US News Judge Forced To Rule Teenage Jehova’s Witness Cancer Patient Can Have Blood Transfusions
Jurors asked to consider if accused men 'really cared' whether alleged rape victim said no
The two men have pleaded not guilty to the charges.Eilis Brennan SC said that a lack of concern for the woman shown by the two defendants outside of the bedroom was “highly indicative” of a lack of concern inside the room.
A High Court judge has ruled that a teenage Jehovah’s Witness can undergo blood transfusions during cancer treatment.
Mrs Justice Roberts made the ruling after the 14-year-old and his mother, who is also a Jehovah’s Witness, said religious beliefs prevented them from agreeing to a blood transfusion.
She concluded that the boy’s life would probably be at risk if he did not undergo transfusions.
The judge analysed issues at a recent private hearing in the Family Division of the High Court in London and has outlined detail of the case in a written ruling published online.
Government's patient safety legislation blasted by doctors and patients
Dr Rhona Mahony, former master of the National Maternity Hospital said the system pits doctors against patients.Ireland’s claims system was described as “adversarial” and “litigious” by various participants at a conference organised by the Irish Medical Organisation on Saturday.
She said the teenager, who has a form of lymphatic cancer, could not be identified in media reports of the case and she has not named the hospital trust which asked her to decide whether transfusions would be in the boy’s best interests.
Neither the teenager or his mother could give doctors consent to perform a transfusion because of their Jehovah’s Witness beliefs, Mrs Justice Roberts said.
But both said they would respect the law and any decision made by a judge.
The teenager has also said he wanted to live and return to “normal life”.
“Without the proposed treatment, I am satisfied that there is a very significant and material risk that the cancer from which (the boy) suffers at the present time will spread and the probability is that his life will be put at risk as a result,” said the judge.
Co Antrim teen accused of rape, blackmail and harassment in case involving five suspected victims
A judge heard he allegedly boasted to police about his computer abilities , saying that he deliberately sought out and crashed strangers’ internet games.During interviews he was also said to have stated: “All girls these days are sl**s.”The teenager is charged with 21 offences, including:rape,causing a child to engage in sexual activity,trying to blackmail one alleged victim into paying £500, and,multiple counts of possessing, distributing and inciting girls to take indecent photographs.
“I am left in no doubt that the anger and upset he may well feel as a result of the authorised imposition of any treatment which involves the use of blood products contrary to the tenets of his religious beliefs are likely to be eclipsed by the ultimate benefits of the proposed potentially life-saving treatment which has been planned for him.”
Jehovah’s Witnesses traditionally object to blood transfusions and treatment with blood products and say their attitude to blood stems from biblical teaching.
Their website, www.jw.org, says: “Both the Old and New Testaments clearly command us to abstain from blood.
“God views blood as representing life. So we avoid taking blood not only in obedience to God but also out of respect for him as the giver of life.”
It highlights a number of biblical references, including passages in Genesis, Leviticus, Deuteronomy and Acts.
Brothers with €1m debt lose home as judge compares situation to ‘paying just two months’ rent over 10 years’ .
Brothers with €1m debt lose home as judge compares situation to ‘paying just two months’ rent over 10 years’Two brothers, one of whom tragically since became blind, were left with a joint mortgage debt that had spiralled to almost €1m.
14-year-old Jehovah's Witness with cancer can have blood transfusion, judge rules - JW.org
Neither the teenager or his mother could give doctors consent to perform a transfusion because of their Jehovah's Witness beliefs, Mrs Justice Roberts said.
Why do Jehovahs Witnesses Ban Blood Transfusions? | Q&A | Podcast 61 Clip
In this clip, I talk about Jehovah's Witnesses reasons for banning blood transfusions. I also answer other questions from the audience. 00:01 - What's the ...