•   
  •   

IrelandDenis O'Brien facing estimated €1m legal bill after Supreme Court ruling

00:50  30 may  2019
00:50  30 may  2019 Source:   independent.ie

European Parliament candidate threatens Dublin Bus with legal action over ban on political ads

European Parliament candidate threatens Dublin Bus with legal action over ban on political ads The public transport company said it would no longer accept political advertisements following a number of complaints this month.

Businessman Denis O ’ Brien is facing an estimated € 1 m legal costs bill after the Supreme Court ruled he must pay most of the costs of his failed case over statements made by two TDs in the Dail about his banking affairs. The seven judge court on Wednesday upheld a decision requiring Mr

Businessman Denis O ’ Brien is facing an estimated € 1 m legal costs bill after the Supreme Court ruled he must pay most of the costs of his failed case However, the fact the Supreme Court had, to an extent, dismissed the appeal on the basis of somewhat different reasoning from that of the High

Denis O'Brien facing estimated €1m legal bill after Supreme Court ruling © IRISH INDEPENDENT Denis O’Brien. Photos: Frank McGrath

Businessman Denis O’Brien is facing an estimated €1m legal costs bill after the Supreme Court ruled he must pay most of the costs of his failed case over statements made by two TDs in the Dail about his banking affairs.

The seven judge court on Wednesday upheld a decision requiring Mr O’Brien to pay the costs of the High Court hearing of his case, brought against the Dail Committee on Procedure and Privileges, the Dail and the State.

However, it directed both sides to pay their own costs of Mr O’Brien’s unsuccessful appeal to the Supreme Court against the High Court decision.

Bailey rejected €600 from hotel to pay her medical bill after fall

Bailey rejected €600 from hotel to pay her medical bill after fall The hotel where Maria Bailey fell off a swing wanted to pay for her medical treatment, but the TD declined the offer. In court papers, lawyers for the Fine Gael politician revealed she returned a cheque for €600 given to her by the Dean Hotel in Dublin following the incident in 2015. Despite rejecting the offer, a claim for hospital and dental costs has been included in the Dún Laoghaire TD's personal injuries action against the hotel.

The Supreme Court has ruled that businessman Denis O ' Brien must pay most of the legal costs of his failed case over statements made by two TDs in the Dáil about his banking affairs. The cost to Mr O ' Brien is estimated at € 1 m .

Businessman must cover estimated € 1 m bill after case over statements by TDs on his banking Mr O ’ Brien wanted the court to direct the Dáil and/or State parties to pay a “portion” of the costs, but Costs liability in this case should be decided on the basis of whether the normal rule the loser pays

Giving the cost ruling, the Chief Justice, Mr Justice Frank Clarke, said Mr O’Brien had argued he was entitled to costs for reasons including he had won on some of the issues raised.

The court considered there was no merit in that argument as the relevant costs jurisprudence did not suggest points could be totted up in such a way.

However, the fact the Supreme Court had, to an extent, dismissed the appeal on the basis of somewhat different reasoning from that of the High Court is relevant, he said.

That, along with the importance and novelty of the underlying issues and their resolution, would warrant “some departure” from the normal rule on costs.

In all the circumstances, he said the court considered the justice of the case would be met by leaving the High Court order on costs in place but making no order on the costs of the appeal, with the effect both sides pay their own costs of the appeal.

Majority of Irish drivers want new laws to lower court payouts on whiplash injures

Majority of Irish drivers want new laws to lower court payouts on whiplash injures Victims of whiplash were awarded an average of €20,000, according to 2018 figures from the Personal Injuries Assessment Board. From January to June 2018, more than half of such claimants received between €10,000 and €20,000 in compensation, while some received up to €30,000. These high payouts are driving up the cost of motor premiums nationwide, the Irish Insurance Federation had warned. A leading Irish neurosurgeon has previously claimed that whiplash is nothing but a “myth” created in the 20th century.

Businessman Denis O ’ Brien has received permission to appeal directly to the Supreme Court over the dismissal of his case against the Dáil and State over statements by two TDs in the House about his banking affairs. Mr O ’ Brien is also appealing an order requiring him to pay the estimated € 1 million

Denis O ’ Brien is seeking a “leapfrog” appeal directly to the Supreme Court over the rejection of his case against the Dáil and State concerning statements made in the Dáil about his banking affairs. The judge also later awarded the estimated € 1 million costs of action against Mr O ’ Brien .

Mr O’Brien’s case arose from statements separately made in the Dail by Social Democrats TD Catherine Murphy and Sinn Fein TD Pearse Doherty in May and June 2015.

He complained those made pointless an injunction he had obtained against RTE some weeks earlier restraining it broadcasting details of his banking relationship with State-owned Irish Bank Resolution Corporation.

He went to the High Court after the CPP rejected his complaints about the TDs actions.

The High Court’s Ms Justice Una N Raifeartaigh dismissed his case for reasons including the reliefs sought were impermissible under the constitutional separation of powers and would have a “chilling” effect on the freedom of parliamentary speech.

The core issue before the Supreme Court was whether the courts can intervene when an Oireachtas committee allegedly fails to obey its own rules.

Last March, a seven judge court ruled any interference by the courts in how the CPP had dealt with Mr O’Brien’s complaint over the TDs’ actions is impermissible under the Constitution.

Johnson to face court over EU referendum 'misconduct'

Johnson to face court over EU referendum 'misconduct' Boris Johnson is to be summonsed to court to face accusations of misconduct in a public office, over comments he made during the 2016 EU referendum campaign. The bid to prosecute Mr Johnson was brought by Marcus Ball in the aftermath of the EU referendum. He claims the former foreign secretary misled the public during the campaign and again at the 2017 general election. "Democracy demands responsible and honest leadership from those in public office," Mr Ball said previously.

Businessman Denis O ’ Brien ’s appeal against the dismissal of his action against the Dáil and State, over statements made by two TDs in the Dáil about Mr O ’ Brien is also appealing an order requiring him to pay the estimated € 1 m legal costs of his failed High Court action. His appeal, listed for two

THE SUPREME COURT has today begun hearing an appeal from Denis O ’ Brien ’s legal team as to why a High Court ruling on Dáil privilege, his privacy, and the associated legal costs should be overturned. The businessman has argued that his privacy was breached by two TDs – Sinn Féin’s

Such interference would amount to an “indirect and collateral” interference by the courts with statements made in the Oireachtas which are protected by Article 15, which confers privilege on parliamentary speech, it said.

MORE NEWS:

'No talking about Jesus or God, only Satan': Court hears details from copybook seized from Boy B's house (The Journal)

Criminal, 41, shot dead in garden 'was last to see murder victim alive' (Independent.ie)

Opinion: Nigel Farage is the most dangerous man in Britain (The New York Times)

Teen charged with fatal stabbing of Azzam Raguragui in Dublin park (Journal.ie)

North Korea to halt Mass Games after Kim fury: Tour firms.
North Korea will temporarily suspend its spectacular "Mass Games" propaganda displays from next week, travel agencies said Wednesday, after leader Kim Jong Un censured the show's content. This year's show, titled "The Land of the People", had its premiere on Monday and was expected to run until October. But Kim Jong Un "seriously criticised" the performance creators for "their wrong spirit of creation and irresponsible work attitude", the official KCNA news agency reported, and travel agencies operating tours to the isolated North have since been told that the displays would be "temporarily halted".

usr: 1
This is interesting!