Health & Fit Intermittent Fasting for Weight Loss Isn’t All It’s Hyped to Be, Research Suggests
5 people explain why they quit fasting diets
Eating only in an eight hour window or picking two low calorie days per week are popular for weight loss, but hard to maintain, dieters told Insider.Two popular methods are the 5:2 diet and intermittent fasting (IF).
- When it comes to losing weight (if that’s your goal), intermittent fasting may not be any more effective than simply reducing total daily calories, shows.
- However, it’s important to eat in a way that works best for you and lines up with your own nutrition and training —consulting with a sports dietitian or other medical expert is the best way to personalize your diet for best results.
, which restricts your snacks and meals to a certain timeframe during the day, may have some benefits depending on your goals. But when it comes to weight loss—if that’s your goal!—a in the journal Science Translational Medicine suggests the approach isn’t more effective than simply reducing the total daily calories you eat, and eating them at unspecified times.
I Can't Stop Scrolling Through These Incredible Weight-Loss Transformation Pics...
In fact, intermittent fasting may even be detrimental to muscle mass, according to lead researcher, Ph.D., co-director at the Center for Nutrition, Exercise, and Metabolism at the University of Bath in the U.K.
Researchers recruited 36 participants and assigned each to one of three groups for three weeks. The first group didn’t intermittently fast at all and just reduced their daily calories by 25%. The other two groups fasted on alternate days, with one group following a fast day by eating 50% more than usual and the other group eating 100% more.
At the study’s conclusion three weeks later, the last group showed no weight loss, while the first group and the 50% group each lost about the same amount of weight but with significant differences, Betts told Runner’s World. Those who fasted and then ate 50% more lost much more muscle mass than the non-fasting group.
More than 66% of People Would do This Type of Intermittent Fasting, New Study Says
A new study suggests how willing most people are to cut their feeding window down and devote it to intermittent fasting.For those who are otherwise healthy—and have the time and resources to follow an IF-style diet—this type of eating pattern can help you improve focus and even assist you in weight loss efforts. The only issue is IF isn't an easy lifestyle to adopt, especially if you have an inconsistent or busy work schedule. However, new research pinpoints the type of IF diet most people may be comfortable following.
“Because of this, anyone who wants to do intermittent fasting needs to keep in mind that they may need to do morein order to maintain muscle mass,” he said.
Video: Intermittent fasting could help you live longer, experts say (TODAY)
Another factor to consider here is quality of foods,, M.S., R.D., a dietitian and certified nutrition support coach, told Runner’s World.
“You may help stimulateif you’re consuming fewer calories simply because you’re reducing the number of hours that you’re eating,” she said. “However, it is certainly possible to offset this calorie deficit if you’re consuming calorie-dense foods during your eating window.”
The premise of intermittent fasting is that you’re meant to be eating nutrient-dense,in relatively normal amounts during the eating timeframe, she added. When you stray away from that with a junk food binge, it’s doubtful you’ll see benefits just from going without eating for 12 hours or more.
The Most Effective Weight Loss Diets, According to Experts
Read on to learn about 10 of the most effective weight loss diets, why they are effective, and who they work best for. 1 Ketogenic Diet
Another caveat is that the study did include men and women, but didn’t differentiate those results. Gillespie said that women generally don’t do as well with this strategy because they tend to be more adaptable to periods of fasting and energy conservation, so it would be interesting to see a study focusing on only women.
Finally, there’s the size of the study—36 participants is considered a modest sample—and the fact that all of the participants were technically classified as “lean” with a body mass index in the low 20s. However, Betts said that the results should not dissuade anyone from trying the tactic, especially if they’re willing to play around with it.
“I do think that different fasting strategies may have different effects,” he said. “For example, whether to vary fasting times each day, how you re-feed, how long you fast, and so on.”
The bottom line? Eat in a way that works best for you and lines up with your own nutrition and training. And, as always, consulting with a sports dietitian or other medical expert is the best way to personalize your diet for best results.
Try 200+ at home workout videos from Men’s Health, Women’s Health, Prevention, and more onfree for 14 days!
One Dangerous Side Effect of Not Getting Enough Vitamin D, Says New Study .
Researchers suggests there's a link between vitamin D deficiency and opioid addiction. Find out what their new study revealed, here.Findings from a new animal study published in the journal Science Advances, suggest that not getting enough of the vitamin may cause people to crave endorphins—the mood-boosting chemical people can get from sun exposure (ultraviolet rays) and exercise. Opioids can mimic a similar effect to neurotransmitters like endorphins, by relieving pain and producing a feeling of euphoria.