Ireland: Ana Kriegel trial: Judge tells jurors to 'exclude sympathy' from deliberations - - PressFrom - United Kingdom
  •   
  •   

IrelandAna Kriegel trial: Judge tells jurors to 'exclude sympathy' from deliberations

10:00  11 june  2019
10:00  11 june  2019 Source:   independent.ie

Gardai arrest motorist caught 'drinking from bottle in car' in Cashel, Co Tipperary

Gardai arrest motorist caught 'drinking from bottle in car' in Cashel, Co Tipperary The arrest was made after the driver was stopped at Rock of Cashel . Gardai arrested the motorist on suspicion of drink driving. Cashel RPU: Car stopped at the Rock of Cashel, driver was drinking from a bottle in the car. Brings a whole new meaning to the phrase “A scotch on the rocks” Arrested on suspicion of Drink Driving. Never Ever Drink & Drive. pic.twitter.com/ZR00BIqSyQ— An Garda Síochána (@GardaTraffic) June 10, 2019 A garda tweet said: "Cashel Roads Policing Unit: Car stopped at the Rock of Cashel, driver was drinking from a bottle in the car.

The judge in the trial of two teenage boys for the murder of 14-year-old, Ana Kriégel has told the jurors to exclude normal human sympathy and empathy from their deliberations . Mr Justice Paul McDermott has begun his summing up of the case to the jury.

Jurors told of blood-splattered scene where body was found and of signs of a struggle. Ana Kriégel was severely and “endlessly” bullied by other children in the period before her alleged murder, her Geraldine Kriégel told the jury on the first full day of the trial that she and her husband adopted Ana

Ana Kriegel trial: Judge tells jurors to 'exclude sympathy' from deliberations © COLLINS PHOTO AGENCY ‘Enormous grace’: Parents of Ana Kriegel, Patrick and Geraldine, attend the trial. Photo: Collins Courts

Jurors in the trial of two boys accused of murdering Ana Kriegel have been told to leave their emotions outside the door when they begin their deliberations.

Mr Justice Paul McDermott told the jury to exclude normal sympathy and empathy from the decision-making process.

The judge has begun giving his charge to the jury.

The two accused, who were both aged 13 at the time, have pleaded not guilty before the Central Criminal Court to murdering 14-year-old Ana Kriegel at Glenwood House, Laraghcon, Clonee Road in Lucan, on May 14, 2018.

Man dies after O'Connell Street stabbing; bus and Luas services disrupted as scene is sealed off

Man dies after O'Connell Street stabbing; bus and Luas services disrupted as scene is sealed off A man in his 20s has been arrested in connection with the incident.

He told jurors they are here as judges of fact. “The essential thing about a judge is they be independent in their mind.” He said they must exclude from their minds an “any normal, human sympathies for any of parties.” It is impossible not to have sympathy for the Kriégel family, he said.

He told jurors they are here as judges of fact. “The essential thing about a judge is they be independent in their mind.” He said they must exclude from their minds an “any normal, human sympathies for any of parties.” It is impossible not to have sympathy for the Kriégel family, he said.

Ana Kriegel trial: Judge tells jurors to 'exclude sympathy' from deliberations Ana Kriegel

Boy A has also denied a charge of aggravated sexual assault.

In his charge to the jury, Judge McDermott said jurors must make their decision on the basis of the facts, on the evidence that had been heard in this case.

He said it was essential that jurors be independent of mind and be clinical in their analysis of the facts.

The judge said it might be useful for the jury to consider the evidence in respect of Boy A first, and then the case in respect of Boy B. This was the way the prosecution had presented the case, he added.

Judge McDermott will continue to sum up the case this morning.

Yesterday, the defence counsel made their closing addresses to the jury.

Patrick Gageby SC, for Boy A, asked the jury to consider if there was any real evidence that Boy A had "planned any of this at all".

China accused of using 'Made in Vietnam' labels to dodge US tariffs

China accused of using 'Made in Vietnam' labels to dodge US tariffs China accused of using 'Made in Vietnam' labels to dodge US tariffs

He told jurors they are here as judges of fact. “The essential thing about a judge is they be independent in their mind.” He said they must exclude from their minds an “any normal, human sympathies for any of parties.” It is impossible not to have sympathy for the Kriégel family, he said.

Mr Colgan told the jurors they had two versions of Boy B - members of An Garda Síochána described him as bright The arrangements made by the judge in the trial to make sure the boys had suitable breaks were not put in place Judge tells jury in Kriégel case to ' exclude normal human sympathy '.

He asked the jury to consider if there was "any solid or real evidence" of Boy A's intention to kill or his intention to kill Ana.

"Has any witness given evidence that Boy A ever said he wanted to kill?" Mr Gageby asked jurors.

Mr Gageby said one teenager had nothing to say about it, and a second teenager, in his evidence, said Boy A had said it but only as a throwaway comment, in a joking way.

The lawyer said there wasn't "a pick of evidence" from the witness box in relation to it.

Mr Gageby said he was not going to tell the jury what their verdict should be, as that was a matter for them. "Your area is the facts," he said.

The lawyer said the accused were only 13 at the time of this incident, and only a year out of primary school. He asked the jury to recognise that young people, particularly those in their early teens, "have an immaturity".

Mr Gageby also said it was worth acknowledging the "enormous grace" which Ana's parents had exhibited in the face of the evidence over the last seven weeks.

Garda on duty witnessed fatal stabbing incident on O'Connell Street

Garda on duty witnessed fatal stabbing incident on O'Connell Street Garda on duty witnessed fatal stabbing incident on O'Connell Street

Earlier, Mr Justice McDermott told the jurors that it was a matter of law and the order stood until any further order. The judge had reminded the jurors that media coverage of the case was not relevant to their deliberations and that they should decide their verdict exclusively on the evidence given in court.

Quirke murder trial jury to resume deliberations tomorrow. Ms Justice Eileen Creedon told the jurors they had to be objective and dispassionate and should not be influenced by But she had to tell them about the rules they had to apply. The judge told the jurors , they could draw inferences from

Ana Kriegel trial: Judge tells jurors to 'exclude sympathy' from deliberations Undated handout family photo of Anastasia Kriegel who was found dead in a derelict farmhouse outside the village of Lucan, Co Dublin, on May 16.

In his closing speech, Damien Colgan SC, for Boy B, said the prosecution cannot prove that Boy A and Boy B conspired or planned to kill Ana.

He said Boy B told a friend that Boy A had "snaked him" as he got him to collect Ana from her home. Mr Colgan said that's "exactly what happened".

"Boy B was set up by his co-accused," he added.

Mr Colgan said there was no DNA evidence connecting Boy B to the scene, nor was there any DNA evidence connecting him to Boy A.

Mr Colgan said the prosecution case is that the two boys planned this together and Boy B collected Ana and brought her to Boy A who then did "untold things" to her.

However, Mr Colgan said this theory does not hold water, and "does not add up in any shape or form".

He said there was "no plan" and Boy B had "no knowledge". He had given gardaí an innocent explanation of collecting Ana - namely, that he had been asked to do so by Boy A who wanted to discuss relationship issues with her.

Weapon recovered from the scene of fatal stabbing on O'Connell Street

Weapon recovered from the scene of fatal stabbing on O'Connell Street Weapon recovered from the scene of fatal stabbing on O'Connell Street in early morning attack (Dublin Live) Hackers may have stolen bank details for Delaney and McCarthy from FAI (Independent.

Schoolgirl Ana Kriégel , suffered a very violent death and fought for her life, the Central Criminal Court has been told . The prosecution said there was an overwhelming forensic case against one of the Mr Grehan asked the jurors to assess the evidence coldly and clinically without any sympathy or emotion.

Ana Kriégel murder trial told no evidence Boy A intended to kill her. Boy B ‘not capable’ of killing Ana Kriégel , father tells court. This will be followed early next week by a lengthy address from Mr Justice Paul McDermott after which the jury of eight men and four women will be asked to begin deliberations .

Mr Colgan then asked the jury to consider what person in their right mind would go to a house, where he's known, and collect a girl, knowing that she would be dead within 45 minutes.

Mr Colgan said this was "so off the radar" that it's not even feasible.

He said the prosecution was relying on Boy B's lies during his interviews with gardaí and arguing this was somehow sufficient to prove its case.

Mr Colgan said Boy B was "clearly telling lies, there's no two ways about it", but he reminded the jury of pathologist Professor Marie Cassidy's evidence when she agreed any person would have been traumatised by what they had seen in that room.

He said the jury must analyse the prosecution case with "a fine tooth comb".

Mr Colgan told the jury they cannot convict Boy B if they believe what he said, that he didn't know what was going to happen to Ana on that day.

Mr Colgan also said that if they have a doubt about what happened they must also give the benefit of the doubt to Boy B and find him not guilty.

The trial continues.

MORE NEWS:

Ana Kiegel trial: Jury asked to consider if there is any 'real evidence' (Indepedent.ie)

Man admits killing great-grandson (Daily Mail)

Lady Gaga's rant after Bradley Cooper's break-up (Mirror)

Couple guilty of 'feeding live foxes to dogs' (Sky News)

Ana Kriegel murder trial: Jury sent home for the weekend after more than seven hours of deliberations.
Ana Kriegel murder trial: Jury sent home for the weekend after more than seven hours of deliberations

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
usr: 1
This is interesting!