watch: Fifa Women ' s World Cup - France re-take lead through VAR - awarded penalty .

France ’s Eugenie Le Sommer celebrates scoring from the penalty spot in the Women ’ s World Cup Group A game against Norway at the Allianz Riviera stadium in It went to a VAR review, before Le Sommer stepped up to render her Lyon team-mate’s error meaningless. France passed the test, just.

Women's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway? © Getty (CHRISTOPHE SIMON/AFP/Getty Images)

Fellow pundit and former England goalkeeper Rachel Brown-Finnis addressed the Laws of the Game more directly, saying: "When you look at the actual letter of the law and the fact that Bibiana Steinhaus booked her, that means she's deemed it reckless which then equates to a yellow card [for] endangering a player. But if we're looking at this particular incident, Torrent comes in and jumps in two-footed. I mean, who's endangering who?"

The Laws of the Game state that a foul should be awarded if a player commits any of the following offences in a manner considered by the referee to be "careless, reckless or using excessive force":

Torrent could certainly have been pinged for jumping at an opponent, so there is a degree of ambiguity to the situation. As for whether Engen got the ball first, that's not directly relevant to the criteria for the foul: the key information is whether or not she kicked Torrent.

Gallery: Who are the women facing a big summer of sport [Read Sport]

Television footage shows a fairly clear connection between her boot and Torrent's lower thigh, so the answer seems to be in the affirmative. Likewise, Engen's momentum going into the challenge is not a mitigating factor so much as a guide as to whether her kick should be judged to be careless, reckless or excessive.

Aussies look for Brazil bounce after France, Germany roll on

Aussies look for Brazil bounce after France, Germany roll on Australia will try to keep their Women's World Cup hopes alive when they face Brazil on Thursday after big-hitters France and Germany ground their way towards the last 16 with narrow wins. 

Who wins every Women ' s World Cup match? Visit SportsLine now to see picks from European expert David Roger Gonzalez is an award -winning writer based in Virginia that has covered pro soccer from Europe's top clubs to The FIFA Women ' s World Cup in France began on Friday, June 7 in Paris.

Former Premier League and FIFA referee Mark Halsey has told Yahoo Sport that Argentine referee Nestor Pitana made the wrong decision when he handed France a controversial penalty in Sunday’ s World Cup final against Croatia in Moscow.

While Steinhaus might, on another day, have awarded a free kick to Norway on account of Torrent jumping into the challenge, she clearly deemed Engen's follow through to be the only clear foul. Given that Torrent made no connection with Engen while Engen planted her boot studs up on Torrent's leg, it's not hard to see how Steinhaus decided she needed to award a penalty.

Women's World Cup: Was VAR wrong to award France penalty against Norway? © Getty (Photo by Hannah Peters - FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images)

Deeming Engen to be reckless as opposed to careless seems harsh, given that the two came to the ball almost simultaneously and any follow through was clearly accidental. Evidently, Steinhaus felt that the momentum behind the tackle warranted a caution.

Norway fans will certainly feel hard done by and, while the final call lies with the ref, the decision could well have gone the other way. While France now face Nigeria, Norway go up against Group A's bottom side in South Korea and will have to hope there are no more controversial penalties lying in wait.

Explore more issues around women in sport and join our fight to empower everyone to experience the lifelong benefits of exercise here.

Plus, Virgin Active have pledged to match donations raised meaning your money goes further to help even more women and girls get into sport.

Related: Britains greatest sportswomen of all time [Read Sport]

France 4 South Korea 0: Renard headers give Women's World Cup hosts flying start.
Corinne Diacre's Les Bleues made a flying start to their home Women's World Cup as France thumped South Korea 4-0 in Paris on Friday.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 9
This is interesting!