Offbeat: Justice Kavanaugh unlikely to heed calls for recusal - PressFrom - US
  •   
  •   
  •   

Offbeat Justice Kavanaugh unlikely to heed calls for recusal

15:26  11 october  2018
15:26  11 october  2018 Source:   reuters.com

Kavanaugh sworn in as Supreme Court justice

  Kavanaugh sworn in as Supreme Court justice The Latest on Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh (all times local):6:20 p.m.Brett Kavanaugh has taken the oaths of office to become the 114th Supreme Court justice, just a couple of hours after the Senate voted 50-48 to confirm him.The quick swearing in enables Kavanaugh to begin work immediately in advance of arguments at the court Tuesday in two cases involving prison sentences for repeat offenders.The court says Kavanaugh took the oath required by the Constitution and another for judges that is part of federal law in the same room where the justices meet for their private conferences.The 53-year-old justice's wife, children and parents were in attendance.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged U.S. Supreme Court cases in which his Recusal demands by Kavanaugh critics including Democratic lawmakers and liberal commentators focused on two main areas: certain cases involving

Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged U.S. Supreme Court cases in which his U.S. law requires justices to step aside when there is a conflict of interest or genuine question of bias, but it leaves the recusal decision in the hands of

Slideshow by photo services

National Council of Churches calls for Kavanaugh's nomination to be withdrawn

  National Council of Churches calls for Kavanaugh's nomination to be withdrawn The nation's largest group of Christian churches on Wednesday called for the withdrawal of Brett Kavanaugh's nomination for the Supreme Court.The National Council of Churches, which represents 38 denominations in the US, wrote in a statement on their website that they believe Kavanaugh has "disqualified himself fromThe National Council of Churches, which represents 38 denominations in the US, wrote in a statement on their website that they believe Kavanaugh has "disqualified himself from this lifetime appointment and must step aside immediately.

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged U.S. Supreme Recusal demands by Kavanaugh critics including Democratic lawmakers and liberal commentators focused on two main areas: certain cases involving

Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged U.S. Supreme Court cases in which his fairness and independence might be questioned after a divisive confirmation fight, according to legal experts. Kavanaugh , Republican President Donald Trump.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged U.S. Supreme Court cases in which his fairness and independence might be questioned after a divisive confirmation fight, according to legal experts.

U.S. law requires justices to step aside when there is a conflict of interest or genuine question of bias, but it leaves the recusal decision in the hands of the individual justices.

Kavanaugh, Republican President Donald Trump's conservative nominee who was confirmed by the Senate on Saturday to a lifetime job as one of the nine justices, took part in his first arguments in Supreme Court cases on Tuesday and Wednesday.

Trump calls Kavanaugh allegations a 'hoax'

  Trump calls Kavanaugh allegations a 'hoax' The president on Monday blasted recent calls for impeachment of the newest Supreme Court justice."I've been hearing that that now they're talking about impeaching a brilliant jurist, a man that did nothing wrong, a man that was caught up in a hoax set up by the Democrats using the Democrats' lawyers, and now they want to impeach him," Trump said on the South Lawn of the White House as he left to give a speech to a police chiefs group in Orlando.

“ Kavanaugh Backs Trump Administration on Jailing and Deporting” Criminals! and, “ Justice Kavanaugh Unlikely to Heed Calls for Recusal .” The left is demanding Kavanaugh recuse himself from everything because of the Blasey Ford situation and his sordid past, his drunkardness

Justice Brett Kavanaugh is unlikely to heed calls by critics to step aside from certain politically charged Supreme Court cases in which his fairness and independence might be questioned after a divisive confirmation fight, according to legal experts.

"Supreme Court justices rarely recuse," University of Michigan Law School professor Richard Primus said. "For Kavanaugh to recuse would be for him to say, 'Yes, I understand you don't trust me ... and I validate that concern.' He's not going to say that."

Federal law requires a justice to disqualify himself from deciding cases "in which his impartiality might reasonably be questioned." In a 2011 report, conservative Chief Justice John Roberts said he had "complete confidence in the capability of my colleagues to determine when recusal is warranted."

Recusal demands by Kavanaugh critics including Democratic lawmakers and liberal commentators focused on two main areas: certain cases involving Trump himself; and cases involving Democratic Party lawmakers or interests, considering Kavanaugh's angry remarks about Democrats during a Sept. 27 Senate hearing. Some also have suggested Kavanaugh should step aside in cases on women's issues in light of sexual misconduct allegations made against him last month. He denied the allegations.

Trump to delay Rosenstein meeting until after Kavanaugh process

  Trump to delay Rosenstein meeting until after Kavanaugh process President Trump said Tuesday that he would delay his meeting with Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein until after Supreme Court nomineee Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation process. "I don't want to interrupt what's happening with Judge Kavanaugh," Trump told reporters on the South Lawn Tuesday afternoon.Trump also said he had spoken wi th Rosenstein, who The New York Times reported last month had discussed wearing a wire to record Trump as part of a possible effort to seek his removal from office under the 25th Amendment. Rosenstein has said the Times story was false.

For a Justice Kavanaugh to participate in internal court discussion or oral argument of such cases, much less vote on their resolution, would involve not just My decades of observing the court’s work and arguing cases there convince me that his required recusal would extend to a very broad slice of

Kavanaugh will “pledge to be independent-minded in the event he has to make such a consideration, as all justices do," a White House official involved with the process told ABC It's unlikely such an assurance will placate Democrats' concerns, though their ability to block the nomination remains limited.

Over the years, justices across the political spectrum have been pressed by critics to recuse themselves in cases with perceived conflicts. Litigants can file motions seeking recusal but rarely do.

During the 2016 presidential race, liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg criticized then-candidate Trump as a "faker," prompting cries by conservative critics of bias. Ginsburg later expressed regret for her remarks but has not stepped aside from any case involving Trump. And no litigant has asked her to.

Despite calls from some conservatives for her to recuse herself, liberal Justice Elena Kagan participated in a 2012 ruling upholding President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act, the healthcare law dubbed Obamacare. Kagan had served as Obama's top Supreme Court advocate when the law was enacted in 2010 but said she played no role in its conception.

Kagan, appointed to the court by Obama later in 2010, recused herself from other cases on which she had worked in Obama's administration. For example, she stepped aside when the court twice upheld the use of race as a factor in university student admissions, a policy known as affirmative action.

Brett Kavanaugh to Be Sworn In as a Supreme Court Justice Today

  Brett Kavanaugh to Be Sworn In as a Supreme Court Justice Today Brett Kavanaugh will be sworn in as associate justice of the Supreme Court later today, according to a statement from the high court, after the U.S. Senate confirmed President Donald Trump’s nominee to replace the retired Justice Anthony Kennedy. Chief Justice John Roberts will administer the constitutional oath, and Kennedy will administer the judicial oath in what the court says will be a private ceremony. That will let Kavanaugh begin work immediately and start hearing cases this week.To contact the reporter on this story: Catherine Dodge in New York at [email protected]

Brett Kavanaugh has become the fifth conservative judge in America’s highest court, after being narrowly confirmed by senators and quickly sworn in amid protests in the Some screams could be heard in the gallery ahead of the vote, with Vice President Mike Pence calling for order to be restored.

McConnell calls Kavanaugh opposition a "great political gift" for GOP. Vice President Mike Pence also tweeted his support for Kavanaugh on Friday. Pence often presides over momentous votes in the Senate, and is expected to preside over the vote to confirm Kavanaugh on Saturday.

'POLITICAL HIT'

Some liberal activists and Democratic lawmakers have pointed to Kavanaugh's Senate Judiciary Committee testimony responding to a university professor's allegation that he sexually assaulted her in 1982 as evidence of his partisanship. He repeatedly assailed Democrats, prompting questions about whether he could be fair in disputes involving Democrats or liberal groups.

Kavanaugh complained of "a calculated and orchestrated political hit" by Democrats fueled by their anger over Trump's 2016 election victory, and called the conduct of some Democratic senators "an embarrassment."

Democrats including Senator Mazie Hirono and Representative Jerrold Nadler have called on Kavanaugh to step aside from any case involving Democratic lawmakers.

New York University School of Law legal ethics expert Stephen Gillers said Kavanaugh's remarks were "too broad and unfocused to give anyone the basis for a recusal motion."

During his confirmation hearings, Kavanaugh refused to be pinned down on whether he would recuse himself in cases involving Trump such as Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation into potential collusion between Trump's presidential campaign and Russia.

"One key facet of the independence of the judiciary is not to make commitments on particular cases," including on recusal, Kavanaugh told Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal.

Trump: Kavanaugh is 'going to make us all very proud'

  Trump: Kavanaugh is 'going to make us all very proud' President Trump voiced his confidence in Brett Kavanaugh on Saturday shortly before the Senate was poised to confirm him to the Supreme Court. "I think he's going to make us all very proud," Trump told reporters before leaving Washington for a rally in Kansas on Saturday evening. "I think he is going to be a great, great Supreme Court justice for many years." Trump acknowledged the bitter months-long Senate confirmation proce ss for Kavanaugh, including partisan brawling this week over a supplemental FBI investigation into allegations of sexual assault against the nominee.

Brett Michael Kavanaugh (/ˈkævənɔː/; born February 12, 1965) is an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He previously served as a United States Circuit Judge of the United States

But because Kavanaugh is unlikely to recuse himself, any party that asks him to do so risks angering him and hurting its chances before the court. Whichever court Kavanaugh is on, the specter of his remarks is likely to hang over the decisions he makes about liberal or Democratic groups or individuals.

If Kavanaugh recused himself in such cases, the court would go from a 5-4 conservative majority to an ideological deadlock with four conservative justices and four liberals.

Kristen Clarke, president of the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law advocacy group, said she expected a "sharp increase" in recusal motions regarding Kavanaugh on a range of issues, possibly including women's rights. Kavanaugh could become a pivotal justice on issues including abortion.

Justices commonly step aside in cases that pose financial conflicts, for example owning stock in a company involved in the litigation.

In 2004, the Sierra Club environmental group asked conservative Justice Antonin Scalia to step aside in a case concerning then-Vice President Dick Cheney, a friend of the justice. Scalia refused, saying he did not think his impartiality could reasonably be questioned.

Emmet Bondurant, a lawyer involved in a major political case heading toward the court involving a challenge to Republican-drawn congressional districts in North Carolina, said he will not seek Kavanaugh's recusal.

"One has to assume that no matter what was said during the confirmation process that he will approach each case, including this case, with an open mind," Bondurant said.

Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; editing by Sue Horton and Will Dunham

This Is Brett Kavanaugh's First Question as a Supreme Court Justice .
Kavanaugh asked his first question about 20 minutes into the first argument of the day . require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); Seated on the far right end of the bench, Kavanaugh listened alongside his eight colleagues to Stokeling v. United States, a case about whether a state robbery offense should be classified as a “violent felony” under the 1984 Armed Career Criminal Act, which is a criminal sentencing law that increases prison sentences after multiple violent felonies.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 3
This is interesting!