Ireland: Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal - PressFrom - United Kingdom
  •   
  •   

IrelandMan jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal

21:10  18 july  2019
21:10  18 july  2019 Source:   thejournal.ie

Man jailed for raping woman in back of car on beach trip

Man jailed for raping woman in back of car on beach trip Man jailed for raping woman in back of car on beach trip

Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal © Getty Images Dance Instructor put home in wife's name to avoid sex abuse payout A MAN JAILED for raping a woman he met after she became lost on a night out in Dublin city has had his conviction quashed on appeal.

Egyptian national Mohamed Okda (33), formerly of Coolfin, Rathdowney, Co Laois had pleaded not guilty to two counts of raping the woman and one count of sexual assault at a flat in Dublin city centre on 9 February 2014.

He was unanimously found guilty on all counts by a jury following a seven day trial and sentenced to 11 years imprisonment with the final year suspended by Justice Michael Moriarty on 23 October 2017.

Dispute between family members that run Claddagh ring business comes before High Court

Dispute between family members that run Claddagh ring business comes before High Court Dispute between family members that run Claddagh ring business comes before High Court

The Court of Appeal quashed Okda’s conviction today, and ordered a retrial, over the trial judge’s failure to instruct the jury at all on the presumption of innocence.

Giving judgment in the Court of Appeal, Justice John Edwards said that although both sides referred to the presumption of innocence in their closing speeches, the trial judge “unfortunately” omitted to do so.

Justice Edwards said it was “almost inconceivable” that one of the most experienced criminal trial judges on the bench at that time would simply forget to give the jury several important instructions.

He said the trial judge proceeded directly into this charge of the jury, or instructions to them, following “succinct” closing speeches by both the prosecution and defence. He went a certain distance before sending the jury home at lunch, stating that he didn’t want the jury to hear “three long speeches” in one sitting.

Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses

Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses

Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal © Graham Hughes via RollingNews.ie Regrettably, Justice Edwards said the “well-intentioned” decision to break his instructions overnight, and resume the following morning “may have had the unintended consequence of causing” everyone in the courtroom “to lose focus” and be “somehow under the mistaken impression after the overnight break that the judge had covered more ground on the previous day than he had in fact done”.

Justice Edwards said the failure to instruct the jury at all on the presumption of innocence was a “fatal flaw”, that rendered Okda’s trial unsatisfactory and his conviction unsafe.

He said the failure to instruct a jury on the presumption of innocence had previously occurred in a 2003 trial that lead to a successful appeal. In that case, the late Justice Adrian Hardiman said the failure to instruct the jury on the presumption of innocence risked “understating its importance and perhaps relegating it to the status of a mere technical rule”.

Phone cable used in attempt to 'strangle taxi driver' during terrifying hijacking, court hears

Phone cable used in attempt to 'strangle taxi driver' during terrifying hijacking, court hears Phone cable used in attempt to 'strangle taxi driver' during terrifying hijacking, court hears

Retrial order

Justice Edwards, who sat with President of the Court of Appeal Justice George Birmingham and Justice Brian McGovern, ordered a retrial.

Okda was remanded in custody to appear before the Central Criminal Court on Monday next.

In her evidence to the Central Criminal Court, the married mother said that she lived outside Dublin and was visiting the city with two female friends for a night out. At the end of the night she said she was drunk and tired.

She lost her friends and became upset because they weren’t responding to texts or phone calls. The accused man approached her and offered to help her find her friends, she said.

He suggested she come back to the flat where she could continue to try to contact her friends on her phone. She said that once she was back in the flat he raped her.

She said she feared for her life during the attack and begged Okda not to kill her. After it ended she ran out of the flat and waved down a passing taxi-driver who saw she was in distress and took her to gardaí.

MORE NEWS:

'The explosion of love has been deeply palpable' - Fair City's Karl Shiels' partner pays tribute at funeral (Independent.ie)

Margaret Fleming killers jailed for 14 years after two decade cover up

Margaret Fleming killers jailed for 14 years after two decade cover up Edward Cairney and Avril Jones were found guilty of murder at the High Court in Glasgow last month.

Man, 30s, arrested after late night car and helicopter chase on M1 (Dublin Live)

'His family are extremely concerned for his safety' - appeal for info about missing man (Independent.ie)

Behind the scenes the night Trump partied at Mar-a-Lago with Jeffrey Epstein and NFL cheerleaders (The Washington Post)

Irishman jailed in the US for running online black market site.
An Irishman was jailed in the US for his part in the operation of an online black market site. Gary Davis, who is from Kilpedder, Co Wicklow, was extradited from Ireland to New York in relation to the website Silk Road. 

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 2
This is interesting!