•   
  •   

Ireland'Appalling waste of time' - man who claimed he was humiliated when friend's bag checked in shop has €75K damages claim dismissed

18:05  24 may  2019
18:05  24 may  2019 Source:   independent.ie

Solicitor Gerald Kean awarded €160k in damages after jury finds he was defamed

Solicitor Gerald Kean awarded €160k in damages after jury finds he was defamed Solicitor Gerald Kean awarded €160k in damages after jury finds he was defamed

'Appalling waste of time' - man who claimed he was humiliated when friend's bag checked in shop has €75K damages claim dismissed © Pic: Collins Courts Gary Cosgrove, 25, from Crumlin Road, Dublin

A Circuit Court judge has called a €75,000 defamation case against JD Sports and Diverse Security Services Limited “an appalling waste of time” before dismissing the case.

Gary Cosgrove (25) of Crumlin Road, Dublin 12, had told Ms Justice Jacqueline Linnane that he had been carrying out some last-minute Christmas shopping in Dundrum Shopping Centre on the 23 of December 2015.

Mr Cosgrove said he had been accompanied by two male friends and they had gone into JD sports where one of the friends had purchased four items. He told the Circuit Civil Court that after they left the store, a security guard had come up behind them and snatched the bag from his friend’s hand.

Man and woman hospitalised after apparent stabbing in Cork

Man and woman hospitalised after apparent stabbing in Cork Man and woman hospitalised after apparent stabbing in Cork

'Appalling waste of time' - man who claimed he was humiliated when friend's bag checked in shop has €75K damages claim dismissed © Getty

He said the security guard had asked the three of them to accompany him back to the shop and he had done so because he felt intimidated. The bag had been checked at the front of the store by the guard and it had been discovered a security tag was still attached to an Armani jacket. It had been removed by a member of staff and the three men had departed the store.

Judge Linnane said that although Mr Cosgrove had not purchased anything in the store, he is the only one who had decided to take an action. She said Cosgrove had claimed to be embarrassed, humiliated and intimidated by the incident whereas one of his friend’s had found the whole thing funny.

'Appalling waste of time' - man who claimed he was humiliated when friend's bag checked in shop has €75K damages claim dismissed A shop sign for JD Sports (PA) She said although Mr Cosgrove had told the court the three men should have been brought into a back room to have the bag searched, she believes this would have made the whole incident more noticeable.

Complaint made to gardaí over alleged electoral fraud in Sligo

Complaint made to gardaí over alleged electoral fraud in Sligo Complaint made to gardaí over alleged electoral fraud in Sligo

She said from the three men’s descriptions, it had been clear the entire shopping centre had been extremely busy with people bumping into each other, yet everyone had been able to stare at the bag being checked.

Judge Linnane said Cosgrove and one friend had told her they had heard no beeping as they left the store, but the other friend had said he thinks he might have heard it. There had also been conflict over the description of the security guard.

'Appalling waste of time' - man who claimed he was humiliated when friend's bag checked in shop has €75K damages claim dismissed © Getty

The judge told barrister Conor Kearney, who appeared with Shaffrey Solicitors for JD Sports that the security guard’s evidence had been that the incident never occurred.

Judge Linnane said to Tom Clarke, who appeared with Pembroke Solicitors for the security company that even if the incident had happened, she saw no justification for a claim whatsoever.

Cosgrove had not been defamed and claims in the premises of him having been accused of stealing and being part of a criminal gang were not true, she said.

Exit poll shows Greens will top European poll in Dublin amid big gains for the party

Exit poll shows Greens will top European poll in Dublin amid big gains for the party The exit poll has Ciarán Cuffe on 23%, with Fine Gael’s Frances Fitzgerald on 14%. Fianna Fáil’s Barry Andrews and Independent TD Clare Daly are both on 12%. Sinn Féin’s Lynn Boylan is on 10%; if these polls are correct, she will not be re-elected as an MEP. © RTa The Green’s Saoirse McHugh is on 12%, which puts her in third place in the Midlands-NorthWest area. Fine Gael’s Mairéad McGuinness and Sinn Féin’s Matt Carthy are on 25% and 15% respectively in those areas. Maria Walsh and Luke Ming Flanagan are in a battle for the final seat, as both are on 10%.

Judge Linnane dismissed the €75,000 claim against JD Sports Fashion Plc, trading as JD Sports and Diverse Security Services Limited before calling it “an appalling waste of time”.

A spokesperson for AIG Insurance said after the case it was delighted with the outcome. It fully intended challenging all claims in court in which they felt there was a reasonable chance of success. By fighting cases the company aims to reduce costs to customers and persuade claimants to think hard before “wasting court time” with potentially questionable claims.

MORE NEWS

Gunman wore no mask as he waited for shooting victim (Dublin Live)

TD Bailey 'rejected hotel's €600 offer' (Independent.ie)

Widespread rain shows to return (Mirror)

Sniper towers in place for Trump's Irish visit (Independent.ie)

34-year-old Deaf woman sues HSE over being placed in facility for the elderly.
Counsel said she had been put in the nursing home on a temporary basis, but that was almost two years ago. Jennifer has been left isolated from her peers, and her current situation counsel said was like being in “solitary confinement” and she lives her life mainly through “a computer screen,” counsel added. Jennifer can only communicate through Irish Sign Language, which nobody else at the nursing home can understand, and has to use either an iPad or phone text messages to communicate with others at the home.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 3
This is interesting!