OffbeatAs Trump dismisses climate change report, California plans to use it against him
Buried? Feds to release major climate report day after Thanksgiving
The federal government will release a major climate change report – Volume II of the National Climate Assessment – on Black Friday.
WASHINGTON - The ominous climate change report the Trump administration released on Thanksgiving weekend could provide legal ammunition for states such as California, which are suing or threatening to sue the federal government over weakened regulations on fossil-fuel industries, automobiles and other contributors to a warming climate.
U.S. report to detail costs of climate change as Trump downplays threat
U.S. report to detail costs of climate change as Trump downplays threat
"Absolutely, we will use every bit of that report," California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said Wednesday in Washington, where he appeared with acting Environmental Protection Agency administrator Andrew Wheeler.
In line with the administration's position, Wheeler downplayed the report, known as the Fourth National Climate Assessment, saying it was launched during the Obama administration, assembled by career federal employees and did not reflect Trump's economic priorities.
Ocasio-Cortez on climate change report: People will die if we don't act now
Rep.-elect Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) called on the U.S. to act "urgent[ly]" after a report from the federal government found that climate change is expected to have an enormous impact on the country in the near future. In a Twitter post, the New York Democrat reissued her call for a special House caucus on climate change, a demand that some progressive activists have called for in the wake of Democrats' takeover of the House. "People are going to die if we don't start addressing climate change ASAP," wrote Ocasio-Cortez on Friday following the report's release. "It's not enough to think it's 'important.' We must make it urgent.
California has filed more than 20 environmental lawsuits against the Trump administration the last two years, joining other states in challenging rollbacks on methane emissions, hydraulic fracking and fuel efficiency standards for automobiles. More lawsuits are expected as the EPA finalizes rules to weaken the Clean Power Plan - an Obama-era rule aimed at reducing pollution from coal plants - and revoke California's authority to set its own vehicle tailpipe standards.
Some of this litigation hinges on whether the EPA must regulate greenhouse gas emissions and protect public safety under the Clean Air Act. Following a landmark Supreme Court decision, the EPA in 2009 issued what is known as the "Endangerment Finding," which requires the agency to take action to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide, methane and other heat-trapping gases. Trump's EPA has not challenged that finding, meaning that it is obligated to comply.
Al Gore and Environmental Groups Accuse Trump of 'Burying' Climate Report With Black Friday Release
The federal government report was released without fanfare Friday, when many Americans headed to the stores for the Black Friday sales. Compiled as a result of collaboration by more than 300 federal government and independent scientists, the report warns that unchecked climate change will impact human health, safety, and cost the country hundreds of billions of dollars. The report was reviewed by 13 federal agencies.
David Hayes, a deputy Interior secretary during the Obama and Clinton administrations, said the recent climate assessment details threats to public safety posed by climate change, which California and other states are sure to cite as they make their arguments in court.
"This provides more ammunition for lawsuits that are out there asking the EPA to take action," said Hayes, who now heads the State Energy and Environmental Impact Center, which assists attorneys generals on environmental matters.
Jeff Holmstead, a Washington-based lawyer and assistant EPA administrator during the George W. Bush administration, said that litigants will no doubt cite the federal report.
But some of the ongoing litigation and policymaking, he said, involves questions of whether the Obama administration exceeded its authority in setting regulations, such as the Clean Power Plan. The Trump administration is now modifying rules on those grounds, he said.
"This report won't be relevant in those situations," said Holmstead, a partner with the Bracewell law firm in Washington, D.C.
Trump dismisses findings of U.S. government report on climate change
U.S. President Donald Trump said on Monday he had read parts of a U.S. government report projecting that climate change will cost the country's economy billions of dollars by the end of the century, but he does not believe the economic impacts will be devastating. "I've seen it, I've read some of it, and it's fine," he told reporters at the White House. Asked about severe economic impacts, he said, "I don't believe it." Last year, Trump announced he would withdraw the United States from the 2015 Paris Deal to combat climate change.
Becerra and the EPA's Wheeler appeared separately Wednesday at an energy event organized by The Washington Post.
Both were asked about the federal climate assessment, which assembled a range of studies to forecast impacts of climate on different parts of the country, and under different scenarios of expected warming. Some of the most dire forecasts involved California and the Southwest, which could experience a tripling of large fires, heat wave fatalities and water shortages according to the report.
Wheeler said he believed that "man has an impact on climate," as does carbon dioxide. He said that the president's main concern was that media, citing the report, projected that climate change could significantly damage the nation's economy.
Wheeler, a former industry lobbyist, added that he hadn't read the report before it was released and made no effort to review it. "If we had intervened and made changes to the report we would have been accused of manipulating the scientific recommendations of the career staff," he said.
Since releasing the climate assessment on Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, the Trump administration has worked to discredit its findings.
In a briefing Tuesday, White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said the report, compiled by 14 federal agencies, was "not based on facts." Trump, in an interview with the Post later that day, said he doesn't see impacts of climate change, and sees himself as part of a group of people with "very high levels of intelligence" who are non-believers in the reported science.
White House: Federal climate change report 'not based on facts'
White House press secretary Sarah Sanders denounced a new climate-change report as "not data driven" and "not based on facts," sharpening the Trump administration's repudiation of the document crafted by 13 federal agencies. Sanders denounced the National Climate Assessment during a Tuesday press briefing, defending President Trump's publicly expressed doubt about its warning of potentially severe ocean-level rises and associated economic costs. "You have to look at the fact that this report is based on the most extreme modeled scenario, which contradicts long-established trends," Sanders said.
Becerra said he looks forward to using the report in litigation his office has filed against the administration, along with other attorneys general.
"In this particular case, the facts speak dramatically, and it comes out of his own shop," said Becerra. "For him to not read the report, to ignore what it says, it just confirms what disturbs so many people about the Oval Office."
Neither Becerra nor Wheeler gave any indication if the EPA and California are close to striking a deal on greenhouse gas emissions for automobile fleets.
The EPA and Department of Transportation want to roll back emissions requirements agreed upon by California and the EPA in the Obama administration. California has threatened to go with its own standards, prompting the Trump administration to threaten to revoke California's authority to set pollution rules stronger than the federal government's.
If the two sides can't reach a settlement, it could lead to years of litigation. It could also force U.S. auto companies to make plans for two separate sets of automobiles - one for California and states that have adopted its rules, and one for the rest of the country.
Becerra said Wednesday he's confident California will prevail in any litigation. But if the case ultimately reaches the Supreme Court, as many expect, the addition of Justice Brett Kavanaugh makes the outcome much less certain than when Justice Anthony Kennedy was the court's swing vote.
"California and the Trump administration and auto companies all have an incentive to work something out," said Holmstead, the former EPA official.
"The auto companies would like to have the certainty on a one-nation program. California doesn't necessarily want to roll the dice with the courts ... and the Trump administration wants something that is sensible for the auto industry. So I still think there is a decent chance we will see some kind of compromise."
Visit the McClatchy Washington Bureau at
Leaders gather for key UN climate talks in Poland.
Leaders from around the world are arriving for the ceremonial opening of the climate conference in southern Poland that will discuss ways of curbing climate change. The two-week conference in Katowice is expected to work out how governments can report on their efforts to reduce green gas emission and keep global warming well below 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit), as agreed in 2015 in Paris. Host Poland will propose a declaration Monday for a "just transition" away from coal mining, the supplier of its main source of energy, to take into consideration the situation of people employed in the sector.
See The Climate Report That Shreds Donald Trump’s Science Denials | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC
Ari Melber breaks down a new U.N. report that says climate change will soon threaten millions of Americans despite Trump's repeated claims of a “hoax.
CNN 's Martin Savidge ShOCKED TRUMP refutes MAN-MADE climate change | CNN BREAKING NEW
CNN 's Martin Savidge ShOCKED TRUMP refutes MAN-MADE climate change | CNN BREAKING NEW CNN NEW DAY [6AM] 11/24/2018 | CNN BREAKING ...