•   
  •   
  •   

OffbeatSome experts believe Trump can be impeached for conduct performed before becoming president

15:41  06 december  2018
15:41  06 december  2018 Source:   washingtonexaminer.com

Both political parties guilty of weaponizing impeachment

Both political parties guilty of weaponizing impeachment The criminal justice system must not be used to even scores or further the interests of one side. Both parties have been guilty of trying to weaponize the criminal justice system. Some Democrats want to investigate and possibly prosecute Ivanka Trump for using her personal email for government business. As the Guardian put it, "what goes around comes around." The chant of "lock her up" cuts both ways. Former FBI director James Comey was right in concluding the sloppiness of Hillary Clinton in using a private email server should not be prosecuted. (He was wrong, however, in the way he handled the matter.

A movement to impeach Trump for allegedly violating constitutional bans on receiving certain gifts What can a president be impeached for ? Maybe Trump would be more likely to get out of the way and avoid all or some impeachment proceedings – in this truly hypothetical scenario – if Trump felt

Can President Trump be impeached for money laundering he did before he became President ? By and large though, it does appear that a president can be impeached for crimes they committed prior to becoming the president .

Some experts believe Trump can be impeached for conduct performed before becoming president© Provided by MediaDC: Washington Newspaper Publishing Company, Inc.

Michael Cohen’s recent plea deal with special counsel Robert Mueller revealing more about President Trump's involvement in a possible real estate project in Moscow has sparked whispers of impeachment from Trump's critics once again, and some legal experts say a president can be ousted, at least under certain circumstances, for conduct performed before taking the oath of office.

“My view, which represents the decisive majority opinion, is that President Trump can be impeached for conduct before he took office if there is an exceptionally close connection between that conduct and his acquisition of the office,” Joshua Matz, an author of To End a Presidency: The Power of Impeachment, told the Washington Examiner.

Ivanka Trump defends her use of a private email account

Ivanka Trump defends her use of a private email account President Donald Trump's daughter told ABC News that using the private email account cannot be compared to the flap over Hillary Clinton's private email server. Ivanka Trump says her private account emails were archived and contained no classified information. She says she didn't delete any of them. The Washington Post reported this month that she used the personal email account to conduct official government business. Republicans and Democrats in Congress say they're reviewing the situation to make sure she complied with federal records law. Clinton says she never knowingly emailed classified information.

Whether president can be removed from office turns on politics as well as legal questions. The bigger issue is whether his conduct could lead him to being impeached . This is a political process While some Democratic lawmakers have claimed that Mr Trump may be mentally unfit to continue in

Only two presidents have ever been impeached in the history of the US, and it's not who you think. As an analysis piece the BBC ran at the time noted, "in their eagerness to bring down the president , they never stopped to think whether the charges could be proved beyond reasonable doubt".

Generally, he continued, “presidents cannot be impeached for conduct before they take office unless that conduct related to the corrupt acquisition of the office.” But other experts say the exception is even broader.

Federal prosecutors revealed last week that Cohen had cut a deal with Mueller’s team, and appearing in federal court, Trump’s longtime lawyer pleaded guilty to lying to Congress about plans for a Trump-branded tower in Moscow.

Cohen initially told congressional investigators consideration of the Moscow project ended in January 2016. But according to court records, discussions about the potential deal continued as late as June 2016, after Trump clinched the Republican presidential nomination.

Documents also revealed Cohen discussed with Trump during the campaign a trip to Russia and spoke to a top member of the Trump campaign about potential travel.

Trump’s latest tweets cross clear lines, experts say: Obstruction of justice and witness tampering

Trump’s latest tweets cross clear lines, experts say: Obstruction of justice and witness tampering George Conway and others suggest that Trump's tweets might be obstruction. Here's what we know.

It’s really hard to impeach a president . The founders included the provision, from the very start, as the weakest, “break the glass in case of Richard Nixon resigned before a vote in the full House could be taken. Sunstein assesses his articles of impeachment thus: not impeachable for evading taxes (too

Can Trump be impeached under this definition? The biggest charge in the impeachment case against Trump right now is his business and the conflicts of interest it causes.

Cohen’s revelations about the discussions over a Trump-branded tower in Moscow stand in contrast to the president’s statements denying business ties to Moscow. In January 2017, Trump told reporters he had “no dealings with Russia.”

In addressing whether a president can be impeached for conduct prior to assuming office, legal experts point to the 2010 impeachment of former U.S. District Judge G. Thomas Porteous. Porteous was convicted of four articles of impeachment, which included conduct while he was a state-court judge.

Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, cited Porteous’ case when discussing whether sitting officials can be ousted for offenses committed before acquiring higher office.

“We now by constitutional terms — in a country that rarely has impeachment trials — have a precedent that you can be impeached and removed from office both for prior crimes and for lying under oath,” Schiff said during an event in October.

Democrats shouldn't try to impeach Trump — yet

Democrats shouldn't try to impeach Trump — yet Donald Trump is a bad man and a bad president, a "leader" whose main redeeming quality appears to be that he's too lazy and undisciplined to effectively implement all of his cruel and anti-democratic ideas. The sooner he leaves office, the better off Americans will be. But Democrats should hold off impeaching him — for now. There was a flowering of impeachment talk over the weekend, after prosecutors not-so-indirectly accused Trump of committing a felony. The crime? Violating campaign finance laws during his presidential campaign by directing hush-money payments to porn stars he'd allegedly slept with.

Experts : Trump is edging closer to ' impeachment territory'. The flood of bombshell reports against the president has prompted some lawmakers and pundits to ask a version of the same question: Can Trump be impeached for indiscretions that critics believe jeopardize national security and may

However, some Constitutional experts believe these laws would not stand up in court. Don’t hold your breathe on this one either, especially because Trump comes into office with both a GOP controlled House and Senate, but there is always the possibility that he could be impeached once he takes over.

Gene Healy, a vice president at the Cato Institute who focuses on executive power and the role of the presidency, said Porteous’ case provides a model for answering the question of impeachment for pre-presidential misconduct.

“When you understand that the impeachment process fundamentally goes to fitness for office, you can’t draw a bright line that says anything that happened before this certain date when the president assumed office, you get a clean slate and the clock starts after an election or confirmation,” Healy told the Washington Examiner. “That’s not the way it’s supposed to work.”

Because impeachment deals with whether one is fit for office, “it stands to reason that conduct that occurred before somebody assumes their post, when it’s exposed, is relevant to that kind of inquiry,” he added.

“We need to go one level below or unpack by one level what it means to have a business deal with a foreign power,” Jeffrey Engel, co-author of the book Impeachment: An American History, told the Washington Examiner. “Obviously that means that the foreign power has some financial interest or financial sway and you could be influenced by money. And we certainly know the president is influenced by money.”

Trump concerned about being impeached, sees it as a 'real possibility,' source says

Trump concerned about being impeached, sees it as a 'real possibility,' source says President Donald Trump has expressed concern that he could be impeached when Democrats take over the House, a source close to the President told CNN Monday. The source said Trump sees impeachment as a "real possibility." require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); But Trump isn't certain it will happen, the source added.

Though impeachment is extremely rare, some legal experts say Trump 's unresolved business entanglements are "not something we've seen before " and Trump could also face impeachment if he is found to have colluded with the Russian government or obstructed the intelligence community's

Learn about the only two presidents impeached by the House and why they were never convicted by the Senate. Only the most serious of offenses should ever be pursued under mechanisms for impeaching a president , and they are spelled out in the Constitution of the United States: "treason

“Secondly, it also gives them classic opportunities to blackmail the president because Trump said numerous times on the campaign trail, ‘I have no foreign dealings with Russia,’” he continued. “If that’s not true, then the Russians at any time could choose to disclose that information and provide proof.”

Healy and other legal experts also point to the Constitutional Convention in 1787, when George Mason argued a president who has obtained the office through corrupt means should not be allowed to escape punishment.

The circumstances of Porteous’ impeachment reflected the concerns the founders had regarding obtaining an office through fraudulent means, as one of the articles of impeachment said he lied to the Senate and FBI to obtain his seat on the federal bench, according to a September report from Healy.

Michael Gerhardt, a professor at the University of North Carolina School of Law, said that in following Porteous’ case, a president can be removed for actions before assuming office if that conduct “were similar to a kind of fraud or if it could be viewed as defrauding the American people to secure the office.”

“It wouldn’t just be the misconduct, but the fact that the people weren’t given the chance to take that into consideration when voting on the president,” he told the Washington Examiner.

“What the Founders really cared about was trust and integrity,” Engel said.

But despite the criticism over the president’s pursuit of a real estate project in Moscow, Matz said that conduct is not sufficient to support articles of impeachment, and neither is lying about his business dealings there.

Further investigation from the special counsel’s office and Congress is needed, he said.

"There are credible allegations of serious wrongdoing and abusive power that merit further investigation, but at this point, a sufficient factual record does not yet exist to justify the filing of articles of impeachment against the president,” Matz said.

Last week, the president dismissed the allegations from Cohen, claiming his former lawyer was lying to secure a lesser sentence and arguing that running for president didn’t preclude him from pursuing business deals.

The new Democratic House chairs are likely to face pressure from their base to move toward efforts to remove the president from office. Still, House Democratic leaders claim they have left pursuing impeachment of Trump off their to-do list for the next Congress, when they take control of the lower chamber.

ABC’s Stephanopoulos teases first interview with Cohen post-sentencing.
ABC's George Stephanopoulos on Thursday teased a new interview with President Trump's former lawyer Michael Cohen, the first interview since Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison. The interview is set to air during Friday's "Good Morning America." "Just sat down with Michael Cohen for his first response to sentencing and President Trump. Watch tomorrow on @GMA," Stephanopoulos tweeted. Just sat d first response to sentencing and President Trump. Watch tomorrow on @GMApic.twitter.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!