Ireland: Man (75) has conviction for raping granddaughter quashed over concerns he was unfit to stand trial - PressFrom - United Kingdom
  •   
  •   

IrelandMan (75) has conviction for raping granddaughter quashed over concerns he was unfit to stand trial

17:40  22 july  2019
17:40  22 july  2019 Source:   thejournal.ie

Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses

Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses Two thirds of motorists in Ireland caught speeding 'not receiving penalty points' on licenses

A man jailed for raping a woman he met after she became lost on a night out in Dublin has had his conviction quashed on appeal. He was found guilty on all counts following a seven-day trial and sentenced to 11 years in jail with the final year suspended by Mr Justice Michael Moriarty on October

Yet ANOTHER rape case disgrace: Man , 26, has his conviction quashed after spending two years Danny Kay spent more than two years in jail for a rape he did not commit He had his conviction quashed when a relative uncovered Facebook messages He was also made to see a psychiatrist because he was judged to be ‘in denial’ because of his

Man (75) has conviction for raping granddaughter quashed over concerns he was unfit to stand trial © Nick Ansell The teenager was arrested while trying to enter the Old Bailey (PA) A 75-YEAR-OLD man has had his conviction for raping his granddaughter quashed after reports were obtained to determine whether he was fit to stand trial at the Central Criminal Court more than a year ago.

Christopher Redmond, of Rathvilly Drive, Finglas, Dublin 11, was found in recent weeks to have had a severe form of dementia for some time “with no prospect of recovery”.

An earlier report, prepared prior to his trial early last year, found him to have a mild cognitive impairment but there was nothing to suggest he was unfit to be tried at that time, the Court of Appeal was told.

Ana Kriegel trial: Sentencing of schoolgirl's murderers adjourned until October

Ana Kriegel trial: Sentencing of schoolgirl's murderers adjourned until October Ana Kriegel trial: Sentencing of schoolgirl's murderers adjourned until October

Welsh international’s conviction quashed , but decision to allow evidence about complainant’s sex life causes outrage. International footballer Ched Evans has been found not guilty of the rape of a 19-year-old woman, but the decision to allow the jury to hear the sexual history of the complainant has

A NSW man has had his convictions quashed for raping his brother a decade ago. 'That is to say, I am left – after considering the totality of the evidence that was adduced at the trial – with a reasonable doubt about whether RP understood that the sexual intercourse which he had with his brother was

Redmond’s granddaughter, Leanne Murphy, spoke outside court to say she was “appalled” by the outcome.

I was unfit to be raped as a child. I didn’t have a say. I didn’t understand (why I was raped) so on the basis that that man doesn’t understand now, he gets to walk free. That is not any justice.

Redmond had pleaded not guilty to four counts of rape and five counts of sexually assaulting his granddaughter at the Tolka Valley pitch and putt club, where Redmond worked, in Finglas on dates between January 2002 and May 2004.

Murphy, who waived her right to anonymity so that his details could be published, was aged between seven and nine at the time of the abuse.

He was found guilty by a Central Criminal Court jury following a trial in early 2018 and sentenced to five years imprisonment by Justice Úna Ní Raifeartaigh on 27 April 2018.

Mexican drug lord El Chapo sentenced to life in US prison

Mexican drug lord El Chapo sentenced to life in US prison The 62-year-old was taken to the US to stand trial after he twice broke out of Mexican prisons. The guilty verdict triggered a mandatory sentence of life without parole. Guzman told US District Judge Brian Cogan before he was sentenced that he was denied a fair trial. He said Judge Cogan failed to thoroughly investigate claims of juror misconduct. Under Guzman’s leadership, the Sinaloa cartel was responsible for multiple murders and smuggling mountains of cocaine and other drugs into the US. Guzman’s lawyers said he was framed.

A federal judge has ruled a suburban Chicago terrorism suspect mentally unfit to stand trial on charges he placed what he believed to be a bomb outside Adel Daoud, 22, from suburban Chicago is facing terrorism charges but deemed incompetent to stand trial after his talk of shadowy conspiracies.

A Co Louth man ’s conviction for raping a 15-year-old family friend has been quashed over a ruling which prevented his lawyers from questioning the A Central Criminal Court jury found the man guilty and he was sentenced to eight years imprisonment by Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy on July 29th, 2016.

After Redmond was convicted, but before he was sentenced, he was assessed by a consultant forensic psychiatrist from the Central Mental Hospital, who found him to be suffering from a significant cognitive impairment. It was likely to have been present for a number of years, the report stated.

However, the question of whether Redmond was fit to be tried, specifically under Section 4 of the Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006, was not addressed in the report as he had already been convicted and “that ship had sailed at that point”.

An earlier report, prepared prior to his trial, found him to have a mild cognitive impairment but there was nothing to suggest he was unfit to be tried at that time.

Court of Appeal

The Court of Appeal heard that Redmond did not initially respond when he was asked to plead to the first count on the indictment. He had to be prompted and then pleaded not guilty.

Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal

Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal Man jailed for raping woman after she became lost on night out has conviction quashed on appeal . Egyptian national Mohamed Okda (33), formerly of Coolfin, Rathdowney, Co Laois had pleaded not guilty to two counts of raping the woman and one count of sexual assault at a flat in Dublin city centre on 9 February 2014. He was unanimously found guilty on all counts by a jury following a seven day trial and sentenced to 11 years imprisonment with the final year suspended by Justice Michael Moriarty on 23 October 2017.

Man , 26, who was jailed for four-and-a-half years for rape in 2013 has his conviction QUASHED on He had denied raping a woman and claimed the sex they had was consensual But Kay has now had his conviction quashed after messages boosted his case Danny Kay was jailed in late 2013 after a trial at Derby Crown Court and jurors heard a woman

A man charged with raping his 3-year-old niece beside the Franklin D. Roosevelt Drive in Manhattan in July has been found unfit to stand trial . He was supposed to take the child from a playground to a bathroom, but the police said he took her to a grassy area along the highway and attacked her in view

His barrister, Andrew Sexton SC, submitted that the safety of Redmond’s conviction had been placed in doubt by the report prepared so soon after his conviction. Sexton said Redmond was in the Midlands Prison in a cell with another individual.

A motion to adduce the report as new evidence was adjourned in April to allow both sides make further enquiries.

Counsel for the Director of Public Prosecutions, Patrick McGrath SC, told the Court of Appeal on that occasion that the State intended to have Redmond assessed by an expert from the Central Mental Hospital.

McGrath told the court today that the assessment had been carried out and Redmond was found to have a “severe form of dementia” with “no prospect of recovery”.

I Man (75) has conviction for raping granddaughter quashed over concerns he was unfit to stand trial © Laura Hutton via RollingNews.ie n those circumstances, McGrath said he was instructed to not oppose the appeal and he indicated that there would be no application for a retrial.

President of the Court of Appeal Justice George Birmingham said the medical reports set out the position in “very clear and stark terms”. He noted that the DPP were not opposing the appeal.

Paedophile grandad to walk free just a YEAR into five-year sentence

Paedophile grandad to walk free just a YEAR into five-year sentence His victim insists “he should be left to rot in a cell till he dies.” Redmond, who is her mum’s father, carried out a string of vicious attacks on Leanne between 2002 and 2004 at Tolka Valley pitch and putt club in Dublin, where he worked. He denied all charges and the victim was dragged through a seven-year ordeal from making the initial report to when he was finally locked up in April last year. Ms Murphy, from Finglas, Dublin, wrote on Facebook: “My heart is broke; I feel so let down by the Irish system. “That monster was supposed to be my grandfather, but instead took advantage of a young girl.

“ Unfit to stand trial ” is defined in the Criminal Code. It means that the accused person is unable, because of a mental disorder, to defend against the The law assumes that every accused person is “fit”, unless it is determined by a judge, after a fitness hearing that the accused is “ unfit to stand trial .”

An intellectually handicapped Auckland man has had 39 criminal convictions overturned, after a court has ruled he was unfit to plead or stand trial . In a High Court ruling in August, High Court Justice Graham Lang quashed Christie's 39 convictions after assessing a number of psychiatric reports of

Justice Birmingham, who sat with Justice Patrick McCarthy and Justice Isobel Kennedy, said the court would allow the appeal and make no further order. No referral was made to the Central Mental Hospital because the court itself had not made any determination.

Sentencing Redmond to five years imprisonment in April 2018, Justice Ní Raifeartaigh had applied a reduction to the headline sentence on account of his progressive cognitive impairments.

Speaking outside court, Murphy said she didn’t “want victims to be afraid to come forward because the system has let me down”.

“He got convicted by a jury of 12 people. Why do we have 12 jurors if the system just says then he was unfit to stand trial.”

She said she was a Social Policy and Sociology student at National University of Ireland, Maynooth.

I want to help people. I want change, I want to be a voice and I know you have to gain the knowledge, and be an academic, to be a voice for people.

“I come from a disadvantaged area and sometimes people think your opinion doesn’t matter. Well I’m here to say that my opinion is going to matter and I’m going to scream it from the rooftops.”

MORE NEWS:

Ana Kriegel's killers to be given edited versions of each other's probation reports (Independent.ie)

Ireland set to bask in 26C scorcher (Irish Mirror)

Death of pensioner 'not suspicious' as body lay undiscovered for up to 7 months (Independent.ie)

Opinion: Only Native Americans can say 'go back', Trump (The New York Times)

Swing-gate TD Maria Bailey should be booted from Fine Gael ticket, colleague insists.
Fergus O’Dowd is the first deputy to say publicly she should step aside after the compo claim fiasco . Speaking on LMFM’s Michael Reade Show, the Louth TD said: “Would I prefer that she didn’t stand? I would prefer if she didn’t, yes I would of course. “But I can’t influence that.” Ms Bailey said she regrets taking a now withdrawn case against The Dean Hotel in Dublin after she fell from a swing in 2015. Last week Taoiseach Leo Varadkar dumped her from her role as chair of the Housing Committee after an internal probe.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 5
This is interesting!