Crime He went to prison for killing his 15-year-old girlfriend. New evidence from a bloody shoe may set him free.

15:50  02 december  2019
15:50  02 december  2019 Source:   washingtonpost.com

See the startling video that helped convict Kelsey Berreth's killer

  See the startling video that helped convict Kelsey Berreth's killer New video shows Patrick Frazee's secret girlfriend Krystal Lee at the murder scene showing investigators how she cleaned up after the bloody crimeA national spotlight was trained on a small courthouse in Colorado this week as Patrick Frazee was found guilty of killing his fiancée, Kelsey Berreth, last Thanksgiving. The case had a star witness, Frazee's secret girlfriend, Krystal Lee.

Prosecutors said Nicholas McGuffin killed his 15 - year - old girlfriend in 2000. New evidence from a bloody shoe may set him free . After police found 15 - year - old Leah Freeman’s body dumped off a steep embankment near Coquille, Ore., in 2000, the case sat cold for almost a decade thanks to scant

A man who spent 25 years behind bars for a rape and murder he did not commit walked out of prison a free man after new DNA tests proved police made up evidence against him . Anthony Wright was 20 years old when he was arrested in the horrific sexual assault and killing of 77- year - old Louise Talley

After police found 15-year-old Leah Freeman’s body dumped off a steep embankment near Coquille, Ore., in 2000, the case sat cold for almost a decade thanks to scant physical evidence and no witnesses who had seen Freeman snatched from the street. But prosecutors eventually built a case against Freeman’s boyfriend, using a story of a tumultuous teenage relationship marred by jealousy and one of the only pieces of evidence: Freeman’s blood-splattered Nike sneaker.

a car parked in a parking lot: Coos County prosecutor Paul Frasier convinced a jury to convict Nicholas McGuffin of manslaughter in the death of his 15-year-old girlfriend, Leah Freeman. The verdict was reversed in November.© Google Street View/Google Street View Coos County prosecutor Paul Frasier convinced a jury to convict Nicholas McGuffin of manslaughter in the death of his 15-year-old girlfriend, Leah Freeman. The verdict was reversed in November.

But now, nearly a decade after a split jury convicted Nicholas McGuffin of manslaughter, he may be set free — and that same stained shoe is at the center of his wrongful conviction case.

Judge exonerates three men in 1983 ‘Georgetown jacket’ school killing

  Judge exonerates three men in 1983 ‘Georgetown jacket’ school killing The three men were formally exonerated Monday for the notorious 1983 murder of a junior high school student over a Georgetown basketball jacket. Police and prosecutors had claimed the Georgetown jacket found in Chestnut’s closet belonged to the victim. Now, they acknowledge the jacket had in fact come from his mother. © Provided by WP Company LLC d/b/a The Washington Post ‘It’s unreal’: Three Baltimore men exonerated after 36 years in prison On this month 36 years ago, DeWitt Duckett, a ninth-grader at Harlem Park Junior High School, was shot in his neck inside the West Baltimore school.

He and his 22- year - old girlfriend , Marita Routalampi, drifted throughout Sweden and Finland, eventually After police confronted him with a palm print and a bloody shirt as evidence , Raymond He left the bar, went home, and changed into his uniform. Then he went to his regiment and got an

The 18- year - old was reported to have began a protracted campaign of bullying against the Miss Lelonek, including pinning her against a fence by her 'She went through hell for years, not just the six months they said in court. When she decided to break away from these girls the bullying got worse.'

Subscribe to the Post Most newsletter: Today’s most popular stories on The Washington Post

A judge on Friday found that the state’s crime lab violated McGuffin’s rights by concealing DNA evidence extracted from that shoe, which has reignited speculation about who really killed Freeman.

“Mr. McGuffin has maintained his innocence all along and has fought to prove that the wrong man is in prison,” his lawyer and executive director of the Forensic Justice Project Janis Puracal told the Washington Post. “We believe that the DNA evidence establishes that, and now the court has recognized that the DNA evidence is exculpatory.”

Judge exonerates three men in 1983 ‘Georgetown jacket’ school killing

  Judge exonerates three men in 1983 ‘Georgetown jacket’ school killing After 36 years in prison, Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins and Andrew Stewart were exonerated of murder and released from a Baltimore prison on Nov. 25.

Sentenced to death when he was 15 years old , this was changed to life in solitary confinement after two consecutive governors refused to sign his death Sentenced to death for his third murder, which took place after he escaped from a mental hospital; the sentence was commuted to life in prison .

The 17- year - old reported him six times in the six months before he killed her. Dada pushed her during an argument and she landed on knife in her Versace bag. The family of a teenager who was killed by her boyfriend were dealt another agonising blow today as he was sentenced to just one year in prison .

The Coos County District Attorney’s Office did not immediately return a request for comment late Sunday.

Freeman disappeared on June 28, 2000, after McGuffin dropped her off at her best friend’s house, according to court records obtained by The Washington Post. The friend, Sherrie Mitchell, confronted Freeman over her romance with McGuffin, who was a senior at their high school and three years older than the girls. After the argument, Freeman stormed out of the house.

“I think that he was kind of dangerous and, you know, maybe she liked the danger side of him,” Mitchell told ABC News a decade later.

Around 9 p.m. that night, McGuffin showed up to drive his girlfriend home, but Mitchell told him Freeman had already left. He drove around Coquille in his Mustang, searching for her. Twice, police officers pulled him over for a blown headlight. A witness told the court McGuffin later came to her house to use drugs that night, the Oregonian reported during the trial.

Son of German diplomat, girlfriend paroled 34 years after her parents were murdered in DC home

  Son of German diplomat, girlfriend paroled 34 years after her parents were murdered in DC home Jens Soering and Elizabeth Haysom, two former lovers who met at the University of Virginia, were paroled from jail Monday more than 30 years after they were first convicted in the gruesome slayings of Haysom’s parents in 1985. © AP Photo/Steve Helber, File FILE - In this March 9, 2011 file photo, Jens Soering speaks during an interview at the Buckingham Correctional Center in Dillwyn, Va. For the 14th time, Virginia officials have rejected a parole bid from a Soering, a German diplomat’s son serving life in prison for the 1985 killings of his ex-girlfriend’s parents.

Horace Roberts, 60, was freed from a California prison this month after DNA evidence showed that he had been wrongfully convicted of murder nearly two decades ago.Credit California Innocence 3 after DNA evidence exonerated him in the 1998 killing of his former girlfriend and co-worker.

He was charged in connection with the death of his brother, Michael Kiger, 15 . Michael died several hours after Tyler allegedly punched him in the head. An autopsy revealed that Michael had suffered a fractured skull which lead to bleeding in his brain. Police said the incident occurred after Michael got

Although McGuffin and Freeman’s family immediately started looking for her, police treated her sudden disappearance as a runaway teen case until they found a bloodied shoe almost a week later. It took another month for officers to find Freeman’s body, which had decomposed so severely that a medical examiner could not determine how she had died.

For years, police hit a dead end, until a new police chief reopened the case and brought in outside investigators.

In 2010, the small town’s prosecutor put 100 witnesses in front of a grand jury to indict McGuffin.

Investigators leaned on that deluge of witnesses because police never found DNA, blood stains or eyewitnesses to tie McGuffin to the crime. Prosecutors suggested there was no evidence of blood in McGuffin’s car because he’d thoroughly cleaned the vehicle before officers searched it. And they pointed to a DNA test that they said showed that although McGuffin’s DNA wasn’t on Freeman’s shoes or body, there was no evidence of any other DNA, and therefore no alternative suspect.

McGuffin’s defense attorney argued another man had abducted and killed Freeman, discredited witnesses who may have been motivated to provide damning testimony by a cash reward, and pointed out that the state had failed to tie any physical evidence to him.

DNA on knife handle led to man’s arrest in July killing in east Orange, documents show

  DNA on knife handle led to man’s arrest in July killing in east Orange, documents show Months after a 58-year-old woman was found stabbed to death inside a home on West Jackson Street in east Orange County, her suspected killer was arrested Monday night. Gary Maurice Brumfield Jr., 25, faces a charge of second-degree murder in the killing of Vera Denise Jones. He was booked into the Orange County Jail about 7:15 p.m. If convicted as charged, he faces the possibility of life in prison. Documents made public after Brumfield’s arrests shed light on the circumstances of the woman’s killing, about which the Sheriff’s Office had previously released few details.

A six- year - old boy was killed in a freak accident on Friday after he fell from a plough being driven by his father to clear snow in a camp in Aspen. Herman Slaughter had riding in a Kubota Skid Steer loader on the lap of his father, Nathaniel Slaughter, at the Aspen Grove Family Camp in Provo Canyon when

Joshua Lewis was 18 in February last year when he borrowed a car, lied about having a provisional licence and veered off the road at Longwarry, southeast of Learner driver Joshua Lewis, 18, crashed into a tree, killing 15 - year - old girlfriend . Georgia Larsen died in hospital after the crash in Longwarry

Coos County District Attorney Paul Frasier called it “the toughest case I’ve ever dealt with,” the Oregonian reported during the trial in 2011. But by the time police arrested McGuffin on Aug. 24, 2010, they were so confident they had the right man that law enforcement officials invited a TV crew from ABC News’ “20/20” to film the arrest and trial.

In court, Frasier argued McGuffin believed Freeman was going to dump him, and strangled her in a fit of jealous rage that turned violent. He charged McGuffin with murder, but later added manslaughter to the charges.

“I did that because … I really do not believe Nick McGuffin woke up one morning and said, ‘I have to go out kill Leah Freeman,’” he said in 2011, the Oregonian reported. “An unfortunate set of circumstances came together and Leah ended up dead.”

The decision to include a manslaughter charge also increased the likelihood of a conviction in Oregon, where all 12 jurors must agree to convict on a murder charge, but only 10 need to agree to convict on other felonies.

On July 19, 2011, a decade after Freeman was killed, 10 jurors voted to convict McGuffin of manslaughter instead of murder. He was sentenced to 10 years in prison and sent to a labor camp in the Tillamook State Forest, about 50 miles west of Portland, Ore.

Four years after his conviction, a new lawyer with the Forensic Justice Project, which investigates wrongful convictions based on faulty forensic evidence, took a look at McGuffin’s case. Soon, they found troubling evidence that was never turned over to McGuffin’s criminal defense attorneys.

Two Michigan defenders try to untie Ohio State RB J.K. Dobbins' shoe, get 15-yard penalty

  Two Michigan defenders try to untie Ohio State RB J.K. Dobbins' shoe, get 15-yard penalty Michigan defenders Carlo Kemp and Aidan Hutchinson tried to untie the cleat of Ohio State RB J.K. Dobbins. The stunt earned Michigan 15-yard penalty.Entering Saturday, the Buckeyes had taken seven of the last eight over the Wolverines. Early in the second quarter, running back J.K. Dobbins was running free, and the Michigan defense tried to throw him off by attempting to untie and take off his left shoe.

He is a convicted murderer who was jailed for life in 2004 for killing woman, 21. Right: Amanda Champion – who had the mental age of a 15 - year - old – was found strangled and with her throat cut. After he admitted his crime, the Samaritans worker – who was later forced out of his job – decided to go to police. For no reason whatsoever, he just went out and murdered a disabled person.

At his feet was a bloody four-inch fishing sinker attached to a short piece of line. Twice he came before the state's parole commission and both times it refused to release him . Last May , Michelle Cunningham took the witness stand, unpracticed but prepared to let go of a potentially damning secret.

Puracal, executive director of the Forensic Justice Project, told The Post that DNA analysis from Freeman’s sneaker actually did find an unknown man’s genes in the dried blood stains. The DNA on the shoe didn’t match McGuffin or any of the law enforcement officers who handled the evidence — suggesting that someone else may have killed her.

The analyst at the Oregon Crime Lab who had tested DNA from the shoes knew about the unidentified man’s DNA, but failed to tell police, prosecutors, McGuffin’s defense team, or the jury.

Armed with the new evidence, Puracal and her team filed an appeal on McGuffin’s behalf and went to trial in August.

In court, the crime lab said that in 2001, it had a policy allowing its analysts to withhold evidence of trace amounts of DNA, and argued that the omission did not violate its rules at the time. That claim didn’t impress the judge.

“This case went to trial in 2011,” Malheur County Circuit Court judge Patricia Sullivan wrote in her Friday ruling overturning the conviction. “Significant advances in the detection of trace amounts of DNA occurred in that ten-year period, and by 2011, there is no dispute the results would have been reported at that time, or, that had a defense expert asked, the results would have been disclosed.”

Sullivan found prosecutors and police had made other mistakes as well, like withholding notes from a potentially exculpatory interview, and ruled that, especially in the case of the hidden DNA results, “there is more than a mere possibility” that the jury may have come to a different verdict if it had considered all of the information available in the case.

Puracal said other cases have been tainted when labs encourage analysts to emphasize evidence that helps prosecutors, and downplay evidence that might undermine a case.

“If you have lab folks who are part of the police, their task is to find evidence” to support the prosecution’s case, Puracal said. “I’m firmly convinced we will never know how many cases in Oregon fall under that same policy,” she said.

Sullivan’s decision now sends McGuffin’s case back to prosecutors, who now have to decide whether to appeal, retry the case with the DNA evidence or dismiss the charges against McGuffin.

McGuffin is set to be released as early as Aug. 22, 2020, if the court does not clear his name first.

Texas inmate executed for killing prison supervisor in 2003 .
A Texas inmate was executed by lethal injection Wednesday evening for killing a supervisor at a state prison shoe factory in Amarillo nearly 17 years ago. Travis Runnels, 46, was convicted of slashing the throat of 38-year-old Stanley Wiley on Jan. 29, 2003. Runnels was executed at the state penitentiary in Huntsville. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!