•   
  •   

US NewsWhy the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson

16:15  05 september  2019
16:15  05 september  2019 Source:   msn.com

'A Democratic Outrage': Thousands Protest Boris Johnson Suspending Parliament

'A Democratic Outrage': Thousands Protest Boris Johnson Suspending Parliament With parliament in recess over summer, August in Westminster is typically marked by a state of quiet. 

Queen Elizabeth II greets Boris Johnson in Buckingham Palace.Victoria Jones / Reuters. Every decision she makes on matters of politics is guided by the advice she receives from government ministers (which is why , when Johnson asked the Queen to suspend Parliament, she acceded).

Twitter fantasized about whether Queen Elizabeth II could say " no " to Boris Johnson as her next and 14th prime minister. “ 'I don’ t know why anyone would want the job' – what Johnson says HM the Queen told him during his audience! The PM revealed it during a tour in Number 10 before being told

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson © Victoria Jones / Reuters Queen Elizabeth II greets Boris Johnson in Buckingham Palace.

Throughout her 66-year reign, Queen Elizabeth II has been decidedly neutral. She doesn’t engage in political matters, nor does she share her political views. She has always, as is customary among British monarchs, left the politics to the politicians.

But Brexit has upturned any conception of normalcy in Britain. Perhaps it was only a matter of time before that applied to Buckingham Palace as well.

It finally did last week, when Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced that he would seek to temporarily suspend, or prorogue, Parliament until October 14—an otherwise routine procedure taken at a crucial moment, just weeks before the United Kingdom’s potentially chaotic exit from the European Union.

Sir John Major Joins Legal Bid To Stop Boris Johnson’s Suspension Of Parliament

Sir John Major Joins Legal Bid To Stop Boris Johnson’s Suspension Of Parliament Former prime minister Sir John Major has announced he intends to join a legal bid to stop Boris Johnson from suspending parliament to get a no-deal Brexit. 

Twitter fantasized about whether Queen Elizabeth II could say " no " to Boris Johnson as her next and 14th prime minister. Answer: She can' t . "Mr. Johnson accepted Her Majesty's offer and kissed hands upon his appointment as Prime Minister and First Lord of the Treasury," the palace statement reported.

Johnson , they say , is trying to quash growing opposition to his efforts to leave the European Union. Johnson took office July 24, promising to pull Johnson ’s political opponents are already working to challenge the suspension. They have argued that the prime minister’s request to the queen was “both

What next for Brexit? Follow key developments, expert analysis and multiple perspectives as the UK edges closer to leaving the EU

Though the decision to prorogue Parliament falls squarely on 10 Downing Street, it requires royal approval, which the Queen swiftly granted. But the procedural move was read by some as tacit approval from Buckingham Palace; several headlines framed the suspension as one in which the Queen had a say.

The reality, however, is much more mundane.

What role does the Queen play in British government?

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson © Getty The Queen’s role is largely a ceremonial one, limited to duties such as approving new laws and presiding over the opening and dissolving of Parliament. Every decision she makes on matters of politics is guided by the advice she receives from government ministers (which is why, when Johnson asked the Queen to suspend Parliament, she acceded). Though the Queen holds weekly meetings with the prime minister, during which she retains the right to be consulted on issues of the day, final decisions are, in reality, not up to her.

What happens now MPs have moved to block Boris Johnson from forcing a no-deal Brexit?

What happens now MPs have moved to block Boris Johnson from forcing a no-deal Brexit? Boris Johnson has been dealt a major blow to his authority after MPs wrestled control of parliament and moved to block a no-deal Brexit.

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has rejected accusations that he lied to the Queen over his controversial suspension of Parliament in the run-up to the Brexit deadline.

Decision will cut dramatically the time MPs will have to take action to prevent no-deal Brexit.

Related: 'Secret plan in place to evacuate the Queen' if Brexit turns ugly

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson © Getty

Indeed, the Queen’s Speech, which the monarch delivers at the start of each new parliamentary session to lay out the government’s policy agenda, isn’t written by the Queen at all—it’s drafted by the government. And royal assent, which must be granted for any legislation approved by Parliament to become law, hasn’t been refused since 1708.

So how does the Queen express her views?

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson © Getty She doesn’t. Although the Queen is the United Kingdom’s head of state, she is not its head of government—that role is filled by the prime minister. By avoiding party politics, she is able to position the monarchy as a unifying force in the country—which, at a time when Britain is bitterly divided over its looming exit from the EU, is badly needed.

“Neutrality is the essence of being a symbol of national unity,” Richard Fitzwilliams, an expert on the royal family, told me. “The only time the Queen puts her own words into public utterance is [in] her Christmas message,” an annual broadcast that doesn’t typically touch on politics or policy.

U.K. Democracy, Tested by Brexit and Boris Johnson, Holds for Now

U.K. Democracy, Tested by Brexit and Boris Johnson, Holds for Now U.K. Democracy, Tested by Brexit and Boris Johnson, Holds for Now

The Queen welcomes Boris Johnson at Buckingham Palace. As the Queen ’s powers have been cited in the no-deal Brexit debate, constitutional experts are divided on whether she could intervene to dismiss Boris Johnson and invite a new prime minister to form a government should he lose a vote

Boris Johnson With Queen Elizabeth II when he became Prime Minister. Victoria Jones - WPA Pool/Getty Images. The Supreme Court did not overtly say that Boris Johnson lied to the Queen about the reasons for his prorogation of Parliament, but several lawmakers have already said that is

Related: The Queen over the years in pictures (Photos)

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson

What about the rest of the royal family?

Though the emphasis on political neutrality applies to the whole royal family, there have been a few exceptions. Prince Charles, for example, has boycotted state banquets involving China in protest of the country’s human-rights abuses. The heir to the throne has also publicly spoken out about genetically modified foods and climate change. Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, have been similarly vocal on environmental issues.

“From time to time, issues have been taken up by members of the royal family,” Fitzwilliams said, before noting that expectations are higher for a ruling monarch. “The idea that Charles could one day be an activist king was always rubbish.”

Related: Things you probably didn't know about Prince Charles (Photos)

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson

Surely the Queen has a position on Brexit, though ... Right?

Many would like to think so. For years, people have argued that Brexit is simply too big for the royal family to ignore and that the Queen, through her fashion choices or otherwise, has been quietly signaling her position on the issue that has divided the nation. While those loyal to the Brexit cause have suggested that the Queen is secretly on their side, those opposed to it have held out hope that she might yet swoop in to join theirs.

The reality is, we’ll likely never know the Queen’s political views (if, indeed, she has any).

Brexit: A timeline [Photos]

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson


How’s that political neutrality working out so far?

It hasn’t been easy. In the case of Johnson’s controversial decision to prorogue Parliament, the Queen was bound by convention and precedent to grant his request. Had she refused to suspend Parliament against his advice, as some had hoped, a constitutional crisis would have been the likely result.

“That was what the English civil war was all about,” Robert Hazell, a professor of government and the constitution at University College London, told me of the 17th-century conflict, which established the precedent that the monarchy cannot govern without Parliament’s consent. “King Charles I lost [the war], and lost his head.”

Leave vs Remain: Images of divided Brexit Britain [Photos]

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson
Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson

Isn’t Britain already in a crisis?

The country is certainly in the midst of a political crisis, though it hasn’t reached the point of becoming a constitutional one—at least not yet. That could change if Johnson “starts playing fast and loose” with accepted norms and conventions, Hazell said. One possible scenario that could fall within constitutional-crisis territory is the prime minister advising the Queen against giving royal assent to a bill that would limit his ability to pursue a no-deal Brexit. Another is Johnson refusing to quit if he loses a vote of confidence in his government.

“To the extent that he’s willing to break conventions,” Hazell said, “he does risk asking the Queen to do things which would inevitably then draw her into politics.”

Is the Queen allowed to ignore a prime minister’s advice?

Why the Queen Didn’t Say No to Boris Johnson © Getty Not really. Much in the same way the prime minister is bound by certain norms and conventions of British politics, the Queen, too, is duty bound by tradition and precedents.

The only scenario that would prevent the Queen from taking her prime minister’s advice would be if it were demonstrated that the prime minister no longer commands the confidence of a majority of lawmakers in Parliament (something that can no longer be taken for granted after the Conservatives lost their governing majority). Without the confidence of the House of Commons, “any advice [Johnson] offers to the Queen … is no longer binding,” Hazell said. “That is the sheet anchor ... of democratic accountability.”

Ultimately, the last place the Queen wants to be, on the brink of a looming national crisis, is between her prime minister and Parliament.

MSN UK is committed to Empowering the Planet and taking urgent action to protect our environment. We’re supporting Friends of the Earth to help solve the climate crisis - please give generously here or find out more about our campaign here.

DAN HODGES: Boris Johnson is taking a beating... but Jeremy Corbyn will step forward to save him this week.
DAN HODGES:The Prime Minister should hold his nerve. Because a man on a white charger may be about to come riding to his rescue. A man by the name of Jeremy Corbyn. © Provided by Associated Newspapers Limited 'Corbyn had better watch himself,' one MP tells me. 'I'm going to keep my head down for the next couple of weeks. But when reselection is out of the way, they can't touch me. And then I'm coming for him'. The Labour leader is pictured on Friday in Fife, Scotland The Labour Party conference starts this week in Brighton. With the Government in disarray, it should be the moment for the Opposition to pounce.

Topical videos:

usr: 2
This is interesting!