UK News Coronavirus: Models predicting patient outcomes may be 'flawed' and 'based on weak evidence'
George Alagiah tests positive for coronavirus
The BBC presenter said ‘if I can live with cancer, I can certainly live with Covid-19’.The BBC newsreader said that “if I can live with cancer, I can certainly live with Covid-19.
A group of European scientists worry models that predict how a patient may respond toare “flawed” and “based on weak evidence”.
Will warmer weather halt the march of coronavirus?
Researchers say summer conditions will not be enough to defeat the outbreakThe data for infection rates supports a climactic dimension to Covid-19. “Look at the World Health Organization (WHO) map of the coronavirus outbreak, and it is difficult to avoid spotting a pattern,” writes Tom Whipple, science editor of The Times.
With the new strain emerging at the end of last year, only the relatively few people who have encountered the virus have any immunity against it.
Amid concerns thecould threaten health services all over the world, models have been created to predict everything from who is most likely to develop complications to the length of a patient’s hospital stay.
, rating all as “at high risk of bias”.
They concluded the models are “poorly reported” and “probably optimistic”, adding none should be used “in practice at this point”.
One expert stressed, however, models are often accepted as being “useful but not perfect”, with doctors still having to use their “judgement”.
Coronavirus cure trial volunteers needed as NHS ploughs £2.1m into hunt for Covid-19 treatment
The Government is calling on anyone who has recovered from Covid-19 to take partThose interested in taking part need to have had Covid-19, and managed to fight the virus off.
, however, it can trigger a respiratory disease called COVID-19.
The coronavirus is thought to have emerged at a seafood and live animal market in the Chinese city Wuhan, capital of Hubei province.
It has since spread into more than 180 countries across every inhabited continent.
Latest coronavirus news, updates and advice
Since the outbreak was identified, more than 1.3 million cases have been confirmed, of whom more than 292,000 have “recovered”,.
In Tunis, a police robot to enforce containment
© FETHI BELAID A robot deployed by the Tunisian Interior Ministry patrols the streets of Tunis, April 1, 2020, to call on the population to respect containment due of the new coronavirus The Tunisian Interior Ministry has been circulating for the past few days in the streets of Tunis a police robot, built locally, which calls on the population to respect the confinement imposed since March 22 in order to slow the spread of the new coronavirus.
Incidences have been plateauing in China since the end of February, and the US and Europe are now the worst-hit areas.
The UK has had more than 52,000 confirmed cases and over 6,000 deaths.
Globally, the death toll has exceeded 76,000.
Coronavirus: Models at ‘high risk of bias’
In the review, three of the models predicted the risk a patient would be hospitalised with pneumonia or another coronavirus complication.
Eighteen looked at diagnostic models for detecting infection, 13 of which were via machine learning.
The remaining 10 models predicted a patient’s risk of death or severe disease, or how long they may be in hospital.
Note that the models did not include the Imperial College London simulation that guided the government’s response to the coronavirus outbreak.
The scientists noted only one study included patient data from outside China.
“There is the potential for different ethnic groups or healthcare systems to be different so any scorecard derived outside a UK population would need testing on a UK population for validity before being implemented”, said Dr Ray Sheridan from the University of Exeter.
Coronavirus: Gove, one of the main British ministers, in isolation
SANTE-CORONAVIRUS-GB-GOVE: Coronavirus: Gove, one of the main British ministers, in isolation © Reuters / PIPPA FOWLES / 10 DOWNING STREET CORONAVIRUS: GOVE, ONE OF THE PRIMARY BRITISH MINISTERS, AT ISOLATION LONDON (Reuters) - Michael Gove, one of the UK’s chief ministers, has been placed in solitary confinement as a member of his family has symptoms of COVID-19, reports an ITV reporter. Michael Gove, minister of the cabinet office, nevertheless continues to work, added ITV.
The European scientists concluded all the models were at a “high risk of bias, mostly because of non-representative selection of control patients”.
“A high risk of bias implies that these models will probably perform worse in practice than the performance reported by the researchers,” they added.
With a “few exceptions”, the team felt most of the models had too small a sample size.
“This is a well known problem when building prediction models and increases the risk of overfitting the model,” they wrote in The BMJ.
The models that used machine learning for diagnosis “showed a high to almost perfect ability to identify COVID-19”.
As well as being at a “high risk of bias”, the scientists noted “poor reporting”, and “an artificial mix of patients with and without COVID-19”.
Coronavirus: Models may do ‘more harm than good’
The scientists worry the desire to understand how best to treat COVID-19 patients may “encourage clinicians to implement prediction models without sufficient documentation and validation”.
Christophe: Affected by the coronavirus, the singer is in critical condition
Hospitalized for about ten days, the singer Christophe, affected by the coronavirus, is between life and death according to our colleagues from Here Paris. © Abaca Christophe: Affected by the coronavirus, the singer is in critical condition A few days ago, we learned with sadness that the singer Christophe was one of the many French people affected by the coronavirus. Today, as our colleagues from Here Paris reveal, the interpreter of the "Mots Bleus" is even in critical condition.
Although they stressed we “cannot let perfect be the enemy of good”, they are concerned following these models may “do more harm than good”.
“Therefore, we cannot recommend any model for use in practice at this point,” wrote the team.
The emergence of individual patient data should “validate and update currently available prediction models”.
Professor Derek Hill from University College London said: “Predictive computer models can be really helpful in both managing patients and also developing new treatments.
“The COVID-19 pandemic has led to some very rapid development of disease models.
“These could potentially help focus scarce healthcare resources on patients most likely to benefit from particular treatments and personalise treatment based on the symptoms with which people present at hospital.
“But any disease model used to make critical decisions does need to be carefully tested.
“To state the obvious, if the disease model is flawed, it could end up directing seriously ill patients at the wrong treatment, rather than the right treatment.”
Speaking of the new European research, Professor Hill added: “The overall conclusions are these models on the whole are not trustworthy and could be dangerous to use.
“Care must be taken to ensure doctors don't use disease models to make decisions without knowing these models have been properly tested.
“If a disease model is used to select treatment for a patient, then from a regulatory point of view, it is a medical device.
“You wouldn’t want to use an untested medical device on a critically-ill patient any more than use an untested drug”.
99-year-old WWII vet beats coronavirus in Brazil
A 99-year-old World War II veteran in Brazil was released from hospital with military honors Tuesday after recovering from COVID-19. He was released from hospital the same day Brazil is commemorating the 75th anniversary of its troops' successful campaign in the Battle of Montese in Italy during World War II," the army said in a statement. Piveta served in the army's fourth artillery regiment, which trained in Dakar in 1942, soon after Brazil entered the war on the side of the Allies, the army said.He then returned to Brazil with his regiment to defend the country from an Axis invasion that never came to be.
Dr Sheridan noted the CURB-65 Score is used to assess the severity of a patient arriving at hospital with bacterial pneumonia, while also directing doctors towards the most appropriate antibiotics.
“CURB-65 is accepted as useful but it is not perfect,” he said.
“It is still important to use the clinician’s common sense and experience, so if a scorecard gives a low score but you think a patient look sicker then the clinician should go with their judgement.
“This will also be the case for COVID-19.”
What is the coronavirus?
The coronavirus is one of seven strains of a virus class that are known to infect humans.
Others trigger everything from the common cold to severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars), which killed 774 people during its 2002/3 outbreak.
The coronavirus tends to cause flu-like symptoms, including fever, cough and slight breathlessness.
It mainly spreads face-to-face via infected droplets expelled in a cough or sneeze.
There is also evidenceand .
In severe cases, pneumonia can come about if the infection spreads to the air sacs in the lungs.
This causes them to become inflamed and filled with fluid or pus.
The lungs then struggle to draw in air, resulting in reduced oxygen in the bloodstream and a build-up of carbon dioxide.
The coronavirus has no “set” treatment, with most patients naturally fighting off the infection.
Those requiring hospitalisation are offered “supportive care”, like ventilation, while their immune system gets to work.
Officials urge people ward off the coronavirus byand maintaining .
Coronavirus: Trump suspends funding for WHO .
HEALTH-CORONAVIRUS-USA: Coronavirus: Trump suspends funding for WHO © Reuters / LEAH MILLIS CORONAVIRUS: TRUMP SUSPENDS FINANCING FOR WHO WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President Donald Trump said on Tuesday that he had asked his administration to stop funding the World Health Organization (WHO) following his management of the coronavirus pandemic.