Opinion: Brett Kavanaugh Just Declared War on Roe v. Wade - PressFrom - US

OpinionBrett Kavanaugh Just Declared War on Roe v. Wade

17:51  08 february  2019
17:51  08 february  2019 Source:   slate.com

Key GOP Senator Who Provided 50th Vote to Confirm Brett Kavanaugh 'Not Prepared' to Support Donald Trump in 2020

Key GOP Senator Who Provided 50th Vote to Confirm Brett Kavanaugh 'Not Prepared' to Support Donald Trump in 2020 Moderate Republican Susan Collins of Maine in an interview with "PBS Newshour" declined to say whether she would be backing President Donald Trump.

“I view Roe v . Wade as being settled law,” Collins told reporters shortly after Kennedy’s retirement. He returned to those three justices later in his dissent, in a passage that should be extremely concerning for anyone holding out hope that if confirmed, Kavanaugh would leave Roe untouched.

Roe v . Wade , 410 U.S. 113 (1973), is a landmark decision issued in 1973 by the United States Supreme Court on the issue of the constitutionality of laws that criminalized or restricted access to

Brett Kavanaugh Just Declared War on Roe v. Wade© Provided by The Slate Group LLC U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh Pool/Getty Images

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

On Thursday night, the Supreme Court blocked a stringent Louisiana abortion law by a 5–4 vote, with Chief Justice John Roberts joining the liberals to keep the measure on hold. Roberts’ vote is surprising, but not a total shock: The Louisiana statute is a direct violation of the Supreme Court’s 2016 ruling in Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, and until the court overturns that decision, the Louisiana law cannot take effect. To Roberts, this precedent matters. To Justice Brett Kavanaugh, it does not. Kavanaugh so disagreed with the majority that he wrote a dissent explaining why the Louisiana law should be allowed to move forward—an opinion that should not be taken as anything less than a declaration of war on Roe v. Wade.

Collins boasts best fundraising quarter after Kavanaugh vote

Collins boasts best fundraising quarter after Kavanaugh vote Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) had the best fundraising quarter of her career in office after her pivotal vote to appoint Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court. 

Brett Kavanaugh 's abortion stance has provoked concern on the left and the right as some feel Roe v . Wade hangs in the balance. He hasn’t said much specifically about Roe v . Wade though in public forums. He was cautious about what he said about Roe during his previous confirmation hearing to

Brett Kavanaugh looks on as Donald Trump announces him as his nominee to the Supreme Court in But there is little doubt that Kavanaugh will gut Roe at the first opportunity. Indeed, he has already provided In an irate conclusion, Kavanaugh condemned his colleagues for declaring that “unlawful

Thursday’s case, June Medical Services v. Gee, should be an easy one. It is a challenge to a Louisiana law that is nearly identical to the Texas statute invalidated in Whole Woman’s Health. Louisiana, like Texas, compelled its abortion providers to obtain surgical privileges at a hospital within 30 miles of their clinic. These privileges are often difficult if not impossible to obtain—hospitals can, and do, deny them because they oppose abortion. More importantly, they provide absolutely no medical benefit to women, as the Supreme Court ruled in Whole Woman’s Health. Because these measures impose a substantial burden on abortion providers (and their patients) while providing no benefit to women, the court found them to be unconstitutional.

Kavanaugh accuser Christine Blasey Ford nominated for courage award by Rep. Jackie Speier

Kavanaugh accuser Christine Blasey Ford nominated for courage award by Rep. Jackie Speier Rep. Jackie Speier is nominating Christine Blasey Ford "who sacrificed so much to do what was right for our country and for the pursuit of truth."

Trump’s supreme court nominee was grilled on abortion, gun rights and presidential power on the second day of his hearing.

When Donald Trump was sworn in, he inherited a vacant Supreme Court seat that Mitch McConnell held up for nearly an entire year to prevent Obama from

Then, in 2018, Justice Anthony Kennedy, who cast the fifth vote in Whole Woman’s Health, retired. He was replaced by Kavanaugh, who has a history of upholding abortion restrictions while claiming fidelity to Roe. In anticipation of Kavanaugh refusing to apply abortion precedents, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused to enforceWhole Woman’s Health. Instead, it asserted (falsely) that the Louisiana law does provide some benefit to women (it does not) and that it doesn’t impose a serious burden. (It does: The law would likely shutter two of Louisiana’s three abortion clinics.) Clearly, the conservative 5th Circuit thought it could overturn Whole Woman’s Health on its own, and trust the Supreme Court to play along.

In the lead-up to this week’s decision, Roberts’ vote was an open question. I wrote last week that his “vote on this emergency appeal will reveal how aggressively the chief justice wants to attack abortion access—and whether he’s willing to sacrifice the rule of law to nullify Roe as fast as possible.” On Thursday, we got our answer. While the chief justice dissented from Whole Woman’s Health, he does not seem disposed to let a lower court simply ignore it.

Virginia lt. gov. retains Kavanaugh's lawyers. His accuser hires Christine Blasey Ford's.

Virginia lt. gov. retains Kavanaugh's lawyers. His accuser hires Christine Blasey Ford's. The two law firms that represented Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh and his accuser Christine Blasey Ford are involved in another high-profile sexual assault accusation -- this time in Virginia. require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); The law firm that represented Kavanaugh during his contentious confirmation hearings last fall is representing embattled Virginia Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax as he defends himself against allegations of sexual assault.

Brett Kavanaugh 's abortion beliefs, as gleaned from his record, indicates that he'd likely vote to strip what remains of Roe 's promises. Advocates fear that replacing him with a Trump appointee could be the final step in the conservative movement's strenuous efforts to do away with Roe v . Wade for good.

The Senate confirmed Brett Kavanaugh , 53, to the Supreme Court Saturday, where he could easily serve for more than two decades and change how Collins discussed Roe v . Wade with Kavanaugh . Red-state Dems under pressure for SCOTUS vote. Video raises questions about Kavanaugh 's views.

Kavanaugh feels quite differently. In his dissent, he focused on the fact that, according to the 5th Circuit, Louisiana’s abortion providers did not try hard enough to obtain surgical privileges. That should not matter, because Whole Woman’s Health says the requirement that doctors get privileges in order to perform abortions is unconstitutional, as it bestows no benefit onto patients. Kavanaugh, though, disregarded that conclusion and wrote that the doctors should work harder to get these pointless privileges.

The most astounding aspect of Kavanaugh’s dissent is its credulous belief in Louisiana’s ostensible benevolence toward abortion clinics. He noted that, if the law takes effect, “there will be a 45-day regulatory transition” before it is applied. He also says that Louisiana promised not to “move aggressively to enforce the challenged law” during this period. Kavanaugh accepted the state’s pinky-promise not to swiftly close the clinics—even though they have spent months fighting for the ability to do precisely that. At the end of 45 days, the justice wrote, if the doctors still can’t obtain the privileges, they can go back to district court and start the fight anew.

Illinois lawmakers pass two bills to "modernize" abortion laws

Illinois lawmakers pass two bills to The bills are part of a handful around the country that addresses abortion, spurred by uncertainty surrounding the fate of Roe v. Wade . require(["medianetNativeAdOnArticle"], function (medianetNativeAdOnArticle) { medianetNativeAdOnArticle.getMedianetNativeAds(true); }); Illinois' first bill, dubbed the "Reproductive Health Act," would repeal a host of non-functioning anti-abortion access laws that live on the state's law books. Even though Roe v.

Brett Michael Kavanaugh (/ˈkævənɔː/; born February 12, 1965) is an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States He previously served as a United States Circuit Judge of the United States

Brett Kavanaugh hasn’t even been confirmed to the Supreme Court, and lower-court judges have already declared war on Roe v . Wade . On Monday morning, the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued an astonishing decision upholding a law that’s virtually identical to an anti-abortion measure

This is classic Kavanaugh. On the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Kavanaugh had a penchant for pretending to apply Roe while finding arbitrary reasons to uphold abortion restrictions. Kavanaugh let the Trump administration prevent an undocumented minor from terminating her pregnancy, on the laughable theory that she could find a sponsor who would remove her from government custody, where she could reassert control over her body. It was a pseudo-moderate procedural solution that had the effect of denying the undocumented minor abortion access altogether. Here, Kavanaugh made the same play, pretending like he’d found a reasonable middle ground that, in reality, serves to rubber-stamp unconstitutional abortion laws.

No one should mistake Kavanaugh’s dissent as a genuine compromise. There will always be a way to uphold an abortion law while insisting that somehow, someday, women might still find a legal way to terminate their pregnancies. This kind of maneuvering is alarming, as it could allow the Supreme Court to chip away at Roe without the public paying much attention. At least for now, Roberts is inclined to adhere to Whole Woman’s Health, perhaps out of a concern for institutional legitimacy. But his junior colleague has made it quite plain that he is gunning for Roe. Don’t believe the lip service Kavanaugh paid to precedent on Thursday. He is ready and willing to let states regulate abortion out of existence.

If the Supreme Court Doesn’t Stay a Louisiana Law Next Week, Roe v. Wade Will Be All but Dead.
The future of abortion rights could be decided in the coming days.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

usr: 1
This is interesting!