•   
  •   

US News The ‘Messy and Angry’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying

12:50  21 october  2019
12:50  21 october  2019 Source:   msn.com

Man who fractured teenager's skull with hurley in 'revenge' attack has sentence increased

  Man who fractured teenager's skull with hurley in 'revenge' attack has sentence increased A Dublin man who fractured a teenage boy's skull with a hurley while dispersing a group of youths has been given an extra two years in jail by the Court of Appeal. Alan Curtis (35), of Stannaway Road, Kimmage, had pleaded not guilty to intentionally or recklessly causing serious harm to then 16-year-old David McClelland at Cashel Road, Crumlin, Dublin, on March 28, 2014.Despite claiming self-defence, Curtis was found guilty by a jury at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court and sentenced to four years imprisonment with the final two years suspended.

Changing demographics and sentiment signal that the possibility of a reunion is increasing. Yet few are prepared for what that means.

Northern Ireland ’s mainly Protestant pro-British majority and the Catholic minority, which traditionally favored reuniting with the Republic of Ireland , had been living in peace after decades of sectarian violence. Where was the urgent need for such a drastic change? Then the unforeseen happened.

a sign hanging from a tree: A defaced 'Welcome to Northern Ireland' sign on the border in Middletown, Northern Ireland. © Clodagh Kilcoyne / Reuters A defaced 'Welcome to Northern Ireland' sign on the border in Middletown, Northern Ireland.

DUBLIN—Few people were talking about Irish reunification in the spring of 2016: Most assumed that the Good Friday Agreement had put the issue on ice for the foreseeable future. Northern Ireland’s mainly Protestant pro-British majority and the Catholic minority, which traditionally favored reuniting with the Republic of Ireland, had been living in peace after decades of sectarian violence. Where was the urgent need for such a drastic change?

Then the unforeseen happened. The United Kingdom voted narrowly to leave the European Union. Suddenly, Northern Ireland—which as part of the U.K. had voted to remain in the EU—was to be taken out of the bloc; the border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, an EU member state, would once again be a tangible barrier to movement and trade after a protracted period of near-invisibility. Warnings proliferated of the consequences—economic, security, political—of separating the two sides of the island of Ireland. Chief among these was the risk that the border would again be a flashpoint for conflict, a resumption of the Troubles, which killed more than 3,500 people over 30 years.

Two people arrested over Dublin stabbing which left man in coma

  Two people arrested over Dublin stabbing which left man in coma Two people have been arrested over a Dublin stabbing which has left one man in a coma in hospital. The man had been involved in an argument with two people before he was stabbed several times in the body. The attack is not being treated as a random incident and it’s understood that the victim and the suspects are known to each other. Emergency services rushed to the scene and the injured man was taken to Tallaght Hospital with what have been described as serious injuries.

The ‘ messy and angry ’ prospect of Ireland reunifying (The Atlantic). Opinion: Erdogan’s Ambitions Go Beyond Syria (New York Times).

The ‘ messy and angry ’ prospect of Ireland reunifying (The Atlantic). Opinion: Erdogan’s Ambitions Go Beyond Syria (New York Times).

In this newly febrile atmosphere, the idea that Ireland might someday be reunited, peeling Northern Ireland away from the U.K. and combining it with the republic, no longer seems so farfetched.

What next for Brexit? Follow key developments, expert analysis and multiple perspectives as the UK edges closer to leaving the EU

A bullet-riddled welcome to Northern Ireland. © PA A bullet-riddled welcome to Northern Ireland.

Such a future is envisaged in the Good Friday Agreement, via referenda on both sides of the border, and public-opinion surveys and population trends suggest that this is more than just a remote possibility. For one thing, long-term demographic changes make it likely that Roman Catholics in Northern Ireland, most of whom identify as Irish nationalists, will soon become the largest religious group in the statelet, which was crafted in 1921 specifically to have a pro-British Protestant majority. And sentiment appears to be moving in that direction: Last month, for the first time, a survey found that a majority in Northern Ireland in favor of reunifying, albeit only by a margin of 51–49. (The poll was, notably, carried out by a company owned by Michael Ashcroft, a former senior official in Britain’s Conservative Party, which is officially unionist.)

EXCLUSIVE: One Irish driving test centre raked in €1.3 million in test fees last year

  EXCLUSIVE: One Irish driving test centre raked in €1.3 million in test fees last year A Dublin driving test centre took in nearly €1.3 million in test fees in 2018.  © Provided by Associated Newspapers (Ireland) Limited, t/a dmg Media Ireland driving test The Tallaght test centre facilitated 12,622 tests last year, while Churchtown saw 6,672 applicants, earning €1,072,870 and €567,120 respectively. Elsewhere in Dublin, the Raheny test centre conducted 5,385 tests (€457,725). This means that, between the four Dublin test centres, the RSA took in nearly €3.4 million last year (€3,389,630).

Angry Young Men, various British novelists and playwrights who emerged in the 1950s and expressed scorn and disaffection with the established sociopolitical order of their country. The Angry Young Men were a new breed of intellectuals who were mostly of working class or of lower middle-class origin.

The ‘ Messy and Angry ’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying .

The notion has become so mainstream, in fact, that Peter Robinson—a former leader of the hard-line Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) whose dedication to preserving Northern Ireland’s place in the U.K. once led him to co-found an armed paramilitary group—publicly stated last year that unionists like him would be wise to start planning for a vote, and to be prepared to respect the result. “I don’t expect my own house to burn down,” he said, “but I still insure it because it could happen.”

Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar. The Irish government denies it is pushing for a united Ireland. © Reuters Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar. The Irish government denies it is pushing for a united Ireland.

It is hard to overstate what a remarkable shift this is. And yet, at the same time, it is difficult to understate how ill-prepared everyone is for it to actually happen.

How, practically, would Ireland be reunited? What flag would fly over which buildings? Would residents of Northern Ireland still be able to claim both British and Irish nationality? Would a united Ireland be a unitary state under Dublin’s present structure, reversing (or, some nationalists might say, avenging) Britain’s partition of the island almost a century ago, or would it be a newly federal country, with the north retaining its separate parliament, police, and administration and London standing as guarantor of the interests of Northern Ireland’s unionist population, as Dublin has stood for Northern Irish nationalists?

The Prince in Punjab: Duke and Duchess land in ancient city of Lahore near the Indian border ahead of trip to cancer hospital Diana visited the year before her death

  The Prince in Punjab: Duke and Duchess land in ancient city of Lahore near the Indian border ahead of trip to cancer hospital Diana visited the year before her death The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge arrived at Lahore Airport to meet the city's governor before they make an emotional visit to the Shaukat Khanum Memorial Cancer Hospital and Research Centre.  The couple were greeted this morning by officials and a posy of flowers before going into the airport terminal for a private meeting with the Governor of Lahore, and the Duchess looked ethereal in ivory as she arrived.

The ‘ Messy and Angry ’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying . Theories of International Relations and Northern Ireland . Author CSPtrade. The Sound of the Shuttle: Essays on Cultural Belonging & Protestantism in Northern Ireland .

The ‘ Messy and Angry ’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying . Changing demographics and sentiment signal that the possibility of a reunion is increasing.

Members of the anti-brexit campaign group 'Border communities against Brexit'. © Getty Members of the anti-brexit campaign group 'Border communities against Brexit'.

Such questions are already being debated quietly in many unofficial forums and back rooms, yet neither Dublin nor London is involved. The British government is consumed by Brexit, while Ireland says its priority is to protect the Good Friday Agreement (“The Irish government very firmly does not see Brexit as a vehicle for achieving a united Ireland—they are separate and distinct issues,” a government spokesman said). Even the Northern Irish assembly and executive, which have an array of their own powers, have been suspended for the past three years because of a standoff between the DUP and Sinn Fein, the main nationalist party. As far as is known, no unionist politician has yet joined any of these private conversations about Irish unity. And even those who are prepared to at least consider the possibility remain deeply skeptical, not only of arguments about identity and sovereignty, but of the practical benefits as well.

Gallery: Leave vs Remain - Brexit reveals a divided UK (Photos)

PM 'very confident' MPs will want to vote for Brexit deal on Saturday

  PM 'very confident' MPs will want to vote for Brexit deal on Saturday Boris Johnson says he is confident MPs will want to vote for his new Brexit deal on Saturday. The prime minister told a news conference that his new Brexit agreement is a "great deal for our country".He said Britain will now be able to "come out of the EU as one United Kingdom", despite describing the process as "painful" and "divisive"."The building now begins," he said.Mr Johnson has been negotiating with EU officials to work out the details of his new proposals for Brexit, including solutions to the Irish border problem.

The ‘ Messy and Angry ’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying . Changing demographics and sentiment signal that the possibility of a reunion is increasing. Yet few are prepared for what that means.

The ‘ Messy and Angry ’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying . In 1969 animosities between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland escalated into what is called the Troubles, now nearly three decades of violence during which thirty-four thousand shootings and fourteen thousand bombings

Chief among these is the economic case for Irish unity. In 2016, the Republic of Ireland, flush with tourism, high-tech industry, and foreign investment, had a per capita gross domestic product of €53,300 ($58,800). In Northern Ireland—the U.K.’s poorest region, largely dependent on British government spending, which London puts in excess of £9 billion ($11.5 billion) a year—the figure was €23,600.

But as Steve Aiken, an Ulster Unionist Party member of Northern Ireland’s assembly, notes, much of the region’s trade is with the rest of the U.K., so reunifying with “the south” would have a cost as well. And while incomes are higher in the republic, Aiken, a unionist so moderate that he has lived and worked in Dublin, argues that because of much higher prices and poorer public services, the standard of living in the republic is worse. Take the issue of health care: At present, residents of Northern Ireland can avail themselves of the U.K.’s National Health Service, which is free at the point of care, whereas the republic has a dysfunctional and expensive mixed public-private system. An actor dressed as a soldier in front of a mock checkpoint constructed during an anti-Brexit rally at the Irish border near Carrickcarnan. © Getty An actor dressed as a soldier in front of a mock checkpoint constructed during an anti-Brexit rally at the Irish border near Carrickcarnan.

Reverse arguments also apply. Peter Shirlow, the director of the University of Liverpool’s Institute of Irish Studies, says that many in Dublin’s political and business elite have privately told him that Ireland cannot make up the multibillion-pound annual subsidy from London that currently sustains Northern Ireland’s economy.

“I think the people in the south would vote for unity right now because it’s emotional,” Shirlow told me, “but they haven’t had the debate yet about what it would cost.”

Then there is the issue of security. Extremist unionist paramilitary groups—which murdered hundreds of people during the Troubles—have warned that any move toward Irish unity could rekindle violence. Unionist concerns were not eased when Sinn Fein, the former political wing of the Irish Republican Army and the party most committed to pushing for a border poll in the short term, recently appointed Gerry Adams as its spokesperson on reunification. Adams denies long-standing claims that he was a member and commander of the IRA, which was responsible for most of the killings during the Troubles, and he played a key part in the talks that eventually led to the Good Friday Agreement. But he remains a bogeyman for Northern Ireland unionists. (Adams’s office said he was unavailable to be interviewed for this article.) A motorist crosses the Irish border in Middletown, Northern Ireland. © AP A motorist crosses the Irish border in Middletown, Northern Ireland.

If Irish unity seems more likely in the post-Brexit chaos, there is still little sign that it will happen in the short term by orderly means. Though Catholics may soon be Northern Ireland’s largest religious group, they are unlikely to constitute an absolute majority for some time. Nor is it likely that all of them would vote for a change to the present arrangement: After almost a century in existence as a separate statelet, Northern Ireland is showing signs that a distinct identity is beginning to emerge, and that the old sectarian political lines are blurring. In European Parliament elections this May, the nonsectarian and anti-Brexit Alliance Party saw its share of the overall vote rise to 18.5 percent, from 7.1 percent at the last such vote in 2014. Tellingly, the recent Ashcroft poll that found 51 percent of respondents in favor of unity made no allowance for such centrist opinion.

“Society is normalizing, and it’s happening quietly, without any big fuss,” Shirlow said, pointing to studies that show that nearly a quarter of long-term romantic relationships in Northern Ireland are between people from different religious communities, and a third of schoolchildren in the region have a nonreligious background. “Taxi drivers tell me now about how on Sunday mornings they are going to the [Protestant] Shankill Road to pick up kids to go visit granny in [Catholic] Ballymurphy.” Traffic passes into Northern Ireland. © Getty Traffic passes into Northern Ireland.

Yet there is nevertheless an urgency to the issue: The consequences of Brexit, in both the short and long term, are unclear. Though the Good Friday Agreement stipulates that the U.K.’s secretary of state for Northern Ireland must call a vote on reunification if he believes there is likely to be a majority for change, in reality the process could be far less predictable and orchestrated. An eventual British withdrawal from the EU could, for example, precipitate Scotland’s seeking, and gaining, independence. Were it to do so, would England, the largest of the U.K.’s constituent nations, want to hold on to distant and troubled Northern Ireland?

“If you have any sense of history,” said Paul Gosling, a Northern Ireland–based English economist who has studied reunification, “you have to recognize that important things can happen quickly and not necessarily in the control of governments.”

If the British government called a “border poll” under the present terms of the Good Friday Agreement, a simple majority would be enough to bring reunification, potentially creating a large, deeply alienated, and possibly violent unionist minority in a newly united Ireland. In light of the bitterness created by the U.K.’s narrow vote for Brexit, some politicians have called for further electoral measures to ensure that such a vote had broad consent, either through a supermajority of, say, 60 percent or through some form of “parallel consent” in Northern Ireland to ensure that both communities were, at least in part, on board with the measure.   The ‘Messy and Angry’ Prospect of Ireland Reunifying © AP

But none of these suggestions address the possibility of a chaotic and unintended reunification. The terms of the U.K.’s exit from the EU remain in doubt: The country could leave with a withdrawal deal, or without one; on October 31, or months later. It could stay in the EU, and Scotland might leave the U.K. anyway. This uncertainty only feeds fears of what might happen on the island of Ireland.

“Europe and the U.K. are in a muddle, and we could be pitched toward a united Ireland without there being any time to get ready for it,” said Andy Pollak, the former director of the Armagh, Northern Ireland–based think tank Centre for Cross Border Studies. “If it happens that way, it’s going to be messy and angry.”

MSN UK is committed to Empowering the Planet and taking urgent action to protect our environment. We’re supporting Friends of the Earth to help solve the climate crisis - please give generously here or find out more about our campaign here.

Hariri announces reforms, so will Lebanon get its revolution? .
Demonstrators calling for fundamental changes vowed to keep up protests after Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri on Monday announced his cabinet had approved economic reforms. Sandwiched between antagonistic neighbours, with a diverse populace governed under an archaic power-sharing arrangement between religious groups, Lebanon has put up with dysfunctional governance for so long that it has spawned a quintessentially Lebanese protest culture.

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!